Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
childrenoftherevolution · 10/07/2021 08:35

Many of you are saying the only thing wrong with uniform is the expense. The idea it's better to just make children wear plain black and white polyester supermarket clothes is just...depressing. In many parts of the world children wear comfortable, colourful playclothes to school and I promise they don't have any extra problems with discipline and focus in those countries. They're children! Let them wear their bright trainers and their soft tee shirts and their sparkly hair clips.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 08:34

Oh and I forgot PE kit when listing the 5 sets of uniform per child!

They have PE twice a week and outdoor sport twice a week. So for 2 kids that’s 4 branded PE T-shirt’s, 4 pairs of gym shorts, 2 pairs of plimsolls, 2 pairs of school trainers, 4 pairs of black joggers and 4 black hoodies! And branded PE bags.

I wish they could just wear the PE kits as uniform, so comfortable and practical and as long as the hoodies and t-shirts have the logo the rest could be bought from the high street.

Brefugee · 10/07/2021 08:33

blazer and jumper on at all times unless invited to remove by teacher (not even allowed to ask permission.

What an utterly petty, and potentially bullying, policy. I hope the teachers are all wrapped up very warm, especially the menopausal women - at all times.

If you're going to have a uniform policy, fine. Whatever. Have at it. But the pathetic "top button done up at all times can't take a jumper off without permission" bollocks is controlling and unnecessary. Frankly in my day that would have been the thing that got me thrown out of school (a perpetually warm person) rather than anything else i may have done.

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 08:33

Parents are far more likely to support the school and its culture if they’re not having to spent a fortune on silly impractical branded uniform.
That's an issue regarding uniform suppliers and price though, not the existence of a uniform. I dont agree with expensive single supply uniform and even if a school did have that, I'd not be spending huge sums on money on items that are clearly not part of the uniform.

Parents have to decide what's more important to them: supporting the school even if they don't necessarily agree with all their rules, or showing their child that special people like them are exempt so should totally have piercings/fake nails/trainers when the rules say "no trainers, no fake nails". If they choose the latter because wearing trainers, jeans, and false nails is their priority then they can't be surprised when their child is routinely in detention or isolation for thinking school rules don't apply to them.

Iggly · 10/07/2021 08:32

I was a well behaved child at school and the children who messed with the rules on uniform were always the ones who were also aggressive and scary to be around. I think that when the rules are spelled out like this, it's much easier then to pull those aggressive children aside and have a word with them about their behaviour

So the uniform rules did naff all to prevent bad behaviour…..

At work I don’t have to worry about overly ridiculous constraints on my appearance. I don’t think being stricter about uniform conjured up a better work ethic, that’s nonsense.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 08:22

I totally disagree. A strict uniform policy helps instil discipline and generally contributes to an environment of work and focus. Both of the DCs’ schools have very strict policies- top buttons done up, shirts tucked in, shoes polished, blazer and jumper on at all times unless invited to remove by teacher (not even allowed to ask permission.

How does it help create an environment of work, focus and discipline if children are overheating in blazers or distracted by their top buttons being annoying or worrying about their shirts becoming un tucked?

My high school teachers used to shout ‘shirt alert’ if a shirt was untucked. It just sent kids into giggles. Especially as the teachers were dressed casually!

FuzzyPenguin · 10/07/2021 08:17

I am a few years off the secondary school uniform but I do feel a dress code would be much better. The secondary school here has a very formal dress code and the kids are not allowed to remove their blazers at all. I feel so sorry for them in the summer, also they have no lockers so often the don’t wear coats in the rain as they have no where to hang them so they are sat in wet blazers all day.

I don’t understand why they can’t just have a more relaxed dress code like the primary with polo shirts.

The rules on hair and piercings I can’t get worked up about there are still job which have these types of restrictions.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 08:16

I was a well behaved child at school and the children who messed with the rules on uniform were always the ones who were also aggressive and scary to be around. I think that when the rules are spelled out like this, it's much easier then to pull those aggressive children aside and have a word with them about their behaviour.

I don’t think that’s fair. Those children may have had SEN or sensory needs that made the uniforms feel intolerable to them so they didn’t follow the rules. My friend’s son has sensory processing issues and they break the rules; he doesn’t do his top button or wear a tie properly (he pulls it loose) he won’t tuck in his shirt, he wears girls trousers as they’re stretchy pull up jersey fabric. He’s very well behaved, shy and academically ahead!

Or those children you remember may have come from disadvantaged backgrounds where parents couldn’t afford the proper uniform.

They could have suffered abuse or neglect or had parents who refused to spend on uniform or didn’t care if the kids didn’t wear it properly.

I’m sorry you were bullied but please don’t blame the uniforms.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 08:08

Also why do they need to "learn how to conform" aged six @Funnyfive ?

Countries all over the world don't have uniforms and the adults all seem to cope just fine! Hmm

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 08:07

I don't think £150 is cheap! Especially when you've not included big expenses like shoes which often come to £30-40 per pair, and they'll need regular school shoes plus trainers, plus occasionally things like football studs etc.

Does the £150 include PE kit?

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 08:06

The issue is school culture and whether the students have parents who support the school they send their children to or not

Parents are far more likely to support the school and its culture if they’re not having to spent a fortune on silly impractical branded uniform.

Take the horrible polyester shirts for example; hot and sweaty in summer, cold in winter. Of course I could buy cotton but I’d have to iron it and for a FT working mum that’s another job and more expensive as I’d have to buy from an eco brand. Same for polyester Teflon-coated trousers and shorts with no stretch in the fabric. And ties, I loathe making my 6 year old wear a tie (ghastly nylon things I can never get right!)

Also the sheer amount of uniform is expensive. If you’ve got 2 in the same school that’s 10x long sleeved shirts for winter, 10x short sleeved shirts for summer, 10x trousers or skirts, 10x tights or socks, 10x shorts, 10x jumpers with school logo, 10x fleeces with school logo, 10x ties, 10x black socks and black leather shoes, several packs of black hair ties or plaiting bands.

They have to have a clean set each day due to covid. So if I don’t kit each DC out with 5 sets I’m trying to wash and dry mid week after wraparound care!

And although the younger has a few handed down items they’re spares as by time eldest has done with them they have holes, stains and are faded so she doesn’t want them! And their feet are different widths so no recycling there.

Funnyfive · 10/07/2021 07:57

For £150 I’ve just kit my daughter out with her branded secondary school uniform, I just need to buy shirts, tights and shoes.

To me that is essentially the wardrobe she will wear 5 days a week, no arguments for, I’m hoping, around 18 months to 2 years before she grows out of it. A bargain compared with the wardrobe she’d need if she was allowed to wear her own clothes - let alone the arguments of what was or wasn’t appropriate for school.

My sons uniform was even cheaper and had he been able to wear his own clothes life would have been miserable. He would have wanted to wear designer gear every day, and different every day too, which would have cost an absolute fortune and when I would have refused I can’t imagine the rows!

Uniform - easy, no arguments, cheaper than the alternative and teaches them to conform ready for the workplace.

Demelza82 · 10/07/2021 07:48

Schools can't do anything right can they?

barnanabas · 10/07/2021 07:41

I can see the pros and cons of a school uniform of some sort and am on the fence about that.
But...very rigid school uniforms specifically seem very unhelpful for everyone - the school staff who have to spend time policing it, the parents who have to buy it, and the kids who have to wear it. Where's the benefit?
Last summer I spend £497 on uniform for my three kids (and one of them luckily hadn't grown out of a lot of stuff). That's school-branded PE kit, skirts/trousers etc, as well as the blazer and tie. And includes the odd thing second hand and my kids wearing each other's hand-me-downs sometimes. I could very happily have put that money to better use, but it must be a real struggle for a lot of people. It's a state school and I don't live in an area where you get any choice of where you send your children. It seems dictatorial and very unfair.

SamusIsAGirl · 10/07/2021 07:29

Greenlakes

OK so wearing layers of sweaty polyester in a heatwave is great for learning huh?

Not to mention people with disabilities etc.

I wonder if the teachers wear the same dress code irrespective of seasons.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 07:10

Many places have a uniform, and we as a society happily sign up to work there- we don't then change it whilst whining that it doesn't affect me doing my job and going to the daily mail with a sad face........

But most adult uniforms have logic behind them.

Warehouse staff have to wear steel-cap boots for safety reasons.
Clothing retail staff wear the shops' clothes as a form of advertising.
People who work with fresh food need to wear certain things for hygiene reasons.
Nurses can't wear big earrings and jewellery for safety and hygiene reasons.
Supermarket staff wear uniform so they can be identified easily.

etc etc.

But most importantly - those uniforms are provided by the company or the costs can be claimed back on tax returns. Whereas school uniforms can cost several hundred pounds per child - and for what benefit?

GreenLakes · 10/07/2021 01:28

I totally disagree. A strict uniform policy helps instil discipline and generally contributes to an environment of work and focus.

Both of the DCs’ schools have very strict policies- top buttons done up, shirts tucked in, shoes polished, blazer and jumper on at all times unless invited to remove by teacher (not even allowed to ask permission.

It’s great as everyone knows the standards and expectations and generally abide by them.

