Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
missymayhemsmum · 21/07/2021 22:10

Love the contrast between this thread and one on whether taking a third maternity leave is taking the piss.

Do those who support the two-child rule think that maternity pay/leave should also be restricted to two pregnancies? If not why not? In the UK statutory maternity paid is reclaimed from the state by the employer

dreamingofsun · 20/07/2021 12:29

helenhighwater - not sure about your logic on lower income earners paying more tax. My point was that if your earn under about 30k you are a net taker and not a money generator for the country - taking into account the cost of things like healthcare, education etc. So from a budgetary perspective, if you increase the population of under 30k earners you are actually going to make the public sector funding situation worse

vivainsomnia · 20/07/2021 12:20

It's in no one's interests for children to be in poverty
Of course it isn't. Noone wants to see children in poverty. Everyone wants these children to have the same opportunity.

The issue is whether giving more money is the way to achieve it. If you are a low income family, the extra you use to get for having more children didn't mean more money for the individual children. Statistics seem to show that the introduction of the 2 children limit has indeed seen a reduction in people on benefit having more than 2 children. These two children are likely in a better position than they would have been with 2, 3, 4 more siblings, even with the increase in benefits.

The issue is when families decide to have more despite the limit. What is wrong is that the limit should only apply to families already receiving benefits. Those who didn't need to claim when they had more children, but suddenly finding themselves needing to should be exempt from it at the first time of claiming.

monotonousmum · 20/07/2021 12:16

I was raised on benefits. My Dad always worked full time, apart from a brief period when I was in my 20s and already moved out - the experience was extremely stressful, and benefits were threatened to stop once when he was 6 minutes to the job centre, when it was snowing! He was totally humiliated, and what he really needed was help filling in application forms...it had been over 20 years since he'd last had to do it.
For reasons I won't go into here my Mum hasn't done much paid work, only partially because it wasn't financially viable with us kids.

I knew we were poor. Holidays were camping, and I don't recall them being every year - best holidays ever though. You couldn't help yourself to food from the fridge because everything was accounted for, but we didn't go hungry. My parents did sometimes.

Those benefits enabled us to eat. Get to school, continue education (to college level, not uni - I did that myself in my late 20s). They housed us, somewhere that I can still go back to if I needed to (although they don't claim income related benefits now, home ownership has always been out of reach for my parents).

Those benefits gave a life to myself and my 4 siblings which means none of us have to claim benefits ourselves. I've never had to claim. I drive a reliable car and live in a nice house, with two kids (and would love a third but haven't fully decided yet). I'm in a very fortunate position and still only a few months unemployed from losing it all - income protection not available in my industry.

Money management was not my parents strong point, but it's hard to be good with money when you're poor. Buy cheap, buy twice doesn't mean much when you can't afford the quality to start with. If benefits for my parents had stopped at two I doubt they would have stopped having kids, but my life now is likely to be vastly different.

vivainsomnia · 20/07/2021 12:14

Sod all protection
I see that you do have quite a bit of protection. You have assets you can sell. You have a house that you can sell and move to a smaller property. You have an ex who is earning well and so should be paying a decent amount of maintenance. You have assets you can sell and you have work experience that means you should able to find another job.

I wouldn't think that your family would fall in the poverty trap under these circumstances and the reduction in UC is not going to be a massive hardship in the longer term.

To me it sounds exactly like the protection you need to have in place.

HelenHywater · 20/07/2021 11:00

I think @dreamingofsun although I'm no economist, that relatively speaking there's a higher tax burden on lower paid people once you factor in VAT, tax on fuel etc etc. The higher rate tax payers seem to be more adept at paying less tax.

And if you want to create more higher rate tax payers in the future, you lift families out of poverty. Poverty is the by far biggest cause of worse outcomes for children - more by far than any other factor. Any other factor. It's in no one's interests for children to be in poverty. And that means economic interests if you can't be persuaded by the moral argument.

