Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two Child Limit

705 replies

MobilityCat · 09/07/2021 16:00

Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Getawaywithit · 26/07/2021 10:45

Maybe those women could plan and save before having children, so that they are able to provide?

So before you had your children, you personally had sufficient money in the bank to be able to support your children, come rain or shine, for a minimum of 18 years? You factored in loss of wages should it have turned out that one of your children needed full time care? You were able to pay the mortgage on your family home by yourself? And you could also pay the mortgage, bills and childcare without any additional support from anyone?

Drivingbuttercup1 · 25/07/2021 21:52

My point is that women A and Women B have reached their limit where the man in the situation can move on to women c and have more children.

lynsey91 · 25/07/2021 13:50

@ddl1

Can't afford children? Don't have them!

I agree as regards people who currently can't afford to look after children; it's not like our ancestors who had no reliable contraception. But all sorts of unknowns can come up in the future; and in recent years we've had two totally unexpected disasters: the banking crisis and the pandemic.

If we're going to demand that no one have children unless they're absolutely sure they'd be able to cope with any eventuality, then there will be an awful lot of childless families and an awful lot of only children. We've already moved to some extent in that direction. Maybe it's desirable in some ways - and certainly the two-child cap is preferable to policies in some countries that actively encourage people to have as large families as possible, for religious or nationalistic reasons. But we also have to consider the possible disadvantages, especially with an ageing population; and certainly not assume that everyone should have a crystal ball to predict and deal with all possible disasters - especially as governments don't seem to be great at that!

As I and other have said already, if you stick to 2 children and then something happens that you need benefits, you will get benefits for both children. If you have more than 2 you will only get for 2.

So the moral is stick to 2 children and then no matter what happens you will get help.

So, no it doesn't mean more childfree families (although more and more couples are choosing to remain childfree) or lots of only children

ddl1 · 25/07/2021 12:54

Can't afford children? Don't have them!

I agree as regards people who currently can't afford to look after children; it's not like our ancestors who had no reliable contraception. But all sorts of unknowns can come up in the future; and in recent years we've had two totally unexpected disasters: the banking crisis and the pandemic.

If we're going to demand that no one have children unless they're absolutely sure they'd be able to cope with any eventuality, then there will be an awful lot of childless families and an awful lot of only children. We've already moved to some extent in that direction. Maybe it's desirable in some ways - and certainly the two-child cap is preferable to policies in some countries that actively encourage people to have as large families as possible, for religious or nationalistic reasons. But we also have to consider the possible disadvantages, especially with an ageing population; and certainly not assume that everyone should have a crystal ball to predict and deal with all possible disasters - especially as governments don't seem to be great at that!

Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 25/07/2021 12:44

I think the decision was correct. Paying for two is already very generous on top of schooling, healthcare etc.People are free to have as many children, they just have to ensure they can afford their choices.. Supporting children financially is a parenting basic

This. Can't afford children? Don't have them!

ChunkySloth · 25/07/2021 12:30

@pam290358

If women b can claim benifits then this is a law just for women and unfair. Man can have as many children as he wants.

If women cant claim it's still unfair as she wont be able to have children as she wont be able to provide.

Whether we like the cap or not it's very, very unfair.

Surely the benefit is paid to the parent with care in a case like this. Woman A is unlikely to have custody of woman B’s children so where’s the problem?

Maybe those women could plan and save before having children, so that they are able to provide?
pam290358 · 25/07/2021 12:26

If women b can claim benifits then this is a law just for women and unfair. Man can have as many children as he wants.

If women cant claim it's still unfair as she wont be able to have children as she wont be able to provide.

Whether we like the cap or not it's very, very unfair.

Surely the benefit is paid to the parent with care in a case like this. Woman A is unlikely to have custody of woman B’s children so where’s the problem?

Booboosweet · 25/07/2021 00:31

I think the cap is a great idea. Hopefully it will discourage people from having more children than they can afford. I'm hoping they'll bring it in in Ireland where I live. At the moment child benefit is unlimited here.

Drivingbuttercup1 · 25/07/2021 00:23

So doesnt this enable men to have children carefree with multiple women but women to only have two.

Viviennemary · 24/07/2021 21:11

Goes on number of children in the household claiming I read. So a man can have two children each by multiple women and they can all claim.

Spanielstail · 24/07/2021 19:37

I always wondered how this works if a man has two children with a women A, she then claims benefits but then man goes on to have more children with women B. Will women B be able to claim? As man is already claiming benefits for his two children

Don't have two more children if you couldn't afford the first two?

Ju11tne · 24/07/2021 17:52

@Dervel that was my thought process too.

Dervel · 24/07/2021 16:08

Correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t it the resident parent who get the benefits? So if any man had two children and was the main parent, he too would run into trouble in terms of having two more if he was relying on benefits?

SomethingOnce · 24/07/2021 15:58

Yes everyone knows. And it’s not relevant. Net contributors is what people are talking about here. You know that too. Net contribution is what funds the system, simple math

Let’s not forget though, the numbers people are assigned to represent their narrowly defined ‘value’ (salary, income), that then determine their ‘contribution’ (tax), aren’t necessarily reflective of anything meaningful.

Many people, whose real value to society isn’t at all clear Hmm pull in big ‘value’ numbers (while efficiently minimising their ‘contribution’), and get to tell the rest of us we’re not worth nearly as much.

Fervent belief in the existing system goes a long way, of course, but it is a bit made up.

Getawaywithit · 24/07/2021 14:17

Yes everyone knows. And it’s not relevant. Net contributors is what people are talking about here. You know that too. Net contribution is what funds the system, simple math

Yeah, only net contributors matter. I’m a teacher. And a single parent. According to people like you, I’m not relevant. There are a lot of essential workers out there who have deemed ‘not relevant’. I am at the point of jacking it all in, you might have just lost the education system yet another decent teacher.

Not fucking relevant. Jesus wept.

blissfulllife · 24/07/2021 09:09

@Drivingbuttercup1

I always wondered how this works if a man has two children with a women A, she then claims benefits but then man goes on to have more children with women B. Will women B be able to claim? As man is already claiming benefits for his two children
This....with bells on
sst1234 · 24/07/2021 09:08

@missymayhemsmum

From a purely selfish point of view, I want every child in my child's school and all the families around me to have a stable home and enough to live on, because that way our community is better, we are safer and the school is full of children who are fed, clothed and ready to learn. I want to live in a society where every child is cared for and supported. That's why I oppose the two child rule. Oh and because I had an unexpected third pregnancy and love her very much and am very glad I could have her and pay the mortgage for the few years I needed help.
Only if handing out free money could create stable homes, eh? I think we know how that worked out, the years of benefits for limitless children in the early 2000s created a underclass where it actually became a trap for people who let it become a lifestyle choice. When any form financial assistance goes from being safety net to a comfy mattress, people are not going to try to lift themselves off it. Human nature.
sst1234 · 24/07/2021 09:03

@Getawaywithit

What about taxpayers rights

@Bard6817 You know the majority of people who claim benefits are also taxpayers, right?

Yes everyone knows. And it’s not relevant. Net contributors is what people are talking about here. You know that too. Net contribution is what funds the system, simple math.
Drivingbuttercup1 · 24/07/2021 07:36

If women b can claim benifits then this is a law just for women and unfair. Man can have as many children as he wants.

If women cant claim it's still unfair as she wont be able to have children as she wont be able to provide.

Whether we like the cap or not it's very, very unfair.

sunglassesonthetable · 24/07/2021 07:24

I always wondered how this works if a man has two children with a women A, she then claims benefits but then man goes on to have more children with women B. Will women B be able to claim? As man is already claiming benefits for his two children

you hit the nail on the head.

Drivingbuttercup1 · 24/07/2021 07:17

I always wondered how this works if a man has two children with a women A, she then claims benefits but then man goes on to have more children with women B. Will women B be able to claim? As man is already claiming benefits for his two children

anxiouscrazymum · 24/07/2021 06:58

There should be a an contingency for special circumstances, like losing your job, family bereavement, new illness. However this must be for people that have worked.
For those that do not work then they shouldn't not get any additional money for more than 2 children.

Viviennemary · 23/07/2021 21:39

A good way to stop child poverty is for folk not to have more children than they can afford. And yes I would support maternity pay being restricted to two children.

ChunkySloth · 23/07/2021 16:40

[quote MobilityCat]Will you be affected? Campaigners have lost their legal challenge to the government's two-child limit on welfare payments.
They had argued the policy breached parents' and children's human rights. The Supreme Court dismissed their case.
The rule, which came into force in April 2017, restricts child tax credit and universal credit to the first two children in a family, with a few exceptions.
It was one of George Osborne's most debated austerity measures.
The policy has affected families of about one million children. Campaigners described the decision as "hugely disappointing".
Full story here www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57776103[/quote]
Well it doesn't affect their rights, does it?Confused they are free to have as many children as they like, so long as they pay for them.

Ju11tne · 23/07/2021 16:27

@missymayhemsmum

Love the contrast between this thread and one on whether taking a third maternity leave is taking the piss.

Do those who support the two-child rule think that maternity pay/leave should also be restricted to two pregnancies? If not why not? In the UK statutory maternity paid is reclaimed from the state by the employer

So what's your point about mat pay exactly?

The 2 children rule isn't about about stopping support in every area... it's just stopping some people taking the full on piss. As you can see some people would have 2+ kids without a second thought of the costs.