Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
tillytoodles1 · 09/07/2021 18:13

I had two kids because that's all we could afford. Now they're both adults , working full time, and I have one grandchild who's twelve. There will he no more as my son is divorced and my daughter can't have kids. They both pay all their taxes so they've paid back more than it ever cost the government to raise them. It p*sses me off to see lots of people I know of, neither working, but driving nice cars and smoking. They're probably working cas in hand, as according to most people, benefits are crap.
I'm not having a go at people who need them, but a lot of them have more than two kids, or work cash in hand.

HelenHywater · 09/07/2021 18:12

@ivfgottwins

Lots of middle earner families where both parents work and earn above the national average in wages can't afford to have often more than one child or two or three etc so why should the government (and taxpayer) support low income or no income people have multiple children?
Yes those stupid people having 4 children and expecting the tax payer to pay.

Jesus Christ . Why don't you read and do some research before spouting your ridiculous, bigoted, views?

HelenHywater · 09/07/2021 18:11

@osbertthesyrianhamster

Need to vastly strengthen the rules regarding non-resident parents paying for their children. So many, usually men, walk away from supporting their kids (and find some fool to procreate further with) and leaving the taxpayer holding the bag.
rubbish. The tax payer hardly picks up anything. The vast majority of families receiving UC are in work. They are still in poverty.

There is no safety net. And it isn't feckless parents choosing to have 7 children on top of their fags and booze habit. It's the woman working in the supermarket, your nursery worker, your TA at school.

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 18:11

The birth rate may be going down although looking round my neighbourhood I find that hard to believe but the UK is far too overcrowded.

You can fact check the above. If anything there are too many older people, the median age is 40.

ivfgottwins · 09/07/2021 18:10

Lots of middle earner families where both parents work and earn above the national average in wages can't afford to have often more than one child or two or three etc so why should the government (and taxpayer) support low income or no income people have multiple children?

Kljnmw3459 · 09/07/2021 18:09

I think it's the wrong decision.

osbertthesyrianhamster · 09/07/2021 18:09

Need to vastly strengthen the rules regarding non-resident parents paying for their children. So many, usually men, walk away from supporting their kids (and find some fool to procreate further with) and leaving the taxpayer holding the bag.

HelenHywater · 09/07/2021 18:08

Most of the posts on this thread are utterly utterly depressing.

You do know that children are going without FOOD because of the Tory party policies? That children are in poverty? That children are suffering. Jeez. The inhumanity on this thread.

SapphireSeptember · 09/07/2021 18:06

@TheBestPlansAlwaysFail

Prefacing this by saying I don't agree with this logic - but these policies tend to be designed with the intention to stop the "wrong" kind of large families, i.e. uneducated, parents have low-skilled jobs. The people implementing them are well aware that most (not all, obviously) degree-educated parents will be able to afford a third or fourth child. The issue there is that those families often limit number of children because both parents have a career and the women often delay having children. Germany, for example, introduced changes to mat leave that very explicitly benefitted highly-trained/educated women but punished unemployed or low-earning women. Long-term, I think the UK will do something similar.
Well that sounds shit for women on low incomes, how did that work out?

Love it when people say 'we never get any help from the government'. Yes you do, lots of things are funded through taxes. Why should I (a child free woman) have to pay for your offspring? (Because I don't want to see kids growing up in dire poverty, that's why.)

lynsey91 · 09/07/2021 18:05

Personally I think child benefit should stop at 2 children. No one needs more than 2.

It's all very well saying if you can afford it you can have as many as you want but what if circumstances change? If everyone stuck with 1 or 2 then changes of circumstance would not matter would they?

Having 3, 4, 5, 6 or whatever children because you can afford it but not thinking things can change is just stupid.

The birth rate may be going down although looking round my neighbourhood I find that hard to believe but the UK is far too overcrowded.

The majority of my neighbours with children have 3. Some have more. One couple, neither of whom work, are expecting their 4th. The 3rd was born after the cut off date. How the hell are they affording it? They are both capable of working, have a car each but say they don't want to work!

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 18:02

...and let’s not even mention the massive toll an 8 person family takes in the environment. And of course the richer you are the worse that gets (foreign holidays, bigger car, bigger house etc etc ). environmentally, a well-off British family having 8 kids is probably equivalent to a below average salary family have 15 kids.

But that's ok cause then can afford it 🙄

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 17:59

How can someone "ensure" they can afford kids for their entire future, or even the next 18 years?
You might have a good idea but to "ensure" you're essentially saying you need tens/hundreds of thousands of pounds in savings before you conceive.

No-one can predict whether they will be healthy/able-bodied/able to work at any given salary level for the next couple of decades.

