Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thoughts on baby in nursery at 8 months?

304 replies

babyblues21 · 08/07/2021 20:51

Just that really. My baby will be in nursery from this age and I'm struggling with the idea. Any experiences, either positive or negative? Would a childminder be a better option at this age so my baby has more 1:1 care?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LadyWhistledownsPen · 09/07/2021 13:29

My eldest went to nursery at 9 months and my daughter will start in August also 9 months. Your baby will be absolutely fine at nursery. My eldest went full time until January this year and now goes 3 full days a week 8-5. His sister will do the same.

Justgettingbye · 09/07/2021 12:42

Baby will be fine I'm sure SmileI was in there from 6 weeks old and remember nothing (obviously) and would say I'm a well rounded human being that hasn't been scarred! My eldest went to a childminder for a bit. The positives were it was cheaper, would pick up from pre school, home from home environment, known to the area, downsides were there were younger children (a baby in particular) who cried a lot and my daughter than cried as she didn't like the noise or understand plus you don't really know who is coming in and out of the house and whether tv is being used etc.
I'm looking at both nursery and childminder for my 1 year old and will decide.
I'll be honest I don't have the sanity to be a stay at home mum I need another purpose to get up for and dress up in nice clothes every now and again.
Good luck

PippaGrace · 09/07/2021 12:22

@babyblues21 When looking at nurseries the most important thing to look out for is a high staff turnover. Make sure that most of the staff have been there for a good amount of time. Ask management how many of the staff have been there for at least 2 years and ask how many of the staff are new. Talk to the practitioners and ask them how long they have been key staff members for some of their babies. Another good tip is to read google reviews on the nursery and to search their name on Facebook. Also, try and avoid nurseries with lots of branches. They are mostly in it for the money. Small independent nurseries are more likely to be more nurturing. Don’t go on Ofsted reports alone, they are not always very accurate. The nursery I was at was rated good for years before they were caught out! Lastly, if there is any way you can meet the owner of the nursery then do it. I know for sure that if people had met the owner of the nursery I worked at before they enrolled their children they would’ve run a mile. She was a horrible woman. Had a degree in business, drove a fancy Range Rover, was as plastic as a barbie doll and clearly didn’t give a damn about the children at her nurseries or her staff for that matter. She had a terrible energy about her and was the biggest bully I’ve ever met. She didn’t have a nurturing bone in her body.

BazWazzycantdance · 09/07/2021 12:18

Don’t listen to all the nasty people on here. I’m sorry you’re suffering with PND. I sent my baby to nursery full time (5 days a week) and for the first two weeks cried everyday thinking about what a bad mother I was. But after DD settled I realised I was trying to fit a mould that wasn’t me. Little one loves nursery and gets to experience things I wouldn’t even be able to think up. She waves bye bye (13 months now) and is excited to see me when I pick her up. I’m a better parent now too as my mental health has improved greatly since going back to work. You need to do what’s best and realise that you have many years when they’ll need you more and you can always change the settings to what suits. At this time- little one needs someone to baby sit her and entertain her (let’s be honest) and as my career progresses I can hopefully then have More flexibility and can be there for her in her older years. Hugs. You’ll be judged no matter what choice you make but remember your little one knows who you are and loves you, no matter what. They also know you love them and the bond between you won’t suffer (this is coming from someone who’s mother lived in a different country during by baby years and yet I’ve got the same bond as everyone else; as close as any mother and daughter). X

Lem0nie · 09/07/2021 11:41

Mine son has been in nursery since just before 9 months anything from 2 1/2- 4 days a week 8am-6pm.
He absolutely loves it and gets all the interaction and experiences that I couldn’t give him during Covid.

curlycat · 09/07/2021 11:36

My DD works in a baby room. All the girls love 'their' babies and their babies love them. Yes some days the wee ones cry coming in but then again they cry when they are leaving.
My DD missed them so much when they were closed during lockdowns. To the girls in her nursery its not just a job they genuinely love the babies.
You need to do what suits your family circumstances. My DD was looked after by family but DS was in nursery 3 days a week and noth of them are very well adjusted adults who certainly don't feel we ever abandoned them.
Please be kind to yourself and don't ruin this time off with your wee one worrying about months to come

Rosesareyellow · 09/07/2021 11:34

I think a childminder would be better, but if childminder is ill you could be stuck without childcare, whereas that is far less likely to happen in a nursery as multiple staff.

I think a lot of people worry about this being an issue but it never has for us - my childminder knows lots of other childminders, they meet up and visit each other (Covid restrictions permitting) do school runs together etc so when my childminder has been ill (very rare occasion) or she’s had appointments then it’s always been easy to arrange ‘cover’ as such. The first time I sent DS to someone else for the day I was worried he’d be upset but he knew the other childminder instantly and he just walked in to her house like it’s no big deal, didn’t even say bye to me...
I think a lot of childminders have a good social network like this, but obviously it’s always worth asking beforehand.

Jellyred · 09/07/2021 11:21

I also had major issues with ‘but how will I even know if they are happy?’ I spoke with staff about this and their responses were reassuring for as much as you can trust that.

BarbarianMum · 09/07/2021 11:20

It's such an individual choice OP there isnt really a right answer. Depends on you, depends on the baby. Nursery for a baby never seemed right to me so ds1 went to a childminder. Other friends didnt like the idea of a childminder so their baby went to nursery. Ds2 was so unsettled at being left anywhere that I stopped work for a few years after which he was fine w nursery .

They are all teens now and all equally fine (or not, depending on their mood).

Jellyred · 09/07/2021 11:19

Re sleep training, I Had asked about this as my baby wasn’t a sleeper (we did induction at 10 months but Covid delayed my return to 18m).

While they liked the babies to be in a similar routine, they accepted some wouldn’t and showed me what activities they did with any non-sleepers during nap time.

MissChanandlerBong90 · 09/07/2021 11:17

I think it is very personal, I viewed a childminder and left and cried in the car, I could not send my baby to her, the TV was on - the 3 kids she had while I was there were glued to it, my baby ds cried walking in the front door and didn't stop crying through the visit. I did not warm to her at all.

I had a very similar experience going to see one childminder. Children glued to TV. I also didn’t warm to the childminder’s boyfriend at all, and obviously it was his home. I also wasn’t comfortable with the CM strapping him into a car seat and driving him round for an hour a day.

Not to say that all childminders are bad, far from it, but I definitely don’t think they are automatically better just because it’s a ‘home environment’.

FindYourPorpoise · 09/07/2021 11:11

I agree with @SummerHouse

SummerHouse · 09/07/2021 11:10

I went to a toddler group which was all child minders. It was really interesting. Some were incredible and some were not. I think an excellent child minder is better than an excellent nursery. But an excellent nursery is better than a not so good child minder. Mine went to nursery. Lots and lots of positives but if I had my time again, I would probably find the right child minder.

proudwomansexmatters · 09/07/2021 11:06

My DD went from 8 months old 2 days a week and my DS went 3 days from 1. Both really enjoyed it and they were well cared for.

Go and look at the nurseries and meet the staff before you make your decisions. Ask about how they get them to sleep and see if it fits with your parenting.

One very modern and beautiful nursery near me was just not wowing me and when I asked where the babies slept, she told me always in a cot, never in a pushchair because nursery manager didn't believe in it. I left. My daughter always slept in her pushchair and I didn't have a problem if she slept in a cot but there was no way I was going to leave her somewhere where they would rather her scream than make her comfortable. That wasn't for me.

RubyRedBerry · 09/07/2021 11:00

My DS went in at 4 months i day a week, the nursery LOVED having a baby and made a total fuss of him. I actually wish I'd used a nursery for all the childcare (MIL had him the rest of the week as she pushed for it).

EverdeRose · 09/07/2021 10:58

My little boy had done a morning a week from bring 6 months old.
He loves it. We've never had tears and it's plain to see how much he enjoys going and how much care the staff provide. We get lots of updates and pictures of him enjoying his day.

Previously I thought I'd want him to go to a childminder, but wheb you consider the constant walking to and from school for pick up/drop off in all weather's, the fact that their in a home and any one could pop by, and after watching child minders at soft play repeatedly ignoring the children in their care, and much happier with my decision.

I'd advise the drop and run technique, a quick kiss goodbye and a mummy is coming to pick you up at 1pm then going. Don't hang about.

Ahnowcomon · 09/07/2021 10:54

@igelkott2021 the overwhelming response here towards nurseries has been very positive.

Ahnowcomon · 09/07/2021 10:53

You will be inundated here and hugely reassured with positive responses, these threads are always like that and will often counter their arguments with extreme examples how much better it is than a parent at home who is v depressed and does nothing with the baby (I totally agree) or a sahp who can never get work ever again.
I think it's really difficult for parents these days who don't have family support and the options are often just nurseries or childminders.
I worked in lots of nurseries as I took a year off pre Uni, I adore kids but found nurseries (the ones I worked in were considered good) to be a really unsuitable environment for under 2's, the kids there didn't get enough attention obviously, they didn't have that tactile, warm love from a parent ( of course they get this at home but for a baby hours without is a long time), they didn't get enough fresh air ( huge bugbear of mine), constant illness ( I don't actually think repeatedly getting infections/gastro bugs etc is great for the immune system) and just on the most basic level it's boring. It's not at all this stimulating environment that people might believe. I also didn't like some sleep training methods and yes kids do magically end up sleeping at nurseries but I don't like how this was done.
This is MY opinion and my experiences and I know full well as parents with absolutely no family support how difficult it can be, I know lots of parents don't have have choice but I also don't agree with sticking heads in the sand. Also people can't tell if their baby is happy all day at a nursery and loves it. Under 2s don't socialise with other babies at all, socialisation at this age isn't really important.
I find the attachment theories pretty interesting and the works of Bowlby etc.
My dh and me had to swap over a lot and have both ended up working from home, sometimes I worked f/t, soimetimes he. We definitely made less money initially but now thankfully doing well. However we were also late 20's , early 30's when we had babies so lower salary initially anyway.

we are both back working in established careers now, it wasn't easy but we were both anti childcare pre 2 years and we never have help or even odd babysitting from family.

This is my experience of several nurseries and it's OK for me to have my opinion, it's also fine to have another view. I totally get that plenty don't have a choice and but full time nurseries for a small baby isn't ideal.in my opinion.

igelkott2021 · 09/07/2021 10:52

My son went to nursery from 7 months old. I chose a nursery because I thought it would be more reliable (ie you are not relying one one person who may get ill) and I also thought that if you have more staff, if a particular child is being a nightmare you can take time out, which a childminder can't. And I didn't like the idea of a childminder having five children of differing ages, with a small baby (can't remember the exact ratios now). My son was at nursery until the summer before he started school.

I chose a childminder for after-school care (well didn't choose as the school didn't, and still doesn't, have an after-school club though subsequently had a breakfast club). My son went twice a week during the holidays before he started school. One thing I noticed immediately was the improvement in his vocabulary because he was spending time with older children.

And those making snipey comments about "shoving kids into childcare" can congratulate themselves on marrying someone rich enough to keep them and the kids do they don't have to work. Those of us less "discerning" in our choice of partner had to work to contribute to the roof over our, and our childrens' heads.

Twitchynose · 09/07/2021 10:47

My Dad was horrified at the thought of his grandson attending nursery from 6 months. Seeing how well he progressed there and how happy he was (even went to pick him up a couple of times), he did a complete u turn and was saying how good it was for him to other relatives. Whatever you chose to do, is what is right for you x

QforCucumber · 09/07/2021 10:38

I think a childminder would be better, but if childminder is ill you could be stuck without childcare, whereas that is far less likely to happen in a nursery as multiple staff.

I think it is very personal, I viewed a childminder and left and cried in the car, I could not send my baby to her, the TV was on - the 3 kids she had while I was there were glued to it, my baby ds cried walking in the front door and didn't stop crying through the visit. I did not warm to her at all.

The nursery he goes to (after viewing 3) was a totally different experience.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/07/2021 10:32

Today 10:28 babyblues21

*No idea what Bagheera22 said but from the responses I can imagine and agree, ignore it.
*

Questioned whether I even wanted my baby in the first place since I was "dumping" her in nursery at the "first opportunity" and just "ticking a box" by having her.

Vile.”

So sorry. Thankfully, most people aren’t nasty.

babyblues21 · 09/07/2021 10:31

Downsides of using a nursery. Only one I think. Once they leave nursery wraparound childcare becomes trickier. Friends who used a child minder carried on with them as they did school drop offs, pickups and holiday care where I'd failed to grasp how tricky this would be to navigate!

Such a good point - hadn't thought of this

OP posts:
babyblues21 · 09/07/2021 10:30

@otterbaby

Ugh, this thread has made me feel sick. My 9 month old started this week and I was feeling pretty good about it (though still guilty) until I read about people who worked at nurseries where they just ignored the babies all day 😢 my daughter still isn't crawling, I hope she's not just plonked to the side all day and then they just lie and tell me she's had a nice day 🥺😭

Sending hugs. I'm sure this isn't the case for your little one and these incidents are isolated. x

OP posts:
babyblues21 · 09/07/2021 10:29

@bobcatinthewild

I think a childminder would be better, but if childminder is ill you could be stuck without childcare, whereas that is far less likely to happen in a nursery as multiple staff.

Can I ask why you think childminder would be better?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread