Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 09:54

A school near me has heavy wool/tweed type blazers for boys. Apparently they stink when wet (and obviously cant be popped in the washing machine)

They definitely do. We had them at my private primary and they were horrendous. The classroom stunk of wet dog in winter and they were all dry-clean only so only got washed every 6-8 weeks at best. Pretty grim when you think about it!

Mylittlesandwich · 10/07/2021 09:48

While I was at school there was a massive change in uniform. It went from black trousers or skirt, white shirt, school tie and black jumper/cardigan to overpriced blazer from one supplier, black trousers but if you want to wear a skirt it's in a specific tartan that can only be bought from the aforementioned supplier. And 2 different ties depending on what year you were in. The financial impact was huge. So while I do see the benefits of a uniform it should not be difficult to source.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 09:46

A school near me has heavy wool/tweed type blazers for boys. Apparently they stink when wet

At least wool is water repellent and warm.

Presumably they’re using the wool cycle, proper wool detergent and drying flat?

None of my wool items smell when wet.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 09:44

I don’t see what’s wrong with thick, plain, relaxed fit jeggings tbh. In winter most of the reception class wore them after a mum posted a link to fleece lined thermal jeggings. They had a pull up waist and no embellishments or zips or slogans. They looked almost the same as ‘school’ trousers just had a soft furry thermal lining instead of unlined polyester trousers. Plus they were stretchy.

My DC insist on cotton vests under their school shirts even in summer so I don’t think it’s fair to say kids don’t notice fabric.

I wouldn’t want to wear a polyester blouse, it would be itchy, sweaty and offer no warmth in summer nor any breath ability or wicking in summer. Would you want to wear one?

I just don’t see why button up polyester shirts can’t be replaced by T-shirt’s or turtlenecks?

Macaronirabbit · 10/07/2021 09:29

A school near me has heavy wool/tweed type blazers for boys. Apparently they stink when wet (and obviously cant be popped in the washing machine)
I'm quite glad my DC school has standard machine washable blazers.

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 09:21

Peppallama
It's usually used as a catch all expression in uniform policies to mean "please buy your child school trousers and not whatever some shops stock in their 'school' section that tries to nod to whatever happens to be in trend".

Eg. Buy school trousers, not thick leggings with bright silver zips up the ankles/down the front, buy school trousers not black jeans. Don't completely ignore what school trousers are and then complain when we say leggings are not school trousers because "they were in the school section of New Look".

zyd32 · 10/07/2021 09:19

I can't say my kids have ever commented on the fabrics of school uniforms. They play a lot of sport so their school sports kit is in the wash most days. The artificial materials are much more practical as they dry quickly and don't often rip. I hated the old fashioned heavy cotton rugby shirts for that reason, plus if it's raining (which seemed to be most of the time...), they were a lot heavier to wear once they were sodden.

Personally, I don't mind school uniform. It's easy and it's part of a set of rules the kids have to respect at school, as they will in the workplace. As with haircuts, piercings, certain behaviour etc. I don't understand parents who encourage their kids to push the rules to the margin, it just wastes teachers' time and diverts them from being able to teach or prepare for lessons.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 09:18

We just don't iron, easy! Shirt is covered by blazer and if it's hot and the blazer is off then the creases drop out. We do own an iron if DS wanted to use it.

I was objecting to polyester or poly cotton as it’s harsh on the skin, cold in winter and hot in summer.

The alternative would be to kit my DC out in pure cotton shirts but yes they would need ironing as pure cotton crumples so much the collars won’t stand up

Peppallama · 10/07/2021 09:13

Wtf is a 'fashion trouser'?

kowari · 10/07/2021 09:12

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

Take the horrible polyester shirts for example; hot and sweaty in summer, cold in winter. Of course I could buy cotton but I’d have to iron it and for a FT working mum that’s another job and more expensive as I’d have to buy from an eco brand.

This is bollocks. A secondary aged child needs to be ironing their own shirts! Primary children rarely wear button down shirts and in any case usually have jumpers over the top, I don't know anyone who irons them. My mother never ironed my school shirts. You do not need to buy from an expensive "eco brand" to obtain a cotton school shirt. Hmm

We just don't iron, easy! Shirt is covered by blazer and if it's hot and the blazer is off then the creases drop out. We do own an iron if DS wanted to use it.
StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 09:10

This is bollocks. A secondary aged child needs to be ironing their own shirts! Primary children rarely wear button down shirts and in any case usually have jumpers over the top, I don't know anyone who irons them. My mother never ironed my school shirts. You do not need to buy from an expensive "eco brand" to obtain a cotton school shirt

Mine are primary (one in reception one in year 3) and they have to wear button down shirts.

I’ve never found pure cotton shirts outside of eco brands (which are 5x the price of Tesco) and need ironing.

My mum did iron my high school shirts. I don’t think I ironed anything apart from pillow cases until I left home at 18, she didn’t trust me not to singe stuff 😂

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 09:04

I couldn't disagree more. I think children need lower level boundaries to kick against whilst remaining within the more important boundaries. I think children need to learn that sometimes they have to do as they are told and fit into societal norms. I think there is no great problem getting the right colour hair bobbles or socks without bows and parents that allow this allow a metaphorical finger up at the school staff.

Is it not possible to implement lower level boundaries in other ways? Like all the school rules (line up, behaviour, no running, eating lunch at a set time, warnings and punishments for unacceptable behaviour).

Hair must be tied up for health and safety and socks are essential for comfort, so I hardly think it’s parents putting the middle finger up if they run out of the right colour! Last week I ran out of black socks for my DD as I discovered the ‘clean’ ones were somehow full of sand despite being washed! So she wore blue socks that day and I apologised to her teacher on drop off. The teacher laughed and said no problem.

Parker231 · 10/07/2021 09:02

@Cloudninenine - my DC’s didn’t wear a school uniform. Everyone wore non branded jeans, variety of T-shirt’s and sweatshirts. There wasn’t a culture of bullying as reported in other schools.
@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland - do you evidence of high attainment in schools with a uniform. My DC’s left with all A’s and have never worn a school uniform.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 10/07/2021 08:59

Take the horrible polyester shirts for example; hot and sweaty in summer, cold in winter. Of course I could buy cotton but I’d have to iron it and for a FT working mum that’s another job and more expensive as I’d have to buy from an eco brand.

This is bollocks. A secondary aged child needs to be ironing their own shirts! Primary children rarely wear button down shirts and in any case usually have jumpers over the top, I don't know anyone who irons them. My mother never ironed my school shirts. You do not need to buy from an expensive "eco brand" to obtain a cotton school shirt. Hmm

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 10/07/2021 08:56

My friends dd who grew to 6ft by year 8 wore the schools only available skirt online by the school supplier and spent months in and out of isolation because it was too short. It was the only skirt the school would allow her to wear 🤦‍♀️ In the end she was moved schools because there was just way way to solve the issue short of having her legs shortened!

I literally do not believe she was put in isolation constantly if wearing the skirt as it was intended and the hem had been let down fully etc. I know a family with a daughter in exactly the same position but she was isolated because she was constantly rolling up the already short skirt to bum length. No school would get away with constantly punishing a pupil but failing to suggest a solution. I suspect a solution will have been offered (wearing trousers etc).

Cloudninenine · 10/07/2021 08:54

I think they’re a good idea. Having kids in their own clothes just gives bullies another stick to beat poor / fat / unfashionable kids with. Uniforms are an equaliser.

I agree the rules can be too rigid though - bobble colour and bows on socks aren’t really the be all and end all.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 10/07/2021 08:52

. In many parts of the world children wear comfortable, colourful playclothes to school and I promise they don't have any extra problems with discipline and focus in those countries.

This isnt actually true. In many, many countries school uniforms are common or even required and associated with higher attainment. It's only really mainland Europe and the US where they are less common.

SmileEachDay · 10/07/2021 08:51

especially the menopausal women

What an odd, odd thing to say.

itsgettingwierd · 10/07/2021 08:47

@LolaSmiles

But why is anything that you have said important for a child's learning experience? Does it really matter if heaven forbid, a 15 year old has two piercings in each ear lobe? Or someone wears culotte black trousers because they are understandably much more comfortable than the formal type school insist on. Because it tells you a lot about the attitude that is being promoted at home.

A parent who sees "one ear lobe piercing" and say "oh well DC, we can clearly read the expectations that are on the website and have been sent to us but let's go and get you several piercings and if anyone challenges you then I'll argue with school because your piercing doesn't affect your learning ... it's not like a bit of metal affects your brain pats self on back at how smart they are" is exactly the type of parent who is likely to complain that their child was expected to follow the same rules as everyone else and apparently doesn't consent to the school following their behaviour policy when their child chooses to repeatedly ignore the rules. It's why in normal years there's always dozens of threads on here from posters ranting and raving about the fact their child got detentions "for no reason" when in reality their child has disrupted a lesson, refused to follow instructions and argued back. Said posters are quick to argue that their child shouldn't have to follow any school expectations that they don't like.

As an individual, I couldn't care less if a school has a uniform or a dress code, but when uniforms and dress codes are stated then they need following. If parents have no intention of supporting the basic expectations of school, why send their kids there? Home educate them or find a school that allows them the full freedom to pick and choose what expectations apply to them.

Despite being totally against completely authoritarian rigid uniforms I do believe there is truth in this.

But I also think these parents and their offspring would be like it with anything.

I also supported the school and ensured ds wore uniform. But he didn't attend a school that had a rigid one and funnily enough they had less issues with conforming with what they did ask for than the schools who want clones in matching socks and bobbles.

I would have ensured my ds conformed if our only choice was one of the schools who are rigid but I also think as well the rigid uniform rules affect males far less than females.

Black/grey trousers are just that. Shirt and tie are just that and a blazer is just that. I think whatever height shade and size you are as a male you can fit the uniform.

It's not the same for girls. A pencil skirt for example isn't comfortable for some shapes and sizes - same with the a line tartan skirts (which I actually favour!).

My friends dd who grew to 6ft by year 8 wore the schools only available skirt online by the school supplier and spent months in and out of isolation because it was too short. It was the only skirt the school would allow her to wear 🤦‍♀️

In the end she was moved schools because there was just way way to solve the issue short of having her legs shortened!

And it doesn't wash about the world of work anymore. It's the 21st century. People are no longer prevented from taking top jobs in high earning industries because they have multiple piercings and tattoos.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 08:45

The idea it's better to just make children wear plain black and white polyester supermarket clothes is just...depressing

I know what you mean. I hate all the polyester and nylon! Why can’t they wear cotton jersey joggers and cotton t-shirts (or turtlenecks in winter with a sweater)? Or wool blend jumpers and natural fabrics.

Schools could specify a colour scheme if ‘unity’ is important!

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 10/07/2021 08:43

I couldn't disagree more. I think children need lower level boundaries to kick against whilst remaining within the more important boundaries.
I think children need to learn that sometimes they have to do as they are told and fit into societal norms. I think there is no great problem getting the right colour hair bobbles or socks without bows and parents that allow this allow a metaphorical finger up at the school staff.

This.

Also when the rules are more relaxed pupils just abandon them completely. I was at school late 90s/early noughties at the peak of uniform relaxation. By the time I got to 5th form, they had gone from blazers/shirts/ties gradually to a plain polo shirt and school jumper. With every relaxation of the uniform attainment level fell, considerably. Not only that, but once they got to jumpers only people just never bothered even wearing those, they would just wear a hoody and tell staff it was their "coat".

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 08:41

Parents have to decide what's more important to them: supporting the school even if they don't necessarily agree with all their rules, or showing their child that special people like them are exempt so should totally have piercings/fake nails/trainers when the rules say "no trainers, no fake nails". If they choose the latter because wearing trainers, jeans, and false nails is their priority then they can't be surprised when their child is routinely in detention or isolation for thinking school rules don't apply to them.

I agree piercings and fake nails should be banned, they’re a health hazard eg if they get infected or ripped out playing sport.

Trainers does it really matter if you stick to school colours?

I buy all the branded uniform via M&S do the school benefit from that?

I think one can support the school whilst disagreeing with some of their rules.

Uniforms have changed very little since I was at school! Except I had to wear a sash too. They got rid of the sashes as kids used them to tie each other to trees! 😂

Pinuporc · 10/07/2021 08:40

At DDs school we get an email if hot weather is forecast (probably over 25°c) saying they are permitted to not have blazers that day. I'm pretty sure the teachers dont all wear jackets until explicity told they can take them off.

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 08:39

Brefugee
Most of us who've worked places with that rule tell our classes at the start of the year that they can remove their jumpers and blazers when they like. It ticks the box and we can get on with teaching.I haven't the time or inclination to lose learning time giving individuals permission through the lesson .

More often than not I find that the classroom can be far too hot, I've removed my blazer, 75% of students are in shirts and then 25% are in their jumpers complaining of being hot, with the occasional student wearing a t shirt under their shirt! Shock

WutheringTights · 10/07/2021 08:38

@SleepingStandingUp

It's a bit odd you're more perplexed about kids not being able to wear shellac nails than a green hair bobble.

Uniforms aren't the issue, 3000 petty rules are. Ours need grey or black bottoms, yellow top, blue jumper. PE is dark trainers, dark bottoms, white top. Ok primary but the equivalent is possible for secondary

Our primary is the same (naice middle class intake, outstanding school etc). At least, the school tries to insist on logo'd stuff in the uniform letters they send home from time to time, but almost every single parent completely ignores it and continues sending little Tarquin in wearing basic non-logo'd stuff in the correct colours. Most of the kids have lots of support at home, tutors etc so the Head seems to have the sense to quit while she's ahead and doesn't push it any further.