Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wheelchair woes and baby buggies

332 replies

MobilityCat · 08/07/2021 02:30

As a wheelchair user I have had problems with buggy owners refusing to fold buggy and hold the baby. I've been left sitting in the rain because the person won't fold the buggy because "my babies asleep".
I 've seen buggies loaded with groceries and person holding the baby asleep in their arm. Occasionally someone will debus with the buggy to make the space available but it's rare. I know people are normally good and decent so what changes them on the bus?

OP posts:
MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 08/07/2021 16:49

It used to be the norm for someone on the bus to come and hold your baby while you got the folded buggy and shopping on the bus. God,I feel ancientHmm

yikesanotherbooboo · 08/07/2021 16:28

I'm quite old so folded the buggy before getting on the bus. My mil had a story of manhandling her toddler , large baby and folded push chair on in which as was the norm she passed baby to a seated woman and had to listen to him screaming until they all got off a few miles up the road .

SleepingStandingUp · 08/07/2021 16:22

@TheSunShinesBrighter

I think a lot of people are assuming the buses run every 15 mins. As I said above, ours are 4 times a day with a two hour wait in between. It’s a shuttle service and it’s destination is a hospital. The full journey back and forth from a rural destination takes 1.5 hrs.

So... who gets the space on the last bus of the day? Does the mother with her buggy get off? What if she’s just been to the hospital with her ill child? How does she get home? One person is going to be left in a really difficult situation.

This is why a lot of people don’t rely on public transport. The situation is not always straight forward.

The problem is the frequency of the timetable and size of the bus.

But it doesn't matter about the Mom, she can just walk home. That's what o was told on another thread - just walk!! It's her own fault for not petitioning for a buggy space on her bus, even if she's never used the service before. The default answer doesn't seem to be bus companies knowing they need more spaces which is patently obvious or any sort of compromise. On MN it just seems to be to exclude ALL parents with pushchairs because SOME parents with pushchairs are selfish
TheSunShinesBrighter · 08/07/2021 16:13

@BlackeyedSusan

instead of arguing abolut the competing accesss of bugggies and wheelchairs, one should be arguing with the regulators, and bus companies for not providing adequate space.
Exactly this. Also a decent, more regular service would be nice.
BlackeyedSusan · 08/07/2021 16:12

instead of arguing abolut the competing accesss of bugggies and wheelchairs, one should be arguing with the regulators, and bus companies for not providing adequate space.

BlackeyedSusan · 08/07/2021 16:10

buggies have paid...if you ask them to get off, give them a free ticket for the next service as the bus tickets are a big chunk of some people's weekly budget... and they have paid to be transported for a set distance.

but that was an explanation of why some people would not want to get off the buis and wait for the next. they may have missed one bus because they could not get on due to another buggy. they may miss thhe next one as there is already a buggy/wheelchair on, thus thye are unlikely to give up their space with no guarantee they will get the next one. some serrvices only run evey half hour, or hour even.

the main thing is there should be more spaces so that more buggies and wheelchairs can get on.

TheSunShinesBrighter · 08/07/2021 16:07

I think a lot of people are assuming the buses run every 15 mins.
As I said above, ours are 4 times a day with a two hour wait in between.
It’s a shuttle service and it’s destination is a hospital. The full journey back and forth from a rural destination takes 1.5 hrs.

So... who gets the space on the last bus of the day? Does the mother with her buggy get off? What if she’s just been to the hospital with her ill child? How does she get home? One person is going to be left in a really difficult situation.

This is why a lot of people don’t rely on public transport. The situation is not always straight forward.

The problem is the frequency of the timetable and size of the bus.

CatsArePeople · 08/07/2021 16:04

There were many debates on this subject, and i remember the latest ruling (at least in our area) was first come first served.

jumpbounce · 08/07/2021 15:56

@NeedingAGoodNap

Not all buggys actually fold down, so it’s possible they can’t. I also wouldn’t feel comfortable trying to hold a wiggling baby on a bus as some of the drivers around here think they are formula one drivers
As a regular bus user with multiple children because I don't drive. I have always had a decent big pram for off roading etc because I walk A LOT but this is not practical for the bus because it doesn't fold compact nor is it an easy fold. So instead of being an entitled bugger I also had a cheap buggy that folds easily one handed and small for bus use as well as a sling so I can pop baby from pram into sling and then have 2 hands free to carry the folded pram on board the bus or put it into the storage area. If you use buses this is what you do, you use equipment practical for it.
roarfeckingroarr · 08/07/2021 15:51

If someone's baby is asleep, can't you get the next bus? Just a kind thing to do, especially when the baby is small and the mother is probably shattered.

MolyHolyGuacamole · 08/07/2021 15:45

@NVision

Poor mum left stood in the cold/rain with babies/kids in tow and bags of shopping vs single adult in mobility chair or scooter waiting for next bus
It will be the matter for me, HTH
NVision · 08/07/2021 15:42

@ShortBacknSides

Poor mum left stood in the cold/rain with babies/kids in tow and bags of shopping vs single adult in mobility chair or scooter waiting for next bus

Totally ableist post. Despicable.

I’m tempted to report it, but perhaps it’s better to let people see how you think @NVision

That “single adult “ in a wheelchair may very well develop a life threatening condition such as pneumonia from being left in the cold or the rain because of ableist views such as this.

My post was cut short, I added to it immediately after. Just stating what can often be the perception to people on the bus or drivers.
TotorosCatBus · 08/07/2021 15:36

I'm really sorry OP. Some parents are massive ducks and should realise that the wheelchair spaces were campaigned for and buggies have backpacked on the great work by those campaigners.
There are grey areas like disabled children in buggies but the space is for wheelchairs and buggy users should campaign for a possible buggy area on top of the wheelchair area - especially in areas where the buses aren't frequent.

I've used buggies on buses back in the day where only unfolded buggies were allowed and when buggies were allowed in the wheelchair space if they were free. Of course it's much easier wheeling the buggy on but it shouldn't be at the cost of wheelchair users.

Akire · 08/07/2021 15:35

Some disabled people travel free so think that’s dig for we have more rights to the space. If you can’t wheelchair yourself up a massive hill then your own bad luck sort thing

MargaretThursday · 08/07/2021 15:33

Buggies have paid to receive a service
How have they paid? I never paid for any of mine until they were 5yo and definitely out of a buggy.

BlackeyedSusan · 08/07/2021 15:12

Buses should be more adaptable and offer more space to accommodate both buggies and wheelchair. Buggies have paid to receive a service, some of the parents may be disabled and not manage folding etc...I can see why they would not want to fold down but overall I think the bus companies/ regulators are at fault for not ensuring that there is adequate space for both or a refund for those who get chucked off with a buggy. Writing as someone disabled with disabled children who would not be able to decant them from a buggy.. or stand at a bus stop without considerable pain or falling over and being unable to walk. (but used our limited budget for a car for this reason.) (In my case it would be three disabled people versus one disabled person as both my children are disabled as well but undiagnosed at that point)

It is really shit that wheelchair users and parents can't guarantee getting on a bus / staying on a bus.

MobilityCat · 08/07/2021 14:52

@ShortBacknSides

Poor mum left stood in the cold/rain with babies/kids in tow and bags of shopping vs single adult in mobility chair or scooter waiting for next bus

Totally ableist post. Despicable.

I’m tempted to report it, but perhaps it’s better to let people see how you think @NVision

That “single adult “ in a wheelchair may very well develop a life threatening condition such as pneumonia from being left in the cold or the rain because of ableist views such as this.

@ShortBacknSides Reporting would be a bit extreme. I offered @NVision sympathy because I've also sat in the wind and rain because the bus was inaccessible. As several folk have pointed out we shouldn't pitted against each other, we're all in this together and a bit of give and take is all that's needed.
OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 08/07/2021 14:50

The stupid covid rules of one pushchair or one wheelchair doesn't help. So people can sit in every row of the bus but a person in a wheelchair on one side and a baby on a buggy on the other side are somehow causing a covid risk. I offered to move the other day and was told they couldn't let a person on in a wheelchair whilst a pushchair was on. Utterly ridiculous. There's two spots. Then the next driver will permit it.

ShortBacknSides · 08/07/2021 14:26

Poor mum left stood in the cold/rain with babies/kids in tow and bags of shopping vs single adult in mobility chair or scooter waiting for next bus

Totally ableist post. Despicable.

I’m tempted to report it, but perhaps it’s better to let people see how you think @NVision

That “single adult “ in a wheelchair may very well develop a life threatening condition such as pneumonia from being left in the cold or the rain because of ableist views such as this.

lakesummer · 08/07/2021 14:19

We cross posted hardbackwriter I agree with you that baby change should be in standard male and female toilets.

On the multiple issue, I needed to use an accessible baby change because I couldn't physically access most female toilets with the dc.

I carefully chose a pushchair the same width as a wheelchair so I could get most places. It meant I could change my babies while out and about.

It isn't acceptable to leave babies in pushchairs by themselves in public places. So you need a space that they can stay with you.
It wasn't about being easier it was about being possible.

I do think that working on making more spaces accessible both to wheelchair users and pushchair users would be a good way forward.
Rather than pit two more vulnerable groups against each other leaving everyone else untroubled

Wheelz46 · 08/07/2021 14:18

Completely agree any able bodied person should absolutely give up the wheelchair seating if they are their with a pushchair and you have every reason to be angry at those who try to refuse.

I didn't mean for the post to sound like the lady with the pushchair was in the right, I just thought it was a tough dilemma for the bus driver especially if the lady in the wheelchair had needed to get to the same school to pick up a child, especially if the next bus made either late.

Maddiemademe · 08/07/2021 14:11

100% agree with you OP (am fellow wheelchair user).

MobilityCat · 08/07/2021 14:01

@Wheelz46

I would never hesitate to fold up a pushchair to make way for a wheelchair user. I always made sure if I got on the bus, I had an easy to collapse pushchair.

I have only ever seen 1 occasion where it was a little awkward.

Pushchair user, said she had arthritis and was not comfortable holding the baby on a moving bus, people did offer to hold the baby for her but can't blame her for politely refusing.

The driver advised the parent they needed to get off and wait for the next bus, she was absolutely devastated, crying that she had to get to her elder child's school to pick them up and if she waited for the next bus she would be late.

Both ladies were really nice and sympathetic to each other with the lady in the wheelchair saying she didn't mind waiting for the next bus but if she hadn't, I would have really felt for the bus driver being put in that predicament.

I will always give way to someone offering a a reason for declining, as I said to another post, his disabled child would get preference. Give and take is part of our lives so why should this be different? It's people who are able to stand or walk and just refuse to make adjustments for others that make things awkward and embarrassing for others.
OP posts:
JesusSufferingFuck22 · 08/07/2021 13:58

@SlothinSpirit
I live in on a semi rural route so the option of making someone get off and wait 30 minutes for the next bus doesn’t sit well with me. Also the whole getting on and off the bus and clipping myself in just seems a bit scary. Fortunately for just now I have my mobility scooter for local trips and my DH drives me if I need to go further.

lap90 · 08/07/2021 13:53

It's unfortunate that in such cases the driver hasn't intervened and asked those with a buggy to fold it or get off the bus and wait for the next one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread