Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unequal finances

286 replies

Itsraimy · 08/07/2021 22:52

Prompted by another post, but my partner and I (no kids and live together but not married) are discussing how we split our finances.

I earn circa 100k and DP earns circa 25k. Maybe IABU but if our household outgoings are 3k I think it’s fair enough that I put in 2k and they put in 1k.

Partner thinks that’s a bit unfair but I feel a bit aggrieved to put in a true ratio as feel I’m being penalised for earning a lot more.

If we split purely on salary, I’d put in £2.4k and they’d put in £600. AIBU suggesting we go for a 2k from me, 1k from them split?

OP posts:
doesparentingsuck · 09/07/2021 16:02

People saying pool your money are absolutely.bonkers.

Do NOT pool your money for any fucker

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 09/07/2021 16:02

You’re more generous than me. I’d be expecting nothing less than 50/50 in a dating relationship. I’d pool everything if married as see that as very different.

If they want more disposable income they can work more etc.

I’ve taught my children to expect to pay their way and not to expect others too or feel they have to pay more based on their sex etc.

doesparentingsuck · 09/07/2021 16:00

If partner is 4 days a week then no fucking way! And your have no DC, sorry but bills should be 50/50 - maybe your suggestion as 50/50 might wipe his salary out it not your fault he can't work a full week

doesparentingsuck · 09/07/2021 15:58

Well he earns 25% of what you do so technical wouldn't 25% of the bills be more accurate? Or to be honest I'd still expect 50/50 lol depends how long you've been together if you have kids etc I'd say

Bollindger · 09/07/2021 15:45

I think tell him you will share bills as said.
Then you shift the extra money you have into a high interest savings account, so your both living off the same income.
do not use your savings for Holidays or anything.
Tell him your doing this so you can see his point of view.
If things work out, your going to have 35K in savings for a wedding, if he still gets jealous and complains about the lack of luxurys, it would be worth lettting him have his extra £400 a month and make him go HALF on all bills, for luxurys.
To be honest if you find he wines about being poor, then he should WORK more, not use you as a cash cow,

warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 15:32

I think these threads are always difficult because there are so many variables. Personally I agree with your DP that there is more to live than working long hours, five days a week and I would rather have a better work-life balance. You could always work a four-day week yourself if his extra free-time bothers you so much :)

I know you say he benefits from your wage via nice holidays and the like, but would you be happy to sacrifice things like nice holidays, weekends away, meals out to fancy restaurants in order to fit in with his budget if he was paying a higher proportion of the household bills?

Crankley · 09/07/2021 15:14

I voted YANBU because he appears to have zero ambition and only works four days a week (I would find this deeply unattractive but you are obviously ok with it). He doesn't do any housework on his day off, you pay for a cleaner. So what does he do? Sit on his arse all day?

What will happen if you marry and decide to have a child? That's you out of your well paid job for x months. Having to exist on his £25k, what if he doesn't increase his hours or get a new job? Will that piss you off?

Frankly he wouldn't be getting any more of my money in your situation. I would be putting as much as possible in pension and savings. You will need them if he's not going to step up and be an adult by getting a better paying job if/when you have children.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 09/07/2021 15:12

Also fairly speaking your DP has chosen to 'spend' 20% of their salary by working only 4 days. That's their choice but it comes at a cost, so I would add an extra £5k to their salary for that alone. Just as you would have to if you decided to work 4 days. Surely they don't expect you to pay for it.

Biker47 · 09/07/2021 15:03

@IcedSpice

You should be taking home around £ 5,117.14 with a 20% pension payment
20% of £8,333.33 isn't £733.83. Monthly net wage for someone on £100k is £4,557.73.
Mummyoflittledragon · 09/07/2021 15:02

@BillMasen
When couples have been together years and the higher earner if male wants or has kids with the female op, this is somewhat different as women take a financial hit to become a mother. Married or in a committed partnership is different.

Despite buying a property together, op’s partner seems very happy to sponge off op. Op describes them as immature. I think posts would be similar if were op a man with a female partner.

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 09/07/2021 14:55

You are not married & you don't have kids so personally I think your current split is more than generous.

If you are female and you do plan on having a child one day, I'd be putting your extra money in the relationship aside to fund that. Your partner whatever their sex is on two t be able to sub you on maternity leave or with childcare or baby stuff. So don't let them have an easy ride now, they can pay their fair share so if one day you both do decide to have a kid there are savings put aside already.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 09/07/2021 14:54

While you are unmarried and don't have children together, or any other mutual commitments, and while you have such a huge disparity in earnings, a financial split that leaves you better off than DP is fair. You are already subsidising DP quite a lot.

I also overpay our mortgage frequently and we own the house 50:50.

If you own the house 50-50 and you are not married then it's daft for you to overpay the mortgage. Mind you given your different attitudes to money it was probably a bit daft to buy a house together in the first place, especially not on a 50-50 financial basis. Amount owned should have been based on the amount you each put in.

partner is just very chilled and thinks there is more to life than working

There is, espeically if someone else is subsidising your life. Would DP feel so relaxed if you suddenly decided to go part time and only earn 15K a year?

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 09/07/2021 14:50

@Rach212

You earn x4 what they earn. Therefore surely you should pay x4 what he pays??!

Why should he pay more because he earns less

Because part of the reason he earns less is because he chose not to work full time.
Biker47 · 09/07/2021 14:46

If they were married, you might have a point as assets would usually be considered joint (i.e. 'family money') in a marriage.

I'm married, and we have our own money. I earn double what my partner does. I pay a token amount more into the joint account each month, and pay double what they pay in mortgage over payments, and that works for us.

I think they've got a good deal, they're paying half what the OP is paying, doesn't matter if they're only earning a quarter, they're still being subsidised generously, especially when they're 50:50 on the deeds and have no kids, partner should be doing more, no good wanting a "laid back lifestyle and job" and expecting someone else to foot the bill.

Pipsquiggle · 09/07/2021 14:36

Genuinely interested that some people seeing marriage as being more significant to buying a house together.

Getting out of a marriage with no children can be far easier to get out of than disentangling from property.

I don't think OP has any qualms about her DP earning significantly less than her and she does seem open to paying more - it's just how much more.

I think people saying it should be 50/50 as they aren't married and don't have children, when there is such a disparity in take home pay are bonkers and says more about them and how much they usurp money over functioning happy relationships

Figgygal · 09/07/2021 14:33

Contribution to the household should be proportionate with the salary or at least that’s how we always had it in our house both pre-and post children

Rach212 · 09/07/2021 14:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Dora33 · 09/07/2021 14:31

Your dp is unfair to expect you to subsidize them more than you already do while they chose to work a 4 day week.
If they wish to have more disposible income per month, they should first increase their work days to 5 a week. They seem to think they should have the best of both worlds, work less while you work more hours and share more of your income.
Only when there are children would I expect to totally sharing a full time and part time income in a relationship.

Sunflowers095 · 09/07/2021 14:08

@shivawn

Yikes, I can't believe you'd be happy to leave your partner with 500 a month while you have 2.6k. Doesn't sound like your really committed to the relationship so is there any point in both of you wasting your time on it?
But the partner doesn't do any more housework. The partner could earn more but wants to work less hours. The partner could have more disposable income but they chose not to.

If they stopped working should OP pay for everything then?

Why should she pay the way for someone who makes an active choice to work 4 days a week and remain at the current pay they're at?

Blendiful · 09/07/2021 14:06

I think there are lots of factors to this.

I think if you aren’t married with no DC either then household Expenses (mortgage/rent, bills etc) should be 50/50. You use half each so you pay half each.

Other expenses are debateable. You can have your own e.g phones, gym etc which if you can afford to have luxury, you do, if your partner can’t, they don’t.

But if it’s things like holidays, days out, regular activities that you want you both to do and you want to do ‘better’ because you can afford to (example a holiday to the Caribbean vs a holiday to Spain), then realistically you are probably going to have to pay more of a portion, or compromise and do the cheaper holiday.

I am all for supporting eachother but I would also be loathe to pay so much more just because I earn more. Same as I wouldn’t expect my partner to pay more if he earnt more, unless we were married had DC and we’re making compromises as a family like maternity leave, working less due to childcare etc.

Otherwise I would instead look to maximise my own income to try and get closer to my partners to have the luxuries too!

Anonymouslyposting · 09/07/2021 13:51

YABU, I don’t think relationships work as well when you don’t treat money coming in as joint. There was a time when u earned £100k more than DH (then DP) and we still split bills on a percentage basis. The higher earner still ends up with more spending money but it feels more like a partnership.

Also, no idea whether this applies in your situation but often the lower earner would probably have gone for cheaper options for accommodation/other things if they weren’t with the higher earner. Unless the higher earner wants to move somewhere less nice or smaller then they should pay more.

On the other hand, if DP is just lazy that’s different. If he’s working part time and can’t be bothered and you’re not ok with that then you shouldn’t have to subsidise. But if he’s working a comparable amount (or contributing to the household in another way ie childcare/housework) then I wouldn’t feel comfortable getting him to pay more than his percentage.

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 13:51

Also to add - we can’t judge whether OP is being U because we don’t know how much she has left at month end. Out of the 2.6K remaining how much is she actually paying for all the others things?
Until there’s true figures it’s hard to say who has more left at month end.if OP wants to maintain a high earner lifestyle and expect partner to contribute equally its U but she seems to have been very generous already so…

seven201 · 09/07/2021 13:47

I think your dp wouldn't have such large outgoings if he wasn't living with you? Presumably you have a big ish mortgage? It depends if you agreed everything before buying a house. Maybe he doesn't want to pay 1/3 of the cleaner costs or whatever and would prefer to clean himself?

Once married things change, but before that I think it's fair enough to split it in a different way but you need to agree everything before committing to big costs.

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 13:46

@Merryoldgoat

I also hate the implication that Lower paid = not worthwhile

There are teachers, teaching assistants, nurses and more on £25k or less. I earn more than that part-time but I guarantee they work harder than I do.

But the point isn’t about worthwhile though is it - it’s about whether someone’s a dick for being resentful about paying more. In a family where someone stays home/goes part time to look after the kids and manages the household it is 100% U for the higher earner to not pay more. But if someone is resentful that an unmarried partner bring less to the table financially - that isn’t U. They have to either make the choice to continue paying more or leave the relationship and find someone better suited to them. It depends on what they value. People may say that it’s ‘shallow to look at money’ but people can pick partners based on whatever criteria they want. OP bought a house with a partner knowing what he was like. She has to leave if she really can’t stand it or reconcile. It’s her decision. But neither choice is dickish.
billy1966 · 09/07/2021 13:36

[quote Itsraimy]@TheFoundations I’m fine with my partner not wanting a stressful job and thinking there is more to life.

I’m fine with paying 2/3 of our household outgoings and paying for holidays and overpaying our mortgage.

I’m just not sure I’m fine with paying almost all of our monthly outgoings. Clearly I’ve split opinion.[/quote]
If you intend to have children and carry the mental load, you may feel very different about "Mr. Laid back", within a few years.