Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Changing names when marrying

429 replies

WellLarDeDar · 08/07/2021 15:02

I had liked the idea of taking on DHs name if we ever married and thought I wouldn't bat an eyelid but now it's time (wedding imminent!), I've discovered I'm more attached to my maiden name than I thought, but also still do like the idea of taking DHs name. I think his surname is really nice but it feels really weird thinking I wont have my old name anymore. Naively, I never expected to be unsure over it, it's a very strange feeling.

Is/was anyone else in two minds about it? I'm curious to hear what other people think.

Also, do you think it would be weird for someone to change their maiden name to a middle name and take on their DH/DWs name as a surname?

(DH said that he would love for me to take his name but it's up to me entirely so there's no pressure from him at all. Neither of us want a double barreled surname)

OP posts:
onlyhereforthecake · 08/07/2021 20:47

I am another one who finds it bizarre more women don't care about this in today's world

my decision to change my name or not has 0 impact on the previous centuries, so it's a complete moot point as things stand now. As we now have the choice to keep name, add name, either of us change name... it's not a sexist choice anymore.

And it might not matter to you, but it matters to many of us to have the same name as our kids! It's makes life a hell of a lot easier too.

I changed my name, it was my husband's. Now it's MY name too.
If I was in a lesbian relationship, would taking my partner's name sexist too?

Saoirse82 · 08/07/2021 20:46

I'm double barrelled. My sis took her husbands name and she wishes she'd gone double barrelled too, she ended up giving her two boys her maiden name as a middle name. We're expecting our first child and it'll be double barrelled too. Its fairly common now anyway with children as a lot of parents aren't married so child gets both names.

AliasGrape · 08/07/2021 20:45

I was kind of the opposite in that I always knew I was going to keep my name but when it actually came to it I kind of wanted to change it too.

I’ve kept it on everything official but I tend to use a variety depending on the situation - still my name for work stuff and on official documents, sometimes call myself the double barrelled version and sometimes go along with being ‘Mrs Hisname’ if people call me that too.

mswales · 08/07/2021 20:44

I find it so depressing and frustrating that this question still results in the same stream of "I wanted us all to have the same name so I took DH's name" responses. Sometimes with the "and his was nicer out of the two" or "I like tradition" additions. Doesn't address/answer the question of the centuries of inequality and patriarchy that this tradition upholds. I am another one who finds it bizarre more women don't care about this in today's world - it is like the last bastion of totally culturally accepted (and even celebrated) sexism.

coulditbecominghome · 08/07/2021 20:39

plus faff of admin.

coulditbecominghome · 08/07/2021 20:39

I didn't change my name as my is nicer.

DrSbaitso · 08/07/2021 20:38

My husband's name is also his father's, and so on. What I'm just not feeling is the idea that it's so much more feminist and yay women to have my father's name than my father in law's name. I follow the logic, but ultimately, father's name or father in law's name, I don't feel I'm making a massive feminist statement either way.

You could maybe choose a new name together as a couple. I do actually know a few people who did that. Personally I just didn't feel strongly enough about it. Husband has a lovely name that goes well with mine, and I like him. That was fine for me.

Phantasmo · 08/07/2021 20:36

The handmaidens who refuse to countenance the idea that a woman has her own name at any point in her life.

TurquoiseDragon · 08/07/2021 20:34

@WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia

It's old fashioned and sad that women still feel the need to do this. I know it's not a popular view but why? It comes from when men owned women

Yes, much better to keep your maiden name and be your father’s property

So, for your husband it's his name, but for you it's your father's? What a load of crap.

No one owns a name. Once my name was entered onto that birth certificate, the name became mine, not just my dad's. I've neverer changed my name, and have zero intention to do so. I have a name so don't see the point.

disconnecteddrifter · 08/07/2021 20:33

Got married in 2007 and most people I know didn't take their husbands name as felt was sexist. The fact that people do now makes me wince a bit tbh

DrSbaitso · 08/07/2021 20:32

@Marmaladee

Not saying marriage is a bad thing and I actually do think finding someone you want to commit to and making it work is an achievement and deserves celebrating. But I still do think There are a lot of women see marriage as the ultimate achievement and changing their name as a badge of honour to show off that they have been picked.

I agree. What I don't understand is why I have never had any desire to. Been together twenty years and I don't know what it's all about, I'd hate everything about marriage. The wedding for starters

You probably should look into what it's all about if you really don't know what it entails and what it might mean for you. You still may well decide you don't want to do it, but it would be an informed choice.
DrSbaitso · 08/07/2021 20:30

@IcedPurple

Great. I am personally fine with this one and glad I could use it to my advantage. I respect any other woman's choice to change or retain her name as she wishes. If it changes so that men can do it just as easily, that's great too.

It can only change when men want it to change, which they don't, because almost no man would give up his name and family history for a woman's.

And that's exactly why I don't think it makes any feminist difference which relic of ownership you prefer to use. Born under one, marry into the other, either way you're under that relic, so just choose whichever one offends you least or makes you happy.

Well no. If Sarah Smith keeps her name and passes it on to her children, then they're taking their mother's name, aren't they?

And the name I was born with is my name.

They're still taking their grandfather's name. I don't see how it's significantly different from what we usually do now, though, because it's still your father's, or kids' grandfather's, name. They're almost all male line names ultimately at this stage and I don't find it objectionable for women to decide which line they prefer.

Maybe if I'd liked my maiden name and its connotations more, I'd have done something like that, but it's still male line so I don't think I'd have felt I was making a massive point. I'm not going to saddle myself all my life with what is, to me, a toxic and ugly-sounding name rather than the one I prefer to have in order to satisfy someone else's principle.

I simply do not see "born under this name, relic of father ownership" as significantly different or preferable to "take married name, relic of husband ownership", especially when the latter is a choice.

Deadringer · 08/07/2021 20:26

I have been doing research into my family history and it's very fruastrating trying to find female ancestors, they just disappear once they marry. A bit off topic but I was reading Barack Obama's book and he was talking about his first visit to Africa, he could trace his male relatives back a fair bit but the women's names and history weren't passed down at all. All those women, just forgotten. I think it's quite sad really, and i hope my dds keep their names'. Not their father's name, or their maiden name, their name.

MostTacticalNameChange · 08/07/2021 20:24

@onlyhereforthecake

The socialisation that getting married is the ultimate win for women

I think you should separate 2 things:

the "being picked" aspect, which is debatable
the "legal protection" to wives and more importantly mothers.

Yes, legal protection is incredibly important - there should be much more education around it that - so many women get screwed over.

But is it the main motivation for wanting the proposal and the wedding? Not as often as it might be.

cloverleafy · 08/07/2021 20:22

My husband took his surname and kept his as a middle name. So yes, perfectly possible.

If you want to keep your name though, do. There's also no rule you have to make any change on your wedding day. You can keep your name and review it later if you change your mind.

Marmaladee · 08/07/2021 20:16

Not saying marriage is a bad thing and I actually do think finding someone you want to commit to and making it work is an achievement and deserves celebrating. But I still do think There are a lot of women see marriage as the ultimate achievement and changing their name as a badge of honour to show off that they have been picked.

I agree. What I don't understand is why I have never had any desire to. Been together twenty years and I don't know what it's all about, I'd hate everything about marriage. The wedding for starters

onlyhereforthecake · 08/07/2021 20:15

The socialisation that getting married is the ultimate win for women

I think you should separate 2 things:

the "being picked" aspect, which is debatable
the "legal protection" to wives and more importantly mothers.

Iggi999 · 08/07/2021 20:12

Ladies and Gentlemen.. the bride and groom!

Chachachawoo · 08/07/2021 20:12

I did the same as @MackieMayor
Been almost 20 yes too
Technically I changed my name to his but email etc and work stuff is maiden name and it works well for me.

kayakingmum · 08/07/2021 20:09

[quote thisplaceisweird]@kayakingmum your master of ceremonies can say whatever you want him to say! Don't let that be a blocker to such an important decision[/quote]
Thanks but I'm at a bit of a loss as to what he can say instead.
Maybe - "here is the happy couple - First name partner and first name me". It's really tricky.

MostTacticalNameChange · 08/07/2021 20:03

There are a lot of women see marriage as the ultimate achievement and changing their name as a badge of honour to show off that they have been picked

@onlyhereforthecake

That was me and I stand by it. And in no way am I saying I'm better than anyone and unaffected. The socialisation that getting married is the ultimate win for women did a huge number on me - big pressure from family, FOMO from peers getting married, anguish because he hadn't proposed, fear that I'd end up alone, envy at weddings etc. It got so bad it ended in an ultimatum and he agreed to marry me when looking back I don't think he really wanted to Sad but it still felt like a win because I'd completed that goal I'd be fed from birth.

Was just getting into feminism at the time so was staunch on the name thing but have done a lot of learning since then and can now see my need to conform for what it was.

Not saying marriage is a bad thing and I actually do think finding someone you want to commit to and making it work is an achievement and deserves celebrating. But I still do think There are a lot of women see marriage as the ultimate achievement and changing their name as a badge of honour to show off that they have been picked.

IcedPurple · 08/07/2021 20:00

I personally like the idea of sharing a surname, it gives me a sense of unity and it's kind of an exciting representation of a new part of our life starting.

Is there any reason the name you 'share' couldn't be your name?

Marmaladee · 08/07/2021 19:52

[quote WellLarDeDar]Thank you everyone for the responses. So interesting to hear what everyone has to say and the discussion is fun! Nice to know other people have chosen to make their original surname a middle name so I think I am warming to that idea.

I appreciate those sharing the feminist POV but please dont tell me I shouldnt take my DHs name or be judgemental. A large % of women do, its very common and it's entirely my choice and I'm in no way a poor submissive helpless woman having my name taken from me! Changing my name in no way diminishes my value or status as a strong independent woman.

It's true it comes from archaic traditions but traditions can be reclaimed. I feel in no way pressured or controlled into the name change, it is completely up to me. I personally like the idea of sharing a surname, it gives me a sense of unity and it's kind of an exciting representation of a new part of our life starting. Kind of like when my title changed from Miss to Doctor. But I do love my family name as obviously I associated it with different parts of my life.

Phantasmo · 08/07/2021 19:48

You can relax, @ForeverAintEnough3. Apparently approx. 90% of women in the UK take their husband's name. You're very much in the majority and I'm sure can just about cope with some criticism of the tradition.

WellLarDeDar · 08/07/2021 19:47

Thank you everyone for the responses. So interesting to hear what everyone has to say and the discussion is fun! Nice to know other people have chosen to make their original surname a middle name so I think I am warming to that idea.

I appreciate those sharing the feminist POV but please dont tell me I shouldnt take my DHs name or be judgemental. A large % of women do, its very common and it's entirely my choice and I'm in no way a poor submissive helpless woman having my name taken from me! Changing my name in no way diminishes my value or status as a strong independent woman.

It's true it comes from archaic traditions but traditions can be reclaimed. I feel in no way pressured or controlled into the name change, it is completely up to me. I personally like the idea of sharing a surname, it gives me a sense of unity and it's kind of an exciting representation of a new part of our life starting. Kind of like when my title changed from Miss to Doctor. But I do love my family name as obviously I associated it with different parts of my life.

OP posts: