Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unequal finances

286 replies

Itsraimy · 08/07/2021 22:52

Prompted by another post, but my partner and I (no kids and live together but not married) are discussing how we split our finances.

I earn circa 100k and DP earns circa 25k. Maybe IABU but if our household outgoings are 3k I think it’s fair enough that I put in 2k and they put in 1k.

Partner thinks that’s a bit unfair but I feel a bit aggrieved to put in a true ratio as feel I’m being penalised for earning a lot more.

If we split purely on salary, I’d put in £2.4k and they’d put in £600. AIBU suggesting we go for a 2k from me, 1k from them split?

OP posts:
FunMcCool · 09/07/2021 20:30

Why she couldn’t work*

FunMcCool · 09/07/2021 20:29

If you’re partner thinks it’s unfair she should work full time like other able bodied adults who don’t have children. She can’t expect you to just sub you. If she works less she has less money. That’s it.

It’s different if she had a reason why should couldn’t work.

Itsraimy · 09/07/2021 20:11

When we got together 5 years ago, we didn’t have a huge salary disparity. Both about 30k FTE. I’ve been promoted a lot since then and am where I am now. She’s taken a (voluntary) decision to go part time

OP posts:
warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 20:07

I think DP feels annoyed that I am building up a big pension and have a lot of disposable income and personal savings hence the ‘ask’ to equalise.

I think you should be paying proportionately to your incomes when it comes to household bills, but if she wants more money in her pension pot or more disposable income, she needs to increase her hours like everyone else.

It's not fair for her to choose 4 days a week then complain about her lack of money.

HalzTangz · 09/07/2021 20:05

If the mortgage is 50:50 then everything should be split 50:50 (minus personal accounts such as Amazon etc). If he wants to contribute less he needs to agree a lower percentage of owning the property

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 20:05

*if you marry

Why does your DP think you having more money is an issue? Have you asked her why she feels entitled to your money?!

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 20:03

Was your DP earning more before - and then made the choice to drop?
Do you differ wildly in your personal spends (e.g you buy Gucci, she has Primark’s finest)?

Married or not after a certain point in the relationship it’s strange to have such a huge disparity. But savings will benefit both and if you’re married she will get some on divorce

purplepenguin91 · 09/07/2021 19:24

It depends on how long you have been together, etc. My DP earns significantly more than me (a similar ratio to you) and we split everything 50:50 for the first 5 years or so of our relationship. Now our money is just pooled. I never even considered that he should pay more because he earned more

wedswench · 09/07/2021 19:22

@Itsraimy

Yeah I take the point on the house equity but it does seem fair to me to be 50:50. We both contributed equally to the deposit and previously have paid equally to the Mortgage.

I think DP feels annoyed that I am building up a big pension and have a lot of disposable income and personal savings hence the ‘ask’ to equalise.

Well yeah but are you planning to get married eventually? Pension will benefit you both
Fupoffyagrasshole · 09/07/2021 19:16

Yep not your fault he is in a low paid job! He wants more disposable cash then earn more money

Itsraimy · 09/07/2021 19:07

Yeah I take the point on the house equity but it does seem fair to me to be 50:50. We both contributed equally to the deposit and previously have paid equally to the Mortgage.

I think DP feels annoyed that I am building up a big pension and have a lot of disposable income and personal savings hence the ‘ask’ to equalise.

OP posts:
Biker47 · 09/07/2021 19:00

Split down the middle, of what is left, your partners "fair share" is £950, so even if you kept leisure money and savings as is, your partner is up to the tune of £450 a month on top of whatever their remaining wages are. Not a bad deal for a lot of people.

I don't think you're doing yourself any favours overpaying a mortgage at £5k a year, when you're joint tenants, and not tenants in common with stated shares in ownership.

Itsraimy · 09/07/2021 18:55

@Biker47 you’re probably right. I guess we’ve tried to cover ‘everything’ in the household outgoings so the money each of us has ‘leftover’ is ours to do as we wish

OP posts:
warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 18:54

Would your partner have gotten a 1k/month mortgage if it wasn't for your income? Because I suspect if she was on her own, her outgoings would be much less, though I suppose it's area dependent.

Biker47 · 09/07/2021 18:52

Why is £1k of your £3k outgoings; joint savings and leisure? Just have your own savings at whatever level you can afford, and £250 going back to yourselves seems counter intuitive.

altiara · 09/07/2021 18:48

We’re both a similar age (30s) I have just been very career motivated and partner is just very chilled and thinks there is more to life than working 😂 I actually love this about them but it is causing some tension

@Itsraimy if you weren’t such a high earner, would your DP be able to think this? Or is it just because she’s happy to be subbed by you?

If it was me, I’d be doing 50:50 on everything while you are not married/no kids. BUT, that would mean the house/lifestyle would be one that the lower earner could afford or if you went for a more expensive house, the the higher earner would have a different percentage. Then if higher earner wanted more luxuries on top, then they would find that.

I think if you’re spending more, then I would say you want more equity in the house.

Zari29 · 09/07/2021 18:48

I would usually say that the higher earner should pay more but ops situation is very different. Her dp chooses in their 30s to have the luxury of settling for this income and lifestyle. Ultimately it comes down to taking advantage of op - would your dp do this If they were single or had a dp earning similar to them? You are funding this very comfortable lifestyle. And tbh anyone can be kind, loving and funny when they have this cushy lifestyle.

CastawayQueen · 09/07/2021 18:44

@Itsraimy for a high earner your outgoings dont look too high either. If your partner was single - would they really have made choices that leave them £500 a month to themselves after joint expenses? That’s a lot of money. Far more than most people have ‘free’ every month. Would they be able to afford to work a 4 day week and spend time on their hobby?
In this light it isn’t unfair to expect them to contribute an equal amount to what they would have spent as a single person. The fact that you earn more is irrelevant.

Of course if the hobby is something they are serious about and could eventually provide a side income it’s a different story. But I don’t see why expecting them to pay at least as much as they would have paid single is a big issue. When I was single I’d have spent over 1K in rent and bills alone.

Itsraimy · 09/07/2021 18:17

Partner isn’t a high earner but I don’t feel I can ‘do better’. They’re kind, funny, a great person. But you’re all right, we do need agree a way forward on this.

OP posts:
FunMcCool · 09/07/2021 18:15

@Itsraimy i would say they need to be working full time. It’s unfair on you to carry the full burden.

Itsraimy · 09/07/2021 18:13

Hi all,

Thank you for all your feedback. Thought I’d update with the questions asked;

Our 3k household outgoings cover
Mortgage 1k
Bills about 350
Food about 250
Joint savings 500
Petrol (I bought our cars outright) 100
Leisure 500 (split evenly, both of us take 250 from this and put in our ‘personal accounts)
200 ish - dental insurance/house insurance/pets insurance (we have a dog who is calamitous and who’s premium is high)

On top of this, I pay for our holidays. The house is owned 50:50. I also regularly overpay our mortgage when I get bonus etc. Probs to the tune of about 5k per year overpayment.

Both of us are female for those asking on gender.

Partner works 4 days as they like to have time to work on their hobby. Fair enough and this might provide a side income in time.

OP posts:
Alarae · 09/07/2021 17:37

DH and I did 50:50 until we were married, then when my salary eclipsed his we changed to a net salary percentage.

If you have made choices due to your higher income (such as a bigger house) then it would be fair to pay more for those. Similarly you should probabaly kick in a bit more for utilities due to a larger home.

If you wanted it to be morally fairer then net percentage is a way to go however I would base this on your DP's 5 day a week income, as it would be a cold day in hell that I subsidise someone getting to work less than full time (unless they had reasons such as medical issues, children together etc).

MilduraS · 09/07/2021 16:42

My DH earns more and pays proportionately but only the mortgage and utilities because he's the one who wanted a bigger house than we need, I'd happily live somewhere cheaper to have more money to spend on other things. We pay 50:50 for food, holidays, pet costs and days out but they are no more extravagant than when I lived alone. If he was insisting on 3 weeks all inclusive in the Maldives twice a year, I'd have a different view. We each pay for our own cars, insurance, phones etc because we can set our own budgets (e.g he has a Tesla, I have a VW up!). Oddly he's often been the one pushing to pool our expenses. I've decided not to because I don't want to feel guilty for not contributing more or feel guilty for spending the money I've earn.

doesparentingsuck · 09/07/2021 16:02

Unless you have DC, even then - highly debatable

Bluntness100 · 09/07/2021 16:02

No way, you’re not married no kids, they need to pay their way. You’re not being unreasonable.