5zeds · 20/07/2021 09:53

The idea of “nudging” people to do what you want by penalising children is gross.

SomethingOnce · 20/07/2021 09:28

I’m sure some policy bod could come up with numbers that would nudge behaviour to achieve the right, erm, balance in a way that feels more positive than punishing children for their parents’ choices and setting up the country for a demographic disaster.

SomethingOnce · 20/07/2021 09:21

@dreamingofsun the two-child cap seems to have been intended to discourage particular reproductive choices that PPs have discussed; I wonder if incentivising a limit, rather than punishing those exceeding it, would be better (and cheaper) all round.

Perhaps higher rate taxpayers mightn’t be so cautious and hesitant to have larger families if the safety net was able to function properly as a safety net - when circs genuinely change - and not an incentive (tbh, I don’t know how much the latter has been the case, but evidently some take that view). Higher rate taxpayers who genuinely want larger families are unlikely to be put off by missing out on a cash gift.

5zeds · 20/07/2021 09:11

I think high earners and low earners both tend to have larger families

dreamingofsun · 20/07/2021 08:48

somethingonce - i'm probably going to get flamed for this.....but if the aim is to produce future taxpayers then you would want lots of higher rate taxpayers - less than about 30k income you are actually a negative drain on the tax system. And stats show that you are more likely to get these from higher educated mothers, and these are less likely to be on benefits anyway.

5zeds · 20/07/2021 07:59

You already are significantly poorer if you have more children and have the benefits of having them. There’s no need to enhance the way things are.

SomethingOnce · 19/07/2021 23:06

Also, great posts by @missymayhemsmum and @HelenHywater, to which I would add that, in the end, punishing children with poverty costs society a fucking fortune.

Perhaps a ‘thanks for producing taxpayers/sorry you didn’t have the child(ren) you’d hoped for/congrats you didn’t have any children you didn’t want’ cash gift, redeemable after age 45 for those with zero/one/two would work? Anyone who fancies three or more loses the cash gift but gains a different gift. This might achieve what the two-child cap set out to achieve, but in a way that works better for blameless children and the society in which we all live.

SomethingOnce · 19/07/2021 22:49

A number of PPs don’t seem to understand that in order to avoid the pitfalls of a rapidly ageing population, we need future taxpayers, and that the current 1.6 birth rate is an average. So, in order to maintain even this dismal 1.6 (predicted to fall further), where some people have 0 children, and there are many more onlies than has historically been the case, some people have to have two or more Shock because that is how averages work.

Stopping at one or two, to be sensible and responsible, is a preoccupation of relatively well-educated, affluent people. It makes a sort of sense in the short term.

HelenHywater · 19/07/2021 20:48

@Spanielstail

But someone promising to dig ditches is a bit Wooly isn't it?

How about ensure you both paid o to the mortgage so you come out with money towards a new house. Have savings. Maintain a job.

Have critical illness Insurance so the mortgage gets paid if you are sick.

Ensure you are married in a long term relationship before procreating.

None of it is fool proof but combined adds several layers of protection in.

But this is bullshit. This isn't real life.

Alot of people don't have mortgages. They live in rental properties.
Many can't afford mortgage protection. Many don't have critical illness cover. People don't have savings, because they spend all their money on food, and living, and rent.
Many mothers give up work (see threads on here ad infitinum) because their salary doesn't even start to cover childcare and their job doesn't allow them any flexibility, and their ex doesn't do any housework, or drop offs, or school holidays . So they are left relying on their partner, who becomes their ex.

Most people think their marriage or relationship will last - mine was 20 years
People get pregnant accidentally or they have twins.

And when the relationship ends and the mother (because it's usually her) doesn't have enough money - you leave the third child out of any calculation? So you get no rent for the third child, no UC, no tax credit. How is that right? The family and the child just suffer?

I know you won't get persuaded by my post, but your post exemplifies what is so wrong with society today.

5zeds · 19/07/2021 20:47

Some of these ideas are very Victorian. There seems to be a strong element of wishing to punish those who have larger families rather than protect those who fall on hard times. Personally I think everyone should choose how many children they want and then do there best and everyone should expect to support those who need it. We have enough to do that.

Getawaywithit · 19/07/2021 20:41

How about ensure you both paid o to the mortgage so you come out with money towards a new house. Have savings. Maintain a job.Have critical illness Insurance so the mortgage gets paid if you are sick.Ensure you are married in a long term relationship before procreating. None of it is fool proof but combined adds several layers of protection

ODFOD.

  1. Joint mortgage secured on two full time salaries. Successful business, detached house in south east, new cars on drive way, children in private school.
2.,Thousands in joint savings, plus a buy to let property. Ex cleared out the savings on his way out. Moved into said property.
  1. Both working in business. No previous periods of unemployment.
  2. Plenty of insurance. But you can’t insure against your husband running off with his accountant.,
  3. Together 6 years before first baby, 3 of them married.

Sod all protection.

lynsey91 · 19/07/2021 20:24

@Getawaywithit

If you want more than 2 then you really need to think how you would cope if something happened and not just think you will be able to get enough benefits

People change and are unreliable. My ex said he would dig ditches to support his family. When he decided our marriage was over, that was no longer the case. Other than discuss what would happen if the relationship breaks down, what else do you suggest?

Simple, stick with 2 children.

We don't need large families and 2 is enough for anyone. Then if something unforeseen happens the benefits you will be entitled to cover the 2 children

missymayhemsmum · 19/07/2021 20:21

From a purely selfish point of view, I want every child in my child's school and all the families around me to have a stable home and enough to live on, because that way our community is better, we are safer and the school is full of children who are fed, clothed and ready to learn. I want to live in a society where every child is cared for and supported. That's why I oppose the two child rule. Oh and because I had an unexpected third pregnancy and love her very much and am very glad I could have her and pay the mortgage for the few years I needed help.

Spanielstail · 19/07/2021 19:22

But someone promising to dig ditches is a bit Wooly isn't it?

How about ensure you both paid o to the mortgage so you come out with money towards a new house. Have savings. Maintain a job.

Have critical illness Insurance so the mortgage gets paid if you are sick.

Ensure you are married in a long term relationship before procreating.

None of it is fool proof but combined adds several layers of protection in.

Getawaywithit · 19/07/2021 19:18

If you want more than 2 then you really need to think how you would cope if something happened and not just think you will be able to get enough benefits

People change and are unreliable. My ex said he would dig ditches to support his family. When he decided our marriage was over, that was no longer the case. Other than discuss what would happen if the relationship breaks down, what else do you suggest?

lynsey91 · 19/07/2021 19:14

@ddl1

But they know when they choose to have more than 2 children that should something happen in the future (which it of course could) they will only receive benefit for 2 children. Up to them to make sure they can manage if that happens or not have so many children

But the things that happened in recent years were not things that could have been readily foreseen: the banking crisis of 2008, and the recent and current pandemic. (Or if you think they could have been, why didn't most governments in the UK and worldwide do a better job of planning for them?)

If people didn't have children unless they could be ABSOLUTELY certain of having enough money for them under all possible circumstances - nobody would have any children at all!

Well of course things can't be foreseen. Anyone can lose their job, become ill, have their OH walk out on them as well as major things happening in the UK or world such as covid.

That is why really sticking with 2 children is the sensible thing to do. If you want more than 2 then you really need to think how you would cope if something happened and not just think you will be able to get enough benefits

Getawaywithit · 19/07/2021 17:43

What about taxpayers rights

@Bard6817 You know the majority of people who claim benefits are also taxpayers, right?

Karaokehell2021 · 19/07/2021 15:47

I think its a good thing.

Ju11tne · 19/07/2021 15:47

@dd1 that's not what the poster is saying. You can have children two children at that. If you want to have a bigger family you are now expected to cut your cloth accordingly!