Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 11/07/2021 19:56

Did Dervel just suggest food stamps for mothers if their partners default on child support? Because benefits 'disempower' people?
FOTTFSOFATFOSM. Benefits are all that's between you and being on the street. Its not having the pittance that disempowers you, its the red tape.
You sound utterly clueless.

In a society run by people who were not complete sadists, the State would pay the child support, and recover it from the defaulting parent.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/07/2021 19:38

@Dervel

I agree enforcement on child support is terrible, but the problem is the cost of enforcement often way eclipses the sums recovered, so in those instances what would be the point?

There should be a social safety net of some kind, but probably not to the point that it disempowers people from improving their own circumstances. Where is that line precisely? I don’t know, if we look at it problem by problem, if there are children literally starving would a food stamp policy be appropriate?

If you don’t contribute to the financial upbringing on your child the penalty should be simple: jail for neglect!
Dervel · 11/07/2021 18:26

I agree enforcement on child support is terrible, but the problem is the cost of enforcement often way eclipses the sums recovered, so in those instances what would be the point?

There should be a social safety net of some kind, but probably not to the point that it disempowers people from improving their own circumstances. Where is that line precisely? I don’t know, if we look at it problem by problem, if there are children literally starving would a food stamp policy be appropriate?

Seymour5 · 11/07/2021 14:47

I have mixed feelings, why people have to or choose to claim benefits isn't simple. I believe in taking personal responsibility for our choices, we had two children, and on a lowish income even with both of us working (no qualifications, left school at 15) we knew more was not feasible. We were eventually able to afford a three bedroomed house, in a reasonable area, and after one short spell of unemployment in the very early days, never got any means tested benefits again.

I met families as a housing worker who expected to be rehoused into bigger properties simply because they'd had more children. A bit like this:

www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/uk-news/mum-says-family-10-living-20987938

I think generally the attitude that we can have what we want without working for it is handed down through families, as is personal responsibility and a work ethic. I also meet quite a few women who haven't worked for years in my volunteering role. Their reason for not working is often 'I have children'. Then the children grow up, and the benefits reduce. it's a huge shock to some.

Lastly, I agree with all the posters who feel strongly that both parents, whether together or separate, have a duty to support whatever children they create. The UK is very lax on enforcing child support, and often its a pitiful amount compared to how much contribution a working resident parent makes.

IlonaRN · 11/07/2021 14:27

@Belleoverandover

Just a thought (and I don't mean the free 30 hours as I and others found there were restrictions on how it could be used and the childcare provider I used wasn't setup up for the free 30 hours yet it was the best and closest option to my work), why not make nursery and wrap around care once at school free for parents that work full time? For those that work part time they would get coverage for the hours they work including commuting time instead of child benefit to incentivise parents to work? There's no incentive for the current 30 free hours for parents to work.
I had thought this too, but actually do agree with the blanket offering.

It is quite often those parents who don't work whose children are most disadvantaged. Granting them access to the early years settings (i.e. nurseries) means they learn things that they won't if they are at home with their parents. It is therefore a potentially massive help for the children that they can access the childcare.

IlonaRN · 11/07/2021 14:19

I think some of the problem is the language used.

It is (of course) terrible to think of children in "poverty". However, "poverty" is defined as 60% of the median wage. As the median wage is ~£29k, that means that any child in a household with less than ~£20k income is in "poverty" by definition.

WrongKindOfFace · 11/07/2021 14:06

@Willyoujustbequiet

Will this affect children looking to be adopted?
Adopted children can be exempt from the limit. www.gov.uk/guidance/universal-credit-and-families-with-more-than-2-children-information-for-claimants
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/07/2021 14:03

I’ve lost count of the number of posts I’ve seen re people claiming they can’t work as they have children, won’t do more than sixteen hours as benefits will go down, can’t possibly move etc. The system currently allows people to make choices others have to pay for actually what you’ve lost count of is the number of people who can’t find 9-3 work in school time that pays enough to live on, what you’ve lost count of is the number of people who can’t afford the crippling costs of childcare in this country.

Willyoujustbequiet · 11/07/2021 13:52

Will this affect children looking to be adopted?

Roxy69 · 11/07/2021 13:44

2 is enough. The world is hugely overpopulated as you know.

HadEnoughofOtherThreads · 11/07/2021 13:39

Two children is more than enough if the parent/s can’t afford to be financially responsible for their first or second child
without assistance from the Welfare State.

sleepygnome · 11/07/2021 13:27

I asked about the children that exist, and your answer is that they should go back in time and not be born, or alternatively their parents should just "learn to budget", which is meaningless.

The 2 child limit was brought in in April 2017. Any 3rd child that already existed before then gets full benefits as born before the cutoff. The policy change was widely reported and has been since. Any child born after then it is up to the parents to make the decision as to whether they can afford a subsequent child with no extra taxpayer support. Why would anyone choose to have a child they know they cannot afford and will suffer? That's child abuse.

LuaDipa · 11/07/2021 13:23

@coulditbecominghome

It’s awful for the children who cannot choose to be born into a small family. Imagine growing up in poverty because your parents made bad choices and you, as a child, are punished? It’s insane.

It is insane & I don't see why the children should suffer. Plus where do you draw the line?

This.

We only had two kids because I knew that I could always manage two no matter what. My own df died young leaving my dm with 3 kids to raise so I know first hand how quickly things can change and it was important to me to know that I was giving myself the best chance to cope without help should the worst happen.

That being said, children don’t ask to be born, so while I don’t understand the mindset of low earners having lots of children, the kids are definitely not to blame and they should never be forced fo suffer as a result of their parents choices. I think the two child benefits cap is utterly wrong because the kids are still here, they just have less support. Where is the good in that?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 11/07/2021 13:19

@Getawaywithit

Is the extra money always spent on the dc anyway?

Course not. Every last person who has ever claimed any kind of benefit is as feckless as the day is long. Clad in designer labels, smoking, drinking vodka with perfectly manicured nails and a huge TV.

Jesus fucking wept.

You forgot the foreign holidays, nice car and the the sky package

Did anyone print out the benefits/immigration Bingo Cards?

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 11/07/2021 13:05

@Viviennemary

What happens to people who can't afford a big enough house. Or afford a better car or buy nice clothes. They have to make do with what they've got. I know folk in this position. They don't expect other folk to pick up their costs for more children.
Exactly. Or they pick up extra hours or a second job etc.

I’ve lost count of the number of posts I’ve seen re people claiming they can’t work as they have children, won’t do more than sixteen hours as benefits will go down, can’t possibly move etc. The system currently allows people to make choices others have to pay for.

Getawaywithit · 11/07/2021 12:48

Is the extra money always spent on the dc anyway?

Course not. Every last person who has ever claimed any kind of benefit is as feckless as the day is long. Clad in designer labels, smoking, drinking vodka with perfectly manicured nails and a huge TV.

Jesus fucking wept.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/07/2021 12:44

Currently the UK benefits system pays for housing costs, costs for 2 children, support for parents who aren't working or can't work, disability benefits, support so they don't have to pay counil tax, free prescriptions, free school meals whilst also providing free education, free healthcare, subsidised leisure activities and clubs etc you’re looking at this the wrong way round. Most people who receive benefits work,
Ask yourself why they need propping up by the tax payer when they are earning a full salary..:::

woodhill · 11/07/2021 12:42

Is the extra money always spent on the dc anyway?

Getawaywithit · 11/07/2021 12:35

Currently the UK benefits system pays for housing costs, costs for 2 children, support for parents who aren't working or can't work, disability benefits, support so they don't have to pay counil tax, free prescriptions, free school meals whilst also providing free education, free healthcare, subsidised leisure activities and clubs etc

Erm….everyone gets free healthcare and education, not just people on benefits. And not everyone on benefits gets everything you mention - I claim tax credits and the disability element but I have never had a free school meal, free prescriptions, have always paid council tax and don’t claim housing costs. Because I’m not eligible…because I work,and pay my taxes.

claralara42 · 11/07/2021 12:27

hey either stop at 2 children or they will have to spread the benefit payments further and learn to budget just like loads of families with 1 or 2 children currently do

I asked about the children that exist, and your answer is that they should go back in time and not be born, or alternatively their parents should just "learn to budget", which is meaningless.

Thanks so much for your epic insight. Hmm

Viviennemary · 11/07/2021 12:26

What happens to people who can't afford a big enough house. Or afford a better car or buy nice clothes. They have to make do with what they've got. I know folk in this position. They don't expect other folk to pick up their costs for more children.

sleepygnome · 11/07/2021 12:24

So can you tell us all what should happen to the children whose parents don't have enough money to look after them properly?

They either stop at 2 children or they will have to spread the benefit payments further and learn to budget just like loads of families with 1 or 2 children currently do.

Currently the UK benefits system pays for housing costs, costs for 2 children, support for parents who aren't working or can't work, disability benefits, support so they don't have to pay counil tax, free prescriptions, free school meals whilst also providing free education, free healthcare, subsidised leisure activities and clubs etc. Just think about that for a minute - that people can live in a country where so much is given for free (or rather provided by other taxpayers), yet people still complain.

dreamingofsun · 11/07/2021 12:06

Thats the kids that are suffering because the parents have had more than 2 and cant cope financially....

dreamingofsun · 11/07/2021 12:05

Having read through the posts on this thread i think that the limit on 2 kids is right - both for environmental, government funding reasons and to discourage people having kids they cant afford.

But there needs to be things like wrap around school care to ensure the kids dont suffer more than necessary - so they are fed etc and have a good a start educationally as possible.

claralara42 · 11/07/2021 11:44

@Thehop

I agree with the limit. I have more than 2 children, but we work bloody hard to pay for them.....as is only fair.
So can you tell us all what should happen to the children whose parents don't have enough money to look after them properly?