Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
LemonRoses · 13/07/2021 17:43

@lazylinguist

The pro-uniform people just go "la la la" and stick their fingers in their ears when anyone asks them how come schools in other countries manage perfectly well without uniforms, or asks for any evidence that wearing a uniform magically makes children behave better.
Not at all. It’s about self selecting social groups, for us. You look at the schools (such as many free schools) that attract middle classes and aspirational cohorts and one means of silent selection is through strict uniform policy. The parents likely to support blazers, ties correctly knotted and uniform coats are also likely to be parents who enforce other boundaries. That results in cohorts who have similar standards and attitudes towards school. As a parent, I’d want my children in a school where they had peers that had same ambition and parents that supported them to realise their ambition. Attitudes to learning start very young, achievement is started at nursery level and grows with the children.

The uniform itself is broadly irrelevant, but the culture underneath is very important. Where nobody wears uniform, it’s clearly not the same. Germany notably doesn’t encourage the wear uniforms but it does have a very differentiated school system at secondary level.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 17:40

Exactly. Going to a non-uniform school, that issue was pretty rare due to the lax dress code. The gist was as long as your clothes didn’t show anything inappropriate (undergarments) or say anything inappropriate you were fine. They didn’t care about nail polish, piercings, or what colour hair you had.

Yes - my kids' school dress codes were a one-line sentence. Something like no offensive phrases and no hats. They do have to wear closed-toe shoes in labs and workshops.

Turns out kids can learn just as well with multiple piercings, green hair, ripped jeans and flip flops on as they can in uniforms, and teachers get to focus on stuff like teaching rather than policing how many earrings Alexis is wearing.

kowari · 13/07/2021 17:39

@LemonRoses

We would have consciously avoided schools where the children wore jogging pants after nursery age. They need to have a clear differentiation between lounging around at home and a working environment.
Jogging pants are for sporting activities. Primary aged children run around, play games, do outside learning, do activities on the floor. Jogging pants are entirely appropriate for those activities.
Fizbosshoes · 13/07/2021 17:38

The pro-uniform people just go "la la la" and stick their fingers in their ears when anyone asks them how come schools in other countries manage perfectly well without uniforms, or asks for any evidence that wearing a uniform magically makes children behave better.

And manage to ignore that an enormous number of jobs and careers are not dependent on wearing blazers, kilts, ties, or skirts of a requisite length. The industry I work in is largely made up of small companies (up to 20 people) and self employed. One of my clients owns several shopping centres as well as other businesses. He wears jeans and trainers most days. I can think of one person who regularly wears a suit and tie.

The head teacher of my DC suggested children would look after aka not lose their uniform if it was new and branded!! Grin because obviously no one (adult or child) ever loses expensive things!

lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 17:13

The pro-uniform people just go "la la la" and stick their fingers in their ears when anyone asks them how come schools in other countries manage perfectly well without uniforms, or asks for any evidence that wearing a uniform magically makes children behave better.

phoenixrosehere · 13/07/2021 17:12

Girls can easily turn school uniform into a hooker outfit if they want to. At my school girls wore mini skirts to the top of their thighs, platform shoes, wonderbras under tight white button up shirts, heavy make up. Staff tried to police it constantly and failed. I remember girls being hauled out in assembly and shouted at for too short skirts. Girls being made to remove eye makeup and nail varnish in front of the class. It didn’t stop them.

Exactly. Going to a non-uniform school, that issue was pretty rare due to the lax dress code. The gist was as long as your clothes didn’t show anything inappropriate (undergarments) or say anything inappropriate you were fine. They didn’t care about nail polish, piercings, or what colour hair you had. A friend of mine had 13 piercings, 6 on one ear and 7 on the other and she was an honour roll student from primary through secondary.

A shirt with inappropriate words one would have to wear inside out.

Trousers sagging (mainly boys), a padlock would be placed on them to hold them up (you would have it removed at the end of the day) or expected to wear gym shorts or joggers (we were allowed to pick our own gym clothes as long as they were appropriate for sports and met the dress code).

Low-cut or tight-fitting tops, you would have to wear your PE shirt, borrow something from a friend, or wear a coat/jacket/cardigan for the rest of the day. If you didn’t have any of that, you could either call your parents to bring you something, purchase one from the school (£6-8, which you can pay either that day or at the end of the year) or go through the lost and found. If it was a one-off, school was more inclined to let you borrow one (had laundry facilities) or if they knew of your family’s financial situation.

There was no way you would be sent home. However, if you were a repeat offender, your parents would be contacted for a meeting and you would serve a Saturday detention.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 17:11

@Parker231

What about the schools in Europe, Canada and North America - the majority don’t have a school uniform but have high achieving schools (nephews and niece went to schools in these countries).
But just think what those poor non-uniform school kids could have achieved if they'd been lucky enough to wear scratchy polyester uniforms to learn in! Grin
StrangeToSee · 13/07/2021 17:09

We would have consciously avoided schools where the children wore jogging pants after nursery age. They need to have a clear differentiation between lounging around at home and a working environment

Isn’t that learned behaviour though, associating smart formal trousers with schoolwork and joggers with lounging?

If they wore joggers to school you could dress them in something else at home to make it seem different eg leggings/jeans/yoga pants or joggers in a different style/colour?

I don’t see how children being comfortable sitting, standing, climbing (yes our school has an adventure playground and they wear uniform in it) could possibly hamper learning? Unless we teach them that formal and uncomfortable= work.

CecilyP · 13/07/2021 16:55

I agree with uniforms and can't get my head round why any parent thinks their princess should be allowed to go to school dressed like a hooker if they so wish.

I can’t get my head around why you think there are only 2 alternatives!

You all knew that kids would be required to wear a uniform before you became pregnant with them so why the mock outrage?

Seriously? So you think people shouldn’t have children if they don’t like school uniforms! In any case, many parents would have seen their local school changing from a simple polo shirt and sweatshirt combo to a more formal, expensive blazer-heavy uniform between pregnancy and their child attending. And I don’t think anyone could have anticipated the extent of the expensive uniform PE kits!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/07/2021 16:51

They need to have a clear differentiation between lounging around at home and a working environment

Why? Mine works better at home than at school. Why isn’t comfort the priority? I lecture in fashion history. I find some of the posts on here just bizarre. Like they are stuck in the 1950’s

We live in a casual age in terms of dress. It’s the schools that are out of step not the workplaces. People need to move with the times. Work dress is much more relaxed than even 15 years ago. Schools need to keep up!

The main key to enhance learning would be comfort. So not tight polyester trousers or scratchy blazers. Just jeans/leggings and hoodies is what they need.

TiddyAndFletch · 13/07/2021 16:46

@TeenMinusTests

Given how casual most offices are these days I don’t understand why schools are ever more draconian.

However many jobs do often require a uniform:

  • airline pilot
  • shop worker
  • vet nurse
  • railway worker
to name a few.
A key difference is that a uniform at work is supplied - you don't have to fork out for it, and you can even claim tax relief on the cost of cleaning it.
Parker231 · 13/07/2021 16:45

[quote GreenLakes]@Parker231

Both myself and DH are in professional roles and are expected to dress accordingly.

We’d both be marched straight to senior management if we turned up in shorts![/quote]
GreenLakes - I am senior management in a global corporate finance organisation. I have no problem if any of my teams attend work in shorts or jeans. I judge by the quality of their work not by their outfit.

Parker231 · 13/07/2021 16:42

What about the schools in Europe, Canada and North America - the majority don’t have a school uniform but have high achieving schools (nephews and niece went to schools in these countries).

TheKeatingFive · 13/07/2021 16:41

But the vast majority benefit from the focus and discipline provided by a uniform.

You don’t have a single shred of evidence to support this.

You just keep parroting it.

That doesn’t make it true, the experience of children all over the world testifies to that.

GreenLakes · 13/07/2021 16:37

@Parker231

Clearly some DC like your DS can work hard while wearing casual clothing.

But the vast majority benefit from the focus and discipline provided by a uniform.

Pinuporc · 13/07/2021 16:35

You all knew that kids would be required to wear a uniform before you became pregnant with them so why the mock outrage?

I saw local kids wearing school uniform before my kids started school. I dont have a problem with uniform. I do have a problem with being forced to buy it from one supplier and having to make an appointment to go to the overpriced shop when I could get some almost but not quite the same for half the price in M and S. And the kids blazers didnt have price tags attached so no I didnt know that some (state) school blazers are over £100.

Parker231 · 13/07/2021 16:32

@LemonRoses - why?

DS is finishing his masters at Uni - he has spent the last four years in jeans or shorts. He has a 1st - what difference would wearing more formal clothes have made. He went to a non uniform school from ages 4-18 and left with all A’s.

TheKeatingFive · 13/07/2021 16:27

They need to have a clear differentiation between lounging around at home and a working environment.

Why do clothes have to provide that differentiation?

And how do most other countries school children and the vast majority of professional services manage it I wonder?

LemonRoses · 13/07/2021 16:21

We would have consciously avoided schools where the children wore jogging pants after nursery age. They need to have a clear differentiation between lounging around at home and a working environment.

lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 16:05

What makes me laugh is that schools basically have uniforms because parents like them, not because they're under any illusion that it makes the students or school any better. But then the same parents who loved the idea of their little year 7 angels in the smart blazer spend the next 5 years moaning about buying uniform and their child having to stick to the uniform rules!

tennisballboy · 13/07/2021 16:02

@chocolateorangeinhaler

I agree with uniforms and can't get my head round why any parent thinks their princess should be allowed to go to school dressed like a hooker if they so wish. You all knew that kids would be required to wear a uniform before you became pregnant with them so why the mock outrage?
😂😂😂 you are a loon!
StrangeToSee · 13/07/2021 14:33

I agree with uniforms and can't get my head round why any parent thinks their princess should be allowed to go to school dressed like a hooker if they so wish. You all knew that kids would be required to wear a uniform before you became pregnant with them so why the mock outrage?

Girls can easily turn school uniform into a hooker outfit if they want to. At my school girls wore mini skirts to the top of their thighs, platform shoes, wonderbras under tight white button up shirts, heavy make up. Staff tried to police it constantly and failed. I remember girls being hauled out in assembly and shouted at for too short skirts. Girls being made to remove eye makeup and nail varnish in front of the class. It didn’t stop them.

I hoped by the time I had kids uniforms would have become more relaxed eg school colours and comfortable joggers and sweaters. Some schools have. Many haven’t reached that yet.

StrangeToSee · 13/07/2021 14:26

‘Joggers with zip pockets could work too’

Yes- for lounging around at home. Not for a school! DC need to be in a working mindset which is very difficult in joggers and tracksuits.

I’m genuinely curious here. Why do you think a working mindset requires smart clothes?

I spend all my working day in scrubs (that resemble pjs) and trainers. I have no difficulty getting into a working mindset. Before covid scrubs weren’t compulsory so I wore smart business clothes in line with our dress code. Provided my clothes were comfortable they didn’t affect my working mindset at all. Scrubs haven’t altered my work ethic.

When I work from home I focus just as well in joggers and a t-shirt than if I wear tailored trousers and a blouse.

When my DC get home I let them change into pjs. At weekends or in the holidays they wear joggers, sweaters, dresses, trainers. I haven’t noticed a difference in their ability to do homework or calculations depending on what they’re wearing. Children are constantly learning, I think instilling a love of learning is the best skill we can give them.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 13:53

I’m always baffled on these threads by the fact that students around the world are able to graduate high school having worn joggers throughout, yet British kids can only manage it if they’re wearing some kind of polyester jacket with pockets.

Parker231 · 13/07/2021 13:42

Clothing for school years doesn’t need to be any different than Uni. Jeans, T-shirt and hoodie or shorts in the warmer weather are perfectly suitable.