Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
FindingMeno · 09/07/2021 16:54

Oh and you can tell the less well off kids in uniform anyway.

dementedpixie · 09/07/2021 16:53

My dd never wore trousers to school at secondary and prefers skirts out of school too. No I don't think the default should be trousers at all

FindingMeno · 09/07/2021 16:53

I totally agree.
Ffs our school even set a colour code for face masks.
They focus so much on whether shirts are tucked in they fail to see way more concerning behaviour.
The rules are outdated for many modern workplaces.

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/07/2021 16:51

Unisex ? So default male then, forgetting that girls may well find skirts easier or more practical or comfortable . Why can't unisex just mean allowing the boys to wear skirts too.

lazylinguist · 09/07/2021 16:49

I'm a teacher and I agree. I think school uniform is outdated and unnecessary. Most of Europe seem to manage fine without it. If state schools have a uniform, it should be affordable and generic (e.g. any grey school skirt of x length etc).

I also think that if you do have a uniform, there's an argument for having an entirely unisex, trousers-only one, assuming again that you are not too rigid about the cut. I don't buy the whole 'trousers are unflattering' line. School uniform is rarely particularly flattering. Lots of different styles of trousers are available, even if you disallow leggings etc.

SamusIsAGirl · 09/07/2021 16:46

Looking at OECD and other statistics internationally, there is no correlation in terms of performance between school uniform being present or not.

QuestionableMouse · 09/07/2021 16:46

If uniform was that essential to learning, collages and universities would have them.

I hated mine- the stupid tie use to get cause on the desk and half strangle me, or the horrible girls who bullied me would yank it. I had to be cut out of it once because of that.

My uniform at work is provided for me so it doesn't cost me a penny. It's also refreshed regularly so it stays looking nice. They also don't care what colour or type socks or hair elastic I wear.

Uniform prices are insane, especially for stuff like branded blazers.

It should be simple, comfortable (no wearing blazers on a scorching hot day!) and practical.

SamusIsAGirl · 09/07/2021 16:45

The thing about adult uniform is that there is often a PPE aspect to it as well as it making sense - in a restaurant you want to know who is actually working there. The times I have worn a uniform in adult life were when it made sense and the dress code made sense (e.g hair tied back, no nail varnish, no dangling earings, closed-toe footware not to high a heel etc).

And since when does threatening children with detention over clothing help them study better? Looks like magic and ritual to me.

Pandamumium · 09/07/2021 16:44

I used be a Secondary teacher in the U.K. and I admit that I got fed up having to insist on correct uniform. The head used to say that it was something for the pupils to rebel against, so they wouldn’t rebel against other rules!
I then moved to France 20 years ago, and my three children have been through the French school system where there is no uniform. I have not found it to be a problem. My children have not been dressed in designer clothes, more Primark and supermarket. They have never been bullied for what they wear. The only issue we had was school bags. At one point it was Eastpak, and then Fjällräven Kånken (?), but that would have been the same in the U.K.
I now teach the last year of Primary and I like to see the children’s personalities being expressed in what they wear.

NothingEverChangesButTheShoes · 09/07/2021 16:42

I do wonder re secondary, is there any need? These days many, many teens shop at Primark regardless of social background. You can tell if uniform is worn or second hand on the first day of Year 7. That marks a card for a whole school year.

RoseMartha · 09/07/2021 16:41

I am on low income but I prefer my dc to wear a uniform otherwise my teen girls would constantly want new clothes to stay cool and on trend and it would in the long run cost me more money if uniform didnt exist.

I do think though that some of the items are overpriced.

Usernamenotavailabletryanother · 09/07/2021 16:37

Having taught in uniform and non uniform secondary schools, I much prefer non uniform. I found sending children home for wearing the wrong colour socks when they’ve not had breakfast and struggled to even get to school utterly soul-crushing. Plus you could focus on, you know, actual teaching.

I preferred it as a parent too when my children were at a non uniform primary school (so did they). Whatever was clean was worn. Non uniform days are such a novelty, children seem to stress about their clothes in a way that children at non uniform schools don’t on the whole.

Although my older child’s secondary does have a uniform (hardly any non uniform secondaries left) I like the way they talk about it- we had a letter saying that they want to challenge ideas about conventional beauty and that’s why they don’t want students to wear acrylic nails and false eyelashes. Non of this misogynistic stuff about short skirts having an effect on boys which still happens in many schools Hmm

DoubleTweenQueen · 09/07/2021 16:37

School uniforms are a lifesaver in our house - the excess time and anxiety on home-clothes days is ridiculous and I wouldn't survive that every day of term.

Uniform is simple for a go-to outfit in the morning. No labels or fashions to worry about. Regulation style, colour (and length) more equitable for all pupils.

Idea is that pupils dress formally for their education and representing their school - sets an expectation & tone. A psychological influence.

Not expensive when comparing cost per wear, and if you size up (take up, in; let down/out). Sports kit (secondary) usually decent quality. Plain hair accessories inexpensive in comparison to fashion items.

Silly to have frequent changes resulting in additional expense though.

MereDintofPandiculation · 09/07/2021 16:37

I think statistically schools with a stricter uniform policy perform better so that’s probably why. ah - I see. You mean that if you have a low performing school and you institute a strict dress code, performance will increase markedly? Hmm

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/07/2021 16:36

I disagree with uniform. However if there is one it should be easily accessible and affordable.

This single supplier branded stuff needs to go. There's nothing you can achieve in a 35 pound logo blazer that you cant do in a 10 pound asda one.

Uniform.has become a way to price out people schools don't want. So instead of these children being evenly distributed across all schools and able to be supported better they attend the same 2 or 3 schools and get lost in the crowds amongst others with competing needs.

Schools need to stop the sexust policies where boys can wear 5 pound asda trousers but the girls have to spend 20 quid on a skirt ( let's face it girls school trousers don't fit very well most thr time )

All this naming the back.of your pe kit shirt needs to go too. Its incredibly wasteful that chloe from next door can't have your y shirt that's only been worn a few times and is in perfect condition unless she changes her name to anne by deedpoll. Wtf is that about?

Why can't they just have a little badge/pin to signify houses. Why does it have to he coloured piping or logos that again means you can't pass down to anyone else.

I wish they would ban all thee petty rules that make perfectly good items seemingly unusable and forcing u into the school shop purchase.

Unless no other country produces pilots drs paramedics then the need fir a uniform at 25 In chosen professions then 4 years olds don't need to be in shirts and ties.

Bonkers.

warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 16:35

@TeenMinusTests

Given how casual most offices are these days I don’t understand why schools are ever more draconian.

However many jobs do often require a uniform:

  • airline pilot
  • shop worker
  • vet nurse
  • railway worker
to name a few.
Yep, and the same applies in the US and Canada where kids don't wear uniforms.

Children don't need to wear uniform to school to learn about wearing uniform as an adult.

MildredPuppy · 09/07/2021 16:31

I wouldnt mind a uniform that was cost effective and practical.
I found the plus side at primary was zero thought into what to wear and it washed well and actually was cheap apart from the logo jumper which was still only £12. It also kept their home clothes nice.

Secondary is a whole different level of expensive stuff that doesnt wash well and isnt practical for the weather conditions or level of light for large parts of the year.

PurpleOkapi · 09/07/2021 16:29

The "better for low-income families" argument is nonsense, unless the school is giving them away for free. It may be true that uniforms are cheaper than giving in to a child's every whim when it comes to designer clothes and whatnot. It's not true that a week's worth of uniforms costs less than a week's worth of perfectly appropriate casual clothes that you can get secondhand or at cheap retailers. That's what the comparison should actually be here.

thebeesknees123 · 09/07/2021 16:29

I agree with you. A secondary school is a huge expense and worry for low income families. There are many ways of identifying a child's background even with a uniform. Things also got lost or damaged causing even more aggro.

If you have your own clothes , you don't need to spend 200+ or replace overpriced garments from one or two shops.

I also think heads can get very petty over uniform rules, often at the expense bigger issues. It's often used as a smokescreen, I find.

I know children can be competitive about fashion but they'd soon get bored. It wouldn't be like non uniform day everyday and it works in other countries well enough

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 16:25

It's just crazy. My daughter does all kind of sports in school and her branded (£30 a go) school gym leggings get holes in quite quickly. She must've gone through half a dozen or so pairs in a year and is threatened with detention if she doesn't get new ones.

OP posts:
memberofthewedding · 09/07/2021 16:23

Ive never agreed with school uniforms. And I disagree that there are better for low income families! Kids from low income families either dont have the uniform, the wrong version of it, or an older scruffier version.

I went to school in the 1950s when regulations were not so draconian. Because we were a low income family my mother sourced my uniforms from second hand markets and army surplus stores. I felt ashamed. I would have been laughed at had my grandmother not stepped in and provided the money for the appropriate garments.

Parents should form an action group and push back hard for a much cheaper generic uniform which can be sourced from supermarkets.

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 16:21

To those who agree with school uniforms, why? What purpose do they serve? They do not assist with learning, they don't help students concentrate. They serve no purpose at all. A general policy of nothing too short/low cut etc would suffice.

I remember being in secondary school in the mid 00's and our headmaster used to walk around with a ruler, measuring girls heels. If it was found to be even a little too high, they would get detention. I under sky scrapper heels aren't practical from a health and safety perspective but teachers who enforce rules to that extent are in my opinion, control freaks who enjoy the power

OP posts:
SamusIsAGirl · 09/07/2021 16:20

I wonder if any thought to school uniform is given to:

  1. Pupils with disabilities and/or neurodivergent.
  2. Cost - can most of the uniform be made up from generic items?
  3. Punishment for uniform - status of uniform may not be something entirely under a student's control.
  4. Practicality for activities and environment - fewer things make me angry than layers of polyester in a heatwave or people struggling with unsuitable footwear in bad weather.
  5. Sexist dresscodes - what exactly will happen if girls wear trousers or boys wear skirts?

Don't underestimate the effect that useless uniform rules can have a disproportionate effect on mental health - it is one fewer thing you cannot control when you are a teen when you are already having to go to school and not have control over whom you are with.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 09/07/2021 16:18

Doesn't sound unreasonable to me (apart from the bobbles!) but then I was at school in the 70s/80s when we had boundaries. And it was only a comprehensive, nothing posh.

Bitofachinwag · 09/07/2021 16:13

There's little point in school uniform unless everyone looks exactly the same!