Aria999 · 10/07/2021 01:19

Also

I went to schools with uniform and was bullied for my lack of fashion sense on non uniform day

But

How was I supposed to develop fashion sense or a personal style when I was wearing uniform all the time?

DS (5) feels strongly he wants to choose and wear his own things and I think that's valuable.

SD1978 · 10/07/2021 01:17

I think part of it being puerile, is part of the appeal to me. Kids are evil little guys. Anything they can grab on to your bully kids- they'll take it. I didn't grow up with a lot of money. Wear what you want days were a fecking nightmare as I never had the 'right' clothes- in a uniform, not saying there wasn't bullying, but at least it stopped that Avenue. Also, rules. They exist. Learn to follow them. Do it now, and then they will be easier in later life. Many places have a uniform, and we as a society happily sign up to work there- we don't then change it whilst whining that it doesn't affect me doing my job and going to the daily mail with a sad face........

SushiGo · 10/07/2021 01:12

@PurpleOkapi

The "better for low-income families" argument is nonsense, unless the school is giving them away for free. It may be true that uniforms are cheaper than giving in to a child's every whim when it comes to designer clothes and whatnot. It's not true that a week's worth of uniforms costs less than a week's worth of perfectly appropriate casual clothes that you can get secondhand or at cheap retailers. That's what the comparison should actually be here.
I really agree with this.

Trying to get uniform second hand is such pot luck at most schools. There's no guarantee you will be able to eg, buy a blazer for £5 on facebook if you are working and other people getting in first every time your child's size pops up.

If you are decking your kid out using primark and charity shops you wouldn't even bother with a blazer, and whatever you did buy can be worn at the weekend too.

This is particularly true when it comes to shoes. For a teenager, the cost of school shoes, trainers and football boots to a nitpicking level of detail could so easily be cut down without a uniform.

Aria999 · 10/07/2021 00:59

Yes I can't see the point of uniforms and we made effort to get a school without them.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 09/07/2021 23:35

I hate uniform. I come from a uniform-free country so haven't experienced it for myself, but having had to navigate uniform-compliance with DC1 who has sensory issues has been a nightmare, and only looks set to get worse once they start secondary in September. The uniform list is long and prescriptive and sooo expensive. I'm halfway through and have already spent £250 on one each of 50% of the required garments. The lightweight polyester emblem blazer is a 'slimline' fit, so DC1, with her swimmer's shoulders was signed up for a woolen version in a boxier cut, which cost £65, more than double the poly version.

I would love to see a standard issue tracksuit uniform, worn with a polo shirt and trainers. DC1 has been fretting about secondary uniform since Christmas, and I know it is going to be a source of daily anxiety and conflict, and this with a child who would do anything to be able to comply and fit in.

Allington · 09/07/2021 23:17

Thank goodness DDs school has uniform so she doesn't get bullied...

Except this week she had the choice of going to homework club or being escorted to the bus stop by the head of year to protect her from the bullies threatening to see her after school.

Bullies find an excuse to bully, it isn't about the issue they claim to be an excuse

BiBabbles · 09/07/2021 23:04

You're not unreasonable to not like uniforms, but the idea that there is no individuality with uniforms or that not having them would mean kids would have all this individuality ignores there are plenty of other factors.

Without a uniform, there would be a dress code, and that dress code would likely include rules on piercings and other things you might find ridiculous. I knew many growing up in the US, even the most lax, that had rules on piercing because of how it affected PE or issues with them getting yanked out. Some uniforms are ridiculous and some dress codes are ridiculous - some are sensible. Some places enforce their policies in ridiculous ways in either case - some try to be sensible. It's more a school administration issue with the community they're in than a uniform v dress code.

I have no strong feelings either way - one of my kids goes to a place without (though does have to wear protective coveralls in the workshop), two goes to a place with, there are pros and cons with either way for them, me as a parent, and for staff trying to police it (and even with the most lax codes, there will be someone pushing at the boundaries). I don't think white button-up shirts as part of uniforms are as practical as they're made out to be and I do think it's unfair on parents when a school goes through multiple head/academy changes and ends having to deal with multiple uniform changes, but personally, I wish the schools I'd grown up with in the States had some of the rules on hair dye and appearance that I see in the UK. It would have saved me a load of mocking to not have my mother be able to change my hair colour or some of the random shite she pulled. The idea that lax codes result in young kids being able to express their individuality ignores how much the parents play a role in that.

zyd32 · 09/07/2021 22:57

I'm not sure I agree that kids wearing second hand uniform are bullied. The three (private) schools my kids have attended all had thriving second-hand uniform shops and parents rarely bought blazers new in particular (£20 rather than £100). Parents received a share of proceeds from their uniform sales as did school so it was popular with everyone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread