Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rigid school uniforms

688 replies

Waitrosedisaster · 09/07/2021 15:44

I've just had the usual letter from my child's secondary school, where it outlines all the dos and don'ts surrounding school uniform for the next academic year.

Is anyone just absolutely sick of the outdated concept of strict uniforms? The nitty gritty details of 'only black or brown hair bobbles', 'no bows on socks', 'all clothes including p.e kit must have the school logo'. Why? Just why? My personal favourite this year is the following 'any piercing other than single lobe piercings will be removed immediately, regardless of when piercing was obtained'. Also, nail varnish and shellac will also be removed immediately? Wtf?

School uniforms (other than being used as a money making scheme) were originally used for purposes not to dissimilar from uniforms for prisons, or mental health units. They were used to strip away a person's individuality and make them more likely to conform and obey as they are effectively 'uniform'. It's such an outdated concept and I find it bizarre that schools are able to even dictate which (overpriced) shops the uniform must come from.

I hear arguments from teacher friends about how uniforms are better for low income families, but are they really? Unless the parents do not work, are they even able to claim money off uniforms?

Anyone else agree?

OP posts:
Valenciaoranges · 11/07/2021 12:32

I'm a teacher and hate the outdated concept of anyone wearing ties. It looks ridiculous and so unnecessary for young people. I think some kind of uniform is ok but not so rigid as no nail polish/jewellery/make up etc

warmfluffytowels · 11/07/2021 12:22

[quote GreenLakes]@warmfluffytowels

Whether a rule is logical or sensible, or whether you personally agree with it is totallly irrelevant.

As a parent, you agree to abide by the decisions and policies of the school when you enrol your DC. If you are no longer willing to support those rules, you need to withdraw your DC.[/quote]
Many parents have no choice over which school their child attends. Where we are, there is one high school - no other choices unless you're able to pay for private, or are able to pay several hundred per term for transport to other schools. Withdrawing them and sending them elsewhere isn't as easy as you seem to think it is.

Parents send their kids to school because it's the law for them to have an education and they don't have the knowledge (or finances) to home school their kids. That doesn't mean they have to agree with a bunch of pointless rules about nail polish, shoes and top buttons.

claralara42 · 11/07/2021 12:13

[quote GreenLakes]@warmfluffytowels

Whether a rule is logical or sensible, or whether you personally agree with it is totallly irrelevant.

As a parent, you agree to abide by the decisions and policies of the school when you enrol your DC. If you are no longer willing to support those rules, you need to withdraw your DC.[/quote]
Absolute rubbish, I agree no such thing.

Whatwouldscullydo · 11/07/2021 12:07

And rules that are racist or sexist should he followed too?

GreenLakes · 11/07/2021 11:57

@warmfluffytowels

Whether a rule is logical or sensible, or whether you personally agree with it is totallly irrelevant.

As a parent, you agree to abide by the decisions and policies of the school when you enrol your DC. If you are no longer willing to support those rules, you need to withdraw your DC.

warmfluffytowels · 11/07/2021 11:53

It is our duty as parents to support schools and expect our DC to meet their rules and expectations.

I actually don't agree with this. Not all rules are logical, sensible or make any amount of sense.

GreenLakes · 11/07/2021 11:41

@StrangeToSee

The thing is that you are telling your DC it’s ok to break school rules. If the rule is top button done up and tie worn properly, that is what you should enforce (regardless of whether you agree personally with it).

It is our duty as parents to support schools and expect our DC to meet their rules and expectations.

StrangeToSee · 11/07/2021 10:09

Ok. So then the rule is “No false nails” What about these?

Those look like short gel nails or acrylics with a traditional French manicure. Neat and smart. I don’t think short natural looking nails should be banned, French or French Fade or natural pink even if they’re gel or acrylic.

However if they’re false nails or false tips, there’s a risk they could get caught on stuff during PE/sport and ripped off, damaging the nail bed. So I’d still say no false nails or false tips for school. Although it’s quite hard to tell a fake nail nowadays as lots of girls use natural looking nail wraps or gel etc?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/07/2021 10:06

I was a teacher for 25 years. I loathed uniforms. They have no impact on attainment. Everywhere else across the world seems to manage to educate their young to a good standard without an itchy blazer or collar and tie.

Dh and ds and 2xdss have professional jobs. None of them wear a tie or jacket. They just wear t shirts and shirts. Usual dress code these days is smart casual for office work.

grey12 · 11/07/2021 09:55

Just remembered. Saw it on holidays in Brazil, all the kids had tshirts/polos with the school logo (I remember them being bright blue) but besides that they could wear what they wanted. Some had jeans on, others white skirts, for example. And whatever shoes they wanted. That seems ok for me, better than strict uniform

Parker231 · 11/07/2021 08:35

There is no evidence that wearing a school uniform improves behaviour and attainment or the majority of schools around the world would be failing their pupils - which they aren’t.

itsgettingwierd · 11/07/2021 08:02

@tsmainsqueeze

I can see the point of a basic affordable for all uniform , but i absolutely loathe the ridiculous attitudes and rigid rules some schools adhere too. My daughters school are obsessed with trouser fabric and tightness something i can not possibly consider getting worked up about . I see the point of sensible shoes and short nails but what the hell does it matter if the shoes have a discreet label or the nails have a colour ? There are so many more important issues in a school to be concerned about main one i imagine is getting a kid to engage with education , schools should choose their battles. Growing up is all about finding your style , your tribe etc schools might be better off embracing that. And as for equalising we all know that kids , sadly ,easily work out who has less .
This.

Basic affordable and accessible to all uniform is fine.

The new competitive "we are the best school as look at our clones walking down the street and don't look at our actual results or ofsted report" is not.

My local sink academy which switched to academy and is still doing badly is in the middle of a area of low socio economic deprivation.

The parents were disenfranchised with education and so are the pupils. Making them wear £18 school skirts which come in 1 style despite your personal size, height and shape is not engaging them in education.

There isn't an element of choice here either. Most secondaries are 2-3 miles apart and always full - very few get out of catchment and those in catchment who don't get their first choice are preferring to send their kids elsewhere on bus or train.

Perhaps if they enticed people in with a high quality education and affordable uniform those who cannot get into their own school would attend the academy. They would be a positive influence on their peers who don't get it from home.

Same with the strict rules re pens etc. Some kids don't have them, they would rather miss school than get another detention or move up to isolation. It's not teachers responsibilities to provide these things which I know they are having to do. The government needs to fund schools properly so those who already have the greatest disadvantage aren't disadvantaged out more due to expensive uniform and lack of stationary.

UndertheCedartree · 10/07/2021 22:52

@GreenLakes - I would say shorts were common all year round very many decades ago! I was at Primary in the 80s and all the boys wore trousers then.

00100001 · 10/07/2021 22:07

@Dishwashersaurous

Not at school. It's just a distraction
So, your kids obviously only go to school in uniform, and never partake in home clothes days/charity dress up days etc?

Because obviously if green nails are a distraction, then kids in spotty clothes is just as distracting...?

tsmainsqueeze · 10/07/2021 21:58

I can see the point of a basic affordable for all uniform , but i absolutely loathe the ridiculous attitudes and rigid rules some schools adhere too.
My daughters school are obsessed with trouser fabric and tightness something i can not possibly consider getting worked up about .
I see the point of sensible shoes and short nails but what the hell does it matter if the shoes have a discreet label or the nails have a colour ?
There are so many more important issues in a school to be concerned about main one i imagine is getting a kid to engage with education , schools should choose their battles.
Growing up is all about finding your style , your tribe etc schools might be better off embracing that.
And as for equalising we all know that kids , sadly ,easily work out who has less .

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 21:57

As for nails, I don’t see the issue with clear nail polish in high school. As long as nails are short and clean what’s the issue?

Long false nails or gel/acrylic extensions are obviously a safety hazard so I agree with banning those.

StrangeToSee · 10/07/2021 21:53

My kids have had to wear shorts, have very strict uniform rules, limited set of haircuts

Buy the uniform (second hand if needed), wear it, job done. I wouldn't encourage my kids to push the boundaries of what's deemed a school trouser or leggings because it's unnecessary and not fair on staff. Complying with school rules is part of kids learning to be respectful.

I’d rather my children were warm and comfortable than shivering with cold because the rule states shorts must be worn in winter! Why teach kids to passively and obediently follow an outdated rule set?

I openly tell my infant DC I disagree with the rule about button up shirts, ties and formal trousers (when they moan about them) but I add it’s a school rule so we have to try and comply whilst adapting it as best we can. Adapting for us means trying to make their uniform as comfortable and weather appropriate as we can get away with. It means buying my daughter black leather shoes with the ‘wrong’ colour sole because these are the best fit. And backing her up when the teacher complains. Why is that unfair on staff? Do yellow soles impede learning or cause staff distress?

My priority is not what the staff think, but that my children are warm, comfortable and focused on learning. If that means buying thermal fleece-lined jeggings for mid winter so be it. If it means letting them keep their top button undone and their tie loose who is it hurting? They comply with normal schools rules and are both respectful and academic.

If I forced them to have bare legs in winter, badly fitting shoes, a tight top button and tie, or trousers that failed to keep them warm I’m sure they’d be less focused on studying and more fidgety, and may lose interest in learning at school. Why make kids uncomfortable or cold for the sake of an old tradition?

Hair styles: fair enough, as long hair increases the risk of lice and getting caught playing, so both mine have it short or plaited.

dementedpixie · 10/07/2021 21:31

I didn't say there was a no false nails rule. I just disputed that the picture you showed was nail polish. I dont really care what's on their nails tbh

SmileEachDay · 10/07/2021 21:29

That's not nail polish
That's false nails

Ok. So then the rule is “No false nails”?

What about these?

Rigid school uniforms
dementedpixie · 10/07/2021 21:13

That's not nail polish
That's false nails

SmileEachDay · 10/07/2021 21:13

I don't see an issue with nail polish

Ok, so lets look at that. What about these:

Rigid school uniforms
Brefugee · 10/07/2021 21:10

Bloody Norah are you still doing the shorts thing?ridiculous

Don't be ridiculous OP. Teenagers would be wearing no end of outrageous outfits for school, because it's what teens do. They push boundaries so if you remove boundaries (uniforms) classes would

Don't be daft. Schools in Germany don't have uniforms but they do have a dress code. For eg no strappy tops - tops had to have sleeves. (so regular t-shirts were ok). Skirts had to be within a few cms (can't remember) of the knee. etc etc.

The reality? they wore jeans and t-shirts and hoodies and in the summer they exchanged the jeans for shorts (short-shorts not allowed). And the sun still rose every day, and the earth kept on turning.

SmokeyDevil · 10/07/2021 21:08

I think school uniform is pointless.

Kids will always compare stuff. If you don't have them comparing clothes (which they will anyway regardless if they are wearing them at the time or not, they will mention their new trainers or bag etc), then they will compare phones, laptops, tablets etc. They will do it regardless, and a kid that comes from a low income house still struggles with that, might do more if they end up in secondhand uniform.

Also, if a kid is a brat and has been taught no manners from their parents, a uniform isn't going to magically transform them into a decent human being. They will still be a brat, they will still bully, they will be one of the ones bullying the poor kids on not having the latest iPhone or trainers. They will still be assholes, just in black and white.

Not every job has a uniform, and you go into that job knowing that's a requirement if you choose that line of work. You aren't forced. It's your choice. The kids don't have a choice in this, you are forcing them and they have to go to school. Why not at least let them be comfortable? Probably find they are a bit happier then to go to school, I know dress down days at mine people tended to be happier.

warmfluffytowels · 10/07/2021 20:57

@Dishwashersaurous

Not at school. It's just a distraction
lol, what are you talking about?

How is nail polish distracting?

dementedpixie · 10/07/2021 20:50

Distracts from what?
My dd wears nail polish and still managed to pass her exams and is heading off to Uni after the summer

Swipe left for the next trending thread