Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask questions about autism.

282 replies

coodawoodashooda · 09/07/2021 19:06

About 10 years ago i was in a meeting about autism. The leader said something like, 'if the child could......... then they didnt have autism. What was the quality that was being referred to? Was it empathy? I cant remember and for various personal reasons id really like to know.

OP posts:
hopingforabrighterfuture2021 · 11/07/2021 14:09

So many things that get trotted out, wrongly, about autism.

There is a spectrum, an autistic spectrum, on which people with autism sit. You can’t be ‘a bit on the spectrum’. HOWEVER. I do think that there are many people, who are now adults, who weren’t diagnosed as children, who are have autism. They just haven’t been diagnosed, would be on the ‘milder’ end of the spectrum, if they had been diagnosed, and have learnt to mask well.

Some of the most ridiculous misconceptions of people with autism/possible autism I’ve come across:

X loves lining up his trains, could he be autistic? (No, he just likes things to be organised)
Are you sure X has autism, he has great eye contact and lots of friends? Hmm
You’re so (insert word here) to have an autistic child, they must be really good at (insert word here)

I am not the parent of a child with autism, but I have lots of experience in working with children with autism, and some of the things people come out with are awful, and mis informed.

Vanishun · 11/07/2021 14:06

I think we can all agree that it would be better if the world was an easier, more accepting place for autistic people.

I can't blame anyone for trying to help their kids to adapt to it or do better.

I am also guessing that if you're the kind of person who joins mumsnet, you're probably quite caring and analytical and looking for the best way of parenting. So mums here are probably usually attuned to whether ABA is helping their kids or stressing them out.

toastantea · 11/07/2021 13:59

I don't have a problem with people who decide not to use ABA. I do have a huge problem with people demonising it and accusing me of torturing or abusing my child, when what I have done is enable him to live in our society and become a full partcipant in it.

You changed your child to suit society. That says it all to me. Im not here to fight though. It's hard enough without that so i shall just leave it at that. An ABA scrap is t worth anyone's time.

theDudesmummy · 11/07/2021 13:56

I now live in a country where ABA is a much more integral part of the philosophy of all disablity services than it is in England, and it is a very good thing.

theDudesmummy · 11/07/2021 13:55

That may well be the case, and I'm glad you too had a good outcome. I do still firmly believe that mine would not have been able to get to where he is today without ABA. And everyone should do what they believe best for their own child, with all the information they can garner. I don't have a problem with people who decide not to use ABA. I do have a huge problem with people demonising it and accusing me of torturing or abusing my child, when what I have done is enable him to live in our society and become a full partcipant in it.

toastantea · 11/07/2021 13:48

@theDudesmummy

ABA changed my DS from a continually self-harming, unable to communicate, constantly stimming and screaming and completely non-social child into a highly communicative, non-self harming, very social child who has a very full and happy life. He skiis, swims, cycles, waterskiis, rides horses etc. None of that would be possible without the years of ABA. I am not here to bang on about it, got over that years ago, but I still find it sad that the most effective therapy for those behaviours is not used by people because of an outdated and clinically inaccurate way of thinking.

Equally my DS who is exactly as you describe at the start turned into a happy and well adjusted adult who copes with life and enjoys lots of things too. He didn't have ABA.

theDudesmummy · 11/07/2021 13:41

ABA changed my DS from a continually self-harming, unable to communicate, constantly stimming and screaming and completely non-social child into a highly communicative, non-self harming, very social child who has a very full and happy life. He skiis, swims, cycles, waterskiis, rides horses etc. None of that would be possible without the years of ABA. I am not here to bang on about it, got over that years ago, but I still find it sad that the most effective therapy for those behaviours is not used by people because of an outdated and clinically inaccurate way of thinking.

Percie · 11/07/2021 12:39

@coodawoodashooda

For those of you with an adult diagnosis, what do you feel better about since being diagnosed?
I was only diagnosed recently with Asperger's, but it has helped make sense of so much. One big example is patterns in clothing - in OK with repeating patterns but not with random ones, if I try to wear them, e.g., I've been given a top then I should wear it when I see the giver, I feel misshapen, physically uncomfortable and like I have a spotlight on me, it stops me concentrating on anything else. You couldn't tell because I hide it. Since the diagnosis I've got rid of all those clothes and it's removed a huge stress, I just hadn't connected the dots between the pattern and the feeling until the diagnostic process.

The other thing it has helped with is PTSD - I'm about to begin trauma therapy, apparently there's been some research that certain therapies won't help much if you're autistic, so I've been added to the waiting list for the more appropriate therapy.

It's very hard to explain how relieving it feels to make those connections and finally be able to do something about the feelings because you know why now.

UndertheCedartree · 11/07/2021 10:14

Regarding PTSD - my autistic son was initially refereed to CAMHS as they wanted to rule out his autistic traits as being caused by trauma. So there is obviously some overlap here. I would therefore get your DS seen by CAMHS initially for assessment regarding PTSD and take it from there.

Lougle · 11/07/2021 08:33

@coodawoodashooda

Youve all been amazingly helpful. Thank you. So is it the process of the diagnosis that provides the clarity that gives so much comfort, or is it the support afterwards? Remember, im thinking out loud, not trying to upset anyone.
I think the process of assessment can be very affirming. For example, early on in the screening process (the bit where they decide if full assessment is warranted) when my DD was asked 'What would you do if a child you didn't know came into the playground and wanted to play?' she responded 'Well that isn't happening!' the assessor laughed and said that he needed to write that down. Most people would have seen her as rude, or exclusionary. He understood that she was expressing her discomfort at change.

The diagnostic process, for DD2, was the ADOS assessment and a parental interview called the 3Di. The 3Di was very reassuring, because you're asked lots and lots of questions, and your answers are put into the computer programme. At the end it collates the results into 4 domains (Social reciprocity, Communication, non-verbal communication, and restrictive/repetitive behaviours and interests) and gives a score for each. The report we got also gave the minimum score for clinical significance and the maximum score available. DD2 scored 24.2 for social reciprocity - the maximum score was 30 and the minimum score for clinical significance was 10, so we could see that she had 'qualified' by a long way.

For DD2, the fact that someone actually said to her 'you have autism' and explained that the autism means that she finds some social situations hard and that she needs extra help to understand the 'rules' of communication, was really helpful. Suddenly she understood why she finds it impossible to ask teachers for help, why she wants to be invisible in class, why she doesn't like change, why she still puts things in her bag so it feels the same weight on days when she doesn't need to take anything to school, why she's so drained after school, etc.

Also, it's helped because school are aware of her needs. They make sure she's sitting near the teacher, so she can ask for help discreetly and they can notice if she needs help. She has a '2 minute early' pass so she isn't so anxious when she's moving to the lunch hall/leaving school. She has a toilet pass so she can use the toilets during lessons. They've just done assessments for access arrangements. She's done too well to qualify for extra time, but they are going to give her a quiet room and rest breaks, so that if she gets flummoxed, she can turn her exam over and raise her hand, then the time will stop while she calms down and thinks, then she'll turn her paper back over and the timer will start again.

Many of her wider social circle don't know about her diagnosis. I think she has told her very close friends.

coodawoodashooda · 11/07/2021 07:42

Yes, thank you.

OP posts:
PopLife · 11/07/2021 07:39

Thank you @BlankTimes

UndertheCedartree · 11/07/2021 00:07

@x2boys - the autistic spectrum refers to the fact people have different strengths and weaknesses in a number of areas - it is not about some being less affected than others.

PopLife · 10/07/2021 23:52

This is a very enlightening thread. Thank you all for sharing your experiences. Has anyone been diagnosed as an adult and can explain what an assessment involves please? Do you have to have lots of proof of what you were like as a child?

aquashiv · 10/07/2021 23:45

That trainer was wrong.

UndertheCedartree · 10/07/2021 23:37

Could it be imagination? This isn't true autistic people can have a good imagination but struggle with social imagination.

toastantea · 10/07/2021 23:31

Ok. Don't dismiss an international group full of autistic people as 'more American stuff' unless you have personal experiences of it...

I looked and that is what I saw.

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 10/07/2021 23:30

@toastantea

Anyway, there are autistic people who post there about how they benefited from ABA and autistic practitioners of ABA post about what it actually entails and how respectfully they use it. ABA can be horrific and abusive but that's not to say that all practitioners are abusive or that it can't be beneficial for some.

I just had a look. More American stuff.

The ABA, of course the 'practitioners' are going to say they use it respectfully. Of course the autistic people are going to say they benefited from it. They are programmed to do that. You cannot therapy the autism away though. ABA can be horrific and abusive because it is horrific and abusive. Trying to train a person out of their very most natural behaviour to suit others Confused

Ok. Don't dismiss an international group full of autistic people as 'more American stuff' unless you have personal experiences of it...

I rather rest my case.

RickiTarr · 10/07/2021 23:24

Thanks @JulesRimetStillGleaming - I think I need that group.

toastantea · 10/07/2021 23:23

Anyway, there are autistic people who post there about how they benefited from ABA and autistic practitioners of ABA post about what it actually entails and how respectfully they use it. ABA can be horrific and abusive but that's not to say that all practitioners are abusive or that it can't be beneficial for some.

I just had a look. More American stuff.

The ABA, of course the 'practitioners' are going to say they use it respectfully. Of course the autistic people are going to say they benefited from it. They are programmed to do that. You cannot therapy the autism away though. ABA can be horrific and abusive because it is horrific and abusive. Trying to train a person out of their very most natural behaviour to suit others Confused

JulesRimetStillGleaming · 10/07/2021 23:15

My favourite autism Facebook group is 'when you're tired of autistic people but you are an autistic people'. It pokes fun at some of the more extreme views espoused by the 'autistic community'. Anyway, there are autistic people who post there about how they benefited from ABA and autistic practitioners of ABA post about what it actually entails and how respectfully they use it. ABA can be horrific and abusive but that's not to say that all practitioners are abusive or that it can't be beneficial for some.

I don't have a view either way as I have no personal experience but read some autistic social media and you're pretty much told what to think about certain things. I prefer to make up my own mind.

lakesummer · 10/07/2021 23:09

For my diagnosis (not autism) I would say that the most important part was the emotional impact, understanding I wasn't stupid or lazy just had a different brain. So the clarity was the key part.

The diagnosis meant it was much easier to achieve my full potential academically, from a terrible start I ended up doing well and have several degrees and professional qualifications.

I see the same pattern play out with my ds and his different diagnosis, the key is the personal peace it brings.

But proper support at school does help both with academics and importantly teacher relations.

RaspberrySchnapps · 10/07/2021 23:09

@Aspinelli clarity! that's it, that's what DS has and its made all the difference.

coodawoodashooda · 10/07/2021 23:06

Nayday

Thank you. I can see why.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread