Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extending the school day is a terrible idea

233 replies

footballdisharmony · 08/07/2021 10:15

Apparently Boris thinks that extending the school day is the 'right thing to do' (as reported in the Guardian today) I think this is an awful idea. I'm interested what others think?

I think keeping them at school longer is a mistake and is unlikely to be properly resourced to really make positive impact. Why not just invest in more more teachers/TAs/targeted help. A longer day just eats further into time with friends and family, and time to do other extra curricula activities that children actually really want to do and get a lot from. My primary DC already have homework, spellings, times tables and reading to do after school - surely they need a bit of time to just relax and play!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Howshouldibehave · 10/07/2021 08:48

@Littlepaws18

A longer day is already standard practice in most schools for examination groups. This is by no means a new idea or even workable for these groups as they already do it! Extend them any more and they will need to sleep at school!
Don’t give Gavin Williamson ideas Grin
Littlepaws18 · 10/07/2021 08:42

A longer day is already standard practice in most schools for examination groups. This is by no means a new idea or even workable for these groups as they already do it! Extend them any more and they will need to sleep at school!

Howshouldibehave · 10/07/2021 08:33

@Maggiesfarm

I would have thought 7pm was quite a normal time for dinner during the week when you have children.
We certainly didn’t eat that late when mine were at primary. We eat at 6pm generally-even now they’re teens.

I don’t think anything will come of this plan because it won’t be funded properly. Even the possibility of eg extending the (unpaid for teachers so no ‘cost’) lunch hour from half an hour to an hour, to push back the finishing time from eg 3.30 to 4, won’t help as the support/catering staff will have to be paid for more hours. If this comes with no funding, it won’t happen.

Funding for providers for specialist sports/music/art etc will NEVER happen!

Maggiesfarm · 09/07/2021 23:52

I would have thought 7pm was quite a normal time for dinner during the week when you have children.

onlyhereforthecake · 09/07/2021 20:39

Dinner is at 6.30PM latest.

Oh, I see why the idea of diner at 7pm is so shocking now 😂

MiaMarshmallows · 09/07/2021 19:04

Not in our circles they don't.
Dinner is at 6.30PM latest.
Anyway, as I said, I can't see them keeping the kids in school till 6pm every night so not even worth thinking about it.

claralara42 · 09/07/2021 18:49

It's already too long in the UK. Infants where I am finish school at 1.40pm, they're 7 before they stay until 2.40pm

FartnissEverbeans · 09/07/2021 18:37

Can I just point out to everyone who’s saying that private schools have a longer day - yes they do, but they also have much longer holidays.

I work in a private British school overseas. I’m contractually obliged to work from 7am - 4pm. However, we have three weeks at Christmas and Easter and a much longer summer, as well as half terms and various public holidays.

My 4yo attends my husband’s (similar) school and he is exhausted by the long days. He’s really hard work in the evenings as a result and we have to put him to bed around 6:30pm. His class teacher actually advised keeping his week to 4 days only and said she’d say the same to all parents but the rest of them are paying!

onlyhereforthecake · 09/07/2021 18:13

@MiaMarshmallows

Who wants young kids eating dinner at 7PM or later though? I can see the government maybe tagging half an hour onto the end of the day but not till 5-6PM. It just isn't workable for many people.
plenty of children eat at 7pm or later Confused

I know on MN everyone comes home from work mid-afternoon and has time to cook from scratch and have tea at 4:30- 5pm, but back in the real world, it's not that common. People are still working at that time!

Kids are in childcare, in clubs, with friends. 7pm for diner is more than reasonable. Most kids have an afternoon snack, they are far from starving.

MiaMarshmallows · 09/07/2021 17:09

Who wants young kids eating dinner at 7PM or later though? I can see the government maybe tagging half an hour onto the end of the day but not till 5-6PM. It just isn't workable for many people.

Morgan12 · 09/07/2021 15:57

Oh those pesky capitalist tories up to no good again.

You get what you vote for I suppose.

DadOnIce · 09/07/2021 15:49

Teaching pay is based on the number of class contact hours they have , i.e. 192 teaching days in a year. (It is -- please don't argue the toss about this because it has come up time and again on here and this has been proved to be right.) So are those who are in favour of extending the school day also in favour of extending school budgets (paid from tax) so that all teachers in all schools are paid for the extra contact hours these extended days will involve?

I am actually strongly in favour of paying more tax to fund schools (and the NHS, etc.) better. but not necessarily like this.

PixieAndProsecco · 09/07/2021 15:49

[quote Doodlebug71]**@PixieAndProsecco* children deserve to have the best*. Perhaps so, but they generally don't get it. Teaching has been in crisis for years (as you alluded). People who are outstanding/brilliant at what they do don't usually put up with the pay and condition that come with teaching.[/quote]
I agree.
I can teach them what they need to know in maths, literacy, hwb and their various topics.
I can manage some art, music and sport but to make these opportunities worthwhile they need to being in sports coaches, art and music teachers and they need to pay the price.

honeyytoast · 09/07/2021 13:58

Awful idea. I was still in school not that long ago and I remember very well how fucking tired I was all the time despite passing out at 8pm, the school bus always being late so I never got home before dark in winter, last lesson of the day always being a write off (even teachers recognised this), the panic of realising you might not get enough sleep for whatever reason to get through the next day, etc etc.

The school day isn’t efficient enough to be extended. So much of it is travel, waiting around for the bell, sitting in registration, break, lunch, “lesson starters” and so on.

Doodlebug71 · 09/07/2021 13:58

@MiaMarshmallows

Thinking of some kids I know, they do clubs three times a week and the times they start vary between 5.30PM-5.45PM. They do them outside of school. There's no way their mum would want them to stop those and I also don't think they would start later either. How are dinner times/bedtimes all meant to fit in? I also worry for the out of school providers such as childminders, nannies, after school clubs etc. All would go out of business as no need for them.
Those meal times. It depends on what times you already eat. Lunch here is 12 noon. Dinner is 7-8pm, sometimes later. When we're out later, during summer evenings, for example, we eat later.
Doodlebug71 · 09/07/2021 13:53

@PixieAndProsecco children deserve to have the best. Perhaps so, but they generally don't get it. Teaching has been in crisis for years (as you alluded). People who are outstanding/brilliant at what they do don't usually put up with the pay and condition that come with teaching.

Bryonyshcmyony · 09/07/2021 13:41

How ridiculous
They'd just have to change the timings.

MiaMarshmallows · 09/07/2021 13:39

Thinking of some kids I know, they do clubs three times a week and the times they start vary between 5.30PM-5.45PM. They do them outside of school.
There's no way their mum would want them to stop those and I also don't think they would start later either. How are dinner times/bedtimes all meant to fit in?
I also worry for the out of school providers such as childminders, nannies, after school clubs etc. All would go out of business as no need for them.

chocorabbit · 09/07/2021 12:55

Basically, if a child or their parents want to have 1-1 or small class teaching, or to play at an advanced level clubs will need to bring lots more teachers or better expert subject teachers and clubs would charge £xxx per month for small classed like private ones which is unaffordable for many parents. Also, if you are at an advanced level for a sport you'd rather play and compete with children who are at the same level and certainly chances are that they will be spread over many different schools AND boroughs. Children also make friends from other clubs which they attend.

Bryonyshcmyony · 09/07/2021 12:50

I don't know. Dd finishes at 5 and is on two elite sports pathways and it's fine. They start later to accommodate those who live miles away or who are at private school, just my experience obviously

chocorabbit · 09/07/2021 12:47

@Bryonyshcmyony

My issue - both my kids are elite in sports. That certainly wouldn't happen in a school based sport environment. They finish school at 3/15 and are out 4 evenings a week 5-9pm doing their 'thing'. How are the schools going to cater for those kids?

The clubs would start later.

But they would also need their "elite" specialist coach and equipment or e.g. being taken cross county etc with their own extremely advanced lot.

Whenever our children have attended sports clubs at school (they are NOT "elite" level) they keep doing the same thing every year, or even every term when the club restarts!

The same used to happen when the school would take them swimming. The only children who could swim were the ones whose parents had taken them to paid lessons. The rest would keep on being on shallow water and the same level perpetually. DS2 managed to learn to swim because he is clumsy and did something different from what the instructor told them. But he was never made to advance and every year they would start again with basics and not do anything further than that, it was totally hopeless and he was very demoralised! They had God knows how many children to teach at the same time. DS1 only learnt to swim at his secondary which had a swimming pool but they had to close after Y7 because they couldn't maintain it, guess why? Government cuts! So DS2 never had swimming lessons at secondary. Now they government want teachers to work extra hours too and save even more money!

TheABC · 09/07/2021 12:38

I am not paying much attention to this as it will require a massive amount of funding, even if it's just for enrichment activities, using TA's. I can't see the current Government approving the expenditure unless it involves another dodgy contract for their backers.

chocorabbit · 09/07/2021 12:35

@Blankscreen

There is a huge difference between primary children age 6 or 7 and a 13/14 year old in terms of what they can cope with at school.

DSS went to a state comp and it was dire barely any homework in his GCSE years (the final year of which was cut short by covid). He finished at 2:50. You certainly have to be very self motivated to do anything other than gaming if the school you are at doesn't set you homework

Dh emailed/called the school numerous times about the lack of work they never replied or got back to him.

We tried to set DSS work but it was really hard virtually impossible to motivate him.

He used to come home and go on his sodding X box with all his school friends.

The sport offering was awful

Lots of teenagers need to be made to do something other than gaming./social media. Keep them at school and make them do sport or obligatory homework but they can cope with a later finish than 2:50

I believe they have intervention for subjects in which they are weak during lunch time or even after school. But O-M-G yes, that school did sound dire! I guess you couldn't afford tuition or couldn't choose which subject to pay for?

The reality is that even those pupils that study at private schools end up paying for tuition, even some that attend really good private schools. I have read threads about it. I know parents IRL taking their children out because they couldn't afford the extra for tuition fees. Private schools do offer extra-curricular activities but many of them you have to pay. We knew people who were paying £150 per half term for weekly half hour lessons which might be standard privately but when you already spend so much money you simply can't afford it.

DoingItMyself · 09/07/2021 12:33

Opportunism on the part of government. 'Oh, to help the children we're going to extend the school day,' meaning 'This is our best chance to do what governments have wanted to do for years, extend the school day so that it covers most normal working hours.' And do it in a way that teachers have to accept it...
Saves working parents money, as posted above. Places children where governments need them ready for indoctrination - 'citizenship' was the in thing when I was teaching, years ago. All mind-control.

Bryonyshcmyony · 09/07/2021 12:25

[quote Peaplant20]@Bryonyshcmyony but she said the clubs finish up to 9pm so if they start later they have to finish later. You can’t really have children finishing clubs after 9pm at night! Especially having done an extra long day at school. They do need time to sleep after all.[/quote]
Well if all schools adopt it then the clubs will have to adapt.

Swipe left for the next trending thread