Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
Twitchynose · 10/07/2021 10:50

@StrangeToSee

We just don't iron, easy! Shirt is covered by blazer and if it's hot and the blazer is off then the creases drop out. We do own an iron if DS wanted to use it.

I was objecting to polyester or poly cotton as it’s harsh on the skin, cold in winter and hot in summer.

The alternative would be to kit my DC out in pure cotton shirts but yes they would need ironing as pure cotton crumples so much the collars won’t stand up

Definitely don’t let your precious child work in the NHS then. Polycotton tunics and polyester trousers are the norm! Tunics and trousers need to be washed and pressed by staff at home, no laundry service.
warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 10:45

I meant they should check the uniform policy before buying the shoes.

And what if they can't afford new shoes that fall under the uniform policy?

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 10:42

Which is fine, but lots of parents have no choice about where to send their children. Lots of areas have one high school to choose from, so there's no option to send them elsewhere if you disagree with the uniform policy
I meant they should check the uniform policy before buying the shoes.

Not here. The school supplier sells one unflattering for all style of school trousers for girls (and one style of skirt
That's because your school has decided to have single or limited supplier uniform.
School trousers can be bought in dozens of shops across the high street. The shops are full of them.

AnUnoriginalUsername · 10/07/2021 10:42

I think it's control for the sake of control. Like a post I read a while back about a man insisting his son collect his dinner immediately after it was made. It had no impact on anything, the kid wasn't eating with anyone, it was just a case of dad being able to make him do something because he's the boss. The way I wore my tie at school did not affect anyone else, a student wearing pink nail varnish doesn't affect anyone's learning. Why do we feel the need to control teenagers and then complain when they're not capable of thinking for themselves when they suddenly turn 18.

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 10:40

SinkGirl
Then that comes under SEN and needs raising with the SENCo so appropriate options can be put in place. We've got students like your twins and they wear joggers in the same colour. It's all approved. Another of my students wears a PE polo top instead of a shirt.

In a 10-11 form entry school it doesn't stop the requirement of buying school trousers being reasonable.

I think reasonable parents sometimes don't realise the impact that unreasonable parents have on schools, which is why it's easier to have simple, clear uniform rules in many cases.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 10:40

I always suggest people check their school's uniform policy.

Which is fine, but lots of parents have no choice about where to send their children. Lots of areas have one high school to choose from, so there's no option to send them elsewhere if you disagree with the uniform policy

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 10:37

SinkGirl
I always suggest people check their school's uniform policy.

Something being sold in Clarks doesn't mean it's automatically going to be OK. Clarks sell a range of black shoes at back to school time. It's up to parents to check what's OK for their school. If the school says not to have trainers then buying a trainer type shoe was always going be a risk.

Some schools, like mine, accept the slightly more trainer style shoes, so Clarks will sell those. Others schools don't.

SinkGirl · 10/07/2021 10:37

Most of the "but why does it matter?" arguments work both ways. If it doesn't matter then there's no problem buying a pair of school trousers instead of leggings/joggers/jeans/jeggings etc.

Because for some kids there is a problem. My twins are perhaps an extreme example but I know plenty of autistic kids in mainstream.

At the moment one of my twins will only wear joggers. If I try to put different trousers on him he will fight to keep them off.

I think policies should be more inclusive personally. The fights that some of my friends who have ND kids have to have every single morning to get uniform on them is awful for everyone, and their learning certainly isn’t helped by the constant sensory onslaught of clothes that are distressing them.

Pinuporc · 10/07/2021 10:37

"School trousers" means that students can find a pair of school trousers in a cut that fits and suits them. There's enough options out there and lots of shops sell school trousers

Not here. The school supplier sells one unflattering for all style of school trousers for girls (and one style of skirt)

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 10/07/2021 10:36

I hate school uniforms, I think they're petty, uncomfortable and pointless. I hated wearing them when I was at school and feel for my dd now being forced to wear clothes she hates.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 10:34

If it doesn't matter then there's no problem buying a pair of school trousers instead of leggings/joggers/jeans/jeggings etc.

Of course that can be a problem. It means buying an extra set of clothes when what they already own would be suitable, for starters.

If a school has set its uniform then parents who choose to buy items that aren't on it are being ridiculous.

What if they're sending their kids in the only clothes they have because they can't afford to keep replacing school uniform once their kid grows out of it? It's fine saying "well buy second-hand" but that only works if the second-hand shop has your DC's size in the first place.

School uniform is expensive and many families can't afford to keep replacing things at a cost of £20-30 per logoed item - especially when there's a generic version for 1/4 of the cost.

Twitchynose · 10/07/2021 10:32

Piercings tend to be a health and safety issue, they can get caught or pulled ripping them out, not just in PE, but in lots of interactions, even taking science goggles off for instance. Nail polish, heavy make up and jewellery are no goes in catering, so if kids are doing any food tech (or whatever it’s called now) it’s a hygiene issue. Lots of jobs have restrictions on what you can wear, how smart you look, how hair is tied back (or even the colour of your hair. My NHS contract said hair must be in a natural colour range! We won’t mention my distinctly purple hair where on a very hot and sweaty day my long ponytail leaked purple dye down the back of my white tunic…).
That said, I think uniform should be fit for purpose. Shirts and ties in hot summer wear help no one and expensive items with school logos should be banned. A generic, easily available and affordable uniform should be standard.
I get what people are saying about one style/cut of trouser for example not fitting all the girls. Just don’t let them get a job in the NHS then, I don’t know any woman who finds the standard NHS trousers my trust issued, comfortable or flattering!

SinkGirl · 10/07/2021 10:29

The one I can’t get my head round is the parents that go to Clarks and buy black shoes and they’re not allowed because they look “too much like trainers”. I’m talking about black leather shoes that have a slightly trainerish shape. What’s the issue there?

I can understand some of it, but a lot of it seems completely illogical. Like I say, I’m lucky we don’t have to worry about this but I do feel for parents who have this to deal with.

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 10:29

Why not just "wear plain black/grey trousers". Why the need to specify the style? Does it really matter if Josie wears leggings but Sophie prefers something else?
"School trousers" means that students can find a pair of school trousers in a cut that fits and suits them. There's enough options out there and lots of shops sell school trousers

If schools don't want leggings in their uniform then fine, just like they don't say boys can wear board shorts, or tracksuits.

Most of the "but why does it matter?" arguments work both ways. If it doesn't matter then there's no problem buying a pair of school trousers instead of leggings/joggers/jeans/jeggings etc.

It doesn't matter whether you would choose a different uniform, or I would chose no uniform, or whether someone else would rather have leggings worn as trousers throughout secondary. If a school has set its uniform then parents who choose to buy items that aren't on it are being ridiculous.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 10:28

@worktrip

Don't be ridiculous OP. Teenagers would be wearing no end of outrageous outfits for school, because it's what teens do. They push boundaries so if you remove boundaries (uniforms) classes would e Have kids looking like they came out of a nightclub. Of course many would dress more sensibly but there will always be the rebels.

A uniform should be simple, grey skirt or trousers, white blouse or shirt, navy jumper or sweatshirt. No expensive blazers or logos, and leeway to mix and match styles to allow some individuality

Don't be ridiculous OP. Teenagers would be wearing no end of outrageous outfits for school, because it's what teens do. They push boundaries so if you remove boundaries (uniforms) classes would e Have kids looking like they came out of a nightclub. Of course many would dress more sensibly but there will always be the rebels.

Or they could just have a dress code like they do everywhere else in the world?

dementedpixie · 10/07/2021 10:28

@TheGenealogist

I like school uniform because it's easy and doesn't lead to hours of stressing about what to wear.

But we are in Scotland where state schools have not gone down the "logo on everything" route which many English schools appear to have done. My kids at senior school need a black blazer with a badge (£32) and a tie (£5). Everything else is black and white and the school don't care whether you buy it from Asda or Harrods. PE kit with logos doesn't exist - kids are told to wear what they want, only rule is no offensive slogans, no football kit, no alcohol branding.

I'm also in Scotland and very similar although the school specifies blue PE shorts (£5/£6) and white t-shirt from anywhere. There is a blazer (£35) and tie (£5) and then you can have any black skirt/trousers and white shirts/blouses
Pinuporc · 10/07/2021 10:22

But we are in Scotland where state schools have not gone down the "logo on everything" route which many English schools appear to have done. My kids at senior school need a black blazer with a badge (£32) and a tie (£5). Everything else is black and white and the school don't care whether you buy it from Asda or Harrods. PE kit with logos doesn't exist - kids are told to wear what they want, only rule is no offensive slogans, no football kit, no alcohol branding.

I'd be completely on board with this type of uniform.

kowari · 10/07/2021 10:20

I don't iron casual clothing so the way I see it is if the school insists on uniforms then they can have those unironed too. DS 15 doesn't care if anything is ironed but if he did he could do it himself!

TheGenealogist · 10/07/2021 10:18

I like school uniform because it's easy and doesn't lead to hours of stressing about what to wear.

But we are in Scotland where state schools have not gone down the "logo on everything" route which many English schools appear to have done. My kids at senior school need a black blazer with a badge (£32) and a tie (£5). Everything else is black and white and the school don't care whether you buy it from Asda or Harrods. PE kit with logos doesn't exist - kids are told to wear what they want, only rule is no offensive slogans, no football kit, no alcohol branding.

kowari · 10/07/2021 10:16

The alternative would be to kit my DC out in pure cotton shirts but yes they would need ironing as pure cotton crumples so much the collars won’t stand up
The DC could iron the collars if they wanted them to stand up

worktrip · 10/07/2021 10:16

Don't be ridiculous OP. Teenagers would be wearing no end of outrageous outfits for school, because it's what teens do. They push boundaries so if you remove boundaries (uniforms) classes would e
Have kids looking like they came out of a nightclub. Of course many would dress more sensibly but there will always be the rebels.

A uniform should be simple, grey skirt or trousers, white blouse or shirt, navy jumper or sweatshirt. No expensive blazers or logos, and leeway to mix and match styles to allow some individuality

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 10:12

Speaking more generally this is exactly the problem schools have: they make a fairly simple rule like "wear school trousers, not fashion ones, not jeans, not leggings" and some parents see that and decide that doesn't apply to them.

Why not just "wear plain black/grey trousers". Why the need to specify the style? Does it really matter if Josie wears leggings but Sophie prefers something else?

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 10:10

@StrangeToSee

A school near me has heavy wool/tweed type blazers for boys. Apparently they stink when wet

At least wool is water repellent and warm.

Presumably they’re using the wool cycle, proper wool detergent and drying flat?

None of my wool items smell when wet.

All wool blazers I've ever owned have been dry-clean only ones, and I had them from three different suppliers for school.

And water repellent and warm isn't remotely useful in the summer months and just leads to sweating and trapped odour, which is then stuck in the fabric until the blazers can be dry-cleaned at half term.

In winter months, most kids take their own coats to school on top of blazers anyway so the they don't need to be water repellent anyway. I'd much rather kids wear a cheap, machine-washable blazer that cost £30 or so, than one from that costs well over £100 from the official outfitters!

LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 10:05

I don’t see what’s wrong with thick, plain, relaxed fit jeggings tbh
Because most of the fashion items sold by shops as school uniform are not plain relaxed fit jeggings, and also if the uniform says "school trousers" then it means school trousers, not school trousers unless you think a pair of fashionable leggings is better in which case do what you like and not school trousers unless you would prefer to wear relaxed fit jeggings.

Speaking more generally this is exactly the problem schools have: they make a fairly simple rule like "wear school trousers, not fashion ones, not jeans, not leggings" and some parents see that and decide that doesn't apply to them.

It doesn't matter what you, me or anyone else decides we would prefer a uniform to be. If a school has clearly said what the uniform is then going to and buying items that aren't in the uniform is silly, but some parents do it year in year out.

Macaronirabbit · 10/07/2021 09:55

At least wool is water repellent and warm.

Ideal for a summer day!Grin

They wear them all year round and yes they probably are warmer than the synthetic ones in the winter. I'm not sure anyone who chose their own clothes would wear a wool blazer in summer though.
No idea how they wash them, I've just heard other parents say they smell when wet , and take forever to dry.

Swipe left for the next trending thread