Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unequal finances

286 replies

Itsraimy · 08/07/2021 22:52

Prompted by another post, but my partner and I (no kids and live together but not married) are discussing how we split our finances.

I earn circa 100k and DP earns circa 25k. Maybe IABU but if our household outgoings are 3k I think it’s fair enough that I put in 2k and they put in 1k.

Partner thinks that’s a bit unfair but I feel a bit aggrieved to put in a true ratio as feel I’m being penalised for earning a lot more.

If we split purely on salary, I’d put in £2.4k and they’d put in £600. AIBU suggesting we go for a 2k from me, 1k from them split?

OP posts:
AmandaHugenkiss · 09/07/2021 09:34

@minatrina

This thread makes me sad.

Your monthly outgoings are significantly higher than what most people earning what your partner earns would pay. This is obviously due to your higher salary.

When you bought your house, did you consider that you should buy a smaller/cheaper house to accommodate their salary? Or did you want what you could afford and then expect your partner to stretch themselves to afford it?

YABU

This is an extremely good point.

DP and I earn approximately the same, so when we bought we agreed a 50/50 split on ownership and mortgage payments. After a previous failed relationship that got messy, if I was earning 3 times his salary and overpaying the mortgage, I think I would have suggested a 75/25 ownership split with a legal contract.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 09/07/2021 09:10

I've been in your shoes, realised they could never match my earnings etc no matter how much effort they into their career.

It was either drop the chump and find someone else or throw my lot in and consider everything we did moving forward to be a joint enterprise.

You've bought a house together and you're still unsure how to pay for everything between the pair of you?

My advice to you would be to not be completely transparent about your earnings and stick away @ 10% every month as your personal shit happens fund.

Everything else to my mind you're at the point where you should both be coming out with the same amount of "spare" cash, you've got 6k coming in, £3k going out, save 1k a month/overpay the mortgage jointly and have 1k each a month as jollies money (upping or reducing the savings amount to suit your particular lifestyles). Regarding it still as your money and their money always causes resentments.
Just be happy together and accept that your footing much more of the bill

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 09:08

The ‘regular household expenses’ don’t matter. He chose to earn less and you know it - and you won’t be happy living a lifestyle he can afford. So you will be stuck paying for any extras and the cost of your joint lifestyle (such as lions share of rent for a bigger place, holidays ) forever. Why should he do ‘extras around the house’ just to make up for you being a higher earner when you knew what he was like and still chose to date him?
Unless he’s spending his personal money on personal things he wouldn’t be able to afford without meeting you (like luxury clothes and expensive alcohol) I wouldn’t say they’re taking advantage. Even if they put in extra £400 they still ask you for money as you say you pay for extras so you’re making it up either way aren’t you?
Unequal relationships don’t last unless there are children or the lower earner does a great deal for the higher earner for this very reason.
Attitude to earning is a very important value (as is religion and wanting children) and is a potential dealbreaker.

BumbledBee · 09/07/2021 09:05

I think it's almost fair but it does feel like most of the expenses will be based on the fact that you earn a lot and therefore out of your partner's hands a bit. Apologies if this has been covered, but as the mortgage will be the bulk of it and based on earnings, can you split mortgage, council tax and food (because chances are you don't buy groceries frugally because of your income) according to salary and then split utility bills 50/50?

poptartsarefood · 09/07/2021 08:57

This relationship is pretty financially unequal and without marriage/kids there is no reason for the OP to make it more equal and sub their partner. Normally you would expect another adult who isn't a dependent to pay 50:50, split housework 50:50 and pay for extras equally.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 09/07/2021 08:53

@PizzaCrust

This isn’t fair at all, unless they’re choosing to work part time for no reason or something.

IMO you add your salaries together, deduct bills and savings then split the rest down the middle.

They aren't married. Why should she pay him even more to be her boyfriend?

He chooses to work part time, gets a better standard of life than his salary could afford, is living in a home he couldn't afford to pay for - which he will get far more out of than he put in should they split, eating food he would struggle to pay for over and above the rent, holidays, clothing etc etc.

@Itsraimy your problem is that your financial arrangement and his expectations of you have started to niggle. You may well have been fine with it up until now but his attitude, that it's unfair for him to pay so much, and your perception, that you don't want to be paying for everything, aren't being met with a compromise that works for both of you.

You need to talk about this fully and frankly or it will snowball leaving you both feeling resentful.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/07/2021 08:52

@InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest

You went down a path that allowed you to earn more than them. You deserve to have more disposable income IMO. YANBU.
Would you say this if the sexes were swapped?

Wife works as a nurse, ft, earns 30k
Husband works as a human rights lawyer, ft, earns 120k
No kids

Should he squirrel away the masses extra he earns?

FunMcCool · 09/07/2021 08:46

Does his work have the option of 5 days a week?

Roomonb · 09/07/2021 08:41

I voted YABU until you said you were overpaying the mortgage and paid for all holidays etc as well.

If he took on the lions share of stuff at home, garden, life admin I think that would be different or if he was primary carer for DC but tbh I’m not sure that you should be paying more given that he doesn’t.

He could pick up another day of work , it’s lovely yo be chilled etc but not if its at the expense of someone else. If he’s happy not worrying about earning much then he’ll be fine with less disposable income.

I think you are being pretty generous already tbh.

IcedSpice · 09/07/2021 08:38

You should be taking home around £ 5,117.14 with a 20% pension payment

Unequal finances
minatrina · 09/07/2021 08:37

This thread makes me sad.

Your monthly outgoings are significantly higher than what most people earning what your partner earns would pay. This is obviously due to your higher salary.

When you bought your house, did you consider that you should buy a smaller/cheaper house to accommodate their salary? Or did you want what you could afford and then expect your partner to stretch themselves to afford it?

YABU

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 09/07/2021 08:26

You went down a path that allowed you to earn more than them. You deserve to have more disposable income IMO. YANBU.

FindingMeno · 09/07/2021 08:20

If you are serious about the longevity of the relationship you need to stop thinking as a me and start thinking as an us.

AmandaHugenkiss · 09/07/2021 08:20

[quote Itsraimy]@TheFoundations I’m fine with my partner not wanting a stressful job and thinking there is more to life.

I’m fine with paying 2/3 of our household outgoings and paying for holidays and overpaying our mortgage.

I’m just not sure I’m fine with paying almost all of our monthly outgoings. Clearly I’ve split opinion.[/quote]
I think it should be a true ratio based on salary earnings. That’s the fair way of doing it. You have bought a house with your partner, you are committed, and if this was a woman on a lower wage Mumsnet would be bloody outraged the split wasn’t fair. These are essential household expenses and you knew his wage when you committed to buying with him.

But then, I’d suggest that you maybe think about a 50/50 on luxuries. He shouldn’t expect you to subsidise him for luxury holidays unless you desperately want something fancier than he can afford and you are willing to pay.

Myself and my partner both think there is more to life than work, but accept that if we take a lower paying job for work/life balance, you have to accept your “optional” lifestyle (luxuries) has to be adjusted accordingly.

Paq · 09/07/2021 08:20

Then he does the lions share of the home work.

No, they don't.OP has a cleaner and does most of the cooking because they enjoy it.

MiddlesexGirl · 09/07/2021 08:18

I've only read the first two pages which have been pretty much 50:50 in whether yabu or not, but there's a very clear solution here that may have been mentioned already and that's to split the difference in opinion.
So instead of £2K/£1K or £2.4K/£600
make it £2.2K/£800.

camouflagejacket · 09/07/2021 08:05

The bank presumably lent you 3x your JOINT salary. Ie they weighted your salary as 4/5 of the deal. Not 2/3. Been in a similar situation and higher earner paid ALL the mortgage and then we spilt on the bills and holidays. Higher earner also had a nicer car.
I bet you feel dead generous buying all the expensive treats though, don't you? Man up!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/07/2021 08:04

@Bizawit had a good idea about spitting as if he (have we established it’s a he?) worked 5 days a week - so as a proportion of the full time salary. But I think that’s with him also picking up the lions share of housework, as you’d still be effectively subbing his choices.

It does make a bit of a difference if it’s a he or she, in a way, as a male partner hasn’t had to contend with the gender pay gap, fewer opportunities etc. So we’d know that wasn’t part of the picture. I dont really like threads that are left gender neutral as it always makes A difference, even if it’s a small one.

OhEff · 09/07/2021 07:56

You're adults with no joint financial responsibilities except household bills. Those bills should be split 50:50 UNLESS you as a higher earner, refused to live in a place the lower earner could afford half of. Then you pay the difference.

That's my view. I would never expect a higher earning partner to subsidize my pursuit of a less profitable career and I wouldn't support a lesser earner. Up to the point when career sacrifices are made for childcare purposes then I would take the MN favourite of 'family money'.

Snowpaw · 09/07/2021 07:53

As others have said, it seems like he’s living a lifestyle outside of his means. You’re not unreasonable for wanting a good lifestyle / home on your level of pay, but I guess you either find someone who is at a similar level to you financially to be able to share it more equally, or you accept that you will be subsiding his lifestyle for the foreseeable. Or you downgrade your home and and move into somewhere he can afford half of, if financial equality is important to you. Personally I think it’s a rough deal for you - presumably you have worked very hard to get where you are and he hasn’t had to do that, but gets the lifestyle that comes with it and potentially half of the house if you split. It’s easy to think “there’s more to life than careers” if you are living in a nice house with regular holidays provided for you and don’t have to worry about money because of your partner’s hard work!

Dashel · 09/07/2021 07:51

I think regardless of how you split the bills, they are two things I would think about, firstly why they are only working a four day week and if they are using the time productively as for studying or doing all the housework, life admin etc or just chilling, this would effect how I would split the bills.

I would also stop overpaying the mortgage until you were married or had dc and would put the savings in a S&S isa in your name. That way if you split you aren’t giving them half.

3Britnee · 09/07/2021 07:35

@Itsraimy

Both salaries are gross. So my take home is about 4.6k after pension. Theirs is 1.5k after pension.
How are they supposed to pay their other bills and have money to live if they only have 500 left?

Just split up and get with someone you are happy to share with.

megamoomin72 · 09/07/2021 07:32

I think the problem is that your household outgoings are quite large. On 1.5k take home per month, I wouldn’t have dreamed of spending 1k on rent and bills per month. If your standard of living matches your salary but not DPs, I would say YABU.

That said, why isn’t your DP working 5 days if you don’t have DC? Confused

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/07/2021 07:25

Why isnt the partner working full time?

Meggymoo777 · 09/07/2021 07:25

I don't think this is fair at all to be honest... if you own the house 50/50 then presumably if you were to split then they would get 50% of the house... therefore they should be contributing 50% of the mortgage. Same with all bills, shopping etc - they are consuming half of these costs so should therefore pay 50%. If your DP can't afford 50% of these costs then he/she shouldn't have agreed to this house/lifestyle or needs to increase their earning potential. Why are they only working 4 days a week?

I would not be happy floating a 'D'P in this way having been career orientated, working to get up the ladder and then having a more stressful, 5 day job.

If it comes to a point where you marry and have DC then yes, pooling income can make sense. But as it stands, I think you're being over generous paying 2/3 of all of these bills.

Swipe left for the next trending thread