Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Office colleague not contributing

184 replies

BlueVixen · 08/07/2021 22:13

AIBU in thinking the one person in our small office who didn't contribute towards a box of chocolates and a card for the cleaner shouldn't sign the birthday card. I suggested it in the office today and immediately two colleagues thought it was a good idea an put £2 in the 'pot'. Ended up with £8 (including my contribution). Enough to by a box of chocolates, a card and some wrapping paper. Showing a bit of appreciation. The cleaner is lovely. She cleans a whole building, not just our space, and is cheerful and personable and works hard. The colleague who didn't stump up £2 is not hard up. She and I are both pretty new in the office. She left the office whilst we were talking about it. I'm not sure what to do. Small problem - in the scheme of things but ........

OP posts:
ddl1 · 09/07/2021 10:26

To add:

(1) If it was a big workplace, I could understand if 'them's the rules' about only signing if you've contributed. But if there are just 6 people in the office, and everyone signs it except one person, then it may give the cleaner the impression that this person is deliberately slighting her. Not fair to the cleaner; and risks stirring up trouble between colleagues.

(2) This is slightly derailing the thread; but for those who say that they only contribute/ collect for 'big' 'significant' birthdays: I hope that you are only doing so for people who have indicated that they are celebrating these. For some people, having their work colleagues make a 'thing' of their age would be much worse than getting no card or present at all.

thedancingbear · 09/07/2021 10:20

@ddl1

While I think that if she's not hard up, it's a bit mean of her not to contribute, I think YABU in expecting her not to sign the card. The cleaner may value the good wishes just as much as the present. Also, I think one has to be careful to avoid situations where everyone will notice and judge who did and didn't contribute. Sooner or later, this will involve someone who is hard up or has some unexpected financial crisis: not something that people are necessarily going to wish to inform everyone at work about.
Exactly this. Once you recognise that some people may be genuinely broke such that £2 is material to them, it then boils down to the OP judging whether someone is a ratbag or not for not contributing, based on what she knows about their circumstances. And presumably letting everyone in the office know her decision. It sounds pretty toxic to me.

Also, what's wrong with 'I don't really know x so I'm not going to give her money, but I'd be glad to wish her happy birthday by signing her card'?

comebacksunshines · 09/07/2021 10:20

Yes but I am a better person for choosing to not try to coerce others into spending their money in a way that I dictate.
Coerced ?
The op is asking the protocol, no mention of isolating or demanding money from the colleague.
You sound like you think you're a cut above because you don't contribute to a team effort. Why not contribute to a team collection if you're going to buy something for that colleague anyway, other than to distinguish yourself from your colleagues and claim more credit for your actions.
Both options are fine, but be honest about what you are doing and don't try to crack on your a better person for it.

MrsMaizel · 09/07/2021 10:18

@thedancingbear

so who else is not contributing ? Office of 6 minus her is 5 x2 = 10 pounds ? Unless it's too early form me this morning .

The cleaner, presumably?

It is early mind.

oh maybe 🤔
CaptainCaveMum · 09/07/2021 10:14

@Hobnobsandbroomstick Star

Hobnobsandbroomstick · 09/07/2021 10:10

I work with over 75 people, and there's a collection every week for so and so's 46th birthday, their 7th child, 'their hamster died so we're sending some nice flowers' etc etc.

I've stopped giving any money, unless it's a big birthday or significant life event and I actually know and/or like the person, and even then it's a pound maximum cos I'm tight Wink. I'll sign the card if asked though, cos I'm a CF Wink.

ddl1 · 09/07/2021 10:04

While I think that if she's not hard up, it's a bit mean of her not to contribute, I think YABU in expecting her not to sign the card. The cleaner may value the good wishes just as much as the present. Also, I think one has to be careful to avoid situations where everyone will notice and judge who did and didn't contribute. Sooner or later, this will involve someone who is hard up or has some unexpected financial crisis: not something that people are necessarily going to wish to inform everyone at work about.

lazyarse123 · 09/07/2021 10:02

We have this. I used to do the collections and it's a real pain. I would let anyone sign contributed or not but a couple of colleagues think you shouldn't sign if you haven't paid but as has been said that can be a bit awkward for the recipient.
We have now stopped collections and just leave it ip to individuals if They want to buy something for someone.

MRex · 09/07/2021 10:01

It would give the cleaner pleasure to have more people sign the card, so she should sign. It's only a few quid from each of you, so seems a bit stingy to guard the card.

The contribution is really for the gift not the card; you have to accept that not everyone will want, or might not be financially able, to contribute to every gift in the office.

Backhills · 09/07/2021 10:00

I wouldn't expect to sign the card if I hadn't contributed and sometimes I don't, for reasons ranging from, I forgot, didn't have any change, don't support the cause, or feel it would be two faced as I don't actually like the person.

If I'd arranged the card though, I'd just leave it out for people to sign, without thinking too much about who had the right.

stayathomer · 09/07/2021 09:57

Not the point of this thread, but as you were struggling for money, why did you continue to pay a lot each month for a nice car when you could barely pay your mortgage and for food? I get you need a car, but a cheap run around even bought with a small loan would probably be less per month than hire purchase on a car considered nice.
We couldn't get a loan unfortunately and sorry, when I say nice car it was a small skoda but nice looking iykwim. Cheapest we could get. We'd bought 2 cars previous to this within 3 years and couldn't afford servicing them, both constantly broke down. And we needed a car because we lived very rural, nearest shop was 15 mins drive, nearest house 2 fields away!!!

CaptainCaveMum · 09/07/2021 09:55

@comebacksunshines

I never contribute to office collections. If I want to buy a gift for someone I do it myself. I don’t need to make a public performance out of it. You're making more of a performance out of it by choosing to separate yourself from a team collection, that would give you relative anonymity. Team efforts usually collect more money, so recipient gets a better present. Both options are fine, but you're not a better person for choosing to buy a separate present, that your post implies.
Yes but I am a better person for choosing to not try to coerce others into spending their money in a way that I dictate.

And I am a better person for choosing not to isolate a new co-worker from her colleagues with my performance gift-giving.

Grin
comebacksunshines · 09/07/2021 09:40

I never contribute to office collections. If I want to buy a gift for someone I do it myself. I don’t need to make a public performance out of it.
You're making more of a performance out of it by choosing to separate yourself from a team collection, that would give you relative anonymity.
Team efforts usually collect more money, so recipient gets a better present.
Both options are fine, but you're not a better person for choosing to buy a separate present, that your post implies.

GaspGulpScream · 09/07/2021 09:29

Perhaps she wants to give her a separate present, just from her? She hasn't asked to sign it so there is nothing to discuss at the moment. Poor woman being judge for something that hasn't happened yet

Wrotten · 09/07/2021 09:21

She doesn't have to contribute.

But, keep it in mind when there's a collection for her...

PatchworkElmer · 09/07/2021 09:21

Has she actually asked to sign the card though? She could just want to opt out of the whole thing.

Dishwashersaurous · 09/07/2021 09:16

If she didn't contribute then she doesn't sign the card. Simple

CaptainCaveMum · 09/07/2021 09:15

Clearly I’m a sociopath according to half of MN Grin

I never contribute to office collections. If I want to buy a gift for someone I do it myself. I don’t need to make a public performance out of it. If there’s a card doing the rounds, I’ll sign it if asked. If someone wants to be pissy about it, I’m not bothered. I’ll get my own card, or just, you know, speak to the person and say ‘hey, happy birthday/anniversary or congratulations.’

@BlueVixen
If anyone chose to highlight my choices and suggest I was stingy or not a team player, I’d suggest to my boss that they were a petty bully who needs to focus on the job in hand, rather than being a self-appointed arbiter of moral worth. You say you are relatively new to this job. But you are trying to impose your views on to office culture and trying to alienate your colleagues from this one co-worker. Leave her alone. Do your job.

Oh and no need to patronise the cleaner with your cheap chocolate middle class guilt.

MaMelon · 09/07/2021 09:11

We circulate a big envelope containing a card for signing and adding money to - that way you only get to sign the card if you’ve put money into it. We don’t have a suggested amount - some put in change, others put in notes - you just add your name to the front of the envy to tick you’ve seen it.

comebacksunshines · 09/07/2021 09:06

Let her sign the card.
If it's no biggie for her not to have contributed, it's no biggie to let her sign the card.

What if everyone took the same attitude and no one contributed anything ?
It's absolutely fine not to contribute to a work collection, because they're not your thing, you don't like the colleague etc..
But it creates animosity amongst the people that do.
Fair enough if you've got no cash on you that day, but often those people are usually the ones that always do it and expect to sign the card, you get to know who they are fairly quickly.

Skinnytailedsquirrel · 09/07/2021 09:00

I'm quite glad I work in my lovely office, where everyone gets a card and cake on their birthday, paid for by work (people can opt out). That includes our cleaner, the maintenance guy and people on year long contracts.

I'd hate to work in an office like that and it surely doesn't mean anything to receive when it's all organised and you know what's expected.

The height of absurdity was when I worked in an office (family business) where the previous PA organised birthday collections for the OWNERS. Once I got settled in I spoke to them and they agreed it was completely OTT. The other staff were so relieved to have the ridiculousness stopped.

SmokeyDevil · 09/07/2021 08:55

@stayathomer

There's times in life you suck things up, I think the is sone of them. Maybe she didn't have the money with her, maybe she didn't hear. And I hate people saying they know people have money, nobody nobody knows what people's outgoings are. I worked in a n extremely wealthy place when we were gasping for money. People would have seen nice car (bought second hand on hire purchase and needed because we lived rurally), great job and not known we were paying my entire wage on childcare and struggling to pay a mortgage monthly. I skipped coffee breaks ('I've work to do' was what I'd say) and would bring in lunch all the time. There were times I'd stand in front of the vending machine and talk myself down from buying something because if I went to the supermarket later we might be short this much. When there was an office lunch out planned I'd say I had to meet somebody, same with nights out. Given it's two pound it is more likely not this but just all the people saying people are cheap etc, you just don't know
Not the point of this thread, but as you were struggling for money, why did you continue to pay a lot each month for a nice car when you could barely pay your mortgage and for food? I get you need a car, but a cheap run around even bought with a small loan would probably be less per month than hire purchase on a car considered nice.
IcedSpice · 09/07/2021 08:43

@cadburyegg

YABU. I can’t stand the expectation that you’ll contribute to collections in offices often for colleagues you don’t know that well. One bonus in working from home. That being said my work didn’t do them for birthdays unless it was a big one.
But if you don't contribute then you don't get to take credit.

You don't get to be pissy about it either ( when there are not financial issues )

comebacksunshines · 09/07/2021 08:43

@AbsolutelyPatsy

ask her if she wants to sign, dont be mean spirited. 6 of you in an office? have you spent all the money or will you have spare?
It’s the work colleague being mean spirited. Don’t have to contribute, but then you don’t sign the card.
LookItsMeAgain · 09/07/2021 08:42

Let her sign the card.
If it's no biggie for her not to have contributed, it's no biggie to let her sign the card.

Also, I would tend to donate to an office collection if I knew someone was leaving (retirement/resignation/maternity leave) or if it was a birthday (and only the significant ones). Not really done for 'just to say thanks and we appreciate you'...because that could be opening up a whole can of worms about what you do decide to collect for.