Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
jessycake · 09/07/2021 17:27

I think the logos thing should have to go , some are even encouraging embroidered names which is great if stuff gets lost , but then they can't be passed on . Secondary School Uniforms have always been expensive and people used to save with the school uniform shops ,and badges were hand sewn on but they have taken it to a new level , and sometimes they change them when they find a new supplier or change the Academy gets a new sponsor . Its become a bit of a racket .

phoenixrosehere · 09/07/2021 17:26

School uniforms are a lifesaver in our house - the excess time and anxiety on home-clothes days is ridiculous and I wouldn't survive that every day of term.

So how will they handle the real world? My 3.5 yo can pick out a shirt and trousers as well as grab his coat, hat, and shoes before we take him to nursery. We just make sure its weather appropriate.

The cost of uniforms is ridiculous. One bloody jumper with the school logo £24 yet I can go to H&M and get a nice shirt for £7.99 (one pictured is £8.99) and a pair of chinos for £7.99. The little boy in the picture looks pretty smart to me. Children can still look “smart” without uniforms.

Rigid school uniforms
Whatwouldscullydo · 09/07/2021 17:25

Uniforms aren't the issue, 3000 petty rules are. Ours need grey or black bottoms, yellow top, blue jumper. PE is dark trainers, dark bottoms, white top. Ok primary but the equivalent is possible for secondary

Yy I mean this patented shade of grey stuff is a big problem.

And you can pick up a a black/navy tracksuit top in tesco but the hood is suddenly a problem. Y? It's for pe on a field there's no one who's gonna see it.

Its also very hard to buy plain black sports leggings without a logo. Why is a UA or a Nike logo a problem. Uts an hour twice a week.

DoubleTweenQueen · 09/07/2021 17:22

@PurpleOkapi Workplaces do have a clothing code of sorts, but also grownups don't often experience a similar level of angst or peer pressure our young teens are often under :)

Also, schools have differences in uniform and stringency/enforcement. Our uniform is inexpensive - plain black blazer, striped shirt or plain white with tie, black or grey skirt/trousers. Couple of options for skirt style. All fairly innocuous. Individual interpretation fine to a degree. No-one ever sent to isolation/detention/home for wrong colour socks!
Private school though.
During open windows for ventilation since schools back, more relaxed in that games kit/skins/coats could be piled on at least to keep students warm
Recently asked if we wanted to keep blazer or move to smart jumper instead.

Uniform is much quicker/simpler/less time, anxiety and cash-consuming for us, that's all

Strawberryshitfest · 09/07/2021 17:20

@DoubleTweenQueen

School uniforms are a lifesaver in our house - the excess time and anxiety on home-clothes days is ridiculous and I wouldn't survive that every day of term.

Uniform is simple for a go-to outfit in the morning. No labels or fashions to worry about. Regulation style, colour (and length) more equitable for all pupils.

Idea is that pupils dress formally for their education and representing their school - sets an expectation & tone. A psychological influence.

Not expensive when comparing cost per wear, and if you size up (take up, in; let down/out). Sports kit (secondary) usually decent quality. Plain hair accessories inexpensive in comparison to fashion items.

Silly to have frequent changes resulting in additional expense though.

There wouldn’t be the anxiety/novelty of home clothes if they wore them every day. I wore uniform at secondary then own clothes for 6th form and it was exciting at first/everyone dressed their best/looking on trend was a big deal. After about 3 weeks no one cared it noticed what anyone wore and it was much easier than uniform. I think the psychological influence of working better in a uniform is a myth too-many offices have more causal dress codes, many people wfh, and pupils in Europe and America and universities manage to achieve without a uniform. Pupils who want to learn will do so wearing anything and a uniform won’t motivate anyone who doesn’t want to learn
SleepingStandingUp · 09/07/2021 17:18

It's a bit odd you're more perplexed about kids not being able to wear shellac nails than a green hair bobble.

Uniforms aren't the issue, 3000 petty rules are. Ours need grey or black bottoms, yellow top, blue jumper. PE is dark trainers, dark bottoms, white top. Ok primary but the equivalent is possible for secondary

KingdomScrolls · 09/07/2021 17:13

@Upamountain43 those countries generally have a culture around parental and personal responsibility that just doesn't exist in the UK as a whole. Generally more socially responsible, law abiding etc

KingdomScrolls · 09/07/2021 17:11

It essentially teaches children there are some rules/laws in life you might not like or agree with but you have to follow, which is true. Why set them up to believe they have a say in everything. My big standard state school in the nineties was at least as strict as that and we weren't allowed any make up or jewellery. The ones pushing the boundaries weren't the ones who couldn't afford uniform there were things in place for that, they were the ones coming in in Ralph Lauren shirts, Lacoste earrings (the boys...) Fancy trainers for PE that were five times more expensive than plain black tennis Reebok classic or similar. They were also the pupils pushing boundaries and misbehaving in other areas disrupting lessons for the rest of us, with parents who endlessly backed their little darlings. I don't think it's any coincidence that the worst 'offenders' literally are offenders now. It's the same mindset, that doesn't apply to me, I can do what I want etc.

Sirzy · 09/07/2021 17:10

I do think that having a smart, well enforced uniform does help with the setting standards side of things. I can’t explain why but certainly with local schools there seems to be a pattern.

Ds is starting secondary in September in a school which has strict uniform rules now. They provide all pupils with their first uniform and keep costs down across the board as much as possible.

Upamountain43 · 09/07/2021 17:09

There are few countries in the Western World that have uniforms it always make me wonder how German/French/Swedish children adjust to adult hood when they have not grown up wearing uniforms - how do they manage when they have to wear one at work it must be a nightmare - their countries must be in total collapse.

And how do all these foreign parents manage to cope with dressing their children in the mornings without uniforms existing - imaging the bullying in those countries they must all be traumatised.

And those poor Finnish children who do not wear uniform - i mean they only have the widely accepted best education system in the world but they must all be failing with being forced to wear uniforms every day.

Or maybe all these countries just have much better parents who seem to manage their children's clothing, behaviour and transition to adulthood without such draconian methods from 5 years old.

Strawberryshitfest · 09/07/2021 17:09

I think uniforms avoid school being so much of a fashion show (although bags, phone etc can still be compared). However I don’t know why they can’t say black trousers white shirt and leave it at that, maybe a cheap branded jumper. No idea why there has to be an expensive old fashioned woolen/uncomfortable uniform. Totally out of date with how the rest of society dresses. In the past, people wore blazers/jumpers/skirts/shirts like that and society expected people to look more formal/neat (people wore hats outside, starched collars, got dressed up to go to the shops etc). The rest of society has moved on and many workplaces are casual or smart casual and people wear joggers/leggings out and this is normal, it is not frowned upon to go most places looking a bit of a mess we are just more casual now. So not sure why schools need all the petty archaic rules about socks and hair bands/nail varnish etc. Maybe it was important for children of the past to learn these “boundaries” and social customs but they are totally out dated now and won’t help children learn how to conform/achieve in society they are just an irrelevant pain in the arse in modern life

MrsWinkly · 09/07/2021 17:08

I hate the uniform rules.
So expensive and the boys school is a small, underfunded and unpopular comp.
The head teacher is obsessed. We had a blazer hoo-haa as there is only one uniform supplier for all the schools in our city.
They shut at 5 and don't open on weekends, also 'don't really want to take online orders'. Took us 6 months to get a new blazer (horrible sweaty nylon thing) during lockdown and the school were ridiculous about it. None were coming from the supplier to the uniform shop because of lockdown so no-one in the area could get one. School were aware of this but hassled ds2 every single day, often with head teacher shouting at him. He carried a letter from me with him and a letter from the shop explaining the situation!
Everyone has had a shitty year, clothes are sold out and hard to get hold of, kids are all feeling demoralised by the learning they've missed and schools like ours seem to have their focus all wrong (the teaching was absolutely crap during lockdown).
It winds me up so much, considering how many kids there are at that school who needs financial assistance, that the uniform is so expensive and impossible to actually get hold of.
Also, they now aren't even allowed to remove their blazers in class without permission. They've been sitting mocks in sticky heat and the teacher refused to let them remove blazers for the exam! Has me fuming Angry
Rant over!
In case you hadn't guessed, I completely agree OP Grin

SamusIsAGirl · 09/07/2021 17:08

Also due to gerrymadering and other odd borders there are places in London that aren't in LEAs at all.

FindingMeno · 09/07/2021 17:07

I also agree with the nonsense around piercings, hair colour, make up etc.
It seems the rules expressly go at loggerheads with every natural instinct of a teenager when it comes to self expression.
I do not care what colour my dc's hair is. I care if they're happy, confident and trying at their schoolwork.

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/07/2021 17:06

Do people also not realise that choosing choosing school is a luxury only the few have.

Try that round here where many schools are iver subscribed and thanks to faith schools and grammar schools and academies you can be surrounded by schools and not qualify fir any if them while people from.15 miles away are bussed in.

Its not a choice its " get thrown.in where there's a space regardless if whether u can.get there or afford the uniform.or not"

lazylinguist · 09/07/2021 17:06

I think the other problem is that schools' tendency to have a formal uniform is driven by parents, who like the aspirational look of the smart blazer and logoed shirt when they're choosing schools (and mistakenly believe smart uniform equals good school and well-behaved kids).

But lots of them probably go off the uniform once they have to actually regularly pay for it and once their dc get detentions for not sticking to it. But it's the prospective parents schools want to appeal to, not the current ones!

Parker231 · 09/07/2021 17:06

DT’s went to a non uniform school. From ages 4-18 they wore jeans, T-shirt and hoodies. Shorts if it was hot.

Much easier than specific expensive uniform which everyone hates.

StrangeToSee · 09/07/2021 17:04

Yes, I hate it! My DC are only in infants and have to wear stiff shorts or tailored trousers, stiff button up shirts with ties, logo jumper, black socks, black shoes. No boots allowed (even in winter when we walk to school), PE kit has to have the logo plus a separate kit for outdoor sports.

It’s all so petty and silly!

Most adults don’t wear shirts, ties and formal trousers to work! Kids have to sit on the floor, need stretchy stuff to play in, why does it matter what colour their hair bobble is?

And the hassle of doing up buttons and trying to find black socks each morning! Adjusting waistbands, trying to do up ties!

Time schools got up to date and made uniforms comfortable, pull on and practical. Eg jersey trousers/joggers in black, navy or brown (or whatever the school colours are), a pull on cotton top/tshirt in school colours, a fleecy jumper or hoody or sweater in school colour. Trainers, boots, shoes, sandals, socks in any colour, hair bobbles in any colour. If the school wants a sense of unity they could design an iron-on patch that attaches to the jumper/sweater!

campion · 09/07/2021 17:02

@CupoTeap

Surely if you don't like uniforms you send them to a school without that policy.
There aren't many schools in the UK without a uniform
Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 17:02

@CupoTeap

Surely if you don't like uniforms you send them to a school without that policy.
You think it's that easy? How many non-uniform schools are there in the UK, never mind the county?
OP posts:
Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 17:01

@LolaSmiles

I'd happily have a dress code or a very simple uniform. Unfortunately experience tells me that some parents are apparently incapable of deploying common sense.

This means that what started as "plain black school trousers, no fashion trousers or jeans" means that some parents will buy:
Leggings
Jeggings
Skinny fashion trousers that are basically spray on
Skinny jeans
Low slung black jeans
Cullotes style fashion trousers
Very wide fashion trousers
Trousers with embroidery on them or charms hanging off them
Trousers with large stitched in belts and buckles

Then the parents who are apparently clueless what bog standard school trousers look like will say "but they were in the school section of the shop", missing the point that the shops selling fashion schoolwear are relying on pester power and parents not bothering to read/follow the rules will buy them ^because EVERYONE else is".

Or school uniform says to wear 'plain black leather or leather style school shoes, no trainers' and every year some parents will spend £75 on a pair of black trainers and moan that someone challenged their child. If they show up on Angry People in Local Newspapers then there's usually a sad face photo holding the trainers, whilst parent says they can't afford school shoes after buying their child a pair of branded trainers that's twice the price of school shoes.

A school might say one earring per ear, but some parents think that actually means let my 13 year old have several piercings in school time and be confrontational if anyone points out that my child has to follow the same rules as all the others.

The problem is that a reasonable minority of parents are incapable of following even the simplest uniform codes, so schools have to be increasingly prescriptive.

But why is anything that you have said important for a child's learning experience? Does it really matter if heaven forbid, a 15 year old has two piercings in each ear lobe? Or someone wears culotte black trousers because they are understandably much more comfortable than the formal type school insist on.
OP posts:
CupoTeap · 09/07/2021 17:00

Surely if you don't like uniforms you send them to a school without that policy.

campion · 09/07/2021 16:57

School uniforms are a lifesaver in our house - the excess time and anxiety on home-clothes days is ridiculous and I wouldn't survive that every day of term

But that wouldn't happen as it'd be normal to wear everyday clothes, rather than uniform. As pp's have said, most countries manage just fine.

The amount of time wasted on how a tie should look, collars buttoned, shirts hanging out, skirts too short etc etc is time better spent on teaching and learning.
And many uniforms wouldn't have looked out of place in the 1920s.

LolaSmiles · 09/07/2021 16:57

I'd happily have a dress code or a very simple uniform. Unfortunately experience tells me that some parents are apparently incapable of deploying common sense.

This means that what started as "plain black school trousers, no fashion trousers or jeans" means that some parents will buy:
Leggings
Jeggings
Skinny fashion trousers that are basically spray on
Skinny jeans
Low slung black jeans
Cullotes style fashion trousers
Very wide fashion trousers
Trousers with embroidery on them or charms hanging off them
Trousers with large stitched in belts and buckles

Then the parents who are apparently clueless what bog standard school trousers look like will say "but they were in the school section of the shop", missing the point that the shops selling fashion schoolwear are relying on pester power and parents not bothering to read/follow the rules will buy them ^because EVERYONE else is".

Or school uniform says to wear 'plain black leather or leather style school shoes, no trainers' and every year some parents will spend £75 on a pair of black trainers and moan that someone challenged their child. If they show up on Angry People in Local Newspapers then there's usually a sad face photo holding the trainers, whilst parent says they can't afford school shoes after buying their child a pair of branded trainers that's twice the price of school shoes.

A school might say one earring per ear, but some parents think that actually means let my 13 year old have several piercings in school time and be confrontational if anyone points out that my child has to follow the same rules as all the others.

The problem is that a reasonable minority of parents are incapable of following even the simplest uniform codes, so schools have to be increasingly prescriptive.

PurpleOkapi · 09/07/2021 16:54

the excess time and anxiety on home-clothes days is ridiculous and I wouldn't survive that every day of term.

God help these kids when they have to figure out for themselves what is and isn't appropriate for their workplace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread