Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:33

Yes people can have as many children as they want but stop expecting other people to sub this.

DH & I are higher rate tax payers. I'm far happier spending my taxes subsidising children as opposed to companies who won't pay a decent wage.

Also lots of people don't seem happy to pay their own care when older but is that ok to sub?

MouseholeCat · 09/07/2021 17:32

I'm so uncomfortable with this policy. Life can go tits up at any time, including when you've already had more than 2 kids, and I just don't think it's fair to force kids into poverty for the circumstances they are born in.

This disproportionately impacts women who are more likely to be reliant on welfare while having primary custody of children.

I'm in the US and as a PP said most of the programs, at least in my state, cover kids you have when you enter the program but not more.

I wish people didn't have kids that they can't afford, but the fact is these kids exist and it's not right to punish them for the actions of their parents.

StrangeToSee · 09/07/2021 17:32

And the fact is, children are born into these situations, whether there are benefits to help pay for them or not. So should we just shrug and say it's their bad luck that their parents can't afford to pay for them, so they will just have to suffer? That isn't my idea of a civilised society

Isn’t the aim that parents think twice before deciding to try for a third? Knowing there will be no extra benefits and financial support will make many stop at 2.

If a child is suffering because parents can’t afford housing, food, clothing etc then numerous charities and children’s services step in. The parents will also be assessed to ensure they’re not neglecting the children?

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 09/07/2021 17:31

I love how the older generation think we shouldn’t support those who want children but we should pay for their care whilst they hold on to massive family homes…..Hmm

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:30

Also if I was young now I'd be looking to another country for a better life. Far too much financial burden is being thrown at the younger generations & that was pre covid. Luckily mine have EU citizenship.

VolcanicEruption · 09/07/2021 17:29

I think they were starting to go down the right route.
We stopped at 2 (now 34&31) as even then we knew the world was changing but we did not know how much. We decided to support them through further education and DD is a science teacher 👩‍🏫 abroad. DS is an engineer in food 🥘 production.

Even before COVID the education and health systems were struggling and people were unable to get reasonable jobs hence the Gig economy .
Yes people can have as many children as they want but stop expecting other people to sub this.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 09/07/2021 17:28

@Ohhok

How about fixing the child maintenance service? There must be so many children living in poverty because their absent parent is a dickhead.
Was just going to make this point- change the law to go after the feckless men! And yes it is men!
Folklore9074 · 09/07/2021 17:24

@Nancydrawn

It's going to be very interesting when the plummeting fertility rate and the curbs on immigration catch up to Britain.
This exactly. We should be doing so much more in this country to support people to have families and make it affordable. The birth rate is falling in part because people are leaving it later and later, until they can afford all the things that go along with having children. In many cases they are just not bothering or find it’s actually too late. Tax credits are the tip of the iceberg. We should be thinking about affordable child care, housing etc.
MummytoCSJH · 09/07/2021 17:21

@BrilliantBetty

I think they should go a step further and limit council housing and temporary accommodation to three bedrooms. And housing benefit to be limited to three bedroom rate too. If a family can't afford more (securely!) then don't have more. No reason councils should be forking out for unreasonably large properties because of individuals choices.
Council housing isn't just for people on benefits though? I only got my council house due to working full time.
Ohhok · 09/07/2021 17:20

How about fixing the child maintenance service? There must be so many children living in poverty because their absent parent is a dickhead.

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:20

@SchrodingersImmigrant It's so ignorant & arrogant

SchrodingersImmigrant · 09/07/2021 17:20

@coulditbecominghome

It's going to be very interesting when the plummeting fertility rate and the curbs on immigration catch up to Britain.

Oh don't worry, other similar threads often have posters saying we will just get new immigrants because they will be desperate to come 🤔

Yeah. That always makes me giggle
coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:19

It’s awful for the children who cannot choose to be born into a small family. Imagine growing up in poverty because your parents made bad choices and you, as a child, are punished? It’s insane.

It is insane & I don't see why the children should suffer. Plus where do you draw the line?

Blossomtoes · 09/07/2021 17:18

@Tal45

The world is already hugely over populated, we shouldn't be paying anyone to have children IMO.
We’re not. And never have.
coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:17

@Whammyyammy why should the child suffer?

Mumoftwoinprimary · 09/07/2021 17:17

And the fact is, children are born into these situations, whether there are benefits to help pay for them or not. So should we just shrug and say it's their bad luck that their parents can't afford to pay for them, so they will just have to suffer? That isn't my idea of a civilised society.

This.

(No skin in the game - two higher rate tax payers in this house plus my user name gives how many children I have.)

StrangeToSee · 09/07/2021 17:16

I think it’s wise of the government. Nobody’s saying you can’t have more than 2, just that you won’t get extra financial help to raise a 3rd. You literally ‘earn’ the right to have more than 2 by saving, living within your means and paying for the extra children.

I think it’s really selfish when people who rely heavily on government help go on to have 4 or 5 children (if it’s by choice). People (a minority) used to do it because your monthly payments increased, you were eligible for better housing etc.

Most people I know only have 1 or 2 and say they want to give their children a nice lifestyle, paying for a third would jeopardise that. Or mums often want to go back to work once the youngest is in school, not start all over again with a baby.

Whammyyammy · 09/07/2021 17:16

@coulditbecominghome

It's a bit blinkered to insist that everyone should be just like you.

And the fact is, children are born into these situations, whether there are benefits to help pay for them or not. So should we just shrug and say it's their bad luck that their parents can't afford to pay for them, so they will just have to suffer? That isn't my idea of a civilised society.

I agree

Getting pregnant and subsequently giving birth is not "bad luck", usually pregnancy occurs after unprotected sex, it has nothing to do with bad luck. Surely this is common knowledge 🤔
Cattenberg · 09/07/2021 17:16

@coulditbecominghome

It's a bit blinkered to insist that everyone should be just like you.

And the fact is, children are born into these situations, whether there are benefits to help pay for them or not. So should we just shrug and say it's their bad luck that their parents can't afford to pay for them, so they will just have to suffer? That isn't my idea of a civilised society.

I agree

I agree too.
coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:15

It's going to be very interesting when the plummeting fertility rate and the curbs on immigration catch up to Britain.

Oh don't worry, other similar threads often have posters saying we will just get new immigrants because they will be desperate to come 🤔

AcrossthePond55 · 09/07/2021 17:15

Where I live (US*) the 'rule' is that you are entitled to welfare for the number of children you have when you go on the program. But your grant isn't increased for any subsequent children. I think that's fair and it 'covers' larger families who fall on hard times.

After that, you're on your own. If you can't afford another child on your income then double/triple up on contraception or choose a permanent method and consider your family 'complete'. Many families would like more children than they have, but they regretfully decide that it's not in the cards financially and make contraceptive decisions accordingly. Life will go on.

*I realize the US programs and mindset is very different to the UK's as we don't really have a 'social safety net' like yours.

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:11

It's a bit blinkered to insist that everyone should be just like you.

And the fact is, children are born into these situations, whether there are benefits to help pay for them or not. So should we just shrug and say it's their bad luck that their parents can't afford to pay for them, so they will just have to suffer? That isn't my idea of a civilised society.

I agree

me4real · 09/07/2021 17:09

They've had this for years though.

I can get that people think that people shouldn't be able to have as many children as they want irresponsibly when they can't provide for them. This is why the government brought in most of the measures they did; because it's the sort of thing the majority, which voted them in, wanted.

AddsVsGeorgs · 09/07/2021 17:09

No-one is saying you cant have more than two children.

You can have as many as you like
But after two, You wont financially gain from the benefit system, so you have to pay for them yourself

I think the decision is right

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:09

The world is already hugely over populated, we shouldn't be paying anyone to have children IMO.

You can't look at that without addressing ageing populations & chronic conditions.