Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 09/07/2021 19:42

@coulditbecominghome

Would naturally lower the birth rate

How high do people think the UK birth rate is, it's been declining for years.

This. Every year it’s lower than the previous one.
lynsey91 · 09/07/2021 19:41

@coulditbecominghome

How do you know they weren't?

Well how did you end up in the family then @lynsey91?

What exactly are you going on about? The insurance would be for circumstances changing like losing a job etc.

My parents didn't even receive child benefit for me as I am the eldest so they certainly did not scrounge off taxpayers

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 19:41

Would naturally lower the birth rate

How high do people think the UK birth rate is, it's been declining for years.

youngandbroken · 09/07/2021 19:40

I do think that changes to the benefits system need to be made - it is ridiculous that one my family members doesn't work, nor does their partner and yet have a beautiful house with a garden and 4 children and never had to worry about whether they could afford them or not whilst me and my partner do work, are stuck in a tiny unsafe high rise flat with no outside space and can only afford 2 children - I had to have a termination last year (thanks to a contraceptive failure) because we physically could not afford a 3rd and I have to live with that every single day for the rest of my life - sometimes it does feel like if we were unemployed we'd have a better life. And we aren't on particularly low wages either - my partner has a decent job and we aren't entitled to benefits - so yes, something needs to change BUT I also don't people to suffer and there are genuine cases who have, and who will continue to suffer under this change.

hulahooper2 · 09/07/2021 19:38

I stopped at what we could afford to look after , with both parents in well paid jobs. I think the limit is well overdue

FlyingBattie · 09/07/2021 19:37

On one hand-
Nobody, absolutely nobody has the "right" to have any children.
If we do, then they are our responsibility to feed, clothe, house etc for at least 18 years. Not the governments, unless the government agencies remove them.

That said, is it fair, if, for example, a woman leaves her abusive husband with their three kids, the husband refuses to pay CM, and the woman is left struggling? It is a sexist policy, IMO. And could possibly leave women and children stuck in dangerous situations to avoid poverty.

EmergencyHydrangea · 09/07/2021 19:37

Yeah, just let the "extra" kids starve

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 19:37

How do you know they weren't?

Well how did you end up in the family then @lynsey91?

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 19:35

No they're not.

Err @OverTheRubicon plenty of countries do incentivise.

Gingerkittykat · 09/07/2021 19:35

@Wheretobuy

I agree with the comment about restricting larger council properties to 3 bedrooms max.
Why?

What is one bedroom is needed for a disabled child?
What if there is a blended family?
What if a grandparent comes to stay?
What if someone becomes a kinship carer? (I happen to know someone with 3 bio kids who took on her nephews due their mum's drug abuse, should those 5 kids be crammed into 2 bedrooms?)

lynsey91 · 09/07/2021 19:35

[quote coulditbecominghome]@lynsey91 so you don't have this unicorn insurance then? I'm shocked!

How come your own parents weren't so enlightened? [/quote]
How do you know they weren't? They didn't churn out child after child even though almost 70 years ago there was not as much choice of contraception. They also managed not to have any "accidental pregnancies" which are so common now

Whatinthelord · 09/07/2021 19:35

@Wheretobuy

I agree with the comment about restricting larger council properties to 3 bedrooms max.
Most local authorities have a LONG list of large families waiting for larger properties already anyway.
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 09/07/2021 19:34

@Bigassbeebuzzbuzz

They need to give people to options to get off benefits imho. With 2 adults working fulltime having to claim benefits to top up piss poor wages I dont think we should be blaming people for having more children than they can afford. We should have a system where working full time doesn't mean you need any top ups of uc. People could then see how much money they had left over and make their minds up if they can afford it then.
Maybe the better way is not to have any child related benefits therefore making parents ensure they can afford by choices they make re children, jobs, hours worked and where they live etc. Would naturally lower the birth rate, we’d have more money for schools etc and still have free choice on family size. We shouldn’t be encouraging people to have children that others have to pay for.
coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 19:33

@BarbarianMum but what about the ones who haven't saved enough or anything?

Plus not everyone who has dementia has to sell their house for their care.

caringcarer · 09/07/2021 19:29

In UK people are free to have as many kids as they want. No breach of human rights. Government can only afford to help support two. The other kids still get free health care and schooling. People should consider their circumstances and their ability to financially support kids before having them. When I had my children small there was child benefit and that was it. No government top ups unless unemployed.

bunnybuggs · 09/07/2021 19:28

@Billben

Fully agree with child benefit being restricted to 2 children.
It is not child benefit that is restricted - families of multiple children get child benefit for all of them. The state pension (which incidentally is one of the 'benefits' that IS taxed) it is given to all who have the necessary NI contributions (and if they don't have them - they get pension credit anyway which is worth a lot more) It is annoying that everyone says pension is the biggest benefit cost - it is only big because so many millions of people are entitled to it and it is not a 'benefit' per se (pension credit for the poorest pensioners is)
Wheretobuy · 09/07/2021 19:27

I agree with the comment about restricting larger council properties to 3 bedrooms max.

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 09/07/2021 19:27

They need to give people to options to get off benefits imho. With 2 adults working fulltime having to claim benefits to top up piss poor wages I dont think we should be blaming people for having more children than they can afford. We should have a system where working full time doesn't mean you need any top ups of uc. People could then see how much money they had left over and make their minds up if they can afford it then.

Belledan1 · 09/07/2021 19:26

I know someone who had 5 kids as husband low paid and they got more tax credits each time. This was before the cap came in. She told me once got 300.00 a week in just tax credits. She always made digs about working moms and she chose to be there for her kids. Its come to bite her on the bum now though as they are gradually leaving school and getting apprenticeships and one going to uni so its reduced. She tried to stop one going to apprenticeship cause of benefits. He moved out to live with grandparent as fell out.

Foxglovesandlilacs86 · 09/07/2021 19:24

@Cam77 they actually go to private school, but even if they didn’t, that argument annoys me. Most of us pay tax to pay for things like healthcare and education and benefits. Some of us pay more than others. I pay a lot and I also employ others who pay tax, so I feel like I pay my fair share and so does DH.

However I am willing to admit that I’m in the minority Grin

OverTheRubicon · 09/07/2021 19:21

@Upamountain43

i think a lot of people need to look at the population timebomb we are looking at in this country - many countries are starting to pay people to have children or else they are going to be in a complete mess in a decade or so.

These children are the ones who are going to have to pay for your pension, health and care in old age - its typical short term purely for votes thinking that has typified British politics for years.

No they're not. Masses of jobs are going to be automated or offshored, climate change is going to shrink the percentage of livable land, and worldwide the population is still greatly increasing. The earth doesn't need more people (and I say that as someone with more than 2 children, who appreciates that this is not a sustainable choice).
Foxglovesandlilacs86 · 09/07/2021 19:19

I’ve never thought of it like that but I’m not far off tbh Smile

Billben · 09/07/2021 19:18

Fully agree with child benefit being restricted to 2 children.

BarbarianMum · 09/07/2021 19:16

@coulditbecominghome the current situation is that older people do pay for their own care if they have savings - and if they have dementia can be expected to sell their homes to do so.

tillytoodles1 · 09/07/2021 19:16

@Boomclaps, the first mistake they made was having five kids. Life would have been so much easier with two. Many years ago when contraception wasn't as easily available, it was a problem., but not now.

They made a bad decision not putting plans in place for something like that happening