Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unequal finances

286 replies

Itsraimy · 08/07/2021 22:52

Prompted by another post, but my partner and I (no kids and live together but not married) are discussing how we split our finances.

I earn circa 100k and DP earns circa 25k. Maybe IABU but if our household outgoings are 3k I think it’s fair enough that I put in 2k and they put in 1k.

Partner thinks that’s a bit unfair but I feel a bit aggrieved to put in a true ratio as feel I’m being penalised for earning a lot more.

If we split purely on salary, I’d put in £2.4k and they’d put in £600. AIBU suggesting we go for a 2k from me, 1k from them split?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Essentialironingwater · 20/07/2021 12:34

@itsraimy what did you decide to do?

squid12346 · 10/07/2021 17:32

£500 is fine for him for spending money each month. I agree with you.

camouflagejacket · 10/07/2021 17:28

Hmm, the additional info changes my view. I'd pay the mortgage yourself and split other billls up ((literally, so eg she has to figure out the pet insurance). Good luck!

Biker47 · 10/07/2021 11:24

You are being taken for a mug

This.

Her being resentful that you're doing better and have decent savings and a good pension coming, isn't a good sign in pretty much any relationship. I think in the back of her mind it will be ticking that; if you ever break up, sure; she'll be left with half a house, that you've paid the lions share on, but with you being the high earner you'll be the one who has to buy her out, not the other way round, so she'll have to find somewhere else and then you're free to live happily ever after with your decent pension and savings, that's if you never get married.

Sounds like she currently wants to enjoy a life of being subsidised by you while she can, before you cotton on a decide to move on, without noticing that arguing over money when they're already getting the best possible end of the deal is more likely to drive a wedge between you two, as shown by you posting here and not being too happy about it.

coconutpie · 10/07/2021 11:06

You are being taken for a mug, I'm afraid. Your DP is getting nice holidays, a house subsidised, treats, etc and still expects you to pay more when the fact that she earns less is due to her decision to go part-time while you work in a stressful job. You don't even have kids to justify the going part-time. Fine if she wants to go part-time but she needs to be contributing equally. The fact that you said you think you could do better says a lot - listen to your head. I think your generosity is being taken advantage of and you are being played for a fool tbh.

in2dagroove · 10/07/2021 10:58

You are subsidising your partners lifestyle, which is fine if that works for you both. But if you are feeling resentful you must address it by having an honest conversation. They need to understand it from your point of view, not having a family to support there is no expectation on one partner to support another unless everyone is happy with the arrangements. It's about finding what works for you as a couple, other peoples views shouldn't come into it

Cocomarine · 10/07/2021 10:42

She’s taking the piss!
If your take home is £4.5K and hers £1.5K, with £3K outgoings (luxuries included) then you could equalise by you oating everything, right?

£1.5K left each - with her in a low stress 4 day week and you working hard 25% longer.

Does that seem fair?

No. Because when there isn’t a sacrifice like caring for children involved, being fair doesn’t mean being to-the-penny-equal.

She’s already getting holidays, a car, growing equity from mortgage overpayments, and an extra day off a week.

But she wants more…

You’re the cash cow - you just didn’t see that side of her until your earnings increased.

Rhayader · 10/07/2021 10:22

DH earns 8 times more than I do. When we got married our salaries were almost exactly the same. We have always shared all our money even before kids. However, it’s totally personal choice, this is just what has worked for us.

Bollindger · 10/07/2021 10:14

OP have you actually read what you have written.
As people have said your out goings are more on luxury than expenses.
Your actually giving your partner so much money and you can not see it.
Savings, spends , petrol and food.
Plus YOU paid for the cars.
I'd point this out to them.
As right now I know your happy, but you are funding then a lot.
And say you spent 4k on a holiday and took your partner, well really that's most of the bill money being returned to them in your kindness.

worktrip · 10/07/2021 09:59

I think he should pay a quarter, because that still leaves you with more and is compensation for the extra hours you do. If you marry and have DC then it should family money and a different arrangement

Dashel · 10/07/2021 09:24

@Itsraimy

Hi all,

Thank you for all your feedback. Thought I’d update with the questions asked;

Our 3k household outgoings cover
Mortgage 1k
Bills about 350
Food about 250
Joint savings 500
Petrol (I bought our cars outright) 100
Leisure 500 (split evenly, both of us take 250 from this and put in our ‘personal accounts)
200 ish - dental insurance/house insurance/pets insurance (we have a dog who is calamitous and who’s premium is high)

On top of this, I pay for our holidays. The house is owned 50:50. I also regularly overpay our mortgage when I get bonus etc. Probs to the tune of about 5k per year overpayment.

Both of us are female for those asking on gender.

Partner works 4 days as they like to have time to work on their hobby. Fair enough and this might provide a side income in time.

So if your partner is contributing £1000, but really getting £250 of that straight back and saving a further £250 so really only paying £500 a month for car, housing, pet and holidays and food? Bargain I would say.

I think the real issue is whether you are both in this for the long term. When you are ready to fully commit it should be shared, if you aren’t then I would stop putting any more into joint savings and overpayments on the mortgage and keep savings out of it and then your partner pays her £500 but draws no spending money out of the joint point and the joint savings stay at their current balance until they are spent.

She must have a lot of spending money anyway if all the bills were paid for £750. That wouldn’t cover living and holidays for most people unless they lived at home.

CastawayQueen · 10/07/2021 09:17

@SchrodingersImmigrant

I am normally straight, but... Hiiii. How you doin' OP😏

Just joking. With your update, I think it's wuite clear you are being tajen advantage of a bit. It would be understandable if you paid bit more if you chose the more expensive lifestyle your partner wouldn't on her wages, but the droppi g hours, you basically paying everything. I can't see that ending well

That’s another point - you both started at the same point. Your expenses (?) also based on your joint income at that time. Seems like you haven’t chosen anything more ruinously expensive just that your partner has dropped her hours and you’re earni more. Not fair to subsidise
SchrodingersImmigrant · 10/07/2021 08:38

I am normally straight, but...
Hiiii. How you doin' OP😏

Just joking. With your update, I think it's wuite clear you are being tajen advantage of a bit. It would be understandable if you paid bit more if you chose the more expensive lifestyle your partner wouldn't on her wages, but the droppi g hours, you basically paying everything. I can't see that ending well

Mummyoflittledragon · 10/07/2021 08:34

You bought your dp a car, are paying for holidays, fun stuff, overpaying on the mortgage and contributing more. In return your dp is not doing more around the house despite reducing her hours and staying in a less challenging 4 day a week 9-5 job. You’re not married.

Are you happy contributing more? What is your long term goal? And is this shared with your dp?

On the surface of it, your dp seems to be getting a very easy ride. If you both decided to get married and have a baby and she carried, I would relook at it then. But not now.

CastawayQueen · 10/07/2021 08:09

After having read the update - your partner’s taking you for a ride. You get promoted and earn more - and then she decides to cut her hours?
She’s clearly based her life choices on being subsidised by you. And as pp have pointed out the maths show just how much she benefits.
Don’t give in to her complaint about the £400. Stop overpaying the mortgage. And for the love of God do not get married.

Cookiebox · 10/07/2021 07:42

Hi OP

since my now husband and I moved In together we divide all bills/rent by percentage.
I earn 35k and my husband earns 78k.
By doing it this way I can save quite a bit per month (and so can my husband) we actually save the same amount per month which is good because we're saving for a mortgage.
When we buy I have assets in a flat I rent which I want to sell to get a chunk of the mortgage so again we'll be splitting it % and not 50/50 as I've brought most of the deposit to the table.

JaninaDuszejko · 10/07/2021 07:00

So what we have here is a cock fanny lodger, the relationship started out equal but as the OP's career has taken off she has subsidised her partner's decision to reduce their working hours and is paying a bigger and bigger percentage of the joint costs and doing a lot of the emotional load/actual daily housework as well. Meanwhile the partner gets to spend three days a week fannying about on her hobby that may at some point in the future provide some income. It's something a it arty or musical or dramatic isn't it? She's in her 30s, if she hasn't made it yet she needs to grow up and focus on her real career.

OP, you need to decide, are you happy to have a trophy partner who doesn't contribute financially but is very good looking/a bit arty farty/whatever floats your boat? If not then strip things back to basics . Forget the joint savings and leisure spending and overpayments on the mortgage. Up your pension payments to the max you can pay each year since you don't currently need to live to your income (think it's £40k but that includes employer contributions). Split the bills 50:50, that will be:
Mortgage 1k
Bills about 350
Food about 250
Petrol (I bought our cars outright) 100
200 ish - dental insurance/house insurance/pets insurance (we have a dog who is calamitous and who’s premium is high)
£1.9k total so £950 each. So yes, you should both pay about £1K each. That leaves her with £500 a month fun and savings money (which seems perfectly reasonable on her income) plus her free day a week which is worth ~£375pcm to her in take home pay and you with £3.5K (will be less if you are making extra pension payments). You can use your extra money how you want, max out your ISA, buy a rental property, take your partner on lovely holidays and days out, buy nice clothes/jewellery/art for yourself. Her lifestyle is still being uplifted by you paying for her car and holidays and meals and days out (because I'm guessing you already always pay for that kind of thing since you earn more so like to treat her) but don't increase your contributions to the house costs because if you split she'll get to keep that. If she isn't happy with this completely fair split and enhancement to her lifestyle she needs to think about that money she is 'spending' by not working full time and if she'd rather spend it in hard cash.

LittleOwl153 · 09/07/2021 23:45

So you are already subbing them to the tune of £200 a month in extra mortgage payments, and sending £250 back of the £1000 in spends. And they want to reduce that by a further £400?

So out of their £600 they'd still be getting £250 leisure, and you gifting £200+ a month through overpayment...

So they'd actually be PAYING £150 A MONTH for a half share in a property and household expenses - I can see why they only work part time! I think you are being taken for a mug OP!

Essentialironingwater · 09/07/2021 21:44

Sorry just read the update. So she gets 750 after everything for fun spending, you overpay mortgage and pay for all hols? I think fine if you are sure you want to be with her forever but otherwise you might be feeling quite sore about this in a few years. She also only works part time, I'd say she is doing ok out of you!!!

Essentialironingwater · 09/07/2021 21:41

I sort of agree if not married but why are your outgoings so high without kids when one only earns £25k? Ours are much less than £3k and our gross joint income is higher! If you've chosen a fancier lifestyle/flat above DPs means then you should probably bear the brunt, otherwise I think it's fine until you're more committed but likely to lead to resentment.

Lockdownlumpy · 09/07/2021 21:06

I personally would agree with you. Hard to say why though.
I think if I were doing a more demanding job 5 days per week, and they were doing a cushy number 4 days a week through choice, I would resent that I was effectively subsidising their lifestyle choices.
At the very best, I would say a fair split would be to work it out based on what their salary would be for full time, since they chose themselves to take that pay cut.

CombatBarbie · 09/07/2021 20:53

Well if mortgage is 50/50 and is £1k then she should absolutely pay 500 and then an agreeable split on rest of the bills. She cannot expect to have a 50% share and have lots of expendable income because she has chosen to go 4 days a week.

If you were married with children my view would be different.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 09/07/2021 20:50

I think DP feels annoyed that I am building up a big pension and have a lot of disposable income and personal savings hence the ‘ask’ to equalise.

Entitled, much?

partner is just very chilled

Only chilled about working. Not at all chilled about money.

warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 20:40

@Itsraimy

When we got together 5 years ago, we didn’t have a huge salary disparity. Both about 30k FTE. I’ve been promoted a lot since then and am where I am now. She’s taken a (voluntary) decision to go part time
As she's making a choice to cut her hours, I think she needs to accept that comes with less financial choice and freedom.

She could work full-time if she wanted.

It would be different if she was working PT for childcare reasons or due to health issues of any kind.

BackAwayFatty · 09/07/2021 20:30

I think I would ask DP to contribute a % based on a FT salary given she has chosen to work a 4 day week 🙂