Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wheelchair woes and baby buggies

332 replies

MobilityCat · 08/07/2021 02:30

As a wheelchair user I have had problems with buggy owners refusing to fold buggy and hold the baby. I've been left sitting in the rain because the person won't fold the buggy because "my babies asleep".
I 've seen buggies loaded with groceries and person holding the baby asleep in their arm. Occasionally someone will debus with the buggy to make the space available but it's rare. I know people are normally good and decent so what changes them on the bus?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MobilityCat · 25/09/2021 14:19

@CloMo1995

okay let me clarify. I've NEVER been in that situation, I've never been in the position not to give up that space. my youngest is now 13 months and I hardly catch the bus anymore. I've ALWAYS gave the space up for wheelchair users as when my babies have been newborn I've been lucky enough to get about in a car. I'm just saying in a hypothetical situation. im sorry if it came across as offensive, that wasnt my intent. as I said, the biggest problem around here is trying to get people to move their shopping trolleys out of the wheelchair/pushchair bays. xxx
Your comment wasn't at all offensive so no need to apologise. I did say I sympathised with your situation. Sometimes buggies and shopping trolleys are used as mobility devices but they should be clearly identified as such to avoid misunderstanding.
OP posts:
CloMo1995 · 25/09/2021 09:12

okay let me clarify. I've NEVER been in that situation, I've never been in the position not to give up that space. my youngest is now 13 months and I hardly catch the bus anymore. I've ALWAYS gave the space up for wheelchair users as when my babies have been newborn I've been lucky enough to get about in a car. I'm just saying in a hypothetical situation.
im sorry if it came across as offensive, that wasnt my intent. as I said, the biggest problem around here is trying to get people to move their shopping trolleys out of the wheelchair/pushchair bays. xxx

FateHasRedesignedMost · 25/09/2021 07:51

The wheelchair space is reserved for wheelchairs so buggies/prams either need to move to the space opposite (the fold down seat area that’s unsuitable for wheelchairs) or fold pram or get off.

I normally used to put baby in a carrier/sling before boarding the bus so I could fold pram easily (and carry any bags in the other hand). If the fold down seat space was empty I’d sometimes leave baby in pram but it was a compact pram that could reduce in size (handlebar tucked in etc) so the fold down seat space was still half empty. Occasionally I’d politely ask people to move from the fold down seat area to a normal seat when bus was almost empty so I could fit pram in (normally students or people with dogs) sometimes they made a fuss but most people happily moved. When folded a pram can be still be bulky so if you’ve got bags of groceries, a folded pram plus a large wiggly baby in a carrier/sling it can be tricky to fit into a normal seat without partially blocking the aisle. Still no excuse for taking the wheelchair space though!

When mine got older I used a buggy that folded up into a shoulder bag. Makes going on the bus so much easier!

dancinfeet · 25/09/2021 07:41

@CloMo1995 that’s what pram rain covers are for, and you make sure that you have everything with you to keep baby safe and warm and dry if you have to stand outside in bad weather. Wheelchair spaces are for wheelchair users, it’s fine to make use of them but only when not needed by a person who that space was intended for. And I say this as someone who once got locked one evening on a train at the end of the line (my stop) because I had to fold my pram because a wheelchair user needed the space and by the time I had got myself, toddler, bags and buggy to the train doors they were locked.

Nat6999 · 25/09/2021 01:10

As bus companies replace buses they ought to invest in Bendibuses, we had the old bendibuses in Sheffield & the area at the bend was perfect for pram & wheelchair users, the seat at one side flipped up & the rest of the area was an empty space. It also meant that mothers with small children didn't need to struggle upstairs if the lower deck was full. A bendibus can carry more passengers than a double decker bus can so is better for the environment.

MobilityCat · 25/09/2021 00:49

My buses are tfl (London). I sympathise with your protective feelings toward your child, although I wonder why you have it out in bad weather. That being so you surely dressed it appropriately and had already been in inclement weather before boarding the bus. Being disabled and having breathing difficulty, prolonged exposure in the cold and wet could be fatal.

OP posts:
AudacityBaby · 24/09/2021 23:45

@CloMo1995

what buses are you lot getting on? in nottingham there is enough space on buses for there to me 1 pushchair and 1 wheelchair or 3 pushchairs in the space.

I will always fold my pushchair for a disabled passenger as long as my baby can hold their head up and their body steady while I hold the pushchair down with one hand as well as hold them in my other hand. or I will get off the bus if my baby cant do that and its nice weather, I've done it many times. but I'm sorry if I'm out with a newborn baby and the weather is bad, I cant risk my baby getting sick to give my space on the bus to somebody else, as much as that makes me a arsehole I cant put my childs health at risk. my priority is my babies health.

but tbh, the biggest problem around here is old people refusing to move their shopping trolley things out of the pushchair/wheelchair bays.

I’m glad that the law exists to ensure that those with disabilities ARE prioritised, then, regardless of what your personal priorities are.

I only wish it were enforced more, because this attitude is totally and utterly unacceptable.

CloMo1995 · 24/09/2021 21:28

what buses are you lot getting on? in nottingham there is enough space on buses for there to me 1 pushchair and 1 wheelchair or 3 pushchairs in the space.

I will always fold my pushchair for a disabled passenger as long as my baby can hold their head up and their body steady while I hold the pushchair down with one hand as well as hold them in my other hand. or I will get off the bus if my baby cant do that and its nice weather, I've done it many times. but I'm sorry if I'm out with a newborn baby and the weather is bad, I cant risk my baby getting sick to give my space on the bus to somebody else, as much as that makes me a arsehole I cant put my childs health at risk. my priority is my babies health.

but tbh, the biggest problem around here is old people refusing to move their shopping trolley things out of the pushchair/wheelchair bays.

SlothinSpirit · 14/07/2021 13:21

As many have pointed out, it's not a question of wheelchair users should have priority. Wheelchair users do have priority and anyone who refuses to recognise that is a complete idiot.

Worth bearing in mind though that, at least outside London, regular users of public transport especially buses tend to be from lower-income groups (both wheelchair users and low-income families). Having a low income puts you under increased stress, removes alternatives and makes it more difficult to juggle responsibilities. Hence the desperate mum refusing to get off the bus since she's late to pick up her kids from school after work vs. the wheelchair user trying to get into town to do their shopping. Those with more money can avoid these issues. Well-off parents will load their children and shopping into their comfortable cars and drive most places.

The answer of course is enforced priority for wheelchairs combined with better public transport for everyone.

Akire · 14/07/2021 12:36

@Boonlark

I agree that wheelchair users should take priority. I do just want to say, though, that some people may be using the buggy like a rollator, to assist them with walking. I have EDS and used the buggy this way. But I'd still make way for a wheelchair user.
Using it as a support does not mean they can’t get off the bus at wait. If there are two pushchairs waiting get on and only one can fold then the disabled parent wins over the one who can fold and take spaces until it might be needed for wheelchair.

Millions more prams than wheelchairs. A wheelchair user will face this on nearly every bus. A parent with pram once in blue moon.

Boonlark · 14/07/2021 10:47

I agree that wheelchair users should take priority. I do just want to say, though, that some people may be using the buggy like a rollator, to assist them with walking. I have EDS and used the buggy this way. But I'd still make way for a wheelchair user.

EmeraldShamrock · 14/07/2021 10:41

If the person with the buggy can move it or fold it they should.
Of course there is times they can't, my DS was in a buggy until 5 with sensory overload asd.
I would get off for the wc user not another buggy. I was blissfully unaware of buggy war on buses until I had a baby.
You'd get off for a wc and wait ages on a bus with a free buggy spaces
I'd have people shouting take him out he is huge and I'd have to explain he has autism etc or depending on their approach I'd tell them to MYOB. Blush

x2boys · 14/07/2021 10:37

@Anexschoolbusdriver

My experience as a driver, when wheel chair accessible came in we were told all buggies had to be foldable, no proper prams ( remember prams!) as they couldn't be folded. This was in the written rules. Within a couple of weeks a pram user was refused and was in the local paper with a compo face on. Rules were changed.

Since then law was changed and disabled have priority, but since there is no way a driver can know if someone is disabled, what are they supposed to do? How many threads on here mention invisible disabilities? Isn't it illegal to ask if someone is disabled?

Real prams don't seem to be a thing now, but you do get people who say they can't fold their buggie as it is broken. Or the buggie user might be disabled. People who are so selfish as to not want to move for a wheel chair are not above lying about a disability.

If the driver refused to move the bus and it turned out the buggie used was disabled, what then?

Mind the vast majority of people are decent.

Surely the fact it is a wheel chair space not disabled space is all the driver needs to know? My son is disabled he gets high rate care and mobility Dla due to severe mental impairment, he has a blue badge we have a mobility car, but he doesn't need to go in a wheel chair space on the bus because he's not in a wheelchair.
Sirzy · 14/07/2021 10:32

Because it’s a space for wheelchairs.

Not for prams. Suitcases. Shopping or anything else.

Nobody should need to get off if the person who is using the space collapses the buggy and moves out of it. If they refuse to do that then yes they will need to leave.

Wheelchair users have ONE space on the bus they can use. They need to be in that space so they are safely anchored to travel.

Gooseberrypies · 14/07/2021 10:28

I realise I'm late to the thread and I understand (being disabled myself) that if a pram is taking up a wheelchair space they should move elsewhere on the bus/fold down but I don't understand why people think someone already on the bus should get off for someone who isn't? What if the first person has somewhere important to be on time to as well? For many people getting the bus is their only affordable option otherwise they would obviously do something else Confused

Sirzy · 14/07/2021 10:11

If the buggy user is disabled surely they should be sitting not standing with the buggy on the bus!

Akire · 14/07/2021 09:54

It’s so depressing isn’t it.

A disabled mum who can’t fold pram may be inconvenienced for few short years then the pram will be gone. Wheelchair user…on to the next generation of entitled parents.

Samcro · 14/07/2021 09:50

it always amazes me how long these threads go on for. its a wheelchair space, for people in wheelchairs. so anyone else should move. (of course not children in wheelchair type buggies)
why would anyone not, a sleeping baby... not a wheelchair user.

Akire · 14/07/2021 09:47

If a parent is Disabled they still don’t have the right to the wheelchair space. That would be silly it’s not a hidden disability space if you have a pram. Yes it’s hard if they have to get off the bus rather than fold their pram/hold their baby. But someone has to get off, in law the wheelchair holds trump card. The disabled mum who can’t bend will get on next bus.

A pushchair which works as a wheelchair is of course the same as a wheelchair. Don’t know how many parents would argue their non disabled child can’t possible be taken out and folded there are always some.

It’s really not complicated. When the rules are clear and still society as whole feels they can’t respect them and do their best to get around it really erodes practically the only thing wheelchair have that is just for them. And we not allowed have it in many peoples eyes.

dreamingofyou · 14/07/2021 09:46

saying that my ds5 has a disabled buggy which i dont fold as he has a right to be in the space. i often get abuse from wheelchair users cos of it.

dreamingofyou · 14/07/2021 09:43

4 kids and i use buses regularly. I always get off the bus unfortunately the same cant be said about other users. i remember when i just had dd and a wheelchair user was at the stop. The bus driver told him he needs to ask me nicely to move!!!

Anexschoolbusdriver · 14/07/2021 09:32

My experience as a driver, when wheel chair accessible came in we were told all buggies had to be foldable, no proper prams ( remember prams!) as they couldn't be folded. This was in the written rules. Within a couple of weeks a pram user was refused and was in the local paper with a compo face on. Rules were changed.

Since then law was changed and disabled have priority, but since there is no way a driver can know if someone is disabled, what are they supposed to do? How many threads on here mention invisible disabilities? Isn't it illegal to ask if someone is disabled?

Real prams don't seem to be a thing now, but you do get people who say they can't fold their buggie as it is broken. Or the buggie user might be disabled. People who are so selfish as to not want to move for a wheel chair are not above lying about a disability.

If the driver refused to move the bus and it turned out the buggie used was disabled, what then?

Mind the vast majority of people are decent.

DdraigGoch · 12/07/2021 09:04

@Rosebel

I used to have a double buggy. I couldn't hold two children and fold the pushchair. Then again I think I only used it on the bus twice and there were no wheelchair users on the bus or waiting. Ultimately though they are for wheelchair users and people with pushchairs should give the space up. Another reason why it would be good to have conducters back on buses as they could tell parents to fold the buggy. Drivers are reluctant to do this as there is no back up support for them.
Just wait, the government are trying to take conductors off of trains. Anyone who needs assistance (disabled, elderly, or just plain vulnerable) won't stand a chance.
Billandben444 · 12/07/2021 08:46

That's a good idea and then they'd have to think carefully about which buggy to buy for the bus.

Guavafish · 12/07/2021 07:58

Maybe ppl with buggies should be told to fold them before coming on to bus. Then it change the culture and make it easier for wheelchair users.