Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unequal finances

286 replies

Itsraimy · 08/07/2021 22:52

Prompted by another post, but my partner and I (no kids and live together but not married) are discussing how we split our finances.

I earn circa 100k and DP earns circa 25k. Maybe IABU but if our household outgoings are 3k I think it’s fair enough that I put in 2k and they put in 1k.

Partner thinks that’s a bit unfair but I feel a bit aggrieved to put in a true ratio as feel I’m being penalised for earning a lot more.

If we split purely on salary, I’d put in £2.4k and they’d put in £600. AIBU suggesting we go for a 2k from me, 1k from them split?

OP posts:
BillMasen · 09/07/2021 10:52

@CastawayQueen

Also to add the DP doesn't do housework - basically lives a life of leisure. There's no ISSUE with this at base as long as both partners accept it. But the OP is earning all this extra money at cost to herself (stress etc) - it will definitely rankle seeing her partner living his best life on her dime. It's not really about the money - it's a mismatch in values. I'm a higher earning woman and I could never be with someone who wasn't ambitious - and I'm very protective of my money - so I just don't date lower earning men. Worked well for me...
You’re equating ambition with £, effectively saying lower earners aren’t ambitious. Lovely

I’m a higher earning man. If I came on here and said I made my partner (lower earning, let’s say a teacher or nurse, loves their career) pay half I’d be ripped apart and I suspect you’d also join that disapproval.

Pinkandpink · 09/07/2021 10:51

Stompythedinosaur
I agree with your post 100 %

LindaEllen · 09/07/2021 10:49

@Itsraimy

Both salaries are gross. So my take home is about 4.6k after pension. Theirs is 1.5k after pension.
Honestly, if the outgoings were £3k a month with this split, if I was you I'd cover them. Or if he really wants to contribute in that way, just ask him for £500 a month or something like that.
CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 10:48

Also to add the DP doesn't do housework - basically lives a life of leisure.
There's no ISSUE with this at base as long as both partners accept it.
But the OP is earning all this extra money at cost to herself (stress etc) - it will definitely rankle seeing her partner living his best life on her dime.
It's not really about the money - it's a mismatch in values.
I'm a higher earning woman and I could never be with someone who wasn't ambitious - and I'm very protective of my money - so I just don't date lower earning men. Worked well for me...

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 10:45

@BillMasen You have no reading comprehension skills do you - my post CLEARLY says that it was the OP's choice to date a lower earner, so the only way she can enjoy a joint lifestyle commensurate with her salary is if she pays.
Also your earlier post about the 'other way round' - most lower earning women who post have gone part-time for childcare. They deserve as much as possible from the higher earner because they're facilitating his career and managing the family.
Childless posters no matter what their gender get the same advice - they should pay their own way.

Sceptre86 · 09/07/2021 10:35

You should pay the mortgage, for your car assuming you have one and any other of your own expenses. Your partner should pay for his car, again assuming he has one, then either the groceries or bills (whichever is less) and his own expenses so if he has a hobby, goes to the gym. I would alternate paying in restaurants, bars but if you prefer to go to more expensive places I would expect you to pay. If he works 4 days a week I would expect him to do more around the house and its great that you love to cook but I would expect him to cook too.

honeylulu · 09/07/2021 10:26

I get the point why should the higher earner slog their guts out to subsidise a lower earner who isn't making the same sacrifices

I agree with this. It would be different if the lower earner had sacrificed their earning power/ pension growth to have and care for their joint children and take on a lion's share of housework and cooking but none of that applies here.

He wants a share of your disposable income while considering himself a free spirit who doesn't want to be troubled with a boring or difficult job, has an extra day off a week, doesn't take on a greater share of housework and gets his dinner cooked every night by OP! Plus it sounds like she covers the cost of holidays and meals out so he also gets an uplift to a better lifestyle than he could afford when they do stuff together.

Contributions in proportion to earnings sounds fine to me. This us what me and my husband have always done - we have a joint account for household and child expenses which is proportionately funded. Our disposable income is our own. Mine is higher and like you I pay for more treats (days out, meals, renovations etc). My husband used to be the higher earner and I had less fun money. I'm now the higher earner (by quite a bit) as I went to college in the evenings (covered by a loan I solely paid back myself) for four years, plus two years workplace training to get a professional qualification. That was bloody difficult! My husband moans sometimes that I have more money but I remind him that:
He could have done the same to get a better job/ career but he couldn't be arsed.
When he earned more, he had more money than me.
He gets the benefit of all the extras I pay for including trips, meals out and a nicely renovated house/new furniture we choose together.

Darkstar4855 · 09/07/2021 10:26

I was going to say YABU but if you own the house 50-50 then he should be contributing to the mortgage in that proportion as he’ll get half the value if you split up. I’d go proportionally on the rest of the bills though.

I am a higher earner (roughly 2x what partner earns) and we split proportionally but the house was in my name so he was effectively paying me rent.

TableFlowerss · 09/07/2021 10:24

I don’t really get this mindset. If you’re in a relationship with someone, I assume you love them.

I couldn’t be with someone that was squabbling about money and who pays what etc… surely on your salary you’ll still be able to save?

Anyway it’s none of my business

Stompythedinosaur · 09/07/2021 10:24

I think my issue is that there are many reasons that people earn more or less, and there are not mainly to do with "working hard". They are to do with upbringing, access to education, experience of parenting or other role modelling, opportunities you had access to, maybe some traits like intelligence or mental robustness.

I would hate the idea that my partner, the person who is meant to have my back above all others, was happy for me to live a worse lifestyle because the think that my earning potential indicates I am somehow less valued or less entitled to a nice lifestyle.

It just isn't how loving relationships are in my experience.

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 10:20

@CastawayQueen

The ‘regular household expenses’ don’t matter. He chose to earn less and you know it - and you won’t be happy living a lifestyle he can afford. So you will be stuck paying for any extras and the cost of your joint lifestyle (such as lions share of rent for a bigger place, holidays ) forever. Why should he do ‘extras around the house’ just to make up for you being a higher earner when you knew what he was like and still chose to date him? Unless he’s spending his personal money on personal things he wouldn’t be able to afford without meeting you (like luxury clothes and expensive alcohol) I wouldn’t say they’re taking advantage. Even if they put in extra £400 they still ask you for money as you say you pay for extras so you’re making it up either way aren’t you? Unequal relationships don’t last unless there are children or the lower earner does a great deal for the higher earner for this very reason. Attitude to earning is a very important value (as is religion and wanting children) and is a potential dealbreaker.
Jesus. You’d say this to a lower earning woman? They chose to earn less so suck it up?
BillMasen · 09/07/2021 10:19

@EveryoneIsThere

Two of my adult kids are the higher earners in their relationships and having seen how hard they have worked to get their careers I wouldn’t discourage them from not splitting their money evenly with their partners. Their partners chose not to work so hard. I don’t see why my kids should be subsidizing them. (Obviously I NEVER say this out loud 😅). I know some people can’t ever end up in high paid jobs due to lots of reasons but for many they made active choices not to dedicate themselves to studying etc. BTW before anyone slates me for this opinion you should know I am in the group of people who have chose NOT to dedicate my younger years to getting a high paid career.
You’d really say it’s ok for a higher earning man to make their lower earning female partner pay half?
CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 10:17

@ivfgottwins

This is going to be unpopular because most members on here will be in your husbands situation and be the lower earner so will see it from a totally different perspective..... I earn 3x what my DH does (although not £100k - I wish!) - we split all household bills 50/50 but I pay the childcare bill which with twins and an older child is £1600 a month

I worked very very hard 2 degrees post graduate qualifications and professional accreditation's - my job is challenging and high pressured....I worked hard to get where I am.....he didn't. I don't subsidise my husbands "beer money" . We each have our own spending money but obviously mine is more. But I do pay for the big things like holidays and home repairs.

What's fair is up to you? I don't think it's fair I should work my ass off to top his spending money up to the same level as mine 🤷‍♀️

Obviously there is a significantly higher disparity in income in your situation and I can't say with all honesty whether I would be as strict in equal division of bills as I am at my current salary level

The interesting thing though is what counts as ‘personal’ money in a relationship? There’s obvious things like clothes, gadgets etc. But for me and DP the majority of what counts as ‘personal’ expenses are joint. Like meals and drinks out. What would a higher earner do with that much extra money that didn’t involve their partner? Even if they saved it in their later years they’d still have to share (if partner didn’t save) wouldn’t they?

In the OP’s case it’s irrelevant because they’re a) not married and b) she pays for extras anyway, the annoyance over £400 is odd

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 10:17

Threads like this annoy me

The other way round and there is pretty much consensus. Either all one pot or pay in proportion. Anything less is considered unfair and possibly abusive. It’s always like that

Then a higher earning woman posts and it shifts. There a more even split with a fair proportion of posters saying it’s fine to not be in proportion, or even that 50-50 is ok

One poster even said to split up with the “chump” as hell never earn te same. That would be roundly condemned the other way round.

Op. Split in proportion. Don’t be a dick

EveryoneIsThere · 09/07/2021 10:14

Two of my adult kids are the higher earners in their relationships and having seen how hard they have worked to get their careers I wouldn’t discourage them from not splitting their money evenly with their partners. Their partners chose not to work so hard. I don’t see why my kids should be subsidizing them. (Obviously I NEVER say this out loud 😅). I know some people can’t ever end up in high paid jobs due to lots of reasons but for many they made active choices not to dedicate themselves to studying etc.
BTW before anyone slates me for this opinion you should know I am in the group of people who have chose NOT to dedicate my younger years to getting a high paid career.

HeyDemonsItsYaGirl · 09/07/2021 10:11

Why are you being coy about your sexes? It's so irritating.

wedswench · 09/07/2021 10:09

@Itsraimy

We’re both a similar age (30s) I have just been very career motivated and partner is just very chilled and thinks there is more to life than working 😂 I actually love this about them but it is causing some tension
That's a lovely attitude but it comes with less money!
halloumihalloumi · 09/07/2021 10:09

If your partner isn't motivated to improve their employment to earn more than surely he or she shouldn't benefit from your hard work with fancy holidays? It seems to me they do like those things, but just don't want to work to pay for it. It also seems that your partner does have the ability to earn more but just doesn't. This whole there is more to life nonsense - it reads like, I want to relax and enjoy the fruits of your labour as the fruits of my labour don't pay enough to enjoy life.

Sandinmyknickers · 09/07/2021 10:05

@minatrina

This thread makes me sad.

Your monthly outgoings are significantly higher than what most people earning what your partner earns would pay. This is obviously due to your higher salary.

When you bought your house, did you consider that you should buy a smaller/cheaper house to accommodate their salary? Or did you want what you could afford and then expect your partner to stretch themselves to afford it?

YABU

100% agree with this. This should have been sorted/discussed when you were buying a house together (and maybe % reflected in shares and monthly payments if you were unwilling to compromise on flashy house). Now it is messy
Sandinmyknickers · 09/07/2021 10:00

You own a house 50/50, regularly overpay the mortgage, and are not married.
You're already gifting your partner tons of free money and equity, so why are you bickering over £400 a month? Either of you? This makes no sense.
Why didnt you discuss splits or anything when you bought a house? (How do competent adults get to a point they're earning £100k but seemingly dont have enough financial literacy or understanding to have these conversations prior to making such large purchases and financial commitments together?)

RandomMess · 09/07/2021 09:57

I would write down the extras you have paid for over the years:

Holidays
Mortgage overpayments
Other house purchases and things of note

Divide it by the number of months that time covers and demonstrate how much you are truly paying per month on joint bills/costs/activities versus them.

They have a low level stress 4 day a week and happy to have you support them but thinks you shouldn't enjoy your hard work even though you aren't married and don't have DC??

ivfgottwins · 09/07/2021 09:56

This is going to be unpopular because most members on here will be in your husbands situation and be the lower earner so will see it from a totally different perspective..... I earn 3x what my DH does (although not £100k - I wish!) - we split all household bills 50/50 but I pay the childcare bill which with twins and an older child is £1600 a month

I worked very very hard 2 degrees post graduate qualifications and professional accreditation's - my job is challenging and high pressured....I worked hard to get where I am.....he didn't. I don't subsidise my husbands "beer money" . We each have our own spending money but obviously mine is more. But I do pay for the big things like holidays and home repairs.

What's fair is up to you? I don't think it's fair I should work my ass off to top his spending money up to the same level as mine 🤷‍♀️

Obviously there is a significantly higher disparity in income in your situation and I can't say with all honesty whether I would be as strict in equal division of bills as I am at my current salary level

Newmumatlast · 09/07/2021 09:43

I also agree with another poster that given your outgoings are 3k (more than ours and our household income is higher) and given how low your partner's income is, it seems clear your outgoings match your income more than his. If he were with someone else on the same income as him, he couldn't afford 3k outgoings easily. So that does play a part in what you should pay I think.

Like all high earners with lower income partners, you make a choice. You either pay halves or less than a fair % and live your life at lower means than you can afford- or having nice things yourself and seeing the person you love having less - or you go all in and both share in the lifestyle.

I think if you were male it probably wouldn't be a question of you keeping loads more. In fact many people may be saying joint pot and same spends whereas even paying a fair % you're left with alot more spends (that gives you more because you earn more, but also doesn't leave your partner too scretched paying bills outside their means)

LittleOwl153 · 09/07/2021 09:39

I think what is throwing the issue here - and probably some folks responses is your compartmentalisation if things. If you look at EVERYTHING REQUIRED to be your household - e.g. utilities, council tax, mortgage, food, insurance etc. Depending on your relationship this could be split in many ways. If you are essentially housemates then it should be 50:50, if you are life partners then it should reflect your comparative earnings (although you might want to look at what I'd earnings would be if he worked full time as that would seem fair).

If he cannot afford this split or does not want to pay that much then you should look at the house and change the way you pay the mortgage AND how the house is owned to reflect payments. (And should anyway if you are overpaying or you should find another investment).

I see luxuries as separate - holidays, meals out, trips, coffee on route to work. You each do what you can afford - if you want to sub him then do but you shouldn't feel obliged given your relationship position.

It feels to me like you are putting massively over the odds into this relationship financially and are not feeling that he is contributing fairly. You need to resolve that as it will tear you apart with the resentment. And you need to do that before marriage or kids become involved.

So no YANBU but I can see why it is causing issues. I would resolve by paying proportionally for household bills BUT would rejig the house equity/mortgage so your partner has a bit more cash available.

Newmumatlast · 09/07/2021 09:38

[quote Itsraimy]@Stompythedinosaur I defs don’t live a ‘superior lifestyle’ to my partner. I pay for all the nice holidays and anything they want TBH, I also overpay our mortgage frequently and we own the house 50:50.[/quote]
If you've a mortgage together that suggests to me that you're very committed. In which case I would do whatever I planned to do if I married and had kids with them. In my case that is paying % according to income. I did self fund my maternity recently though and carried on paying my % so presently our % is adjusted a little lower to what I'm earning (which would suggest a higher %) to make up for that.