I am also puzzled by this, I don't have hundreds of thousands of pounds in saving.

HavelockVetinari · 09/07/2021 17:59

@AlexaShutUp

It's a tough one. I do think it's irresponsible to have children that you can't afford to support. I also think there are strong environmental arguments for encouraging people to have fewer children.

However, it isn't quite as simple as that, is it? Some people will accidentally get pregnant and not wish to terminate the pregnancy. Some people will experience a change in circumstances through illness, disability or redundancy etc that mean they are no longer able to afford the family that they had planned. Sadly, some women will get pregnant as the result of rape. Not everyone's lives are perfectly planned. And none of it is the fault of the innocent children who did not ask to be born and who do not deserve to grow up in poverty... even if their parents are feckless and irresponsible.

It is inhumane to deny support to children who really need it, whatever has caused that need.

This.
Cam77 · 09/07/2021 17:59

@HyggeTygge
They’re just talking out of their backsides. Some people who are getting crapped on by the system themselves and are just scraping by themselves take a little perverse pleasure in kicking downwards.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 09/07/2021 17:56

@Pinuporc

I find this fascinating because when you read MN, it genuinely sometimes sounds like it's 18% with less than two.

MN is really not representative of the population as a whole. Reading on here youd be forgiven for thinking the average uk wage was about 80k! Confused

I am aware. Also the Chernobyl chicken feeding 17 for a month 😁

But the concentration is really interesting.

HyggeTygge · 09/07/2021 17:56

(^ That wasn't in response to the OP but to people saying finances should be 'ensured')

HyggeTygge · 09/07/2021 17:55

How can someone "ensure" they can afford kids for their entire future, or even the next 18 years?
You might have a good idea but to "ensure" you're essentially saying you need tens/hundreds of thousands of pounds in savings before you conceive.

No-one can predict whether they will be healthy/able-bodied/able to work at any given salary level for the next couple of decades.

Lots of well-earning people were put at financial risk with Brexit, covid etc - other things they have no control over.

I wish people would be specific about what they actually mean when they say people should "ensure" they can afford kids. Obviously they are expensive so you will probably know if you can't afford them at the moment, but that's not the same thing.

motogogo · 09/07/2021 17:55

You can have as many children as you can afford, the ruling is just that you won't receive extra benefits

Cam77 · 09/07/2021 17:55

...and let’s not even mention the massive toll an 8 person family takes in the environment. And of course the richer you are the worse that gets (foreign holidays, bigger car, bigger house etc etc ). environmentally, a well-off British family having 8 kids is probably equivalent to a below average salary family have 15 kids.

RaindropsOnRosie · 09/07/2021 17:55

If people can't afford to have more than 2 children, they shouldn't have them. Unless a child they can't afford was conceived through rape there is no excuse.

Pinuporc · 09/07/2021 17:54

I find this fascinating because when you read MN, it genuinely sometimes sounds like it's 18% with less than two.

MN is really not representative of the population as a whole. Reading on here youd be forgiven for thinking the average uk wage was about 80k! Confused

gillysSong · 09/07/2021 17:54

@VolcanicEruption

I think they were starting to go down the right route. We stopped at 2 (now 34&31) as even then we knew the world was changing but we did not know how much. We decided to support them through further education and DD is a science teacher 👩‍🏫 abroad. DS is an engineer in food 🥘 production. Even before COVID the education and health systems were struggling and people were unable to get reasonable jobs hence the Gig economy . Yes people can have as many children as they want but stop expecting other people to sub this.
Why should people without children fund the schools and colleges your kids went to, or their healthcare? They don't have kids.

Your kids are ok, but you have no empathy for other people's. So, you are a rich tory.

funinthesun19 · 09/07/2021 17:54

Child Benefit is still paid for as many children as someone chooses to have. It’s child tax credits and universal credit child element which stop at two children.

I have 4 children and receive money for 3. I really can’t get worked up about not getting extra (apart from CB) after I had my 4th. We’re all happy and no worse off. It’s how people choose to cut their cloth.

It’s like people want those with more than 2 children to wallow in it.

Fizzbangwallop · 09/07/2021 17:54

I agree with the pp who said that it’s more important that the CMS is fit for purpose. Too many men get away with not paying for their children. If men knew they wouldn’t get away with non payment of child maintenance it would help save more children from poverty.

I think the idea of. two child limit is fair but it’s unfair when the third or fourth children are already here.

OurChristmasMiracle · 09/07/2021 17:53

I think it has a greater effect on women because realistically it means that women can only have 2 kids that are paid tor as statistically it’s women who are the main carers and therefore claiming benefits.

However men can have 2 kids by as many different women as they choose and get all of them paid for