Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 10/07/2021 09:51

[quote coulditbecominghome]@AlexaShutUp they read it in the Fail so it must be true 🤦🏻‍♀️[/quote]
Indeed.

It's utterly depressing that so many people have so little awareness or empathy for people who live in circumstances that are different from their own. That they assume that people who have somehow fallen on hard times may inevitably be to blame because they haven't worked hard enough or because they haven't planned carefully enough or because they have made poor decisions. Yes, in some cases, some or all of those things may be true, but in other cases, people are just fucking unlucky. It's a shame that some people are so unable to step outside of their privileged little bubbles that they are unable to see how incredibly fortunate they are.

CounsellorTroi · 10/07/2021 09:48

It must disproportionately affect people who have a religious and or cultural imperative against contraception and or in favour of larger families.

Religious/cultural imperatives that take choice and control over their bodies away from women can fuck off as far as I’m concerned.

ExitThisWay · 10/07/2021 09:41

I had more than 2 children, which as a family we could afford. My husband became abusive and I left. He is now not working. So I’m not entitled to child maintenance payments through CMS. Struggling to see how this policy is fair to be honest. It’s like I’m being punished for leaving an abusive relationship.

DynamoKev · 10/07/2021 09:39

I have always been a bit surprised that the cap wasn’t judged as indirect discrimination against religious and cultural propensity for larger families.

It must disproportionately affect people who have a religious and or cultural imperative against contraception and or in favour of larger families.

Viviennemary · 10/07/2021 09:29

Of course working tax credit is a benefit. How can it not be.

coulditbecominghome · 10/07/2021 09:27

@AlexaShutUp they read it in the Fail so it must be true 🤦🏻‍♀️

LobotomisedIceSkatingFan · 10/07/2021 09:27

I agree that WTC should never have been termed a 'benefit'.
That said - I'm on them and have 3 kids; only the first two are on the claim. I think that's probably fair enough. Those who claim for five, six, seven kids are very much in 'taking the puss' territory'.

coulditbecominghome · 10/07/2021 09:27

It's ok to admit you're wrong or you don't understand.

Yes it is prudent to have insurance, no one has stated otherwise.

The issue is the idea that insurance will completely mitigate the financial impact of a parent becoming incapacitated, which the poster you mentioned also disagreed with.

As I already mentioned upthread. It is often difficult to get critical illness cover for certain cancers, losing a limb, hereditary or pre existing conditions, etc. You would know this if you had ever had a policy yourself.

And many insurances are a benefit of work eg private health or death in service which not every employee is eligible for.

CounsellorTroi · 10/07/2021 09:27

Just wondering how things work when a woman has children from successive relationships. Am I right in thinking that if a woman had two children with one man, they split up and she has a third with a new partner, that she is not eligible for benefit for that child?

AlexaShutUp · 10/07/2021 09:21

Why do people keep banging on about life insurance and critical illness cover. I am fortunate enough to be able to have these in place, but a lot of people simply cannot afford such luxuries as they need every last penny to pay for their day to day needs. Are people really so unaware of how a large section of the population lives?

CounsellorTroi · 10/07/2021 09:16

[quote FTEngineerM]@RocksOnTheHill there’s way more available that the pill or coil. You can combine methods such as cycle tracking (avoiding fertile days entirely) and condoms/femidoms, ring and condoms, cap and condoms.

Or cycle track (avoiding fertile days entirely) and use condoms and a vagina ring or cap or something and that is a triple whammy.

If someone took all those precautions and still found themselves pregnant and didn’t want to be abortions are free too if they wanted one. We are lucky in this country.[/quote]
And there’s always vasectomy or sterilisation. I know even they aren’t 100%, but as close as is possible to be.

lynsey91 · 10/07/2021 09:16

@coulditbecominghome

But you stated that insurance would mitigate any financial impact if a parent died or become ill if you stuck to 2 kids?

And yet you have no experience of said insurance or any insurance?

Glad we both agree you don't know what you're talking about 👍🏼

Other posters talked about having insurance in place in case circumstances changed. One poster has even said who her insurance is with.

To gaily have child after child and have no idea what you would do if you lost your job etc is just bloody stupid.

Puffalicious · 10/07/2021 09:13

lynsey91 I'm not saying that-
many will have very young siblings, but not all- . What I am also saying is that I see terrible poverty and this cap is just one example of how things will be made even worse for some children.. I'm saying that holistically poverty is a complex issue and needs looking at very carefully by the best, non-political brains there are. We need solutions, proper, human solutions. I don't think a cap.is that solution. Like I've said, investment and systematic change is the solution. The money is there if we close the massive tax loops for big business.

CantGetNoSleep73 · 10/07/2021 09:12

The whole system is a joke tbh - I have three kids, a ds and twin dds. I don't get wtc but it's not like I planned three children. I had a son and then twins which were a complete surprise. Same for CB why is it fair that two people in the same household can earn £49k each and still get CB but one earner above and it's stopped.

I still know people with 6 kids and still having more, they never worked a day in their lives and never intend to and play the system very well, they bloody joke about how cushy life is. That's who should be targeted, not those who are trying to make ends meet.

AlexaShutUp · 10/07/2021 09:10

Why should the state pay for more than 2 kids?

Because innocent children should not be expected to suffer, even if their parents have been feckless or irresponsible.

Why don't people understand that, while some families might stop at two because of this policy, there will be many more who do not, for a whole range of different reasons. And once those children are here, it matters not a jot whether or not their parents are "deserving". What matters is the welfare of the child, surely?

Do people really think it's OK in a civilised society for us to turn a blind eye to children living in such extreme poverty that their parents can't afford to heat the house or put food on the table? What have we come to if we have stopped caring about this?

GiantHaystacks2021 · 10/07/2021 09:00

2 is enough.
Contraception is pretty much free.
People need to start taking responsibility for their own actions.
Why should the state pay for more than 2 kids?

Getawaywithit · 10/07/2021 08:54

The same should be true of those reliant solely on benefits and those on lower incomes who get additional benefits. Why on earth shouldn’t they be expected to match the size of their family to their ability to support them? Why are they allowed to behave irresponsibly by having more children than they can afford, in the expectation that the state will pick up the tab?

Erm,,,you know that people fall on hard times? Have children they can afford and then something goes wrong?

coulditbecominghome · 10/07/2021 08:41

But you stated that insurance would mitigate any financial impact if a parent died or become ill if you stuck to 2 kids?

And yet you have no experience of said insurance or any insurance?

Glad we both agree you don't know what you're talking about 👍🏼

lynsey91 · 10/07/2021 08:38

[quote coulditbecominghome]@lynsey91 You're back, can I please have the name of the insurance company you use? [/quote]
Oh you are still droning on are you? I don't use an insurance company because I was sensible enough not to have children. Get it now?

coulditbecominghome · 10/07/2021 08:37

Oh & the people who got CB or the equivalent when it wasn't means tested are they still considered scroungers by you or is only those who currently get CB that are scroungers?

lynsey91 · 10/07/2021 08:37

@Puffalicious

Exactly OP. I work in a school with a high percentage of school meal entitlement- I know for sure a huge amount of these kids only get that one hot meal a day. Our dinner ladies know the kids who seem hungry to give a bit more to. The sheer amount of kids who sign up for after school activities/ supported study because there are snacks is unreal. The kids who turn up super early and stay super late because they don't want to go home is increasing. Food banks in the area are bursting with need. There's constant shout outs on social media for school shoes/ school trainers. The amount who come to school in the winter from freezing houses and with no coat is shocking (we provide what we can). I'm at the chalk face every day. This is poverty. It needs systematic change and investment not the cutting of benefits.

The chat of those so privileged they cannot see this makes me so sad. Walk a week in the (split) shoes of these children and come back and tell me about privilege.

Children in school will be at least 5 which means they were born before the cap even came in.

Are you saying that every single one of those children who only get the one hot meal a day, live in freezing houses, have no shoes etc have younger brothers or sisters that were born after the cap? I doubt that very much.

coulditbecominghome · 10/07/2021 08:36

@lynsey91 You're back, can I please have the name of the insurance company you use?

lynsey91 · 10/07/2021 08:31

@coulditbecominghome

It was actually Family Allowance and, no, you didn't get it for the first child

Again it depends when you were born.

My parents definitely got it for their first & it wasn't means tested.

Well obviously it depends on when you were born. As I said (twice) my parents didn't get it for me
PickAChew · 09/07/2021 23:51

@IceCreamAndCandyfloss

Some people will accidentally get pregnant and not wish to terminate the pregnancy. Some people will experience a change in circumstances through illness, disability or redundancy etc that mean they are no longer able to afford the family that they had planned

Contraception is free and methods can be used together so there’s really no need to be “accidentally” pregnant if a person doesn’t want to be. Yes job losses etc can happen but it’s not hard to think I can afford x now but could only afford x if I wasn’t working and make a decision that’s financially sound if things change. Or have good insurance in place or savings.

Contraception does fail.

Some (too many) women are in abusive relationships in which they are repeatedly raped.

People's circumstances do change in ways they can't imagine.

Cheeserton · 09/07/2021 23:49

Your post does not present an actual question to vote on for yabu/yanbu.

Swipe left for the next trending thread