Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dog bit a cat 😪

982 replies

Bluetoybear · 08/07/2021 18:00

Please be kind as I am so stressed over this.. name changed for this SadI have a 7 year old dog which is only walked on a lead 3 times a day in local park and let out in my back garden throughout the day for a wee etc. My back garden has a 6 foot fence around it so my dog can't get out. Yesterday the neighbours cat jumped into my garden and my dog ran after it and bit it on its legSad. My neighbour has taken the poor cat to the vets and has had a big vets bill for it and neighbours husband has came round at tea time demanding I pay it all. He was very vocal about it and said if I don't pay it he will 'sue/take me to court/get in touch with authority's saying my dog is dangerous etc. I am so worried as the cat has awful injuries. I have offered to pay half out of goodwill but neighbours telling me I need to pay all of the bill which I can't afford.

OP posts:
JeansShirtJeansJacket · 09/07/2021 02:48

I understand why you feel bad, I think that's a natural reaction to seeing your pet harm someone else's pet. That being said, you have no responsibility to someone else's pet if it climbs into your back garden. This is the risk that people take when they have outdoor cats.

Don't pay a penny towards their vet bills, and ifthey turn up again ranting at you I would probably advise them that you will be calling the police if they continue to harass you.

KTB19 · 09/07/2021 02:37

@Bluetoybear

He has stopped knocking now.. I have my bedroom window open as it's so warm tonight and he had been knocking and saying to his wife who was outside 'I know she is in there!' my husband was fuming on the phone and is going to come home a couple of hours earlier from work tomorrow to go straight round and see him! I have had surgery on my shoulder so was resting in bed with a book as it's still very sore. Little dog was barking and was no help whatsoever Grin
First thing I would do (as soon as you can) is write everything down and then call your local council and ask to speak to the dog warden. Please do not agree to anything at the moment until you have taken advice.

My 33kg dog is terrified of our indoor cat who weighs 9kgs and would beat the shit out of him. However, if a neighbours cat was to come in our back garden, my dog would more than likely attack it - and badly.

I spoke to our local ranger (we are in Australia so its done a bit differently here) and was told that it is perfectly natural for dogs to not tolerate other cats or dogs in their garden, they can see them as a threat.

I have warned one of my neighbours to keep her cat out of my garden because if I am at work, then who knows what may happen.

Please talk to the council, I know you are upset and worried and I dont blame you but do not agree to anything yet until you have taken advice. If this man keeps at your door then call the police, he is bullying you and that is not fair.

I would hate the thought of my dog attacking/killing a cat but he will defend his garden and if I am at work, there isnt much I can do to stop it. So I can imagine how distressed you are.

Cailleach1 · 09/07/2021 02:31

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

How do you prevent a cat entering a garden? Asking for a friend.

How is that OP responsibility?

If you want to make sure your cat doesn't leave your property, you cat proof it. You basically fence it, quite high with an angle at the top. You can see this on youtube.

That is not the op's responsibility. It is the cat owner's responsibility if they want to ensure their cat doesn't go into other people's gardens which might have resident dogs.

eekbumbler · 09/07/2021 02:17

@Boredoutmymind

You are not in the wrong. DO NOT PAY FOR THE VET BILL.

The authority will do nothing as your dog was in you garden secured and an intruder (cat) came in uninvited.

It is perfectly legal for a dog to attack or bite an uninvited intruder that comes into your secured property.

REPORT NEIGHBOURS FOR HARRASMENT, if they continue to bang on your door and cause distress.
They are just bullying you.

Do not claim on dogs insurance and no need to report it to anyone.
Please take my advise and don't give into bullies.

This absolutely.
eekbumbler · 09/07/2021 02:15

I dont recall suing the foxes that attacked my cat when he decided the cubs looked fun to play with.

Boredoutmymind · 09/07/2021 02:13

You are not in the wrong.
DO NOT PAY FOR THE VET BILL.

The authority will do nothing as your dog was in you garden secured and an intruder (cat) came in uninvited.

It is perfectly legal for a dog to attack or bite an uninvited intruder that comes into your secured property.

REPORT NEIGHBOURS FOR HARRASMENT, if they continue to bang on your door and cause distress.
They are just bullying you.

Do not claim on dogs insurance and no need to report it to anyone.
Please take my advise and don't give into bullies.

JamMakingWannaBe · 09/07/2021 01:39

Don't phone your insurance. Even if you don't claim they will class it as an insurable event and put your premium up. If you do claim, your dog will be classed as "dangerous" and your premium will go up. Third party cover is for events that happen in public spaces (dog runs into road and causes a traffic accident). It happened on your private property, you are not responsible and the suggestion your dog should be muzzled in his own garden is frankly ridiculous.

LunaMuffinTop · 09/07/2021 01:22

Don’t let them bully you into paying anything your dog has done nothing wrong the cat should never of been in your garden so it’s on them to pay the vets bill not you. If they knock on the door again I would phone the police it’s harassment and intimidation.

Cushionsnotpillows · 09/07/2021 01:13

@emilylily YOU said in your post "as a dangerous dog" so you ought to know what the "dangerous dog" legislation is about before mentioning it and upsetting the OP further with threats of her dog potentially being destroyed!

Think of the consequences to the OP before you post random and yes, completely made up shit! I may have had an autocorrect but at least I'm not typing incorrect, inane and possibly very misleading rubbish.

user1481840227 · 09/07/2021 00:58

You shouldn't pay.
If you had a pet mouse or rat and it went into your neighbours garden and their cat attacked it I bet they wouldn't pay!!

emilylily · 09/07/2021 00:51

[quote Cushionsnotpillows]@emilylily maybe try actually reading the relevant legislation first before spouting total makeup shit? Hmm it doesn't mention about biting cats, funnily enough.

OP listen to the dog warden, vet nurse and most sensible folk on this thread, you are NOT liable in any way and they can't get a penny from you. [/quote]
I mean if someone wants 'relevant legislation' then they probably wouldn't be asking on AIBU though?

I'm sorry I was obviously wrong about this- it was my gut reaction and what I probably might have done if my dog was involved in this incident.

I'm very glad to hear that the OP's dog is in no danger of being treated as a dangerous dog. The whole thing sounds really upsetting.

'Spouting makeup (made up?) shit' is a bit of a rude way to refer to my post but maybe you've had a hard day and at least the OP knows she has nothing to fear now.

XenoBitch · 09/07/2021 00:43

Also, cats can inflict pretty nasty injuries too. I know someone who nearly lost an arm due to a cat bite.
Your neighbours cat could well have ended up injuring your dog in self defence... imagine a scratch to the eye. I have known dogs to lose eyes to cats. Would your neighbour be happy to cough up for that? I doubt it.

Cushionsnotpillows · 09/07/2021 00:41

@emilylily maybe try actually reading the relevant legislation first before spouting total makeup shit? Hmm it doesn't mention about biting cats, funnily enough.

OP listen to the dog warden, vet nurse and most sensible folk on this thread, you are NOT liable in any way and they can't get a penny from you.

XenoBitch · 09/07/2021 00:18

Your neighbour sounds like a dick. Don't engage with him any further and log any harassment with the police.
He wont be able to sue or insist your dog be PTS. The cat was in your garden... your dog's territory. There is no way any fault can lie with you.

I have a greyhound, and if a cat were stupid enough to come into my garden then I just hope the cat can run, because my dog can too.

jacks11 · 09/07/2021 00:09

Your dog was in your garden. The cat entered your garden. I have outdoor cats- if you allow them to roam, then one of the risks is they get injured. It would be different if your dog had got loose and chased the cat in a public place or into your neighbours garden or something of that ilk. The owner should have insurance. If they don’t, that’s their problem.

The police will not care- your dog was not out of control in a public place. It was in your garden. It did not attack a person. Your neighbour could try to sue, but I doubt they’d get far.

HJ91 · 08/07/2021 23:58

@EKGEMS I have a strong moral centre and would do anything to protect a neighbour’s beloved pet in future if my pet nearly killed theirs. That’s the ‘world’ I prefer to live in, regardless of whether I am ‘liable’. Sometimes it’s not about whether your liable, it’s about the right thing to do. Or - you’re right about cat proofing their garden to keep kitty safe in future - maybe it would be a good idea for OP to contribute towards this instead. That would be a lovely olive branch.

I believe OP’s neighbours are upset and hurt and that is why they are acting this way. It doesn’t excuse aggressiveness, but withdrawing offers of payment and insisting it’s nothing to do with them will not heal relations (or the poor cat).

ILovesPeanuts · 08/07/2021 23:55

Madness! Don't give them a penny. I have 3 cats but only 1 goes outside. She delights in annoying the neighbours' dog by parading along the fence. But if the dog ever gets hold of her and hurts her it wouldn't even occur to me to think the neighbours were financially responsible. Their garden, their space. It'd be my problem.
I hope your husband puts them in their place.

EKGEMS · 08/07/2021 23:50

@HJ91 What color is the sky in your world? The cat went into her fenced yard-there is no moral or financial or legal responsibility to pay for the cat's injuries! Cat proof her backyard?!! Really? How about have an indoor cat? I've had four indoor cats-they live far longer lives.

theweedonkeyfella · 08/07/2021 23:43

Hope you're ok OP and have had no more visits from your bully of neighbour. I'm a cat owner (well, lets be honest, I'm the house slave to a cat) and she's the most precious thing to us. Luckily she goes no further than our garden and occasionally next doors, who haven't got a dog but if this did happen with her in their garden I would not blame the neighbours or expect them to foot the bill.

DeflatedGinDrinker · 08/07/2021 23:40

Don't allow them to intimidate you

DeflatedGinDrinker · 08/07/2021 23:39

I'm a cat owner, my cat did the same I didn't expect my neighbour to pay my cat ran through their garden it's what I have pet insurance for.

RightYesButNo · 08/07/2021 23:28

@Bluetoybear OP, I haven’t seen someone mention this but maybe I missed a comment. Have you checked your dog over very, very carefully? With fur, you can sometimes miss scratches or puncture marks if the cat scratched or bit your dog. The fact is, unless you saw what happened, you have no idea, so you don’t know your dog is responsible.

For all we know, the cat got too close, the dog barked, the cat took offense so swiped him in the nose with claws, so the dog thought it was defending itself by kicking off. In fact, you don’t even know for sure that the cat wasn’t injured when it jumped into your garden (it’s possible - if it’s never entered your garden before, it could have been struggling to get home) and all your dog did was get very upset at its presence, chase it, and possibly nip at it. I’m more of a cat person than a dog person, usually, but your neighbors are being complete arseholes.

Oh, and I’m sure there’s no way Mr. Neighbor would have yelled at you or tried to knock on your door forever if your husband had been home. What a bullying prick. Don’t give him two pence.

CloudsandTeacups · 08/07/2021 23:25

Echoing nearly everyone else. Your dog was on your property in a secure garden. You didn't invite the cat in. You are not responsible.

As someone who owns indoor cats for the very reason that I wouldn't want them to be injured by another animal or a car I think it was irresponsible of your neighbours to let their pet roam.

WeDontLikeCricket · 08/07/2021 23:24

I can't believe their cheek. The cat should be insured. Totally not your fault or responsibility.

SD1978 · 08/07/2021 23:08

I can not believe the number of people who think that she has any responsibility, for a cat trespassing in her garden and her dog biting it!!!! And aye right- she should muzzle her dog in their own garden in case a cat fancy a wander through.......the mind boggles.......