Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think its harsh to not find one positive thing ??

66 replies

supermario10 · 09/07/2021 15:33

Just read my DS school report and honestly can not find one single positive thing 🙈 any thing remotely positive is then followed up by a negative....

Feel really sad for him 😞

Maybe he's a pain at school ?? Although I have not been told that by school if that is the case. He's definitely a reluctant writer but other than that is doing well at school..

He is in Year 2 ...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fifthtimelucky · 09/07/2021 22:17

My younger daughter is 21. When she was in year 1 or 2 her teacher had obviously cut and paste as she had forgotten to change the name of the child she was writing about.

It was all very generic. The teacher could have been writing about anyone.

Jet888 · 09/07/2021 21:48

Obviously don't know your child so can't speak on their situation but I know I use those sorts of phrases when the child struggles and /or doesn't concentrate well. If your child isn't a major issue in class in terms of learning needs or behaviour then im afraid it's most likely you probably wouldn't have been called to be spoken to...sad and bad reality of very busy days unfortunately. The best conversations I have with the parents in these situations is when we discuss what exactly the parents can be doing at home to help the child. Have seen children come on leaps and bounds after reports like this when parents have concrete feedback like, 'Work on getting him, 2 5 and 10 times table fluent and quick. Try this online app/game etc,' or 'work on quarter to and quarter past the hour' or 'practise b and d' or whatever it is... approach the teacher in a friendly positive way, say you were concerned and want to make sure you know what to focus on in your practise with him at home.

supermario10 · 09/07/2021 21:15

@mrsterrypratchett ... this is exactly what I said! 😒

OP posts:
DroopyClematis · 09/07/2021 20:27

I believe that many schools adopt a generic report writing system, whereby they write according to a script.
Eg, a list of criteria is posed, according to the year group, then children are categorised, according to whether they have met the criteria.
Eg With regard to scissor skills , you'll get 'Jimbo can cut accurately along a given line.'
Or 'Fossie is starting to recognise rhyme.'

I wouldn't read too much in to it. If you're at all concerned then ask to speak to the teacher.

MrsTerryPratchett · 09/07/2021 20:21

The thing is it isn't hard to do.

Billy is a funny and enthusiastic boy which means that he sometimes struggles to focus.

Jane is a perceptive and calm child who sometimes needs support in social situations.

Shit sandwich. It's easy!

ForeverSausages · 09/07/2021 19:43

Sorry OP, didn't mean to hijack. Your post resonated with me Flowers.

ForeverSausages · 09/07/2021 19:41

Thank you @Bridie20! It's actually really comforting to read. He's in year 1 and yup he read the report (it was posted on the Dojo app) and was quite upset. He's very academic though so I wasn't surprised to see the art point, but it's a shame she couldn't at have least mentioned the positives. Fingers crossed for year 2 Smile.

TSSDNCOP · 09/07/2021 19:34

It is, and always has been, my firm belief that a report either at school or work should never have content that comes as a surprise but has comment, where there is a negative, that doesn't have a goal on how to support and improve.

Also, I think dropping a shit report right at the end of term is just bloody stupid as there's absolutely nothing you can do to address it.

I would ask for a meeting with the teacher and if that gets nowhere their senior leader.

QueenBee52 · 09/07/2021 19:33

Im sorry OP..

I bet he's doing as well as the other kids 🌸

Newmumatlast · 09/07/2021 19:26

@Bluntness100

Isn’t that positive op? That he is beginning to, he is starting to etc? That’s progression right?
I thought this too. And perhaps it is accurate that he is beginning to and starting to do those things.
DontBiteTheBoobThatFeedsYou · 09/07/2021 19:23

*welly

DontBiteTheBoobThatFeedsYou · 09/07/2021 19:22

OP you should have said you were a primary school teacher.

It gives way more wellie to what you're saying you've read.

One of my boys is Hard Work but the teacher said some amazing things about him.

Year 2 is so tiny and far too young to be written off (Bluntness is as helpful as always) and if you believe there's an issue then it's worth addressing. If it's the sign of a shit school then that needs addressing.

Bridie20 · 09/07/2021 19:22

@ForeverSausages my reply above was meant to be for you! Sorry!

Bridie20 · 09/07/2021 19:21

That’s awful, especially after 2 years! It has been a tough year but in my opinion the pastoral side of things should have been a priority!

I agree with everyone saying they could have found some positives for sure - every child has something lovely you can say about them! Also, if they have been a little b*er then you definitely should’ve been told because it can be a sign of them struggling with something 😥

Hope you’re ok, OP! Does your child read their reports? I’m in year 5, so always very aware that many of the children will read my comments as well as parents.

Rosesareyellow · 09/07/2021 19:10

You keep hearing about how things are different these days and it sounds like they sure are. It used to be, kid gets a bad report - parent tells child to buck up their ideas. Now if a kid gets a bad report parents get upset with teachers Hmm for what? Not mincing their words enough? And amongst all this getting upset with the teacher presumably parents forget to even have a word with their DCs about their school effort and behaviour. I feel sorry teachers these days.

HopeValley · 09/07/2021 18:57

Quote fail three, was regarding the pp who said most schools have report generating software - I disagree.

HopeValley · 09/07/2021 18:56

Have never worked in a primary school with such software. It takes me 1hr+ per report, which I have to complete on top of my normal workload.

DonLewis · 09/07/2021 18:34

Did you get any numerical marks? In my son's report a 1 is greater depth, 2 expected standard 3, not meeting the required stage, but working towards it and 4 is intervention required.

They get that for their subjects, their behaviour, their effort and focus.

Beginning to... starting to...seems like what you'd write if a child was at a 3 based on that system. Does that feel right?

RickiTarr · 09/07/2021 18:24

@Doona

I agree that "starting to blah blah" is negative language in primary school reports! But the truth is that some kids are super verbal communicators, for example, and in everyone's business, and others are more reserved. Those reserved kids are always going to get "learning to" take part in group activities etc. It's not necessarily a problem that needs addressing. I don't know why there has to be comparison deficit model on everything.
I think it was adopted to be a positive way of phrasing. The old phraseology was much worse.

Comments at the end about personality and behaviour are usually there to humanise them whole thing, though.

RickiTarr · 09/07/2021 18:22

@supermario10

I'll probably get flamed now for saying I'm 'drip feeding' 🤪 but I am a primary teacher and whilst I have been on a career break for some time now I have written lots of reports over the years and have managed to find positive things to say about even the toughest kids! Even if not academically , their personality! I think it's sad that my sons teacher for whatever reason hasn't been able to...maybe he's a s* at school? But I haven't been told that...he's a reluctant writer and I know that myself from working with him at home (homework) my husband and I are both key workers so he has been at school throughout the lockdowns For context for those talking about generic reports he's in a village school with approx 14 in a class
The approved format for reports varies between schools, and between LA areas, though, doesn’t it?

I have enough DC and enough family in teaching to have heard a bit on this subject, and see a range of report styles.

YANBU to prefer something less formulaic and more narrative but, realistically, they are probably quite attached to their way of doing things. If it’s a village school l, I can see that the nature of village life might have contributed to their decision to have an almost “tick box” report style, TBH. Have a friendly chat with the class teacher.

RickiTarr · 09/07/2021 18:15

“Beginning to…”, “Starting to…” mean he has emergent skills in those areas. They write them to a template, commenting on each of the constituent skills in each area of the curriculum. It’s basically a progress sheet for every skill he should be learning.

Talk to the school about how to help to build on his progress so far.

Is his behaviour okay, according to the report?

Clusterfckintolerant · 09/07/2021 18:07

Don't be sad. Speak to the teacher.
Before you do, be clear on where he was academically last September and where/why you think he has progressed. Did you do much home-learning with him or was he in school throughout lockdown? Home learning was invaluable insight for us; we got to see what the children could generally do, what they struggled with, and gave us a useful measure to compare against comments in the report...

Staffy1 · 09/07/2021 17:59

Don’t they ask for feedback? Every report my DS has had has asked for the parents feedback.

statetrooperstacey · 09/07/2021 17:52

My DH once got a school report which said “ Simon really enjoys football, a game at which he has no skill’ that was the best bit.
I got one once which said ‘ Stacey is the catalyst around which all things happen’
We both turned out ok😬
Teacher should try harder though really to find something nice, sorry .

Doona · 09/07/2021 17:47

I agree that "starting to blah blah" is negative language in primary school reports! But the truth is that some kids are super verbal communicators, for example, and in everyone's business, and others are more reserved. Those reserved kids are always going to get "learning to" take part in group activities etc. It's not necessarily a problem that needs addressing. I don't know why there has to be comparison deficit model on everything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread