Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't afford school fees

388 replies

Theemptyvase · 08/07/2021 11:33

I've just found out that my DC is no longer entitled to a free place at her private school.

She's 6 years old and has now completed two years of school and, having found it very hard the first year, she has now settled down and is getting on very well indeed.

There's a possibility that a place will once again become available in a year or two, so we are deciding whether to try to pay the fees ourselves in the hope that:
A) a free place once again becomes available, or
B) in a year or two she'll have the confidence to move school with less trauma

She's made so much progress at her school and become so much more comfortable in her own skin that I'm loathe to move her (despite the alternative school being absolutely fine). We can pay the fees ourself but it will be with quite some sacrifice - we'll be able to afford the mortgage, insurance, food albeit with being much more careful at the supermarket etc, but we'll have no savings and the luxuries will have to go.

I'm strongly inclined to believe that a really positive school experience is worth these sacrifices, but I know I'm biased on these matters. Please could anyone with experience of fee problems and/or shy/sensitive children please offer their advice?

For voting; YANBU to pay school fees. YABU - man up and send her to the other school.

Thanks

OP posts:
HaveringWavering · 09/07/2021 08:43

Whoa, steady in @NursePye. People who use private schools don’t say things like “it’s to avoid mixing with the riffraff”. That is an accusation thrown at private school users by others who want to criticise them.

NursePye · 09/07/2021 08:40

Jesus this thread is depressing!!

Sending your children to private school to "keep out the riffraff" and have your children mix with only middle class professionals.

No wonder we have the government we have if people think that this is what life is about.

The message you are sending your children is that they are a cut above the "riffraff". Nice Hmm.

FWIW I have a DC who was "painfully shy". She has done pretty well in a state school. It's not even an "Outstanding " one either. Hard to believe that some kids can thrive in such an environment if you believe everything you read on MN. She may not get 8s and 9s for her GCSE'S (how will we cope?!!!), but at least she mixes with kids from all kinds of backgrounds and has learned that life can be challenging for others in ways that she hasn't experienced. There is disruptive behaviour, but learning how it is dealt with (by staff and pupils) is another life lesson.

No jealousy btw, the sacrifices that people on here bang on about are not really sacrifices. Plenty of the "riffraff" can't afford new cars or expensive holidays regardless of sending their children to private school. But hey ho, they're just the plebs that have kept the country going over the last 18 months so they don't count. Hmm.

NotTheMrMenAgain · 09/07/2021 08:09

cortex10 staff don't have to pay tax as a benefit in kind on the full value of the cost of the the school fees in these situations - as per Pepper-v-Hart - the benefit is calculated as the extra cost to the school of having the employee's additional child in the class. So basically, it'd cost the school X amount to run a class with 15 kids in, adding the teacher's child to the mix doesn't increase the amount the school needs to pay for the building/heating/staff salaries etc so the actual additional cost to the school would be another set of books/pencils/etc for this additional particular child. So the tax, in my limited experience, is usually next to nothing.

LucindaT73 · 09/07/2021 08:02

@Theemptyvase

I've taught in private schools and know that by now most are on summer hols. So are you saying your head has thrown you this decision in the last week of term?

Have you been to talk to them?

Instead of posting here, surely the first step is talking to your Head and making known your circumstances?

Are you embarrassed to say you'd struggle with fees?

They might find some compromise for you.

In either case it's very poor form to make this announcement so late in the day because there is every chance a child would find it hard to get a place anywhere else at such short notice.
Schools of your choice may be full.

You say 10% of staff have children at the school. This is a small prep school with financial issues. How many children is that? 2? 3? Are you talking to each other and deciding how to approach this?

Terhou · 09/07/2021 07:30

Looking at the terms of the fee payment for the school, it seems they need a decent-sized payment up front, which is even more problematic than the monthly cost

Given that they've dropped this on you at short notice, I would have thought you have a good case for asking that you be given more time to pay.

Glovesick · 09/07/2021 07:26

Not RTWT but I think you should consult and employment lawyer. I think it may be arguable that the free school place for your children may be a term of your contract that the school cannot unilaterally withdraw.

Terms do not need to be in writing, they can be acquired through custom and practice.

See a lawyer then you will know how strong your argument is and whether to push it.

cortex10 · 09/07/2021 07:24

Do you currently pay tax on the free fees as a 'benefit in kind'? If so the cost of funding them yourself may not be as much as you expect.Or maybe you've already taken that into account.

shallIswim · 09/07/2021 07:24

Yes it's a myth that only state school kids have private tutors! Mine certainly didn't, and I know plenty who went private who did. It happens across both sectors. Buying small class sizes doesn't insulate against academic weakness or indeed parental paranoia.

Dogvmarmot · 09/07/2021 07:06

@DeathByWalkies

IMHO / IME the later in the school career you spend on private school fees, the more impact it has on things like A Level results, university destinations and so on.

You seem to get much more bang for your buck paying for sixth form, or sixth form plus secondary, than you do paying for primary and then going state for secondary.

I'd move to the state primary and save up for secondary / sixth form fees.

agree totally with this. private primary seems a waste of money may help if they need it for secondary or at least 6th form. you are a teacher so probably know this but remember when they start the fees can be say £8k but down the road they are £16k..if the local school is fine it mostly depends on their peer group. my dcs went to a highly selective high pressure academic secondary but those from their state primary who went to the local state school ended up on the same courses and same top universities. I think it depends on parental expectations and peer group. and of course the child. BTW the private school pupils all had outside tutors for most subjects! so much pressure..
shallIswim · 09/07/2021 06:59

@Theemptyvase

I do feel a sense of loyalty to the school, and especially to the students. I can't leave them when things are tough.

A few people have asked how many staff children are there and I can say it really is quite a lot, I'd say around 10% of the student body.

Ten per cent? Surely not sustainable. Bonkers in fact, if none are paying Ship out now OP
Pixxie7 · 09/07/2021 06:51

all pegbodasu@ each to their own. The reason I am anti private education is that I think everyone deserves the same start in life.

CakeyCakeyCakeCake · 09/07/2021 06:36

My DD was in private school in the uk. We emigrated and put her in an “exceptional” state school where we are now. It was a nightmare. She was so ahead the teacher just left her to it. After 4 years paying through our noses in the uk, she came here and went back a year academically. (Her teacher was horrible-to be fair to the school). We took her out after a year and put both DCs in a private school here. Best thing we have ever done. She is so much more confident and happy now. We sacrifice but I would never ever ever put her back in state school.

pegboardsu · 09/07/2021 06:01

@Pixxie7 why are you anti private schools?

Pixxie7 · 09/07/2021 04:43

I would move her to a state, although I must admit I am a bit anti private education. The benefits of having a few luxuries will benefit you all, also what happens if you have another child?
She will probably benefit from being a different school to you anyway and if needs you can always get a private tutor. She is only 6 let her enjoy her childhood.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 09/07/2021 04:03

@Biggerbuns

I created a thread with a related dilemma. I was in a similar situation. We were on full bursaries which have gradually been chipped away at.

It’s not just the fees in private education but everything that goes with it. Our children sometimes feel as though we are poor. My heart broke when a child said “they were giving out leaflets about holiday clubs but I didn’t get you one because I know we cannot afford it.

They’ve previously nagged me to go on all sorts, I’ve got one desperate to go on a week’s kayaking course with her friends at £45 a day which is impossible and I’ve had to explain we cannot do it. That literally every spare penny goes on fees, something which we are happy to do for them but we cannot just go to McDonalds for example. Everything is strictly budgeted.

I don’t want to go into the ins and outs of why my children are in the private system (and we cannot realistically move them) but it’s not because we think state schools are feral.

A lot of the parents or mums at least, don’t work, have enormous amounts of disposable income and it does massively add to the pressure.

I know we are doing the right thing by our children and their needs, but it’s bloody tough and if I had my time again I do wonder if the stress is worth it.

Sounds like my family. I went to an academically-driven (and selective) girls' private school and my parents had to scrimp and save to get me there too - I mostly didn't even ask to do the extracurricular trips, and I coped with having second-hand uniform and so on. I did get the occasional extra - like music lessons in sixth form - but I am so grateful to my parents for putting me through that school because the education and advantages I got from it outweigh the lack of "extras" now. Of course that was decades ago though - so things weren't AS expensive as they are now - but I hope your kids understand that you ARE doing your best for them and take advantage of the opportunities available.
Stompythedinosaur · 09/07/2021 00:08

I would move her tbh. Younger is better for a school move I would say - at 6 she will make new friends move easily than joining an established group of 9 or 10 year olds.

I would be worried that the free places may never restart.

ThanksItHasPockets · 08/07/2021 23:28

@Theemptyvase

I do feel a sense of loyalty to the school, and especially to the students. I can't leave them when things are tough.

A few people have asked how many staff children are there and I can say it really is quite a lot, I'd say around 10% of the student body.

That's laudable, OP, but if the school's financial issues are as critical as I and other PP suspect then they won't be able to afford any loyalty to you, or to the other staff and parents.
HaveringWavering · 08/07/2021 22:57

@Theemptyvase

I do feel a sense of loyalty to the school, and especially to the students. I can't leave them when things are tough.

A few people have asked how many staff children are there and I can say it really is quite a lot, I'd say around 10% of the student body.

And what are all the other staff doing/saying about the situation? Also, has this just been announced now, with fees becoming payable from September? How in earth are you supposed to get an alternative state school place between now and then?
Theemptyvase · 08/07/2021 22:54

I do feel a sense of loyalty to the school, and especially to the students. I can't leave them when things are tough.

A few people have asked how many staff children are there and I can say it really is quite a lot, I'd say around 10% of the student body.

OP posts:
Coyoacan · 08/07/2021 22:50

I think it's interesting how people take their free kids education and then as soon as it's taken away, it's like "well fuck you, I'm leaving and taking all my toys with me"

What a bizarre way to think. The OP is working in the school and being paid. If she cannot afford to send your dd to the school she works in, isn't that down the level of salary she receives.

HollaHolla · 08/07/2021 21:31

Seriously. She’s 6. State primary will be absolutely fine for her.

00100001 · 08/07/2021 21:28

@PegasusReturns

Yes, bit it's not OPs school's responsibility to keep that free place for the child.

I disagree. If is a customary element if her employment then it’s their responsibility in the same way paying her is their responsibility.

You have no idea what the school have tried to do to keep the free places...

Who cares?! This is about the OP. The treatment is shoddy and it’s the sign of a sinking ship. Teh OP should jump and quickly.

Not really..noone forced OP to send her child there.

Fine it might be a sinking ship... so she should take her daughter out because she can't afford the fees...which is not what she wants.. Confused

I think it's interesting how people take their free kids education and then as soon as it's taken away, it's like "well fuck you, I'm leaving and taking all my toys with me". It's very much one way...?

Dustyhedge · 08/07/2021 21:23

I wouldn’t in your shoes because

  1. if the school is struggling her school place will be the least of your worries. You wouldn’t want them to go under losing your job and any upfront fees
  2. the things you’d miss out on would be too much for me. I wouldn’t choose private prep over swimming lessons, days out etc
  3. you’re a teacher so will be very well equipped to help your child, more so than the average parent.
willstarttomorrow · 08/07/2021 21:22

OP- I have a friend working in a private school. Every non teacher job is a race between parents for a fee reduction. They all sit in the staff room talking about how many years they have left.

In contrast I work with schools with very qualified support staff who go above and beyond for every child who needs them. Lots of children thrive in state schools with the right support at home.

My niece left a well thought of private school last year for university. Her parents thought she could not cope in state school and one wage went on fees. She was discouraged from taking exams because she would bring the average down. She also has been so protected from real life cannot really cope.

Think very carefully, I know we want to protect our children. Private school is brutal in different ways to a good state school. We are the poor relation but my DD is in a good state school. She is capable and will do well. She is able to interact and feel comfortable with people from all backgrounds. This is not only because of school but I am so proud of how teens within the state schools I work in are challenging injustice and think beyond exams.

amicissimma · 08/07/2021 21:21

If you're a teacher at the school how is it going to work if your DD is at a school with different hours? The state school day is often shorter than private, even if there is an early breakfast club will you have to leave early to pick her up? Surely the point of the free place for staff children is to avoid all that?

I think you need to be careful about paying to keep her there - that would take away any incentive for the school to reinstate the free place.

But it's really hard on your DD. Would you think of getting a job in the state school she would go to? Would that help her?