Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wheelchair woes and baby buggies

332 replies

MobilityCat · 08/07/2021 02:30

As a wheelchair user I have had problems with buggy owners refusing to fold buggy and hold the baby. I've been left sitting in the rain because the person won't fold the buggy because "my babies asleep".
I 've seen buggies loaded with groceries and person holding the baby asleep in their arm. Occasionally someone will debus with the buggy to make the space available but it's rare. I know people are normally good and decent so what changes them on the bus?

OP posts:
namechange30455 · 08/07/2021 11:06

@NeedingAGoodNap

Not all buggys actually fold down, so it’s possible they can’t. I also wouldn’t feel comfortable trying to hold a wiggling baby on a bus as some of the drivers around here think they are formula one drivers
I assume you'd get off the bus then?
shas19 · 08/07/2021 11:06

You either get off, or 9 times out of ten there is actually room for a pram and a wheelchair, just meansthe pramgetting off gor a couple of mind while the wheelchair user gets on. Absolute nonsense about stopping prams on board that cant be folded.

MobilityCat · 08/07/2021 11:04

@lottiegarbanzo Thank you for your kind words of sympathy. I didn't mean it to be taken as an attack on buggies, I'm sympathetic to the mums that are tired and want to get home.
I'm also tired, in pain and need a day to recover from a shopping trip and don't want to engage with hostile passengers. I use a small wheelchair on the bus so that I can fit in if there's only one buggy and one buggy can fit in with me. It shouldn't be an issue needing driver intervention.

OP posts:
Grenlei · 08/07/2021 11:04

@Gothichouse40

Nobody understands the issues wheelchair users face. People have a choice to do the right thing. When I was a young mum it was never expected to take a massive pram on a bus. I had a fold down buggy which went either beside me or on the luggage rack. Wheelchair users don't have a choice, they need to use a wheelchair. I think this debate was on Mumsnet before. What people do forget is disability is like chronic illness, it can happen to anyone at any time. I always thought Id be young and fit forever. How wrong I was.
Absolutely this!

When my DC were small, public transport was pretty inaccessible. So as a new mum who didn't drive and was reliant on buses, I made sure I had a sling to carry my baby in when he was small so I could also carry shopping etc, and as he got bigger and a bit too heavy for the sling (by about 6 months) I got a lightweight umbrella fold buggy that I could fold one handed which we would use for shopping trips. Even my full size buggy still folded flat, but as that was a 2 hander, I only used it if I had someone with me to hold DS and the shopping.

When I see parents now on public transport, most seem to have their babies in enormous prams they clearly could never fold down when needed. I've heard comments before about how buses are now 'pram accessible' - no, they're WHEELCHAIR accessible, the fact that also now allows you to bring your tank of a pram on board is by the by.

Having seen the struggles that friends in wheelchairs have just to get from A to B, I am appalled that anyone would ever feel entitled to occupy the wheelchair space on the bus with their pram. If you have too big a pram, and too much shopping to collapse it, then you can walk! Which is not an option for the wheelchair user.

trancepants · 08/07/2021 11:01

When my DS was in a buggy, I always either took him out and folded the buggy or if I had to, left the bus, when a wheelchair user got on. However one time I had a bus try to refuse me entry because there was a wheelchair user on board. I'd been waiting half an hour and he tried claiming that another bus was right behind him which I new was BS because I had seen this bus on the way out and no other bus had gone since. So I'd have been at least another half hour waiting.

I told him, no worries I'd fold the buggy and hold my son. And he still tried to refuse me entry. At the time DS had a broken leg and a full cast, which was the only reason I had him in the buggy that day. I ended up pointing out to him that he was refusing entry to a child in a cast for absolutely no practical reason. He let me on then, and I went in, folded the buggy put it in the luggage compartment and sat in a seat with my son in my arms. I have to admit that when I got off the bus, I told the driver that I hope he'd learned that there was reason to refuse entry to someone with a buggy if they were willing to fold it, and that I hoped he wouldn't make another person feel as awful as I did. And that it shouldn't have taken my son having an injury for him to relent.

happyjules · 08/07/2021 11:00

Speaking as a Bus Driver who does not drive like an F1 driver if I had a pushchair on my bus user who wouldn't fold the handbrake stays on and I won't move until space is made for the wheel chair user. Simple. It's in company policy and legislation. I have several regular wheel chair users and they are priority users of those spaces.

lottiegarbanzo · 08/07/2021 10:57

Part of this problem is people (parents) mistakenly thinking their opinion matters.

Rules are rules. They apply to you.

If you don't like the rules (that give wheelchair users priority and may require you to get off a bus mid-journey, to let them on), then write to the bus company, start a campaign.

Don't take out your frustrations on other, more disadvantaged, bus users.

Akire · 08/07/2021 10:56

Back in the old days if you did have twin babies and no other option but to get on the bus. You get one out take on bus hand to someone then get off pick up baby 2 fold pram with one hand. Yes double buggy could be done. Yes it was heavy and did your back in but could be done. Then drag by wheels on bus and either put in luggage rack or lay on floor by first seats. Then grab baby 1 off passenger and Balance them both. Everyone helped because that was your only option and most women had to have done the same when they had Small children.

Canigooutyet · 08/07/2021 10:52

I wonder if that why the really introduced the plastic barrier. Stopped all us parents handing a baby to the driver.😂😂

Youdiditanyway · 08/07/2021 10:52

I’ve always said this but buses should have separate spaces for wheelchairs and buggies. I used to use buses a lot pre-covid and I would only generally see 1- 2 wheelchairs on there a week whereas there’d be at least 1 other pram on there with mine every day so in a lot of areas, there’s far more prams than wheelchairs hence why the ‘wheelchair’ space is used by prams.

Of course prams can be folded but there’s nowhere to put them on a lot of buses. I’ve noticed the newer buses have removed the luggage storage at the front and replaced it with another seat so where would the pram even go? Also how can someone be expected to hold a wriggly baby (potentially two if they have twins) and fold a pram?

The clear solution is to provide separate spaces for both. They have this in other countries and it works well.

81Byerley · 08/07/2021 10:47

@Marty13

I'm of two minds on this one.

First off, if you're holding a baby how are you supposed to fold the buggy ? You don't have four arms...

Second, I have a double buggy because my children are very close together. It can fold but it's massive, so wouldn't be easily put away. And it's a massive hassle. I didn't choose this one for kicks and giggles, it was the only double model I found that fitted essential requirements.

Finally, shouldn't there be a space on buses for buggies ? Especially as there are more people with babies than people in wheelchairs. It would be great if both needs could be accomodated at the same time.

When I was a young mum, I'd dump the baby on the driver's lap, get off and fold the buggy, then do the same in reverse when I got off. At least I knew the bus wouldn't leave without me!
NakedAttraction · 08/07/2021 10:45

@bluelavender

In most of London wheelchair users don't have a choice between underground or buses; as the underground network remains largely inaccessible
This is definitely true although it is improving.

There’s a really useful access map from tfl that shows which stations are fully accessible/level to the trains, which have just step up to the train (so fine for a pushchair for example).

Of course it doesn’t help when you get to the station to find the lift is out of order.

ihatethefuckingmuffin · 08/07/2021 10:33

[quote jonastrotters]@ihatethefuckingmuffin My son's buggy is a disabled child's buggy but you wouldn't know at a glance really.

No I'm not folding it down. He is entitled to that space as a disabled person in an adaption that isn't a wheelchair but is a mobility device for him [/quote]
And neither should you.
As soon as I read your post I knew what you meant hence I mentioned those moaning about carrying a bit of shopping should try lift an oxygen tank (or words to that effect).

When step free first came into force it was hard for the driver to determine a mobility chair from a buggy, and one of the reasons iirc behind the barrier.

jonastrotters · 08/07/2021 10:30

@Akire I know, I do agree. It's very difficult to police though in reality

Hopefully my child will be able to go out without any supportive aids as an adult, fingers crossed. People really do, often without realising, discriminate against the disabled

Akire · 08/07/2021 10:28

[quote jonastrotters]@Akire I know. But it's worth considering that many people have probably thought it was just a normal buggy, when in fact it's not

This might happen where a disabled person thinks someone is unreasonable for not taking their buggy down, but it might be a disabled buggy [/quote]
Better all pushchairs are asked fold than we don’t ask anyone just case a tiny percent have a disabled child. I agree you shouldn’t have to wave flag and say my child is disabled but 10years down the line when your child is in proper wheelchair they be in same situation that adults are in now.

Viviennemary · 08/07/2021 10:26

If people are going to be awkward then buses should refuse to acommodate unfolded buggies. That is the only way to solve this.

jonastrotters · 08/07/2021 10:25

Whenever I used a bus, wheelchair user had priority over prams. The bus driver would tell them to fold the pram or to get off the bus.

This has happened to me before. I had to get off the bus too. The driver wouldn't take my word on it being a disabled child's buggy

Thankfully I got good response when I complained

Canigooutyet · 08/07/2021 10:25

@Biffbaff

I don't condone buggy users not moving for wheelchair users - that should absolutely be the case. But there is NO need to bash parents here saying 'you chose to have a baby/two close together/use a buggy' etc. It's not on. Both sets of people need to use the bus and there should be room for both. If there isn't, that does present a problem and it's up to the bus company to manage it if the bus users can't or won't.
What's not on about staying the truth? Those are choices. Wheelchairs aren't a choice. As a person in charge of a pushchair you have several options. As a wheelchair user your option is wait for the next bus or go home.
jonastrotters · 08/07/2021 10:24

@Akire I know. But it's worth considering that many people have probably thought it was just a normal buggy, when in fact it's not

This might happen where a disabled person thinks someone is unreasonable for not taking their buggy down, but it might be a disabled buggy

Guavafish · 08/07/2021 10:24

Whenever I used a bus, wheelchair user had priority over prams. The bus driver would tell them to fold the pram or to get off the bus.

Sorry you are experiencing this level of discrimination. You should contact the bus companies involved. Those areas are for wheelchairs users.

Akire · 08/07/2021 10:22

Nobody is taking about buggies that count as wheelchairs that would be very small % of pushchairs. You can even get tags that say treat this as wheelchair even if was the case the rules were enforced. This isn’t an anti disabled children thread.

Hardbackwriter · 08/07/2021 10:22

@Hadenoughofbloodycovid

Mums have got it much easier on public transport nowadays (I’m not saying it’s a bad thing btw) when my two were babies in the 80’s you had to take baby out the buggie, fold buggie, hold baby, shopping and toddlers hand and try to get on the bus, bloody nightmare!
I think the fact you can get on the bus with the pram unfolded is part of the problem and why OP finds this keeps (completely unreasonably) finding this happens, though - it must have been a real pain doing it at the bus stop but surely still easier than doing it on a crowded bus and I guess you were absolutely certain you could do it before you got on the bus? Also presumably when all buggies were folded to get on they went in the luggage rack - they got rid of them on buses around us years ago so a folded up buggy just has to go on the floor/lent up against a seat, which really isn't ideal.
jonastrotters · 08/07/2021 10:21

@ihatethefuckingmuffin My son's buggy is a disabled child's buggy but you wouldn't know at a glance really.

No I'm not folding it down. He is entitled to that space as a disabled person in an adaption that isn't a wheelchair but is a mobility device for him

MeadowHay · 08/07/2021 10:18

We only got a car quite recently so I used to get the bus pretty frequently with DD before that (although not much with covid going on like), she's just turned 3. As I knew that would be the case I deliberately picked a modest sized, lightweight pram with one-handed fold, and then a very light umbrella fold buggy for when she was about 9m+ and could sit up in it ok. I've never had to get off the bus for a wheelchair user and rarely saw them on buses - and I always thought it was so odd that I saw so few of them, I think they must often avoid it because of other idiots not moving for them. The few times we've shared buses because they have had the wheelchair space and I've used the the opposite size where the folding chairs are instead, and a couple of times I've had to fold up the buggy and squeeze it out the way and pop DD on my lap lap. If she had been asleep on those occasions I would have come off the bus. Of course that would be annoying but the space is for a wheelchair user at the end of the day and they face many more challenges than I do. Also one of the reasons I didn't want to babies very close in age and am also learning to drive is to avoid situations like PP have described where people are on buses with multiple tiny kids and loads of shopping etc. At the end of the day that's all a lifestyle choice and disability isn't.

lottiegarbanzo · 08/07/2021 10:18

You are completely right OP.

I am embarrassed, even ashamed to be associated, simply by virtue of being a parent and sometime pushchair user, with those self-absorbed, selfish, ignorant parents who think that their wants, their petty, temporary inconveniences, are more important than your lifelong needs. I cringe for them. I feel deep sympathy for you.

Wheelchair spaces on buses only exist because of decades of really hard, frustrating, tenacious campaign work, by people with disabilities and their (few) allies. Campaigning that was necessary because society at large chose to view disabled people as sub-human, not as real people who had worthwhile lives to live.

If pushchair-using parents feel strongly, about those few years of inconvenience in their otherwise objectively easier lives, they can mobilise themselves, do the work and do a bit of campaigning of their own, for pushchair spaces.

Selfish cuckoos that they are.