Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dog bit a cat 😪

982 replies

Bluetoybear · 08/07/2021 18:00

Please be kind as I am so stressed over this.. name changed for this SadI have a 7 year old dog which is only walked on a lead 3 times a day in local park and let out in my back garden throughout the day for a wee etc. My back garden has a 6 foot fence around it so my dog can't get out. Yesterday the neighbours cat jumped into my garden and my dog ran after it and bit it on its legSad. My neighbour has taken the poor cat to the vets and has had a big vets bill for it and neighbours husband has came round at tea time demanding I pay it all. He was very vocal about it and said if I don't pay it he will 'sue/take me to court/get in touch with authority's saying my dog is dangerous etc. I am so worried as the cat has awful injuries. I have offered to pay half out of goodwill but neighbours telling me I need to pay all of the bill which I can't afford.

OP posts:
Whitney168 · 09/07/2021 12:20

Hope you've had a peaceful time since your last post, OP. As most have said, you have zero liability here and your neighbours have certainly lost any right to your goodwill offer to contribute. Hope the poor cat is OK, but if they come looking for any contribution at all, tell them that their aggressive behaviour has made you rescind your offer, and if it continues you will be calling the police.

Hope all the cat owners who thought you had any responsibility are now a) a bit wiser on the law and b) have ensured they have adequate insurance to cover the myriad risks if they continue to allow their cats to roam.

Ringsender2 · 09/07/2021 12:14

Hi OP, how are you doing today? Hope that your neighbours have calmed down and that their cat is OK.

OhRene · 09/07/2021 12:12

I have a cat. She's free to roam and if she roams into a dog's garden, she's free to suffer the consequences (as am I). My cat winds next door's dog up and I've told them that if she gets eaten on his turf it'll be her own damn fault. I did also tell neighbour that he needs to stop his dog jumping the fence and coming into mine to get her though. That's where it would be on him to pay vets fees.

GreenLeafTurnip · 09/07/2021 12:11

Do they have any proof your dog bit the cat? If they don't then......what can they do if you deny it? And I say that as a cat owner and not a dog owner!

RaspberryRoyale88 · 09/07/2021 12:09

Your dog did nothing wrong. Dogs chase cats. It was in its garden. Unfortunately the poor cat wasn’t fast enough to get out the way.

I say that as a cat and dog owner.

My cat is an indoor cat, but when she was an out door cat and this happened to her, there is no way I would be cheeky enough to blame the neighbour.

Zilla1 · 09/07/2021 12:08

Might be helpful to understand the logic in some of the 'team cat's' posts where they expect the OP here to pay.

If dog was injured in it's own garden by a roaming cat, would cat owner pay? Is it the owner of an aggressor that needs to pay or are dog's just always liable? If so then if the dog broke into cat owner's garden and was injured, would cat owner pay?

If cat 1 was roaming and injured by another cat 2 in cat 2's garden (with video proof), would cat 2's owner pay for cat 1? Is it not the species but the victim?

MangosteenSoda · 09/07/2021 12:04

Your neighbour sounds awful and you shouldn’t pay a penny.

Sorry this happened, I’d also be terribly upset, but...

Your dog was in a secured space and was entitled to be there. The cat got unlucky through entering the wrong place at the wrong time. It’s a hazard of having a cat.

Tbh, free roaming cats are really problematic. When I was a child, our rabbit got bitten in our garden by a cat. Don’t know whose cat, but luckily we heard the scuffle and could chase the cat away. It had a collar, so was a pet.

A cat we inherited some years later lost an eye and eventually had to be put down after fighting with another cat.

All the damage to wildlife they cause by being natural little predators.

The fact they crap all over other people’s gardens (neighbour’s cat - I’m looking at you).

I like cats, but free roaming cats are difficult pets to care for and to responsibly own. The owner doesn’t have a leg to stand on. Much like the cat it would seem Blush

overnightangel · 09/07/2021 12:02

@Summersun2020

For clarity, I’m a cat owner and love my cat. I really don’t think you’re responsible for this at all. Awful for everyone involved, but just one of those things. Cats will roam, dogs will chase them-cats are usually quick enough to get away. Don’t feel bad op Flowers I do hope the cat recovers.
This , basically. I’m a cat person and not really keen on dogs at all…. But the cat was in your garden, and your dog is allowed to roam free in your garden. They’re being arseholes
Motnight · 09/07/2021 11:58

Op hope you're feeling a little better today.

I am a cat owner and a cat lover. A cat being injured whilst freely out and about is a risk owners take. My cats went through a stage of being in fights with a brute of another cat. It was my responsibility as owner to pay the veterinary bills.

There's some quite unpleasant posts on here.

thereisnophalange · 09/07/2021 11:48

@emilylily

I would definitely pay as the alternative might be your dog being put to sleep if considered to be a dangerous dog.
You're serious, aren't you 🤣
Enough4me · 09/07/2021 11:48

I'm a cat owner. If a cat owner does not want to risk their cat getting injured through going up to other animals, the owner has to keep their cat in.

I had bills for cat fights with a previous cat who was a wimp but wanted to roam. I paid the bills - I couldn't ask my neighbours to pay for their stronger cats!

thereisnophalange · 09/07/2021 11:47

[quote noirchatsdeux]@summerfun12 I think dogs are vile, and if one seriously injured my cat, it wouldn't be biting anything ever again.[/quote]
I think you sound vile.
OPs dog didn't do anything 'wrong', it was just acting on instinct .
If you went and purposefully harmed an animal to teach it a lesson for hurting your cat, that's called abuse and would land you in a whole heap of trouble.

HermioneKipper · 09/07/2021 11:46

I’d say pay nothing and I say this as a cat owner.
If your dog had got into their garden or was loose/out of control on the street then it would be a different story. Your dog was in its own garden and had every right to be there. The cat should’ve known better. And these people should have cat insurance. They sound horrible.

Don’t pay them a single penny.

Hope you feel better soon Flowers

bellabasset · 09/07/2021 11:42

I'm so sorry for you this has happened. I hope the cat will recover soon. But if you want a cat to be safe then you need to cat proof your garden so they can't wander. I might cat proof the fence between your garden and the neighbour's garden.

I think you're right to look at the legal cover on your dog's insurance policy, household policies often have legal cover. I wouldn't want to get into a neighbourly dispute over this so I'd get advice before making any response to them. I hope by the time your dh has returned they will have calmed down.

IntermittentParps · 09/07/2021 11:11

The fact that they were being abusive about it now would mean theyd lost any goodwill from me to helping them out with the bill.

Me too. If he or they both had come round and wanted to talk in a calm way, I might have listened. But the way he's acted, they can fuck off. And do call the police if he harasses you again.

BooksChocolateAndSleep · 09/07/2021 11:11

@Bluetoybear I hope you're ok today. Please do not let the bully of a neighbour upset you. I hope your husband can have a word with him.

Your little dog did nothing wrong, please don't answer the door to the neighbour or pay anything towards the cats treatment. Their cat should be insured and they need to claim through that. x

SteveArnottsWaistcoat · 09/07/2021 11:10

Tell him to fuck off.

It’s absolutely NOT your fault.

Hope the cat is ok and you’re not too stressed. It’s an unfortunate situation, but not one that is your problem.

Ivyiris · 09/07/2021 11:08

Also if your neighbour continues to come and threaten you I would get police involved. He sounds like he's trying to intimidate you. Hope your ok op.

Ivyiris · 09/07/2021 11:06

It would be different if you were walking the dog and it bit but the cat did go into the dogs garden, I don't think it's your responsibility to pay. Sad situation but your dog likely protecting it's territory.

hawkehurstgang · 09/07/2021 10:46

I woukd pay absolutely nothing.

Nobody is going to care at ALL about a dog biting a cat, let alone when that cat entered the dog owner's garden! Nothing will happen.

Angell78 · 09/07/2021 10:38

My dog is not cat friendly and when my neighbours bought cats I made it very clear to them that I couldn’t be held responsible for what might happen to them if they got into the garden, (dog was here before the cats anyway) thankfully no incidents despite the cats occasionally venturing in, but I agree you shouldn’t be held responsible within your own garden, very different if you are out and didn’t have the dog under control but you cannot be expected to pay the bill in this situation, that should be on their insurance.

mightbealittlebitmad · 09/07/2021 10:22

As a free roaming cat owner it's a risk we take letting them out unsupervised. I wouldn't be blaming a dog or it's owner if my cat got attacked because it was in the dogs garden.

A dog is a predator and many will attack something small and furry just like my cat will hunt mice.

If I had a cat who couldn't get out of my garden and someone's escaped rabbit somehow got in and my cat killed it I would not be taking responsibility nor would I assume my cat was some savage who couldn't be trusted around people.

Don't pay anything, it's not your fault, it's theirs for letting their cat out. We know the risks and we just cross our fingers our cats will be fine but unfortunately sometimes they aren't and we have to deal with it.

Sunny4876 · 09/07/2021 10:04

I'm a cat owner and certainly wouldn't expect you to pay,your dog was in his own garden,the cat was the trespasser.

Salanda · 09/07/2021 09:51

[quote MyMabel]**@Sillawithans

I suspect your cat killed birds/mice/rodents that came into your garden too. Should it have been out down for that?[/quote]
@MyMabel @Sillawithans Or, as an analogy with what’s happened to the OP. If your neighbour’s pet hamster/rat/rabbit wanders from their garden into yours and your cat bites it, your cat is liable/should be put down? Come on!

Branleuse · 09/07/2021 09:49

The fact that they were being abusive about it now would mean theyd lost any goodwill from me to helping them out with the bill. They should have pet insurance really if they cant afford to stump up vets bills and have outdoor cats