Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 23:46

Yes, they are starting to incentivise, but no, they're not going to be in a mess if they don't.

Starting? Some have being doing it for years. Why do you think so many are doing it then if it's a disaster?

It's not necessarily a question of distrusting immigrants. Developing countries tend to have younger populations & faster growing economies, those young people may not want to move.

Why is overpopulation always framed around children. Why not question the the idea of keeping people alive as long as possible?

shiningstar2 · 09/07/2021 23:45

I think that the 2 child rule is about right. The world environment cannot sustain massive population expansion. Even without extra child benefit, extra children are very expensive for the State to support. Extra births, education and a life time of health provision to be found. Then there are jobs training and jobs to find and/or State provision if jobs can't be found or are low paid. Each extra child will also have children, impacting on the world environment resources. How can this be sustained?

We had an only child because we couldn't afford more when we were on low wages and before there were working tax credits ext. We had a choice of low paid employment or Unemployment Benefit. No top ups for low paid workers. We chose the low paid employment. We chose to have the one child although we would have liked more. I often wonder if it would have been a better choice to see how we would have managed with more on the low wages without top ups even for up to two but we made the choices we did at the time. Now there is the possibility for top ups to wages for the first two but no more people have to make their own choices too ...stop at two or have more but without the extra support. Different times. Hard choices either way.

jacks11 · 09/07/2021 23:34

I think it is reasonable to have a policy that state supports two children (as far as I’m aware if the second pregnancy is twin/triplet then they are exempt). You can chose to have 1 or 20 children, nobody is stopping you, but the state will only give you benefits for 2. So, you must cut your cloth according to your means. If you can only afford to house, feed and clothe etc 2 children, then 1 or 2 is what you have. It’s called being a responsible adult and parent.

I am not in receipt of benefits. I earn £x per year. My wages do not go up if i have another child, nobody is going to come along and give me a bigger home. When we were deciding to have children, we had to look at what kind of lifestyle we wanted, how that fitted into how many children we could feasibly support and maintain that, or whether we wanted a larger family but with fewer luxuries.

The same should be true of those reliant solely on benefits and those on lower incomes who get additional benefits. Why on earth shouldn’t they be expected to match the size of their family to their ability to support them? Why are they allowed to behave irresponsibly by having more children than they can afford, in the expectation that the state will pick up the tab?

OverTheRubicon · 09/07/2021 23:31

@coulditbecominghome

No they're not.

Err @OverTheRubicon plenty of countries do incentivise.

Yes, they are starting to incentivise, but no, they're not going to be in a mess if they don't. Far more likely that they'll be in a mess if they do - with China allowing more children, and birth rates in many of the poorest and most climate change affected parts of the world continuing high, there will be no lack of young people. At the same time, jobs are being automated and outsourced at an astonishing rate - so far it's mostly hit the less skilled, who have often been a bit sneered at by the same people in white collar and higher paid jobs who are about to see their own roles, from accountants to actuaries to radiologists, also increasingly automated away and partially outsourced (and in all those cases, it's already happening).

So if countries are incentivising people to have children, they're essentially saying that they distrust immigrants and technology so much that they'd rather see the world burn. That's pretty awful.

Graphista · 09/07/2021 23:29

every poster here who signs up to child poverty. Bastards.

Yet none of them has the true guts to admit it!

but @Foxglovesandlilacs86 sums up the blind privilege

Well exactly!

You were raised right!

@BarbarianMum I don't think we're "confused" at all! We just aren't advocating starving children - which ANYONE supporting or not being against this bill IS!

The thing is, the tax payer has been conned into believing this is saving them money. So true

@Standrewsschool I heartily disagree - there's a LOT of "I'm alright Jack" on this thread - and I'm afraid a lot of it is coming from people who may well find...

A - they'll be the ones needing this support in the future

And/or

B - they will be the next target of govt "saving"

That woman on question time had happily voted Tory - inc voting for benefits cuts - while she thought it wouldn't affect her! Then when it did she was angry and distressed and scared for her and her family's future - so similar posters here really need to think on

nobody wants to let children starve

I disagree the more extreme posters here do, and I am certain that this govt doesn't gaf about poor kids until it becomes a potential vote loser for them! Like when a footy player shames them

What is the solution?

How about we start with compassion? With fairness?

How about we start with the costs of mps beyond what they actually need to do the job - pretty sure we can save several billion by stopping expenses, 2nd homes, top class transport, then paying salaries to their wives and kids...

Then how about clamping down on tax evasion

And tax avoidance

On corporate fraud

Stop "spaffing" money on vanity projects and ill thought out and poorly costed policies

Make employers pay an actual living wage so that those in work aren't needing top ups - that would free up a fair amount of money

Stop pissing away money on "paper shuffling" ie "reforms" of things like education that aren't actually necessary

Address the housing crisis and bring housing costs (the main cost for most households) down. Ban mps from being landlords and property developers while sitting as mps - it's a conflict of interest and when you examine voting records mps with these interests almost always vote against anything that makes housing regs more fair, safe, secure and affordable

Address the issue of energy, water and telecom companies charging extortionate amounts and being headquartered overseas and therefore taking their profits within the Uk but paying sod all taxes and not paying to fix when they fuck up either but leaving govt to clean up their messes

Just for starters...

The money IS there it's the political and ideological will - and basic human compassion and empathy that isn't

Getawaywithit · 09/07/2021 23:07

Very little sympathy OP from taxpayers

You realise, of course, that by far the majority of people who claim benefits are also tax payers?

TheNameTheWebsiteForgot · 09/07/2021 22:58

Aged 16 I had a child (this was many moons ago). I was young single mum and on benefits.

When my child was 2yrs old I was funded to go back to college. Books, travel, food and childcare all paid for. It changed my life chances. Straight after college I was working, degree and post grad later I'm still working in a well paid job.

2 years of support = 30 years of paying tax.

I'm not saying this would work for everyone but you either spend time and money on groups providing real help.. or you fund them for a life time.

Puffalicious · 09/07/2021 22:45

The tax payer just spends more on things like children's social care, and then further down the line will need to invest in MH services and crime. As child poverty will cause a crisis in this area further down the line

Hallelujah. Someone with a holistic view. Like the Danish government who invested heavily in early years care 30 years ago: it's now paying for itself AND creating funds as they have a huge reduction in the bill for social work intervention, care, MH, crime and benefits.

FTEngineerM · 09/07/2021 22:43

What is the solution?

Say if infinite amounts of children were covered by the state; there would be nothing stopping some having more and more. If you work and can’t afford more children so you have no choice to stop having them.. what barrier is there for ones who don’t work and can’t afford more children?

And don’t respond with starving children.., even in caps, I get it nobody wants to let children starve obviously

What exactly does the government do?

Standrewsschool · 09/07/2021 22:41

“Actually EVERY SINGLE PERSON who is saying they support this decision is saying PRECISELY that “

No, I think that are saying they want people to take responsibility for their family size, and not to have more children if they can’t afford them/expect others to pay for them.

As cited on this and other similar threads, many working parents stop at one or two children due to financial reasons.

Puffalicious · 09/07/2021 22:39

@BarbarianMum

You can scream and stamp all you like but you are convincing very few people. And you are confusing "not seeing the reality" with "not thinking this is a good solution to the problem".
There's no screaming or stamping, just open discussion. I don't wish to be patronised, least of all by a Tory. If you know the reality what is your solution then? It needs systematic change and investment, but I don't see the right suggesting any of that. As PP have said, can we start with PROPER taxing of big business?
Viviennemary · 09/07/2021 22:39

It is overall a good thing if people have less children. I happened upon a world population site. The increase is terrifying. No way should anybody be encouraging more children.

plumpuddisnice · 09/07/2021 22:39

@worktrip

Very little sympathy OP from taxpayers.
The thing is, the tax payer has been conned into believing this is saving them money.

It doesn't. The tax payer just spends more on things like children's social care, and then further down the line will need to invest in MH services and crime. As child poverty will cause a crisis in this area further down the line.

worktrip · 09/07/2021 22:35

Very little sympathy OP from taxpayers.

Boomclaps · 09/07/2021 22:33

@Whatinthelord

Starting to feel decidedly ‘Daily Mail’ in here.

I thought family size reduced inline with increases in education, wealth and access to healthcare?
Poorer, less educated populations tend to have larger families. So, from that stand point, wouldn’t it be better for people concerned about overpopulation to support better benefits, better access to healthcare and education?

…but na….let’s take a few quid of the families of vulnerable children instead.

YESSS what a logical comment thanks @Whatinthelord
omgthepain · 09/07/2021 22:33

If people can't afford to have children and support them on their wages why should the government pay for extra children??

Some people have 7,8,9+ kids it's a ridiculous idea to pay for them all there needs to be a cut off I think it's quite reasonable but I also think it shouldn't have been for new claims it should have been for people already in the system as it isn't fair to pay for some families with 3 or more kids and not others

They need to be consistent with their approach

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 22:33

There are already discussions about raising the age of free prescriptions to state pension age. I don't expect to see either when I'm old!

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 22:30

@Puffalicious the crazy thing is how some fall for it. The divide & conquer. In reality this won't save any money & they will be going after the next group soon.

Runnerduck34 · 09/07/2021 22:19

Dreadful policy, the ones that suffer from it most will be the children.
Some families will have more than 2 children, be paying their way quite happily but if there was a change of circumstances such as parents develop ill health or lose their jobs they will be penalised.
I didn't know about appeal but its very sad they lost.

BarbarianMum · 09/07/2021 22:19

You can scream and stamp all you like but you are convincing very few people. And you are confusing "not seeing the reality" with "not thinking this is a good solution to the problem".

Puffalicious · 09/07/2021 22:18

Thought you might couldit. Solidarity.

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 22:15

@Puffalicious I work in education & I also see the reality.

coulditbecominghome · 09/07/2021 22:14

@Graphista but @Foxglovesandlilacs86 sums up the blind privilege.

"have family support. No mortgage, we own a few successful businesses and have inherited properties that we rent out"

So basically benefited from family but think children who don't have that opportunity should suffer.

My parents did very well for themselves & have been able to help me. However they were both immigrants & it was drummed into my head how fortunate I was.

Puffalicious · 09/07/2021 22:13

Apologies for the rant and the politics, it's my number one issue that riles me. No-one could witness what I witness and still support this bill.

Puffalicious · 09/07/2021 22:11

Yes Graphista shame on them all.

Your list of 'luck' is so accurate I want to print it out and stick it on the walls of every poster here who signs up to child poverty. Bastards.

If they saw what I see every day, if they worried every summer holidays about the kids that they won't see every day they might understand why I call them utter bastards. The 'I'm alright attitude' purported by Thatcher is threaded through our society ( sorry, she said there was no such thing as society, the fucking sociopath). I'm proud to live in a society that holds each other up. How long that exists remains to be seen with the Tories in power.

Swipe left for the next trending thread