Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cabin Crew interview process ended based on weight - discrimination?

361 replies

CityCommuter · 07/07/2021 22:35

I feel sorry for a friend who has always wanted to be a flight attendant / part of cabin crew for as long as I can remember. She applied and got as far as the first interview phase having already submitted a detailed application form. The form states that 'weight must be in proportion to height'.

She believes that the interview panel judged her when she walked into the room by the way they looked at her (UK size 18, height 5'5"). Obviously weight wasn't mentioned but she didn't get approval for the next interview phase. She thinks it's discrimination on their part and that it shouldn't matter even if she was a size 24! She doesn't even look like a size 18 btw but more like a 14. I'd like to advise her to lose a few pounds but can't as she has always been very sensitive to any weight related conversation even if talking about someone else! What advise would you give her?

OP posts:
HarebrightCedarmoon · 08/07/2021 10:16

All of that sexism is true, but the OP asked only about the weight requirement. Which isn't unfair discrimination.

Neondisco · 08/07/2021 10:15

Why is everyone assuming she need or want to lose weight? Has no on here heard of people being fine with being fat? Feels like you've all been drawn in by diet culture.

33feethighandrising · 08/07/2021 10:14

@PearlNextDoor

Blimey, on your 28th birthday are you no longer given any flights i wonder
Or if you get married or pregnant? It used to be in the UK, that your career as a flight attendant ended if you had a baby.
RampantIvy · 08/07/2021 10:14

@33feethighandrising it's quite possible that the physical requirements for female cabin crew are misogynistic and for practical and safety reasons. Space in aircraft is very limited and I often see overweight people shuffling sideways down the aisle. Can you really see a flight attendant shuffling sideways to push a trolley?

33feethighandrising · 08/07/2021 10:13

@Mibbiesaye

"If they were so blimming concerned about safety, why are female flight attendants put in pencil skirts and heels? If safety was the genuine concern, flight attendants in flats and clothes they can easily move in would be prioritised over appearance"

Heels aren't worn on the flight. CC change into flats for the flight for comfort and safety reasons. Also many airlines now offer trousers as part of the uniform.

From the article I linked.

Beneath an image of gloss and glamour, cabin crew deal with physical health problems that come with the job from varicose veins to sleep deprivation, which some flight attendants say are exacerbated by their uniform requirements.

For former British Airways attendant, Mel Collins, bunions on her feet and severe backache during her time in the air were par for the course. On a typical long-haul flight lasting 10 hours, she would cover some seven miles in mid-height heels – which were part of her uniform – according to her own pedometer reading. She suffered swollen feet and painful blisters.

Aircrew are often expected to maintain full make-up and an immaculate hairstyle throughout their entire shift even during a night flight service

It wasn’t until she was promoted to a more senior role leading a team of about 11 crew members that she felt able to be more assertive and ask to be allowed to wear alternative footwear. “They agreed to let me wear a flat shoe which made a huge difference to my physical comfort,” she says.

PearlNextDoor · 08/07/2021 10:12

Blimey, on your 28th birthday are you no longer given any flights i wonder

Mibbiesaye · 08/07/2021 10:10

"If they were so blimming concerned about safety, why are female flight attendants put in pencil skirts and heels? If safety was the genuine concern, flight attendants in flats and clothes they can easily move in would be prioritised over appearance"

Heels aren't worn on the flight. CC change into flats for the flight for comfort and safety reasons. Also many airlines now offer trousers as part of the uniform.

Iwonder08 · 08/07/2021 10:06

Have you been on a plane? Anyone over size 12 just won't fit into all the small spaces without bumping into passengers/other crew.

MarianneUnfaithful · 08/07/2021 10:06

Whatever the potentially legitimate issues about weight and health (DVT) and physical attribute (need to be able to operate safety procedures etc) of course there is ALSO hideous sexist discrimination going on around brand image etc.

To address any legitimate concerns they should publish precise criteria that correlate with the hoc requirements. Specific height, or BMI or whatever. Like the police, for example.

Encouraging people to apply on a wholly subjective aesthetic like ‘in proportion’ is disingenuous and not in the spirit of Equal Opps.

There are airlines that don’t require women to parade for the benefit of passenger titillation.

MarianneUnfaithful · 08/07/2021 10:00

LobotomisedIceSkatingFan
“How have you been able to work out her BMI
when you don't know what she weighs?”

Good question - the answer being I mixed up the OP’s friend being a size 18 with a Pp shortly after who said she was 18 stone. So I was wrong.

33feethighandrising · 08/07/2021 10:00

This is how men manage to carry on exploiting and objectifying us.

I'm not sure if it's naivety or just that there's a load of the usual MN posters who like to have a go, all chiming in, but all this "you have to be a certain weight for safety" stuff is nonsense. It's an excuse that allows misogynist men to continue to recruit pretty female flight attendants to sell us as sex objects for the male gaze.

The history of female flight attendants is that airlines used them as sex objects to sell the flight, designing skimpy outfits, employing slim and attractive young women and marketing them as if they were sexually available to male passengers.

Here's an article about this. librarypartnerspress.pressbooks.pub/gendersexuality3e/chapter/sexism-takes-flight/

Sure, that was a long time ago, but this is in the roots of the profession and these kinds of sexist attitudes persist with many management - often older men, and also passengers.

In countries where they are allowed to get away with it, airlines do still advertise for beauty standards.

Here's an Air India ad from just a couple of years ago:

Maximum age limit as on 01.07.2019 shall be 27 years
Marital Status: Unmarried
Height / BMI: Minimum required for female:157.5 cms (5’2”) /BMI – 18 – 22
Cosmetic Appearance: Should be well groomed with Clear complexion without any noticeable blemish, no odd scars /birthmarks. Even and regular teeth.

feminisminindia.com/2019/07/22/sexism-female-flight-attendants-await-feminist-revolution/

The only reason airlines don't advertise so blatantly for sexist beauty standards in the UK is they're not allowed to by law - so using weight as a safety issue is their way of getting round it. Don't fall for it!

If they were so blimming concerned about safety, why are female flight attendants put in pencil skirts and heels? If safety was the genuine concern, flight attendants in flats and clothes they can easily move in would be prioritised over appearance.

This issue is covered in this article: www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20180219-what-dress-codes-really-mean-for-cabin-crew

Several of the women BBC Capital spoke with who had worked for a number of airlines and described sexism on a daily basis which they felt could be attributed to the enforced dress code and image: everything from barbed comments about their intelligence to sometimes feeling physically threatened by passengers.

Stop being so bloody naïve, people! The OP has it right, the airlines are sexist and her friend isn't paranoid to feel she's being objectified.

Cabin Crew interview process ended based on weight - discrimination?
Cabin Crew interview process ended based on weight - discrimination?
Emmelina · 08/07/2021 09:56

A size 18 isn’t going to be able to squeeze past trollies that take up most of the aisle, nor will she be able to go down seat rows in an emergency. She’s at much higher risk for DVT at that weight and altitude - they don’t want to deal with a medical emergency on their own staff if they can foresee it!
I’m sure a little extra padding is fine, but size 18 at 5’5 is more than a little extra I’m afraid. It’s not discriminatory, it’s health and safety in that environment. Sorry.

Wroxie · 08/07/2021 09:52

A size 24 person might have an issue squeezing into the galley but not a size 18 - which is a size 14-16 in the US and also the average size for a woman in the US.

I'm smaller now but when I was a size 16-18 I was still smaller than my 6'1" and slim but fairly muscular partner everywhere but the hips - and then only by couple of inches. I could still squeeze into his jeans (I have a habit of doing that when I pull a pair out of the clean laundry basket and it's only when I realise the legs are flopping six inches below my feet that I realise they aren't mine).

Anyway, a 6 foot tall man wouldn't be turned down based on his size and a woman who wears a size 18 absolutely isn't too large to safely do this job. The only way this ISN'T weight discrimination is if the airline has a specific measurement related to the galley sizes on the smallest airplanes they fly, and that they then apply that measurement to all people who apply, whether they or male or female and whether they are a size 18 or a size 8 with massive tits or a brazilian butt lift.

igelkott2021 · 08/07/2021 09:39

Airlines have said that weight has to be in proportion to height for cabin crew for as long as I remember.

It's not an unreasonable stipulation for the reasons people have said.

And unlike height, weight is something you can do something about. Your friend will always be 5 foot 5, but she can reduce her weight.

scrambledcustard · 08/07/2021 09:38

My dd works for Emirates and currently lives in Dubai. Even though there are genuine reasons why the stewards needs to be slim a lot of it is down to looks and presentation.

She had to send in picture with her application then meet ups at a hotel for the first round on interviews. Out of 200 people it was whittled down to 10, out of that 10 only 4 were picked, my dd included.

When they got to Dubai, they had to undertake make up training on how their make up was expected to look, were told they were not allowed to have roots or bad nails and absolutely no visible tattoos. They were warned off eating the flight snacks and they have a yearly weigh in, if they put too much on they are put on weight management. I had a big issue with this, its misogynistic.

However she is 25, slim and is having an adventure. She was part of terrorism training which she received an award for (for being tied up)She lives rent free in an apartment with a pool paid for by Emirates, gets driven to the airports by drivers, stayed in fantastic hotels around the world, gets given pocket money when she has a lay over. Was in The Maldives for two days this week and Russia a few days before that.

She had zero experience with travel, she was P.A before.

Would I want my other DDS to do this ? No

HarebrightCedarmoon · 08/07/2021 09:38

I think it's actually fair enough to state that weight should be in proportion to height for cabin crew. If they said normal BMI they might be discriminating against people who are just over that and muscular but whose weight still appears in proportion to their height.

Basically they want people who can fit down the aisle ok, there is not an awful lot of room on aeroplanes. Probably the fairest way would be to measure everyone rather than base it on visual appearance.

Mrstamborineman · 08/07/2021 09:36

If it’s her dream she’d lose weight.
It was my dream to be a teacher, I worked hard and got there.
Yabu. Have you ever had your luggage weighed?
Been in a lift?
Every kilo counts.

LondonJax · 08/07/2021 09:35

Oops forgot the link to the weight to height chart www.healthyyounaturally.com/nutrition/age-height-weight-chart.htm

LondonJax · 08/07/2021 09:34

I'm 5' 2" and a size 16 and I'm in the overweight section of the BMI.

On the on-line 'weight to height' scale pages I could get away with being 10st 3lb (which still makes me a little overweight on BMI). According to those pages someone of 5' 5" should be no more than 155lb at the top end of 'weight in proportion to height'. According to BMI the top of the healthy range for someone of your friend's height is 149.6lbs. So the weight to height charts allows her to carry an extra 5lb.

So unless she's 155lb or less (11stone 1lb) then her weight isn't in proportion which she should know as it's part of the job requirement.

RampantIvy · 08/07/2021 09:33

Re the wearing of heels - whenever I have flown the flight attendants have worn heels in the airport and when greeting and saying goodby to passengers, but have worn flat pumps while working during the flight. I don't recall seeing any flight attendant wearing heels during a flight.

PotassiumChloride · 08/07/2021 09:29

The weight / height issue I assume is down to the ability to move round the cabin easily. They’re pretty tight spaces. I also expect it’s helpful to be relatively light and have an element of physical fitness during emergency situations.

EleanorOlephantisjustfine · 08/07/2021 09:25

Your friend is being extremely naive. Of course you need to be slim and fit to be cabin crew. You have to be able to squeeze into small spaces. A size 18 at that height is very chunky. You also need to be agile and be able to move quickly in case of emergencies. As for being a size 24 is fine, you are being ridiculous.

For anyone thinking it’s unfair and what are the chances of a emergency, I thought it was unlikely to happen until our holiday jet crash landed coming back from Spain. It was extremely frightened and traumatic. The staff had to move quickly and decisively to get us out via the emergency shoots. There’s no way you could do that if you were overweight.

If your friend wants the job, she should have already researched any physical requirements and taken the necessary action. It’s pointless bleating about it. There’s nothing discriminatory about these rules. It’s just common sense.

My advice to her would be to jump out of victim mode and get herself on a diet and down to the gym, then she hopefully will be able to fulfil her dreams. There’s only herself holding her back.

Paramaribo · 08/07/2021 09:20

I have every confidence that she knows that if she really wants to pursue that career then she needs to lose weight. She may be in denial but she knows.

She has clearly set out the boundary that she doesn't want to discuss weight issues with you, whether relating to her or not. My advice is to respect that boundary, just be her friend and allow her to reach her own conclusions in her own time. It may require some patience on your part but I wouldn't offer any advice nor add any fuel to the fire of this being discrimination and unfair.

Livelovebehappy · 08/07/2021 09:15

Size 18 at 5ft 5 is pretty large. You have to be agile and able to spend long periods on your feet. Implications for being overweight and on your feet could result in swollen ankles and DVT. At least if she really wants the job,she can lose weight. I was turned down for the police years ago for being too short. And there wasn’t a lot I could do about that.

RightYesButNo · 08/07/2021 09:15

She's being treated less well - she's not being offered the job - because she's fat. (If we believe the post.)

With the caveat if this is true at all… ARE we treating someone less well if we deny them a job that’s dangerous to them? I saw many people mention she won’t be able to walk quickly and often and fit in narrow spaces, but to me, it’s more important that obesity is the top risk factor for flight-related deep-vein thrombosis. There are obese passengers who develop it after a single flight. And moving about doesn’t necessarily mean you will never have one, as studies have now shown that cabin crew get DVTs as well as passengers, and that’s cabin crew without any other risk factors, like obesity. Some have even had pulmonary embolisms from it.

It could even be that the airline’s insurance company won’t cover flight personnel with any reason for increased risk of DVTs (I wonder if they’d be able to hire someone with previous blood clots or a blood clotting disorder?) as insurance companies can be ruthless; that’s why they’re so damn profitable. And I don’t think telling someone they aren’t right for a job because they are at the highest risk of a possible job-related condition that could cost them their leg or their life is treating them unwell. Pretending that wasn’t the case seems like it would be almost negligent.