Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is Priti a f***ing hypocrite?!

164 replies

AmIPeriOrAreYouJustAnnoying · 09/07/2021 15:36

https://twitter.com/pritipatel/status/1412892001767460873?s=21

OP posts:
BastardMonkfish · 12/07/2021 00:59

@Brainwave89

As an Indian woman I have watched this thread with some interest. My takeaways from it:
  1. If you are an Indian woman in a position of power be prepared for the backlash particularly from white women who will mock your speach, the way you dress and act. Read through the thread and see.
  1. If you are Asian or Black, you are only allowed to be left wing. If you are not, the vitriol reserved for you as a conservative is double that for anyone else. That being said, if you are a woman of colour in any wing of politics then the vitriol is at least 50% higher. Try speaking to Diane Abbott or maybe Jess Phillips.
  1. If you are an Asian woman, you cannot be interested in Sport, or patriotic. Everyone else can at this time, but you of course are a complete imposter.

Please nice middle class white "left leaning" net mummers do one of two things. 1) have a really good look at your attitudes and see them for what they are 2) Come out of the shadows and just be honest that you aren't that comfortable with us... it was a lot easier to know who to avoid when I was being chased down the street by the APL as a girl.

Baroness Warsi was on the Last Leg last night doing keepy uppys and talking about the Euros for ages...this is a Priti Patel thing.

SugarAndSpiceIsNice · 12/07/2021 00:52

@Brainwave89

As an Indian woman I have watched this thread with some interest. My takeaways from it:
  1. If you are an Indian woman in a position of power be prepared for the backlash particularly from white women who will mock your speach, the way you dress and act. Read through the thread and see.
  1. If you are Asian or Black, you are only allowed to be left wing. If you are not, the vitriol reserved for you as a conservative is double that for anyone else. That being said, if you are a woman of colour in any wing of politics then the vitriol is at least 50% higher. Try speaking to Diane Abbott or maybe Jess Phillips.
  1. If you are an Asian woman, you cannot be interested in Sport, or patriotic. Everyone else can at this time, but you of course are a complete imposter.

Please nice middle class white "left leaning" net mummers do one of two things. 1) have a really good look at your attitudes and see them for what they are 2) Come out of the shadows and just be honest that you aren't that comfortable with us... it was a lot easier to know who to avoid when I was being chased down the street by the APL as a girl.

Exactly my thoughts.

What the left leaning middle class are doing quite well is pushing the hard working, aspirational people of Indian origin towards the Conservatives. I'm very disturbed with the abject racism that they display under the garb of politics and policies of Priti Patel. She hasn't done anything radical or different to what used to be already done under previous governments. So the hate against her must not be against the policies but against her.

SugarAndSpiceIsNice · 12/07/2021 00:43

[quote Brainwave89]@Blossomtoes. I am very grateful your permission for women of colour to have power. Read this thread and see the vitriol. What you do not see, and -perhaps cannot understand is that your sub conscious racism amplifies any concerns you have about a person of colour who’s politics you do not agree with.[/quote]
Completely agree with you.
The scale at which Priti Patel gets hate is really scary.

SugarAndSpiceIsNice · 12/07/2021 00:41

I can't believe the amount of hate and despicable name calling that Priti Patel gets. I think her being of Indian origin has a lot to do with it.
Indians are next in line to the Jewish people for Labour and their supporters. Once Labour and their supporters have had their fill with anti-semitism, they've got harassing of people of Indian origin lined up.

Blossomtoes · 11/07/2021 23:47

[quote Brainwave89]@Blossomtoes. I am very grateful your permission for women of colour to have power. Read this thread and see the vitriol. What you do not see, and -perhaps cannot understand is that your sub conscious racism amplifies any concerns you have about a person of colour who’s politics you do not agree with.[/quote]
What I do not see or understand is how anyone can defend an abhorrent politician and then gaslight those who criticise her with accusations of racism.

Brainwave89 · 11/07/2021 23:39

@Blossomtoes. I am very grateful your permission for women of colour to have power. Read this thread and see the vitriol. What you do not see, and -perhaps cannot understand is that your sub conscious racism amplifies any concerns you have about a person of colour who’s politics you do not agree with.

Blossomtoes · 11/07/2021 20:46

@Brainwave89

As an Indian woman I have watched this thread with some interest. My takeaways from it:
  1. If you are an Indian woman in a position of power be prepared for the backlash particularly from white women who will mock your speach, the way you dress and act. Read through the thread and see.
  1. If you are Asian or Black, you are only allowed to be left wing. If you are not, the vitriol reserved for you as a conservative is double that for anyone else. That being said, if you are a woman of colour in any wing of politics then the vitriol is at least 50% higher. Try speaking to Diane Abbott or maybe Jess Phillips.
  1. If you are an Asian woman, you cannot be interested in Sport, or patriotic. Everyone else can at this time, but you of course are a complete imposter.

Please nice middle class white "left leaning" net mummers do one of two things. 1) have a really good look at your attitudes and see them for what they are 2) Come out of the shadows and just be honest that you aren't that comfortable with us... it was a lot easier to know who to avoid when I was being chased down the street by the APL as a girl.

  1. Have you never seen other women in a position of power mocked? Theresa May, Jess Philips, Nicola Sturgeon are just a few examples. Some of the vitriol directed at them has been savage.
  1. Jess Philips is not a woman of colour. There’s a whole lot of vitriol directed at all members of the current government, regardless of their colour - Sunak, Javid and Zahawi seem to be getting off relatively lightly. The amount of vitriol Anna Soubrey attracted exceeded that directed at all the other female MPs put together.
  1. The Asian woman in question supported booing the England team a couple of weeks ago. Now she’s suddenly a fan. Hypocrisy, no?

I’m very happy to see people of colour in positions of power, just not bullies with abhorrent views.

LemonRoses · 11/07/2021 18:18

Brainwave89. My views on Patel are nothing whatsoever to do with her sex or ethnicity. I find her ideas and political views abhorrent. I don’t really care how she dresses, Johnson hardly sets a high standard. I do care how she acts, it’s true.

I don’t mind Asian women caring about football anymore than I care about white men caring about it. Entirely up to them. I do care about it being used to gain credibility through popularism. Johnson couldn’t even name the goal scorers in the 1966 cup, yet sells himself as a football fan and goes full fancy dress.

I think Sadiq Khan is as good a mayor as Andy Burnham. I think Keith Vaz is sound, as was Oonah King. David Lammy is excellent. Layla Moran is good too. Sayeeda Warsi says some sensible things.

It’s not about anything other than abhorrent views such as;

In 2013, Priti voted against same-sex marriage in England and Wales.

She voted against banning the detention of pregnant women.

She’s been a supporter of the death penalty, saying that it would “deter crime”.

She backed the immigration bills of 2014 and 2016 introducing the rent, work and bank account checks. This lead to members of the Windrush generation being wrongfully told they had no right to remain in the UK.

In 2015 and 2016, she voted for stricter immigration policies. These included forbidding asylum seekers to work if their application took longer than six months.

In 2017, Priti was fired from her position as International Development Secretary for conducting 14 off-the-book meetings with Israeli ministers and business people. She didn’t notify the PM at the time about these meetings.. Israeli officials were undoubtedly interested to meet with her because she controlled some of the funding the UK gives to Palestinian organisations.

Before she left her IDS role, Patel leveraged an £11bn aid budget as a trade incentive to make business deals with other countries in time for Brexit. It is illegal for the UK to explicitly use aid funds in this way, but that didn’t stop her.

She funneled hundreds of millions of pounds worth of the UK’s aid budget into corporate ventures. This included setting up five-star luxury hotels and shopping malls in Nigeria and investing in Chinese online gambling and restaurant chains.

As Home Secretary, she broke ministerial protocol for the second time by serving as an advisor for Viasat, cashing in a hefty £1000 an hour. The ministerial code states that former ministers have to consult the government advisory positions before taking up business appointments within two years of leaving the role.

Brainwave89 · 11/07/2021 17:54

As an Indian woman I have watched this thread with some interest. My takeaways from it:

  1. If you are an Indian woman in a position of power be prepared for the backlash particularly from white women who will mock your speach, the way you dress and act. Read through the thread and see.
  1. If you are Asian or Black, you are only allowed to be left wing. If you are not, the vitriol reserved for you as a conservative is double that for anyone else. That being said, if you are a woman of colour in any wing of politics then the vitriol is at least 50% higher. Try speaking to Diane Abbott or maybe Jess Phillips.
  1. If you are an Asian woman, you cannot be interested in Sport, or patriotic. Everyone else can at this time, but you of course are a complete imposter.

Please nice middle class white "left leaning" net mummers do one of two things. 1) have a really good look at your attitudes and see them for what they are 2) Come out of the shadows and just be honest that you aren't that comfortable with us... it was a lot easier to know who to avoid when I was being chased down the street by the APL as a girl.

Clavinova · 11/07/2021 17:27

thecatsatonthewall
it was only 2 or 3 weeks ago she was supporting booing them BEFORE the game

She didn't condemn the fans for booing rather than support them - perhaps she regretted her words on reflection. I mostly agree with her about identity politics though - I don't think Keir Starmer should have taken the knee, although I don't mind footballers doing so if they want to.

People who support the death penalty nowadays are in full knowledge of the facts, Patel being a leading politician would have been

Priti Patel was not a 'leading politician' in 2011 - in fact she had only been an MP for 18 months when she appeared on QT.

Labour are at least addressing the issues in their party

And yet you were claiming that people cannot change their 'core beliefs' - a lost cause then?

do you believe people like Hancock, Dowden, Jenrick and Javid can be remainers but suddenly become 'Brexitiers' to further their careers?

I didn't claim that Tory MPs were 'far more likely to be genuine' - you were making that claim for opposition MPs - look up 'Corbyn, Starmer, Labour Party' and 'fence sitting'.

Zotter · 11/07/2021 16:25

@Justanotherlurker

The ECHR report did not say the Labour Party was institutionally racist so cringing for you.

Feel free to argue a technicality whilst ignoring the wider issue that it is'nt the Tories being repremanded by the ECHR for open racism.

Especially when the person I was replying to was trying to insinuate that the Tories was an openly openly racist party, nuance and reading the thread might help.

Apologies I quoted the wrong comment above. So in answer to this comment by you.

No, Justanotherlurker, you said the ECHR found the Labour Party was institutionally racist. The ECHR report said that there were 2 unlawful acts of harassment - by Ken Livingstone and a former Labour councillor - and discrimination for which the Labour Party is responsible and identified “serious failings in leadership and an inadequate process for handling antisemitism complaints.” All unacceptable but the report did not go as far as concluding the LP was institutionally racist which it was asked to consider.

Zotter · 11/07/2021 16:23

@Justanotherlurker

Openly racist if convenient, covertly racist when not.

I agree, it's no bad tactics just bad targets as the new found narrative, I suspect on MN though it will be memory holed into a becoming a right wing narrative.

Problem is the internet remembers

No, Justanotherlurker, you said the ECHR found the Labour Party was institutionally racist. The ECHR report said that there were 2 unlawful acts of harassment - by Ken Livingstone and a former Labour councillor - and discrimination for which the Labour Party is responsible and identified “serious failings in leadership and an inadequate process for handling antisemitism complaints.” All unacceptable but the report did not go as far as concluding the LP was institutionally racist which it was asked to consider.
Crankley · 11/07/2021 14:20

@Whoarethewho

Really glad to see when it comes to the polls these peak woke mumsnetters are in a tiny minority. Keep wringing your hands and wiping away you tear smudged makeup. I'm finally glad we have a home secretary prepared to actually enforce immigration controls good on her and I will support even tougher measures.
100% agree. What makes me laugh is if you dare say a critical word about Abbott these same people scream 'racist' and other choice words which is a joke. She's a walking disaster, sent her child to private school whilst berating others who did the same. Such a hypocrite.
thecatsatonthewall · 11/07/2021 13:21

@Clavinova Absolutely nothing wrong with politicians supporting the England team but it was only 2 or 3 weeks ago she was supporting booing them BEFORE the game, what does booing do? support or rubbish the team?

People who support the death penalty nowadays are in full knowledge of the facts, Patel being a leading politician would have been, yet still supported it, which of course she is perfectly entitled too.

Labour are at least addressing the issues in their party, unlike the Tories and the PMs statements on Islam.

Brexit is done, no one believes the UK can ever rejoin, what Labour and other remainers want is a better working relationship with the EU, at least this is acknowledged or do you believe people like Hancock, Dowden, Jenrick and Javid can be remainers but suddenly become Brexitiers to further their careers?

