Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My dog bit a cat 😪

982 replies

Bluetoybear · 08/07/2021 18:00

Please be kind as I am so stressed over this.. name changed for this SadI have a 7 year old dog which is only walked on a lead 3 times a day in local park and let out in my back garden throughout the day for a wee etc. My back garden has a 6 foot fence around it so my dog can't get out. Yesterday the neighbours cat jumped into my garden and my dog ran after it and bit it on its legSad. My neighbour has taken the poor cat to the vets and has had a big vets bill for it and neighbours husband has came round at tea time demanding I pay it all. He was very vocal about it and said if I don't pay it he will 'sue/take me to court/get in touch with authority's saying my dog is dangerous etc. I am so worried as the cat has awful injuries. I have offered to pay half out of goodwill but neighbours telling me I need to pay all of the bill which I can't afford.

OP posts:
EKGEMS · 09/07/2021 16:28

@Funguy Technically you are 100% wrong

warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 16:27

@warmfluffytowels

You must pay their bill, in all honesty. You must be responsible for your dog, which is capable of doing more damage than a cat

Please don't give dodgy advice.

She is under obligation to pay any bills. The cats' owners should have insurance.

She is under NO obligation to pay any bills. Sorry!
warmfluffytowels · 09/07/2021 16:27

You must pay their bill, in all honesty. You must be responsible for your dog, which is capable of doing more damage than a cat

Please don't give dodgy advice.

She is under obligation to pay any bills. The cats' owners should have insurance.

Coulddowithanap · 09/07/2021 16:26

@DixonD the police wouldn't do anything. It is the cat owners responsibly to have insurance to cover things like this.

EerieSilence · 09/07/2021 16:24

@DixonD- are you serious? Why should the OP pay the bill? What legal responsibility does she have for a cat that came into her property?
@MGMidget - the dog is on his own territory. It's their duty to protect it. It's why we have dogs. I would definitely expect my dog to make sure no one comes into our secured and walled garden and walks away unscathed.

HJ91 · 09/07/2021 16:22

@EerieSilence please see my previous posts.

I am turning off notifications; this is turning into an echo chamber.

MGMidget · 09/07/2021 16:21

The cat will repeadly come into your garden and you are going to be afaid to let your dog into your own garden. I think as the cat strayed into your garden it is a natural thing for a dog to defend it against an intruder. Maybe many dogs wouldnt actually bite but just bark. However I dont know! I have a cat who doesnt stray out of our garden but used to have another that did. It kept out of the way of the neighbouring dogs who growl and chase aggressively at cats who they can see walking on the wall between the gardens but can’t reach as there is a trellis in front of the wall. My cat knew better than to chance its luck in their garden where they could get it. I suspect this cat will learn now not to go into your garden but really your dog was in its own garden and the cat was intruding so I think its the cat and their owner’s problem, not yours and you shouldnt be expected to pay the vet bill. Do try and train your dog not to bite though so there are no future problems. But as it’s just a puppy it is understandable.

DixonD · 09/07/2021 16:20

@Bluetoybear

What will happen if they report me and dog to authority's? Sad
This happened to me with my dog.

The police will turn up just to talk to you if they report it. This didn’t happen to me, because I offered immediately to pay the vet bill. It was my fault as the dog belonged to me. There was no question I wouldn’t pay it. It came to well over £1,000.

You must pay their bill, in all honesty. You must be responsible for your dog, which is capable of doing more damage than a cat.

I was devastated when the same happened, but you have to put it right.

BadLad · 09/07/2021 16:20

If I kill a man that is in my garden then I'm going to prison

My dog bit a cat 😪
DynamoKev · 09/07/2021 16:18

[quote Sillawithans]@Bluedeblue your argument is ridiculous. If I kill a man that is in my garden then I'm going to prison. So yeah, your argument is ridiculous.[/quote]
But you are (presumably) a human and that would be killing another human - totally different - and depending on circumstances you might not got to jail anyway (not that it's in any way relevant).
Can't believe you are trying to equate normal dog behaviour with human now.

Coulddowithanap · 09/07/2021 16:18

[quote Sillawithans]@Bonjourfern I think your sense of smell is off there love. The dog that killed my cat had been lined up with a foster family so vet wasn't taking any chances and it was put down. It was a stray dog so no history. I think it was the right call.[/quote]
You can't really compare your situation to the OPs then. Your cat wasn't on the stray dogs property.

EerieSilence · 09/07/2021 16:18

@HJ91 - why should the OP cat-proof their garden? They don't have a cat.
They have no, zero, zilch moral, legal or any other responsibility for the well-being of a cat who came into their garden.

EerieSilence · 09/07/2021 16:16

TBH, people who would put a dog down or are saying it's dangerous because it bit a cat in his own territory (garden) are absolutely ridiculous.
If a dog jumped into my garden and started chasing my cat, I would be pissed off and chased the dog out and wouldn't hesitate to hit it if it meant protecting my cats' lives and well-being.
If my cat were injured in someone else's garden by the dog guarding their territory, I wouldn't say a word. The dog is protecting their own! It's in their nature! FFS people, get a grip.
And I certainly wouldn't pay a cent for a treatment of someone else's cat who was injured in my own secured garden by my dog.

HJ91 · 09/07/2021 16:16

@EKGEMS I think we’ve established you’re approaching this from a standpoint of legal liability, and I’m approaching it from a moral ‘what would I do’ standpoint. So there’s no need to keep tagging me in your replies, please. I am not going to agree with you, you won’t agree with me, and that’s fine.

Also as previously mentioned, OP and neighbours could look at working together to cat proof either garden.

I don’t really think there’s anything more to add, as I have already answered the questions you have around my personal viewpoint. I’m also frankly tired of this conversation; OP has asked for views and she’s received them. But saying that, I hope you have a lovely weekend, and that OP and neighbours agree a way forward where both parties feel listened to.

Fiddliestofsticks · 09/07/2021 16:15

@Sillawithans

No, your argument is ridiculous. This dog will not be put down, not for biting a cat that came into the dog's own garden. We dont use the same laws for dogs as we do for people. You're just wrong.

Ruddyknackered · 09/07/2021 16:14

You are not responsible for the cat's injuries. If 6he neighbour is threatening or harassing you, contact the police.

LST · 09/07/2021 16:14

[quote Sillawithans]@Bluedeblue your argument is ridiculous. If I kill a man that is in my garden then I'm going to prison. So yeah, your argument is ridiculous.[/quote]
Haha are you actually using that as an example 😅😅

Sillawithans · 09/07/2021 16:11

@Bluedeblue your argument is ridiculous. If I kill a man that is in my garden then I'm going to prison. So yeah, your argument is ridiculous.

thelegohooverer · 09/07/2021 16:10

As a cat owner I think you sound like a very lovely person, and I’d have been touched by your concern and your very generous offer to pay half of the bill.

EKGEMS · 09/07/2021 16:10

@brushlaptop You have an astonishing amount of ignorance regarding dog behavior

1WayOrAnother2 · 09/07/2021 16:10

Hope you are feeling better OP.

Your neighbour is especially unreasonable for shouting at you when you are unwell and alone in the house. What a bully.

Your dog did its job - the cat overestimated its own agility and speed. Tough on the cat - but that is nature.

I think that you would know (after 7 years) if your dog was a danger to children/animals in the outside world.

Cookies47 · 09/07/2021 16:10

I am a cat owner.
Do not pay.
Their cat was in your garden. They have probably realised now why they should pay for insurance - it sounds like their cat isn't insured and they are hoping you will foot the bill.
Do not pay.

Sillawithans · 09/07/2021 16:09

@Bonjourfern I think your sense of smell is off there love. The dog that killed my cat had been lined up with a foster family so vet wasn't taking any chances and it was put down. It was a stray dog so no history. I think it was the right call.

Bluedeblue · 09/07/2021 16:08

Cat shouldn't be allowed to roam but any dog that acts like that would also give me real cause for concern

This shows how little you know about dogs!

I look after dogs for a living. At least 50% of them would chase and maul/kill a cat, given the opportunity.

Have you ever looked at dog rehoming websites, like Dogs Trust? Many adverts will say "no small furries", which means "this dog cannot be adopted by anyone who has cats/gerbils etc, as the dog will likely kill them".

Dogs are very territorial in their own domain. I look after many dogs, who are not territorial whatsoever when they are in my home, but it is a different kettle of fish when they are in their own home.

The cat invaded the dogs domain.

EKGEMS · 09/07/2021 16:07

@HJ91 Exactly how can this situation be prevented again? Make cat indoors only? Previous posters say don't pay on a legal basis