Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unequal finances

286 replies

Itsraimy · 08/07/2021 22:52

Prompted by another post, but my partner and I (no kids and live together but not married) are discussing how we split our finances.

I earn circa 100k and DP earns circa 25k. Maybe IABU but if our household outgoings are 3k I think it’s fair enough that I put in 2k and they put in 1k.

Partner thinks that’s a bit unfair but I feel a bit aggrieved to put in a true ratio as feel I’m being penalised for earning a lot more.

If we split purely on salary, I’d put in £2.4k and they’d put in £600. AIBU suggesting we go for a 2k from me, 1k from them split?

OP posts:
CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 11:38

[quote BillMasen]@CastawayQueen I’ve re read your posts and you don’t state (s)he should pay more, just that they would be stuck with them, implying it’s not fair to be “stuck” with them. If that’s not what you meant and you actually agree that a higher earner should pay more then you should be clearer.

I think we differ in our views. I’d happily pay in proportion to earnings, you want to put conditions on that like the lower earner being somehow worthy[/quote]
Do you also t

EL8888 · 09/07/2021 11:37

@wedswench l think you’ve summed it up quite nicely

Pipsquiggle · 09/07/2021 11:36

Pre kids me and my DH earned similar amounts - so we got a joint account and put more or less the same in.

During my pregnancies & mat leaves, this is when my DH's career really took off and he now earns substantially more than me.

We do % contributions. You earn massively more than your DP, % contributions is the fairest way if you are happy about division of household labour. You should pay £2.25k, DP should pay £750

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 11:35

@CastawayQueen I’ve re read your posts and you don’t state (s)he should pay more, just that they would be stuck with them, implying it’s not fair to be “stuck” with them. If that’s not what you meant and you actually agree that a higher earner should pay more then you should be clearer.

I think we differ in our views. I’d happily pay in proportion to earnings, you want to put conditions on that like the lower earner being somehow worthy

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 11:23

@BillMasen again, you haven’t read my posts have you? After repeatedly pointing out that I’ve said that the higher earner should pay more if they have the lifestyle of a higher earner.

Lifestyle equates to:

  1. Extras such as holidays, free range chicken, a bigger house, what have you
  2. The belief in the need to work hard as @wedswench pointed out.

Being a higher earner doesn’t mean you live that lifestyle. I personally would have the exact same on 30K as I would on 60K. In this case there’s no need for the higher earner to pay more is there - the lifestyle is affordable on both salaries.

Secondly is the amount of effort. The drive to build a career regardless of money is a value. The view that there’s more to life than working (and one should work just to have enough to live) is also a value. These fundamentally contradict. If you’re the first type the second is likely to irritate you. Also because they wouldn’t understand why you do what you do and what you sacrifice to get there.

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 11:23

“ I don't see why. The sexes make no difference to the question.”

No but they do to the answers a lot of people give

claralara42 · 09/07/2021 11:22

@BillMasen

I would be very interested if OP were to come back and say they’re a male with female partner. A lot of posters will be very quiet..,
I don't see why. The sexes make no difference to the question.
Habitualhonesty · 09/07/2021 11:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 11:16

I would be very interested if OP were to come back and say they’re a male with female partner. A lot of posters will be very quiet..,

workshy44 · 09/07/2021 11:14

I think its a bit much when you are not married and no kids that he effectively wants you to fund his entire lifestyle. He wants nice holidays, meals out, 50% ownership on a house for 600 quid a month
I can see you getting VERY resentful in years to come. Where is his pride ?
Its all very well him thinking there is more to life when you are the one funding that life so he can chill out and enjoy a stress free job
This is far too unequal imo
I would be very careful of having kids with him

wedswench · 09/07/2021 11:14

I think this has got a bit off track. OP's partner isn't a hard working nurse/teacher/career driven and ambitious person who happens to be on a low wage and thus deserves to share their partner's wealth equally.

They're a free spirited, non career focussed, part time idealist wanting to enjoy all the trappings of her/his partners lifestyle with none of the work

claralara42 · 09/07/2021 11:12

@Viviennemary

I thought in MN world all money is familly money. Except when the lion's share is yours. Hmm
In a family maybe. Not 2 unrelated adults with no kids.
JaninaDuszejko · 09/07/2021 11:11

So from your OP I though YABU. But then I read that your partner only works 4 days a week and you own the house 50:50 but you regularly overpay the mortgage and those change things. So forget the small fry stuff and

a) Assuming there is no healthcare reason, think about why they work 4 days a week and if you are happy to subsidise a lifestyle choice like that. If not then end the relationship. If you are happy to subsidise them then get married, I assume you've been together long enough to make this decision if you are in your 30s and have a mortgage.

b) stop overpaying the mortgage, save any excess money elsewhere (do you use all your S&S ISA allowance?). But if you are committed enough to buy a house why don't you get married?

Once you are married, and particularly if you have children then bills should be paid in such a way as to give you both equal spending money and you should both get equal free time so your DP needs to be doing something worthwhile with that extra day.

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 11:10

[quote CastawayQueen]@BillMasen Teachers and nurses aren't lower earners - of course they earn less compared to investment bankers but not in the 'grand scheme of things' lower earners. While their base salary may appear 'lower' the benefits and pensions are generous. And as they advance through the grades their salaries increase.

Again - the issue is not about money, its about lifestyle. You haven't responded to any of my points despite my first post saying that OP should pay. And you claim to be a man. Did you come on here just to castigate higher earning women?[/quote]
I was using those careers as examples of lower (than me) earners but hard working careers. You were the one equating lower £ with lack of ambition. I was saying I’d fully expect to pay much more into the pot if my partner was earning less.

And what’s your point on lifestyle? That I should have a good one even if that means my partner can’t?

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 11:08

[quote wedswench]@BillMasen but teaching, nursing etc. Is a career and a very stressful one at that.

OP seems to suggest their partner doesn't value a career and doesn't want to work particularly hard, wants a 4 day week etc.

[/quote]
This.

wedswench · 09/07/2021 11:06

@BillMasen but teaching, nursing etc. Is a career and a very stressful one at that.

OP seems to suggest their partner doesn't value a career and doesn't want to work particularly hard, wants a 4 day week etc.

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 11:06

@FlaminEckVera

But the answer will be the same whether they say whether they and their partner are male or female. Confused
Are you new here?
CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 11:04

@BillMasen Teachers and nurses aren't lower earners - of course they earn less compared to investment bankers but not in the 'grand scheme of things' lower earners. While their base salary may appear 'lower' the benefits and pensions are generous. And as they advance through the grades their salaries increase.

Again - the issue is not about money, its about lifestyle. You haven't responded to any of my points despite my first post saying that OP should pay. And you claim to be a man. Did you come on here just to castigate higher earning women?

FlaminEckVera · 09/07/2021 11:03

But the answer will be the same whether they say whether they and their partner are male or female. Confused

FlaminEckVera · 09/07/2021 11:02

@BillMasen

No, but it's just annoying, and weird, when someone keeps calling their partner THEY. I mean WHY? Confused

wedswench · 09/07/2021 11:02

[quote FlaminEckVera]@Itsraimy Why do you keep calling your partner 'THEY?' Confused It must be so much more difficult to keep putting THEY. It's so annoying when people do this!

Is your partner male or female?

And are YOU male or female?

Also, YABVVVU. And mean.

This relationship is going nowhere if you're going to be so selfish with your own money. Maybe you need to find someone else who is on a similar salary to you. Hmm[/quote]
I guess he/she wants opinions based on facts not based on assumptions about the two of them because of what sex or gender they are

BillMasen · 09/07/2021 11:01

[quote FlaminEckVera]@Itsraimy Why do you keep calling your partner 'THEY?' Confused It must be so much more difficult to keep putting THEY. It's so annoying when people do this!

Is your partner male or female?

And are YOU male or female?

Also, YABVVVU. And mean.

This relationship is going nowhere if you're going to be so selfish with your own money. Maybe you need to find someone else who is on a similar salary to you. Hmm[/quote]
Does it make a difference if the partner is male or female?

FlaminEckVera · 09/07/2021 11:00

@Itsraimy Why do you keep calling your partner 'THEY?' Confused It must be so much more difficult to keep putting THEY. It's so annoying when people do this!

Is your partner male or female?

And are YOU male or female?

Also, YABVVVU. And mean.

This relationship is going nowhere if you're going to be so selfish with your own money. Maybe you need to find someone else who is on a similar salary to you. Hmm

Snowpaw · 09/07/2021 10:58

I certainly wouldn’t be overpaying the mortgage on a jointly owned home with such financial inequality. I’d put that into a buy-to-let property in your sole name, or some other investment that is yours alone.

Habitualhonesty · 09/07/2021 10:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.