Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
daisypond · 09/07/2021 22:52

That seems an extreme school uniform, though. My DC secondary was all generic, supermarket-type clothing. Black skirt or trousers, white shirt, grey jumper. Nothing school specific. There was only a specific tie and blazer to be bought - that lasted five years.

SmileEachDay · 09/07/2021 22:41

Until I started working in schools it never crossed my mind the mental gymnastics some people will do to find a way fairly simple principles don't apply to them

Me: Just calling to let you know that the nose bar Lisa has in today is against the uniform policy.
Lisa’s mum: It was her birthday.
Me: oh. Well, I’m afraid it’s going to have to come out.
LM: But it was her birthday present.
Me: That’s difficult. It’s going to need to come out though - as well as the uniform issue it’s also a bit unsafe when she’s doing PE,
LM: I don’t know what you’re expecting me to do, I’ve explained that she’s allowed to have it. Maybe she could not do PE?
Me: She’s not allowed to have it at school -
LM: Can I speak to the Head, you’re not being very helpful and Lisa thinks you’re picking on her.
Me: 🤦🏻‍♀️

kowari · 09/07/2021 22:41

@PuffinDodger

Blazers usually have plenty of pockets
While I'd prefer no uniform, DS loves his blazer for the pockets. He's lucky to have the option as he hates jumpers that go over the head, I bought one in year 7 and it went unused in the drawer until I gave it away. He will wear a zipped jacket or hoodie but not a jumper.
reluctantbrit · 09/07/2021 22:39

@PuffinDodger

Blazers usually have plenty of pockets
Yes, that's why DD will continue voluntarily with the blazer. Also in winter in an old building it is warmer I have been told.

I think she doesn't need a bag, the blazer holds everything she needs for school.

MrsPsmalls · 09/07/2021 22:39

God I hate school uniforms for the unimportant hassle they cause to parents, students and even staff trying to enforce the bloody things. Can you imagine a teacher really caring if a student wears nail polish?? And yet they are paid to pretend they do everyday! Getting themselves the reputation as the most incredibly petty people in the universe when they actually of course don't give a flying fuck. And petty people command zero respect. Will your dc vote with their feet in 6th form? My ds certainly did, taking his best grades in the rather low achieving school with him. Ridiculous nonsense.

reluctantbrit · 09/07/2021 22:37

@MarjorieBouvier

I don't understand why more schools don't have 2nd hand sales. Dcs uniform costs ~£600 new for everything in y7. Got almost the whole lot for under £50 in a 2nd hand PTA sale. But I suppose you have to have parents willing to organise it. Price really shouldn't be a barrier.
Because. after 2-3 years of daily wear the items are showing wear and tear.

DD needs a new blazer in September. While her old one still is fine as it doesn't have stains, no broken seams, no ripped lining, it starts to show that it has been worn 5 days a week for 3 years (minus pandemic home learning).

Unless your child had a sudden growth spur and didn't fit anything the items are worn out.

We got a skirt from our neighbours, the girl moves to 6th form with a different dress code. The skirt is fine as an emergency but not like the one I had to buy new because the zip broke.

Hence the fact that the pupils can spot who only wears second hand uniform vs got a new set and then the next round of bullying/calling names start.

Most parents buy large.

PuffinDodger · 09/07/2021 22:31

Blazers usually have plenty of pockets

LolaSmiles · 09/07/2021 22:27

00100001
You're right. They'll be everywhere. Having a clear uniform (as simple as possible in my opinion) is much easier than having a dress code and dealing with the inevitable pushing and twisting and arguing about what does/doesn't technically count. It also means that life is easier for parents whose kids might turn on the pester power about what everyone else is or isn't wearing, so at least you're only left with the core group of moaners.

I think uniforms should be simple, have a few options, have clear boundaries, and be affordable.
Eg. Plain back trousers, no jeans, no leggings, no joggers, no super skinny or super baggy trousers. White polo shirt or white shirt. School jumper or sweatshirt. Plain black shoes or plain black trainers with no obvious branding or bling.

Until I started working in schools it never crossed my mind the mental gymnastics some people will do to find a way fairly simple principles don't apply to them.

StrongLegs · 09/07/2021 22:26

@warmfluffytowels I'm completely in agreement with you on cost.

I do think that even state school uniforms can be eyewateringly expensive.

I always want to buy two lots of PE kit and 5 lots of daily uniform,
because I frequently mess up with the washing and realise too late that I haven't washed whatever it was that I was meant to wash

It's okay for me because we have a decent lot of money and one child, but I think it must be very hard for families with a number of children and less money. I like to buy good shoes too and they are mind-bogglingly expensive.

I had the blazer and tie and skirt and tights uniform as a child and it was horrible. I'm so glad that so many schools just have the polo shirt and sweatshirt and trousers option. How lovely must it be for the girls to have pockets? I would have given my eye teeth for pockets as a school child.

Fizbosshoes · 09/07/2021 22:25

I dont object to uniform per se, but I do feel aggrieved that virtually every school insists it must come from the same supplier.
My DDs school uniform is navy. Why would it be so awful of me to buy a navy skirt from M and S, instead of the school supplier? Im ok for them to state the style or required length. Is she better behaved wearing the more expensive one?
At the primary school they are required to wear navy shorts for PE. DS currently has pair from sainsburys. They are suitable for sport and fit well...but next year they will need to be branded navy shorts and cost about 4 x as much. How exactly will this improve his behaviour or sporting prowess? He wears football socks that were £2 from sports direct. DDs branded socks are almost exactly the same (I get them mixed up in the wash) but have a stripe and school initials on them, and cost £7.

00100001 · 09/07/2021 22:20

@LolaSmiles I concur.

But I guess they'd be arsehole parents no matter what :(

warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 22:17

@StrongLegs x-post with you!

lazylinguist · 09/07/2021 22:17

I was a well behaved child at school and the children who messed with the rules on uniform were always the ones who were also aggressive and scary to be around. I think that when the rules are spelled out like this, it's much easier then to pull those aggressive children aside and have a word with them about their behaviour.

That's not my experience in 25 years of teaching. There are all kinds of children who push it with the uniform rules. I don't see why having strict uniform rules helps you pull kids aside about aggressive behaviour. If they are behaving aggressively, you tackle that. It has nothing to do with uniform.

LolaSmiles · 09/07/2021 22:16

00100001
In an ideal world I would agree with you. I'd be happy with a dress code, and largely still would be, but I trained as a teacher and realised that a worrying number of parents struggle with straightforward concepts such as "no false nails" and think this actually means "take your 13 year old to get acrylics done, then tell your child that the school can't make them take the nails off, then complain when your child is sanctioned once for the uniform and again for arguing back with several members of staff, then tell your child you don't consent to the detention so they don't have to go, then complain and get confrontational when your child is put in isolation after missing several detentions and/or still arriving with the stupid nails on".
When you've had phonecalls from parents wanting to complain that your colleague gave a detention to their child for refusing to remove the jewellery that is not only against the uniform rules, but was also a health and safety issue for the lesson, you start to realise that some parents either have no common sense or are still full of hangups from their own school days.

lazylinguist · 09/07/2021 22:14

It may be true that many elite and highly successful schools have fancy uniforms. That doesn't mean that other schools emulating the uniforms will make them more successful too, or make their students behave better.

In my experience, strict uniform rules create a whole extra unnecessary source of conflict between staff and pupils. The pupils find it so nitpicky and trivial that it reduces their respect for the school's rules in general. And when you have kids who struggle and are trying hard to improve their behaviour etc, it's very frustrating to feel you have to pick them up on uniform infringements because that's what you've been told to do.

MarjorieBouvier · 09/07/2021 22:13

I don't understand why more schools don't have 2nd hand sales. Dcs uniform costs ~£600 new for everything in y7. Got almost the whole lot for under £50 in a 2nd hand PTA sale. But I suppose you have to have parents willing to organise it. Price really shouldn't be a barrier.

StrongLegs · 09/07/2021 22:12

btw, having said that. I don't think the uniform needs to be expensive. A polo shirt, sweatshirt and general school trousers are fine. It just needs to be clearly defined.

warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 22:11

@StrongLegs

I really disagree. I was a well behaved child at school and the children who messed with the rules on uniform were always the ones who were also aggressive and scary to be around. I think that when the rules are spelled out like this, it's much easier then to pull those aggressive children aside and have a word with them about their behaviour.

I would hope that when they have been told to conform in uniform terms, that would also help them to modify their general behaviour to be less intimidating for the other children.

That's fine, but why does any of what you've said mean that schools should be able to enforce a uniform that costs hundreds of pounds per pupil?
StrongLegs · 09/07/2021 22:07

I really disagree. I was a well behaved child at school and the children who messed with the rules on uniform were always the ones who were also aggressive and scary to be around. I think that when the rules are spelled out like this, it's much easier then to pull those aggressive children aside and have a word with them about their behaviour.

I would hope that when they have been told to conform in uniform terms, that would also help them to modify their general behaviour to be less intimidating for the other children.

00100001 · 09/07/2021 22:05

Dress codes should suffice.

Pretty much every other country has no uniform,and they do just fine.

LolaSmiles · 09/07/2021 22:02

LolaSmiles so you are saying having a strict uniform is a way of filtering out the kind of families that you don’t want??!

No. I didn't say that. You're looking for an argument that isn't there.
As I said quite clearly:
It's entirely possible to teach effectively when the students are in uniform or their own clothes in my experience.

I'm saying that having a uniform or not having a uniform isn't the most important factor as behaviour in schools is complicated. Supportive parents who will support the school will do so whether the school has a uniform or a loose dress code because they're supportive and have the maturity and common sense to know that in life different places have different rules.
The sort of unsupportive parents who will buy leggings when a school uniform says no leggings, who will get their child's ears pierced in the middle of term despite the uniform saying no piercings etc are likely to still be unsupportive of a dress code because their fundamental view is that their child can do what they like and don't have to follow rules that they/their parents don't like.
Parental attitude is a bigger issue than whether a school does or doesn't have a uniform.

SmileEachDay · 09/07/2021 21:59

kowari

I’m a teacher, at a state school. I know exactly why fee paying schools are successful!

My post was in response to a PP who claimed that it was only low attaining schools that needed a strict uniform policy.

As an addendum, I think Eton did drop its top hat policy in recent years.

(Sorry. I’m being a bit facetious but Eton’s uniform tickles me 🤣)

childrenoftherevolution · 09/07/2021 21:51

Yes it was a private school, have since learned other schools have uniforms that are a bit more comfortable for little ones! But still really surprised at how widespread that sort of tradition is, and what a conservative uniform culture there is herein general.

kowari · 09/07/2021 21:51

@SmileEachDay
Fee paying schools are not successful because of uniform, they all select their students, by income if nothing else. Some state schools do the same indirectly by requiring uniform that poor students struggle to afford, encouraging them to attend other schools.

SinkGirl · 09/07/2021 21:48

@childrenoftherevolution

I am American expat and I felt so upset when I had to send my four year old to school in a tie and blazer. What a ridiculous thing to make a toddler wear every day! I will never understand making them wear shorts in winter, poor things. Plus constantly being shouted at to pull up the silly knee socks! And don't get me started about girls not being allowed to wear trousers. It's 2021, not 1921. I like a lot of things about living here but I will never understand the school uniform thing!!
To be fair, most primary schools in the U.K. don’t make 4 year olds wear a blazer and tie, so you chose a school (perhaps a private school) where this was the policy. None of my friends’ reception age kids wear blazers or ties unless they’re going to private school.