Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 21:24

Uniform doesn’t make a difference but caring enough to set clear expectations and give them a more equal playing field does. Much more important for poor children than the middle class children, who have experience of formal wear in other settings, perhaps.

Setting clear expectations, preparing kids for interviews - yes, absolutely. Experience of wearing formal wear? Nonsense. Again - how do you think all those European kids manage? Besides, I don't remember everyone being in suits at Oxford interviews.

As for the implication that it is formality that shows you 'care enough'... Yes, you can care enough to prepare students for a bright future without putting them in polyester blazers. Just like schools do in other countries.

LemonRoses · 13/07/2021 21:18

@Parker231

So the school uniform rules means that children from poorer families, families on benefits etc can’t attend.
Yes of course, that is how silent selection works. Not right, but not uncommon at all. A wool blazer with braid rather than a polyester one or a plaid skirt are frequent ways of ensuring the right cohorts.
lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 21:15

Such a great post!

Thank you. I came gradually to being anti-uniform. I totally understand why it would be really hard for individual schools to ditch it though. It would be a risk setting yourself apart from other local schools when so many parents believe the hype about uniform.

It's interesting having teenage dc in the school where both dh and I work/have worked. It gives us insight into how the students view aspects of the school and policies which in some cases dh has implemented! My dc are bright, high-achieving, rule-abiding kids, but they despise petty rules and teachers who they see as over-zealous about them, and they think uniform is utterly pointless.

LemonRoses · 13/07/2021 21:14

@lazylinguist

He chose to bring in stricter uniform standards in numerous under performing schools as one of many changes. He believes very much that it sets a different expectation.

Ah yes. I've met those kinds of Heads. And I've heard all kinds of 'We believe it sets a different expectation' propaganda. Empty words imo. What sets a different expectation is... actually having a different expectation, and establishing that through policies that make a real and practical difference to behaviour and teaching and learning, which hopefully was achieved through the other changes your husband made. I seriously doubt it was achieved through window dressing.

Perhaps your experience, but he took a fair few RI and inadequate schools in challenging circumstances to outstanding and got many more children into Oxbridge and Russell Group from very hugely disadvantaged communities.

Window dressing opened many doors for many youngsters. It included not only uniform and learning to feel comfortable in more formal wear, but purchasing suits for interviews. They didn’t spend their time pulling at collars and fidgeting with ties because they’d become accustomed to wearing them.

Uniform doesn’t make a difference but caring enough to set clear expectations and give them a more equal playing field does. Much more important for poor children than the middle class children, who have experience of formal wear in other settings, perhaps.

Parker231 · 13/07/2021 21:14

So the school uniform rules means that children from poorer families, families on benefits etc can’t attend.

tennisballboy · 13/07/2021 21:13

They could definitely all afford suits. Says it all really!

LemonRoses · 13/07/2021 21:07

@Parker231

LemonRoses - you mentioned your DC’s sixth form having to wear formal suits - why - even wearing a suit to work is becoming rarer.

What happens to children who can’t afford a suit - it’s not as if it’s going to have much use for other occasions.

They could definitely all afford suits. It was the requirement. Just as they continuing sport in sixth form was and wearing correct sports wear. My daughter has worn hers numerous times since for interviews and work. The blouses she wears still for work.
tennisballboy · 13/07/2021 21:06

@Parker231

LemonRoses - you mentioned your DC’s sixth form having to wear formal suits - why - even wearing a suit to work is becoming rarer.

What happens to children who can’t afford a suit - it’s not as if it’s going to have much use for other occasions.

Our kids had to wear a suit to sixth form - pile of nonsense - school still had shit teaching but again - focus on the PR image and hope no one notices the quality lacking beneath - and leafy suburb so loads of tutoring going on at all levels. Ofsted haven't visited in at least a decade. School don't accept feedback when given - but send out silly questionnaires to tick boxes and tell us everyone is happy - when all the parent moan like shit and know the school is providing a poor education. The system is a joke.
tennisballboy · 13/07/2021 21:01

@lazylinguist

What uniforms do:

Piss off teenagers
Make them uncomfortable with how they look
Perpetuate many teenagers' view of school as outdated, stuffy and irrelevant
Devalue genuinely important school rules
Create something else for teachers to tell kids off about
Make kids think that teachers care more about earrings or sock colour than education
Make students disbelieve schools' insistence that they're all about treating students as valued, unique individuals
Persuade some parents a school is good

What uniforms don't do:

Make students proud of being a part of their school and its ethos Grin
Prevent bullying
Improve behaviour
Help learning

Such a great post! Reminds me of my parent's fear that not smacking my kids would make them unruly, spoilt and thoroughly unpleasant roughians - 10 years later my parents admitted my kids were lovely and didn't need to be smacked around the lugs to knock them into shape. We have lost the plot with kids - stupid rules do not create respect - they never did - in the past you were able to enforce them through fear of having the cane whip them into compliance and at what cost? We have progressed but we need more.
Parker231 · 13/07/2021 21:00

LemonRoses - you mentioned your DC’s sixth form having to wear formal suits - why - even wearing a suit to work is becoming rarer.

What happens to children who can’t afford a suit - it’s not as if it’s going to have much use for other occasions.

tennisballboy · 13/07/2021 20:52

@TheKeatingFive

My husband with a longer teaching and headship history than yours would say differently. He chose to bring in stricter uniform standards in numerous under performing schools as one of many changes. He believes very much that it sets a different expectation.

Oh. One of those heads. Hmm

Stricter uniform standards are always the last resort of the type of head who brings nothing to the table.

In the absence of any actual ideas about how to inspire and lead, they mandate polyester blazers. Wonderful.

Completely agree - new uniform = tickbox (lack of) leadership!
lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 20:48

He chose to bring in stricter uniform standards in numerous under performing schools as one of many changes. He believes very much that it sets a different expectation.

Ah yes. I've met those kinds of Heads. And I've heard all kinds of 'We believe it sets a different expectation' propaganda. Empty words imo. What sets a different expectation is... actually having a different expectation, and establishing that through policies that make a real and practical difference to behaviour and teaching and learning, which hopefully was achieved through the other changes your husband made. I seriously doubt it was achieved through window dressing.

TheKeatingFive · 13/07/2021 20:38

My husband with a longer teaching and headship history than yours would say differently. He chose to bring in stricter uniform standards in numerous under performing schools as one of many changes. He believes very much that it sets a different expectation.

Oh. One of those heads. Hmm

Stricter uniform standards are always the last resort of the type of head who brings nothing to the table.

In the absence of any actual ideas about how to inspire and lead, they mandate polyester blazers. Wonderful.

LemonRoses · 13/07/2021 20:29

lazylinguist We’ll have to agree to differ. Some are truly comprehensive, but not many. Those in affluent areas are impacted by independents, those in grammar systems are impacted by direct selection, those in very poor communities are affected by the more aspirational avoiding if at all possible - often by church attendance.

My husband with a longer teaching and headship history than yours would say differently. He chose to bring in stricter uniform standards in numerous under performing schools as one of many changes. He believes very much that it sets a different expectation.

Views will probably always be polarised. Our children’s sixth form required formal suits. Everyone wore them, no debate. Nobody was disadvantaged by so doing.

daisypond · 13/07/2021 18:45

Tracksuits are school uniform in China, that bastion of strict school discipline, hard work and ambitious parents. Boys and girls wear the same one.

lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 18:40

What uniforms do:

Piss off teenagers
Make them uncomfortable with how they look
Perpetuate many teenagers' view of school as outdated, stuffy and irrelevant
Devalue genuinely important school rules
Create something else for teachers to tell kids off about
Make kids think that teachers care more about earrings or sock colour than education
Make students disbelieve schools' insistence that they're all about treating students as valued, unique individuals
Persuade some parents a school is good

What uniforms don't do:

Make students proud of being a part of their school and its ethos Grin
Prevent bullying
Improve behaviour
Help learning

Cocopogo · 13/07/2021 18:28

Totally agree. DD should not have to wear a shirt and tie or blazer for that matter. Or black coat when it’s warm. Or formal shoes. They should be comfortable.

lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 18:26

it doesn’t take much to determine the difference though.

What do you mean? The difference in demographic between a school in a poor area and a rich one? No, it doesn't take much to determine it. It certainly hasn't got anything to do with uniform though.

Most comprehensives really don’t serve a truly comprehensive intake. Certainly faith based comprehensives also have back door selection, as does location.

Plenty do have a pretty comprehensive intake. The one my dc go to certainly does. The style of its uniform wouldn't tell you much about it though. It has a blazer and tie etc, like virtually all of the schools in the area. The one local comp that's seen as being particularly posh and aspirational has fleeces instead of blazers Shock.

Look, I've taught for 25 years in schools ranging from rough inner city comp, elite private day school, rural posh boarding school, faith school etc etc and I've seen no evidence that uniform improves anything about a school or tells you anything that useful about a school that plenty of other quite obvious things wouldn't tell you better!

Parker231 · 13/07/2021 18:21

@LemonRoses - your comments don’t work with respect to other countries where there is no school uniform. Do all these children fail?

DT’s went to a private London based international school with no school uniform. The majority of the pupils went onto either RG U.K. Unis or their equivalents in other countries.

LemonRoses · 13/07/2021 18:12

lazylinguist Yes, but not uniform alone. I think it’s naive to assume uniform doesn’t play a part in selecting cohorts though. Indeed some schools in poorer areas do try to impose strict uniform to improve discipline, it doesn’t take much to determine the difference though.

Most comprehensives really don’t serve a truly comprehensive intake. Certainly faith based comprehensives also have back door selection, as does location.

lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 18:05

LemonRoses

Well yes, you are just using uniform as a proxy for social class, cultural capital etc. Even then it doesn't really work though, because lots of schools with what you clearly consider an undesirable demographic have just as strict uniform rules as the leafy, middle class aspirational ones.

Besides, arguably most comprehensive schools cater to a socially very wide range of families. So unless your child goes to a private school or a school in an unusually exclusively aspirational area, they are highly unlikely to only be rubbing shoulders with the kind of cohort you describe.

lazylinguist · 13/07/2021 17:55

And manage to ignore that an enormous number of jobs and careers are not dependent on wearing blazers, kilts, ties, or skirts of a requisite length.

Well quite. And ignore that most of those kids who end up in the best jobs go through several years of university wearing whatever the hell they like. I'm sure the top universities would be most keen to learn that they could improve their results and ensure that students study really hard and don't do stupid stuff by insisting they all wear blazers and ties. Grin

Honestly, it's baffling that people still believe this nonsense. The students from the (strict, Catholic, high-achieving) French school that did an exchange with the school where I used to teach found our students' uniforms hilariously quaint, adorable and pointless. The French kids wore jeans and t-shirts. Somehow they still managed to largely behave themselves and do well at school. Shock

Uniforms do not create good discipline. Some schools which have formal uniforms may have good discipline, but that's not cause and effect.

Fizbosshoes · 13/07/2021 17:51

My daughters secondary school sanctioned (after the first lockdown) that on days where they had PE they must wear PE kit with blazer. They were allowed to wear plain joggers or leggings in addition to pe kit.

Around Easter we got a shirty letter saying how disappointed they were that kids had come in with joggers or leggings with sports logos (not allowed) and hoodies (definitely not allowed) and that could we as parents ensure they had the correct kit, this might mean buying online from the school sanctioned shop. Well duh. The shops were closed at the time the letter was sent so yes we would have to buy online!

I found it strange on one hand the letter had also detailed what hard work it was to implement all the ever changing covid protocols (and I have huge sympathy for schools over that) ....but then made extra work for the teachers by asking them to monitor the odd hoodie or nike logo on a pe kit, as if there werent enough actual rules to implement.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 13/07/2021 17:48

*Not at all. It’s about self selecting social groups, for us. You look at the schools (such as many free schools) that attract middle classes and aspirational cohorts and one means of silent selection is through strict uniform policy.
The parents likely to support blazers, ties correctly knotted and uniform coats are also likely to be parents who enforce other boundaries. That results in cohorts who have similar standards and attitudes towards school.
As a parent, I’d want my children in a school where they had peers that had same ambition and parents that supported them to realise their ambition. Attitudes to learning start very young, achievement is started at nursery level and grows with the children.

The uniform itself is broadly irrelevant, but the culture underneath is very important. Where nobody wears uniform, it’s clearly not the same. Germany notably doesn’t encourage the wear uniforms but it does have a very differentiated school system at secondary level*

2 very very middle class secondaries near me. One has no uniform, one has a very relaxed uniform where earrings, hair styles , make up etc are allowed.

My dd goes to the second one. I don’t support outdated blazers and stupid uniforms. Parents are very very keen and ambitious for their children. Uniform seems to make no difference.

As a parent, I’d want my children in a school where they had peers that had same ambition and parents that supported them to realise their ambition

That describes my DD’s school perfectly. But very very relaxed uniform.

The worse the school the tighter the uniform in my 25 years teaching experience.

ZZTopGuitarSolo · 13/07/2021 17:45

If you need to look at whether or not a school enforces a strict uniform policy to ascertain which is the right school then a) your system is broken and b) you're not very good at judging schools.