Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can't afford school fees

388 replies

Theemptyvase · 08/07/2021 11:33

I've just found out that my DC is no longer entitled to a free place at her private school.

She's 6 years old and has now completed two years of school and, having found it very hard the first year, she has now settled down and is getting on very well indeed.

There's a possibility that a place will once again become available in a year or two, so we are deciding whether to try to pay the fees ourselves in the hope that:
A) a free place once again becomes available, or
B) in a year or two she'll have the confidence to move school with less trauma

She's made so much progress at her school and become so much more comfortable in her own skin that I'm loathe to move her (despite the alternative school being absolutely fine). We can pay the fees ourself but it will be with quite some sacrifice - we'll be able to afford the mortgage, insurance, food albeit with being much more careful at the supermarket etc, but we'll have no savings and the luxuries will have to go.

I'm strongly inclined to believe that a really positive school experience is worth these sacrifices, but I know I'm biased on these matters. Please could anyone with experience of fee problems and/or shy/sensitive children please offer their advice?

For voting; YANBU to pay school fees. YABU - man up and send her to the other school.

Thanks

OP posts:
andweallsingalong · 08/07/2021 13:56

I voted yabu, but think maybe it's not that straightforward.

Could you negotiate with the school?

If they're low on pupils could paying 50% of fees be a win/win. They get some money they wouldn't otherwise have. Your daughter gets to stay.

FudgeSundae · 08/07/2021 13:53

@Simbacatisback

It was never free- it was a taxable benefit- so based on that how much will it actually cost as your salary will rise as no deduction.
This is incorrect. The taxable benefit is the incremental cost of providing the place - practically zero. This is well established in tax law.
Tamary97 · 08/07/2021 13:53

Better to move her now. Too risky to keep her there, get a free place, loose it again, etc.

She is young, she will settle

OnTheSeaShore · 08/07/2021 13:52

Wow, some of the comments!!

My lovely boy was lost in state primary. He was anxious and overlooked. He barely accessed the curriculum because he was in a class of 30 children, some of whom had very high needs. The catchment area was one of the highest in the country index of deprivation and the general community was not pro-education or aspirational.

We moved him to a tiny independent. There are 60 something kids in the whole school. There are 7 kids in his class ( in fact that's the whole of year 6) The fees are not what I'd call outrageous. It's around 6k a year and for that he's part of a lovely family of kids who are mostly well behaved and motivated. There's nothing snobby about it at all. It's a very down to earth place and all of the parents are ordinary folks who are making sacrifices to enable their kids to have a better experience.

DS's confidence, happiness, achievement everything has blossomed. He skips into school and back out again and his contentment makes everything in my world right. There's no academic hot housing, it's just a sweet, caring school where everyone matters.

I only regret that I waited till he was on his knees in year 4. I wish I'd sent him years earlier instead of hoping and trusting in a school that made him miserable.

Seren20 · 08/07/2021 13:49

You’re going to know what’s best for your child, OP.

I would say that this sounds incredibly shoddy behaviour from the school/your employer. Especially without any mitigation in terms of salary sacrifice, a % of fees at first etc.

If it’s a small school and I were a parent of a child there, it would definitely ring alarm bells for me re the health of the schools finances and the potential for losing good members of staff.

Hoppinggreen · 08/07/2021 13:48

My DC are at Private Secondary school so I say this with no anti Private bias but what you are doing is crazy. Unless your State School is awful there is no need for Private Primary at all. I appreciate it will be hard for you to teach other children when yours has had to leave but I don’t see what other option you havev
It was always a risky strategy relying on a free place, especially if it could be withdrawn. I know dc with teacher parents and they generally get 50% off rather than full fees and what your school is doing is pretty shitty to be honest. I would also be concerned about my job if I were you as our DCs school is booming and had to add an extra Y7 class last September

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 08/07/2021 13:42

I'd pay the fees for the next year and review at the end of it.
It does seem a bit drastic for your employer to have gone from zero to full fees though - you'd have thought they might have at least gone halfway first!

onlyhereforthecake · 08/07/2021 13:41

I can never understand the English obsession with private school. Is it a class thing? Keeping up with the Jones or wanting to be 'seen' a certain way?

It's the usual hypocrisy - private schools are "for show"

but moving and over-spending on an inflated mortgage to be in the right catchment is fine.

To be clear, I don't disagree with doing either, I think as a parent your job is to provide the best for your child. I am just shaking my head at the usual bitter jealousy.

Simbacatisback · 08/07/2021 13:41

It was never free- it was a taxable benefit- so based on that how much will it actually cost as your salary will rise as no deduction.

Socksey · 08/07/2021 13:39

@Maggiesfarm

As your daughter has settled and is doing well now, I would keep her at the school. You may find that it is not as difficult as you anticipate and, presumably, your salaries will go up from time to time.

Please don't think in terms of 'sacrificing' and certainly never use that word to your daughter. This is your choice, not hers. Later on she may appreciate it very much but 'sacrifice' is a heavy word, makes children feel guilty and forever in your debt. Do it with a smile.

I hope she continues to do well and, who knows, when she is ready to go to big school she may win a scholarship or bursary, or get a grammar school place.

Take care of yourselves and good luck.

Agree with this... My mother still harps on about the sacrifices she made.... no holidays (she's obsessed with that) or other treats... I left school more than 30 years ago... For her it was very much about sending her children to private school rather than the quality of education or what they may gain from it.... And after 30 years apparently I'm still not grateful enough 🙄
Notonthestairs · 08/07/2021 13:37

I think you'll have to do an in-year application to get her in to state school now so you might not have your pick of schools - I'd speak to your county council to assess where places might come up.

Shockingly awful timing by your employer. This should have been discussed months ago.

EvilPea · 08/07/2021 13:36

@IDidNotSignUpForThis

Ps despite working in a private school I personally don’t think it is worth the massive financial investment for most students. Unless you are absolutely minted and money is no object consider very carefully. Admittedly we have planned carefully to be in catchment for outstanding state primary and secondary schools. We are saving heavily for our DCs future - university/ further Ed./ flat deposits etc. All things to consider perhaps, OP?
With house prices being what they are I completely agree. A private education does not guarantee a job that will be enough for a mortgage (or that their chosen career is enough for one).

They will need a home, they don’t need a private education.

Blondeshavemorefun · 08/07/2021 13:34

Private primary is a waste of money, unless very rich

Tho you can afford it now, just less luxuries

What happens when goes to secondary school. Fees increase lots

Take her out now for state

Now her free place has gone via you, it won’t come back so this dilemma will happen again in a year or two

Dontdripme · 08/07/2021 13:30

Take her out, far easy when shes young

RealBecca · 08/07/2021 13:29

In your case i would consider challenging the removal of your free place as a change of contract- what proportion of reduction of salary are teachers without school places taking? If none then id speak to your union.

There os no way your child will get a free space back- if they backfill her with a paying student then that is a paid place that will always be kept as a paid place.

Id also be looking at whether they are currently advertising any vacancies with this perk. How can they no longer afford to fund your daughter's free space then its not due to covid- we are at the back end of furlough and things are due to go back to BAU. They are using covid as a weak excuse, the financial issue for them would have bitten long ago.

Rainbowqueeen · 08/07/2021 13:29

I’d base my decision on free school places never being reinstated. That is a highly unusual perk. More likely, if the school survives, teachers will be given a discount on school fees in the future.

The point raised above about the school closing and so all the parents trying to find a place for their DC in a local state school is also a good one. Assess whether you think that is likely or whether most parents would find and use another private school.
If you value private school for your DC I agree that she would get more value out of private secondary school. I would withdraw her and look at that instead. Give yourself both time to save and the money to give her life experiences

cinammonbuns · 08/07/2021 13:28

@onlyhereforthecake did you miss the part were I said that I don’t believe private school is the best environment for my child - or most children really? I think good schools are regardless of fees.

Suspicioussam · 08/07/2021 13:28

I don't understand how some posters can say it's 'definitely worth it' how can you know without knowing the specific schools?
OP, I have a shy and anxious 5 year old who is also flourishing in his (state) school. We were considering moving areas but might stay put in order to keep him where he is, so I totally get your dilemma.
However, the best time to move them is when they are young and adaptable. If the state school option is good I would go down that route in your shoes. The older they get the more their friendships develop and they become more settled.

Think about the impact of the loss of 'luxury' money on your DC. Will you still be able to afford swimming, activities, toys, days out, holidays? Would you be able to save for that child's future?
Unless I was very wealthy and could still live a comfortable life after school fees, no way would I choose private over a good state school.
My best childhood memories are our family holidays and days out. If I had lost all of them to be in private school my childhood would have been very different and I still succeeded academically anyway.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/07/2021 13:27

If the school unilaterally removes free/staff discounted places for pupils in their system I'd be looking for work in a more financially secure school. Its either in trouble or does not take its responsibilities to staff/pupils seriously enough. Is the discounted fees package a benefit offered to offset lower salaries?

If you have the money to pay, you also have the money to send her to the state school whilst providing all the extras and cultural capital from an enriched environment without spending every spare penny on fees. However using the word "sacrifice" when simply forgoing material luxuries and extras to pay for some other advantage is frankly inappropriate.

IDidNotSignUpForThis · 08/07/2021 13:27

Ps despite working in a private school I personally don’t think it is worth the massive financial investment for most students. Unless you are absolutely minted and money is no object consider very carefully. Admittedly we have planned carefully to be in catchment for outstanding state primary and secondary schools. We are saving heavily for our DCs future - university/ further Ed./ flat deposits etc. All things to consider perhaps, OP?

mellicauli · 08/07/2021 13:22

I think you need to have more faith in your daughter.

She found it hard at first but she adapted and she is now making progress. Why do you think she couldn't do the same again? As you say, the other school is perfectly fine.

Surely our daughters grow strong by showing them we believe in them and that they can cope with the challenges life throws at them.

I think for many children shyness is just a phase that you pass through. I look at my super-confident 17 year old and find it difficult to remember at one point he was shy.

1starwars2 · 08/07/2021 13:22

I would move her now. Friendships are so fluid at 6, it's easier now than later.

You are a teacher so academically she won't suffer.

Also she may gain more local friends.

user68901 · 08/07/2021 13:22

@Poptart4

I can never understand the English obsession with private school. Is it a class thing? Keeping up with the Jones or wanting to be 'seen' a certain way? Or are your state schools totally shit?

Anyway, I don't think sacrificing every little pleasure in life and living on the bread line is worth it. But then, our state schools are perfectly fine where I live.

My husband is from Oz and said pretty much same thing to me and luckily made me see sense . Both girls have done really well and enjoyed their state education plus we’ve been on some fab holidays and never had to worry about money! We’ve also moved around during their primary years and they coped brilliantly.
HugeAckmansWife · 08/07/2021 13:22

I don't think turning this into a generic state vs private thread is worthwhile. They always go the same way. I think a pp makes an excellent point about possible breach of contract and also that I'd be formally presenting this with my union rep to the governors with a view to understanding the financial position of the school as a whole.
And for sausage roll no, the point if private schools is not to keep out undesirable kids. (whatever that means) It's to provide the best possible environment for kids to learn, small classes, less stressed teachers jumping through hoops and focusing on the kids in front of them. We'd bloody love it if all schools could be 12 kids to a class and have access to sport every single day but that requires serious long term investment from the gov. We can only provide what we do because of the fees paid. We're not a rich school at all, can't do many bursaries or scholarships but we do do some. We'd love to be needs blind but we just can't. Please don't make sneery assertions about kids not darkening our doors.

whatonearthnow · 08/07/2021 13:20

Move your dd and look for a new job. The school is struggling financially and that does not bode well. My dcs school went bust. They did not give any warning to either the staff or the parents, it was literally an email to say they were closing. We had to scrabble to find places at other schools, and the teachers were left without a job.

Despite being shy my dcs settled very quickly at their new school, and it worked out well for us. Dcs are more adaptable than adults.