Clavinova · 11/07/2021 12:52

I think Boris handed out the England shirts so everyone thinks the Tories are down with the kids.

Priti Patel's son is aged about 12 or 13 - she is 'down with the kids.' More likely she bought her son an England shirt and borrowed it for the photo.

thecatsatonthewall
@ Clavinova People don't suddenly change core beliefs like the death penalty, anymore than they suddenly change from being in Momentum to joining the tory party.

That statement doesn't bode well for challenging anti-semitism in the Labour Party.

Personally I think attitudes to capital punishment can easily be swayed by topical events such as major terrorist attacks and child murders - with miscarriages of justice swaying public opinion the other way. Priti Patel's original comments were made in 2011 so not necessarily a 'sudden change' in belief for her - although, as International Development Secretary, suddenly being presented with government briefs and committees detailing the realities of capital punishment in other countries could well be responsible for her change of opinion.

TBH if you want to be be successful in politics be a tory, members of other parties are far more likely to be genuine as they have chosen a far harder path to political power.

I think most people were confused by Labour's stance on Brexit - even now - nothing 'genuine' about it.

LemonRoses · 11/07/2021 09:36

@Muminabun

I like, she is doing what she has been tasked to do. We need a strong HS. i feel uncomfortable reading the comments of sheer hate being directed at this woman for simply celebrating the England win.
Who told her to bully such that it took £370,000 to hide it? Who suggested she tries to set policies that breach international maritime laws? What is strong about her?
Muminabun · 11/07/2021 06:39

I like, she is doing what she has been tasked to do. We need a strong HS. i feel uncomfortable reading the comments of sheer hate being directed at this woman for simply celebrating the England win.

Nat6999 · 11/07/2021 03:41

Vile woman who shouldn't still be in a job. I think Boris handed out the England shirts so everyone thinks the Tories are down with the kids. The Euros have been a good smokescreen to cover up the fallout of Matt Hancock & the fact that Covid cases are increasing, once the final is over, whether we win or lose there is nothing for them to hide behind, I'm fully expecting them to blame anyone who went to the pub or to Wembley for cases increasing & further restrictions.

chaosrabbitland · 10/07/2021 23:41

@Blossomtoes

We need immigrants to do the jobs the British won’t or can’t do. We need their youth. We need their skills

Too damned right we do. The UK birthrate is falling every year and the group in which it’s falling fastest is white British. We need skilled immigrants and we need their children.

yes as in skilled , but im wondering how many of these ecomomic migrants crossing over by the boatload to dover are actually skilled or just want to settle in britain because its much more of a soft touch than france or any of the other countries they have passed through that dont put them up in hotels with money each month . i personally wouldnt care if they were skilled or doing a job the english cant or wont do , but most of them just drag put there claims for months and years and spend that time doing black market jobs or existing on benefits , as well as being housed in an already tight social housing shortage if they have kids , im struggling to see how that helps the uk

if priti is discouraging this kind of immigrant , but wanted skilled than im ok with that , but so far shes proving useless at stopping any of them coming in

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2021 23:36

Glad it’s not just me - I thought dementia had come calling.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 10/07/2021 23:15

I’m with you Blossomtoes. Could make neither head nor tale of that sentence. Someone’s possibly started on the pre-match bevvies a bit early?

Blossomtoes · 10/07/2021 22:50

it's no bad tactics just bad targets as the new found narrative

Maybe I’m spectacularly thick tonight but I’ve read that three times and it still makes no sense. Could someone who understands it translate, please?

Justanotherlurker · 10/07/2021 22:47

Openly racist if convenient, covertly racist when not.

I agree, it's no bad tactics just bad targets as the new found narrative, I suspect on MN though it will be memory holed into a becoming a right wing narrative.

Problem is the internet remembers

longwayoff · 10/07/2021 22:40

Openly racist if convenient, covertly racist when not.

Justanotherlurker · 10/07/2021 22:16

The ECHR report did not say the Labour Party was institutionally racist so cringing for you.

Feel free to argue a technicality whilst ignoring the wider issue that it is'nt the Tories being repremanded by the ECHR for open racism.

Especially when the person I was replying to was trying to insinuate that the Tories was an openly openly racist party, nuance and reading the thread might help.