Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
GreenLakes · 10/07/2021 16:40

@Skysblue

A few decades ago all boys had to wear shirts to school until well into secondary. They all survived so I can’t see that it is a big deal or causing any harm to expect shorts until year 6.

There’s no point in having a uniform policy if DC are in all sorts of variations and it is not work properly. That is why the very best schools expect high standards of uniform- it’s about inculcating a culture of high expectations and high effort

itsgettingwierd · 10/07/2021 16:21

[quote GreenLakes]@StrangeToSee

Perhaps there is a correlation between your DC’s school accepting poor uniform and having a ‘not great’ OFSTED.

It is no coincidence that the vast majority of excellent schools have smart uniform policies that are strictly enforced.

A DC appearing at the DCs’ school with a top button undone or yellow shoes will be straight into a one hour detention, so it very rarely happens.[/quote]
Not round my way.

The 2 schools with the strict uniform are the lowest performing and getting worse year on year.

One has just lost its outstanding ofsted rating and the other witches to academy as failing and it still is.

The highest 2 performing schools have a polo and v neck sweatshirt uniform, black shoes (inc black lace up converse for girls) and knee length skirt in uniform colour or trousers.

They have excellent teaching and learning and focus on the right things such as behaviour for learning and being part of society and teaching learning behaviours and a curriculum.

They realise that a blazer does not an A* grade make Wink

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 16:18

Perhaps there is a correlation between your DC’s school accepting poor uniform and having a ‘not great’ OFSTED. It is no coincidence that the vast majority of excellent schools have smart uniform policies that are strictly enforced. A DC appearing at the DCs’ school with a top button undone or yellow shoes will be straight into a one hour detention, so it very rarely happens.

A correlation, I hadn’t thought of that. I viewed the school and liked it, agreed with its nurturing principles, and chose it based on that not Offstead. It’s a primary school although the uniform rules are fairly strict; button up shirts, logo jumpers, tie, logo PE kit right from age 4.

I’d be horrified with a school that put children into detention for not doing up a top button! That sounds so cruel and uncaring. How can the child work properly if they feel their neck is restricted?

As for the shoes, only the soles were yellow. Thankfully the teacher saw sense and allowed her to keep wearing them once I complained.

zyd32 · 10/07/2021 16:15

"I wouldn’t want to wear a polyester blouse, it would be itchy, sweaty and offer no warmth in summer nor any breath ability or wicking in summer. Would you want to wear one?

I just don’t see why button up polyester shirts can’t be replaced by T-shirt’s or turtlenecks?"

Appreciate that fabric is important to you from your posts. Fair enough. It isn't to my family. I couldn't tell you the polyester to cotton content of any top I wear. I can tell you that my sons have worn a variety of school shirts of different fabrics. My son finds the 100% organic cotton shirts (bought by accident from M&S) thicker and therefore sweatier in summer than the poly cotton ones (plus they're hard to iron). Neither son has ever commented on the polycotton mix shirts being itchy, sweaty or anything else. They would put a turtle neck in that category though.

In terms of sportswear, the base layer and activewear clothes are nearly all artificial and are supposedly designed to be breathable and wickable. Hence why they're worn by elite sportspeople.

And this is the essence of a debate over school uniform; we all like different things, fabrics, uniform or own clothes etc etc. I'm sure it's impossible for school to please us all...

dementedpixie · 10/07/2021 16:15

[quote GreenLakes]@StrangeToSee

Perhaps there is a correlation between your DC’s school accepting poor uniform and having a ‘not great’ OFSTED.

It is no coincidence that the vast majority of excellent schools have smart uniform policies that are strictly enforced.

A DC appearing at the DCs’ school with a top button undone or yellow shoes will be straight into a one hour detention, so it very rarely happens.[/quote]
Bonkers!
Does an undone top button stop learning? (My 2 never fasten it and the way the tie sits hides that it's open)
Same with yellow soled shoes. Has no bearing on ability to learn

bullockstoit · 10/07/2021 15:59

I'm all for uniforms but don't think there should be all the silly little rules for example only allowing certain coloured hair ties. Why does that even matter?!

I also hate that most of the uniform for the secondary school here can only be purchased from one shop- it's massively over priced and terrible quality.

DS has been wearing his PE kit on PE days throughout this school year because they weren't allowed to use the changing rooms. He's so much more comfortable especially in warmer weather. I'm really hoping they keep it that way, changing must take up a chunk of the lesson anyway.

GrandTheftWalrus · 10/07/2021 15:59

My dd is starting primary in August and I'm already annoyed at her uniform. It's navy so of course all the cheap uniform is black/grey. Embroidered polo's preferred at 10 a go. Embroidered cardigans at 14 a go. For a 4yo! 2 pairs of shoes, 1 indoor and 1 outdoor. How do they expect people to be able to afford this 2/3 times a year?

Skysblue · 10/07/2021 15:48

Meant to say boys aren’t allowed trousers until YEAR six.

Skysblue · 10/07/2021 15:47

Totally agree OP. The problem isn’t the idea of uniform - that’s fine - it’s that schools insist on sticking to ridiculous concepts that haven’t changed since the 1950s. Why are girls wearing ties? Women don’t wear ties why should girls?

Uniform at a Chinese primary school? A red tracksuit. Cheap, practical, comfy and in my view much nicer looking than the funeral-type dress we put our kids in.

Uniform at a UK primary school? Dull colours that children hate, usually grey or navy. Pull up socks and skirts that a girl can’t exercise in without either flashing her knickers or wearing sweaty cycling shorts underneath which will make UTIs / thrush worse. Plus a compulsory logo jumper that costs £17-25 from one supplier, altho a plain one would only cost £5 at Sainsburys. Shoes she can’t run in properly.

It isn’t any better for boys. Sure the shoes are more practical, but girls usually get the choice between skirt or dress, and can choose between different dress styles / hair accessories. Boys have no way at all to express any of their personality. At our state primary school they aren’t allowed to wear trousers until age six, only shorts. So bare legs in winter for boys, but girls can wear tights (shameless sex and age discrimination).

And the overriding message chikdren are given from the age of four in UK is that what matters most isn’t how you feel or even how you behave - it’s how you look.

GreenLakes · 10/07/2021 15:29

@StrangeToSee

Perhaps there is a correlation between your DC’s school accepting poor uniform and having a ‘not great’ OFSTED.

It is no coincidence that the vast majority of excellent schools have smart uniform policies that are strictly enforced.

A DC appearing at the DCs’ school with a top button undone or yellow shoes will be straight into a one hour detention, so it very rarely happens.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 15:05

Try teaching on a "mufti" day. Like a zoo.

But isn't it like that because it's a novelty?

Evvyjb · 10/07/2021 14:50

I take a measured approach to uniform enforcement. I call out trainers, ridulously short skirts, jeans.

However, when you have watched a child not turn up to school for the 3rd "non uniform day" in the last week of term (and not turn up for days 4 and 5) because he didn't have enough clothes to come in different outfits, then you know uniform is the right thing to do. Noone knows if you're wearing the same trousers 5 days in a row if everyone is wearing the same.

Try teaching on a "mufti" day. Like a zoo.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 14:30

I did get annoyed when my older DD was told her shoes should be entirely black and the soles were yellow! But I sent a note in explaining how hard it is to get shoes that accommodate her high instep and wide feet, and the teacher leg it drop. They were leather, polished and sensible just had the wrong colour sole 🙄

I mean, this what I'm referring to when say schools need to stop making up petty rules - who the hell cares what colour soles someone has on their shoes?! It's bonkers. I can't believe grown adults sit there and think rules like that make sense Grin

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 14:22

I suspect alotof that is because they've been raised in uniform themselves. It's a weir part of the UK "tradition" to stick kids in shirts, ties and blazers at aged 4, for some reason

You’re probably right. I think a lot of parents also dislike confrontation so they buy alternatives that look almost the same.

For example I never do my DCs top button because they say it ‘chokes’ them and I do their ties loosely do they’re not restrictive. I shop around for black trousers they like yet aren’t necessarily school trousers, so that’s thermal fur lined jeggings in winter and thin baggy jersey trousers in summer (or skirts).

They don’t look particularly smart but they’re both academically ahead and well behaved. No snobbery as it’s a state school with a not-great offstead.

I did get annoyed when my older DD was told her shoes should be entirely black and the soles were yellow! But I sent a note in explaining how hard it is to get shoes that accommodate her high instep and wide feet, and the teacher leg it drop. They were leather, polished and sensible just had the wrong colour sole 🙄

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 14:11

"School trousers" means that students can find a pair of school trousers in a cut that fits and suits them. There's enough options out there and lots of shops sell school trousers

I think it’s not as easy for boys. Girls school trousers are often thick jersey stretch fabric and pull up style (eg Tu) but boys ones have fastenings and zero stretch, this is why my friend buys girls trousers for her son with sensory needs.

Also boys trousers all seem to have this Teflon coating (as if girls don’t rip the knees too 😂?) so they’re stiff and restrictive.

Parents generally just want their child to be comfortable, and if that means a different style of trouser I don’t see the issue provided they look like school trousers?

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 14:05

The DC could iron the collars if they wanted them to stand up

At 5 and 7 it would be me ironing the shirts, a job I’d struggle to fit into my already packed weekends (FT working mum). They have to have a clean shirt daily so ironing 10 shirts (plus any spares they’ve used eg if they spilt something) would take a while.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 13:59

Speaking more generally this is exactly the problem schools have: they make a fairly simple rule like "wear school trousers, not fashion ones, not jeans, not leggings" and some parents see that and decide that doesn't apply to them

I understand school trousers need to be not too tight, no zips or slogans or joggers.

But I think typical supermarket school trousers are very impractical for infants, in winter. Especially last year when covid meant all doors and Windows had to be open. Plus infants are expected to sit on the floor for long periods, do lots of outdoor physical activities so trousers with some stretch are less restrictive.

The teacher said nothing about half the reception class sending both boys and girls into school in jeggings last winter. Maybe she didn’t notice as they looked like black skinny fit school trousers. Or she noticed and was glad the children were dressed warmly in thermal fleece lined trousers rather than shivering in thin ones?

They were not immodest in any way and were completely plain.

I have a problem with school uniform being inappropriate for weather. If children are physically uncomfortable or cold/hot how can they concentrate on learning?

I’ll continue to try and find alternatives to traditional uniform that look almost the same, as I don’t want my DC being uncomfortable or restricted by their clothing.

itsgettingwierd · 10/07/2021 13:58

@NoIDontWatchLoveIsland

My friends dd who grew to 6ft by year 8 wore the schools only available skirt online by the school supplier and spent months in and out of isolation because it was too short. It was the only skirt the school would allow her to wear 🤦‍♀️ In the end she was moved schools because there was just way way to solve the issue short of having her legs shortened!

I literally do not believe she was put in isolation constantly if wearing the skirt as it was intended and the hem had been let down fully etc. I know a family with a daughter in exactly the same position but she was isolated because she was constantly rolling up the already short skirt to bum length. No school would get away with constantly punishing a pupil but failing to suggest a solution. I suspect a solution will have been offered (wearing trousers etc).

You not believing it doesn't make it untrue. 🤷‍♀️

She switched to another school that used a supplier that did short, normal and long length skirt in the school style and they had 2 style choices.
The school she moved from was a failing secondary state that switched to an academy and continued failing.

They just made the rules more and more draconian but it didn't improve the school. These schools do exist even if you've never experienced them.

grey12 · 10/07/2021 12:51

Forgot to say that DD is so skinny the trousers keep showing her underwear!!! Angry and yes, I tried fixing it and it didn't work

grey12 · 10/07/2021 12:50

We have money to get uniform and got, for example, the trousers from the uniform shop instead of a supermarket. Within 2 months the knees were a different colour!!!! Ridiculous!

We have jeans from Primark that have been worn by 2 children and are in storage waiting for child no3 to grow!! You can buy nice clothes for cheap

kowari · 10/07/2021 12:46

@bushhbb

*I agree with you. A secondary school is a huge expense and worry for low income families. There are many ways of identifying a child's background even with a uniform. Things also got lost or damaged causing even more aggro.

If you have your own clothes , you don't need to spend 200+ or replace overpriced garments from one or two shops.*


I have a feeling people who say this are wealthy enough to have a full and varied wardrobe for their kids

I would've absolutely hated school without a uniform- it was bad enough with one (wrong coat/shoes/bag). The pressure to wear branded clothes, new outfit everyday and conform to trends. Absolutely no.

Schools offer free or discounted blazers, skirts and trousers for those who really need it. Forcing parents to have to buy 10 Nike tracksuits to fit in at school isn't doing anybody a favour, because that's what it would've been at my school.

Ds has what he wants and needs, but it's simple basic clothing, tshirts, cargo shorts, jeans, hoodies. He has no Nike tracksuits and no interest in them. No pressure to conform to trends at all. I am a lone parent on 20k so not FSM but not wealthy.
LolaSmiles · 10/07/2021 12:45

warmfluffytowels
I've already said several times in the thread that I would be happy with a dress code instead of a uniform. I also think uniforms are good in many cases because some parents seem to read one very clear rule (such as no false nails) and think that means do the exact opposite, usually whilst arguing that it's crushing children's spirits and eradicating creativity if their child doesn't wear blingy plastic nail extensions.

At the end of the day what my preference would be doesn't change the fact that a school having school trousers in their uniform is a reasonable rule.

The problem with the uniform debate is is too many people seem to think that something is automatically unreasonable if it's not the choice they would prefer.

grey12 · 10/07/2021 12:43

@Iggly

You can have rules about clothes to stop inappropriate dressing - you don’t need uniform in secondary schools to address it.

Uniform costs an absolute fortune. It’s disgraceful. And we can afford it!

NEVER had uniform. That doesn't mean we could wear a strippers outfit to school either Hmm I remember this particularly strict teacher telling my friend she had to choose between having a shirt tied around her waist and a "pirate" scarf on her head Grin insane woman
Whatwouldscullydo · 10/07/2021 12:40

Schools then email parents asking for shorts to wear under skirts so they don't show their knickers.

So.we have school trousers that don't really fit girls very well so most opt for skirts but then.said skirts need additional its of clothing to also.make those acceptable for school therfore admitting uniform.is not realky fit for purpose anyway but the one thing that would prevent all this isn't allowed

Aria999 · 10/07/2021 12:35

As long as the children are comfortable and not showing their underwear, why does it matter?

This.

Swipe left for the next trending thread