Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cabin Crew interview process ended based on weight - discrimination?

361 replies

CityCommuter · 07/07/2021 22:35

I feel sorry for a friend who has always wanted to be a flight attendant / part of cabin crew for as long as I can remember. She applied and got as far as the first interview phase having already submitted a detailed application form. The form states that 'weight must be in proportion to height'.

She believes that the interview panel judged her when she walked into the room by the way they looked at her (UK size 18, height 5'5"). Obviously weight wasn't mentioned but she didn't get approval for the next interview phase. She thinks it's discrimination on their part and that it shouldn't matter even if she was a size 24! She doesn't even look like a size 18 btw but more like a 14. I'd like to advise her to lose a few pounds but can't as she has always been very sensitive to any weight related conversation even if talking about someone else! What advise would you give her?

OP posts:
TillyTottenham · 08/07/2021 10:55

I have seen overweight flight attendants on previous flights. Perhaps they got into the job when they were smaller.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/07/2021 10:53

@Wroxie , it’s not just a question of one size 18 person squeezing into the confined space of a galley - there will very often be more than one who needs to be there, and moving quickly.

(Speaking as someone who was once cc).

me4real · 08/07/2021 10:52

^weight must be in proportion to height'.

@CityCommuter So for the job they have to be within a healthy BMI range, and she isn't.

As a PP mentioned I'm sure they would claim some safety reason for it.

LindaEllen · 08/07/2021 10:50

@Peppallama

It's not discrimination because weight isn't a protected characteristic under the equality act.

It's called aesthetic labour, where organisations people to represent the brand. Just like hooters girls basically. It sucks that the job is seen more to be about image and lifestyle of passengers than safety but it's part of the brand and won't stop unless people stop flying with those airlines.

Is it bollocks aesthetic labour. The days of airline assistant being a glamorous job are long gone.

It's about safety. And there has to be an aspect of how much it costs in fuel to transport staff from a to b when they're a few stone heavier, too. You have to think about the job and the working environment and use your common sense to think perhaps why being overweight wouldn't be good.

Nicolastuffedone · 08/07/2021 10:46

Her weight very clearly isn’t in proportion to her height is it? Did she think they wouldn’t notice?

Bunglemom · 08/07/2021 10:43

As former cabin crew we were told that we had to keep below a certain weight as it was a safety hazard if we didnt! Dont forget that during training you have to crawl through a smoke filled cabin and i would imagine a bigger lady or gent would struggle with that.. its not discrimination its for the safety of the aircraft.

roguetomato · 08/07/2021 10:43

It's one of those job that requires physical fitness. You are working in the environment high up in the sky with pressured air, hard work for even fit person. Also they need to act fast in case of emergency. And another big role is a first aider. There were many cases I had to run through narrow aisle to get to the passengers when I was one.

Lurcherloves · 08/07/2021 10:42

I’m just amazed that there are cabin crew jobs going. I expect there are many people with experience going for those jobs

cushioncovers · 08/07/2021 10:41

Certain jobs require certain things, it's not discrimination to say that, not anyone can do any job. Your friend was too big to do the role of a cabin crew member efficiently, doesn't matter how much she wanted to do it or how good with the passengers she would have been she was too big built to be in the restricted space that aircraft's have. If every cabin crew member was a plus size it wouldn't be practical and I say this as a very weight person.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/07/2021 10:40

Singapore Airlines - the best of the best setting the standards for lesser airlines to aspire to. My favourite go to airline!

The Rise Of Singapore Airlines | How An Airline From a Small Island Dominated The Skies

helpfulperson · 08/07/2021 10:38

It would be interesting to see what the height/weight requirements are for men. Many male stewards can't squeeze past the trolley and are tall and broad, certainly weighing more than a size 18 woman.

languagelover96 · 08/07/2021 10:35

This is not discrimination. There are reasons why cabin attendants need to be a certain way. I'm a size 6 but if I was a plus size there would be literally no chance of me being able to stuff suitcases into those overhead lockers on board the planes. It all comes down to safety in the end really.

Weight is not a protected factor contrary to popular belief. I'm sorry for your friend but it seems like she did not know much about the industry rules and policies. Say there was a crisis on board, she would need to be a certain size in order to react in time.

sashh · 08/07/2021 10:34

Everyone knows that there are hardly any size ranges for the uniform. Indeed the Singapore airlines uniform comes in one size - tiny.

And only 2 hairstyles.

I watched a doc about their recruitment and they were very blunt if the hair up style didn't look, "Singapore girl" then a short bob it had to be.

TAM send their recruits in to the jungle on survival courses.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/07/2021 10:33

"The form states that 'weight must be in proportion to height"
Did she not think to investigate that statement further before spending time filling out an application form and attending an interview

Considering her remark that it wouldn't matter even if she was a size 24, I suspect not

And in light of OP's comment about her being extremely sensitive to any mention of weight, asking for feedback's probably unlikely. No matter how diplomatic the recruiters are - and they'll have had a lot of practise - it sounds as if any comment will be unwelcome

33feethighandrising · 08/07/2021 10:32

But the weight requirement isn't sexist. I'm yet to see an obese man working as cabin crew. Make up, heels, pencil skirts - yes, you can call those sexist. Weight requirements aren't.

You are entirely missing the point.

In countries where they can get away with it, airlines recruitment includes blatant sexist beauty standards.

In countries where they can't, they use weight to get round this. They are not only looking at weight for safety, they are ALSO using it as an excuse to employ attractive cabin crew, precisely because people like you and others on this thread say "oh it's about safety" and, for some reason, I don't know why, are so desperate not to see how sexist this industry is.

RampantIvy · 08/07/2021 10:27

Why not do even minimal research before commenting?

Why so rude?

Interestingly, ex cabin crew who have posted on here have all pointed out the practical and safety issues. Although, I agree that attractiveness shouldn't come into it.

I remember on a Cathay Pacific flight many years ago all the female cabin crew wore the same coloured lipstick, and it was perfectly applied and never smudged during the 13.5 hour flight.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 08/07/2021 10:25

@EileenGC

It's depressing to see so many people here making excuses and covering for these sexist practices, or refusing to believe this happens.

But the weight requirement isn't sexist. I'm yet to see an obese man working as cabin crew. Make up, heels, pencil skirts - yes, you can call those sexist. Weight requirements aren't.

Exactly! I would fully support the unifor changes, but as you, I've neevr seen obese male crew
EileenGC · 08/07/2021 10:22

It's depressing to see so many people here making excuses and covering for these sexist practices, or refusing to believe this happens.

But the weight requirement isn't sexist. I'm yet to see an obese man working as cabin crew. Make up, heels, pencil skirts - yes, you can call those sexist. Weight requirements aren't.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/07/2021 10:22

@ 33feethighandrising

You are assuming attractiveness is automatically only sexist and objectification. Many/most of us are not unattractive nor unfit. We like to take pride in our appearance and yes look hot too. But what is wrong with that and looking great a party with “normal” pretty and “less attractive on the outside” people. It that not acceptable because others have different beauty and fitness standards? It has nothing to do with sexism but just liking things with a certain aesthetic or design. We subconsciously have bias towards certain attractiveness. There is default by design trillion pound business in everything to do with appearance and design for everything. In terms of choice of airlines on the same route - safety record, comfort and level of service is my main concern along with value for money. It’s nice to have fit smiling staff too capable of fulfilling their role particularly in a rare emergency where fitness and agility is key.

DocDog · 08/07/2021 10:20

@Streamside

Did she not research this beforehand.Do we see size 24 jockeys?

That's another good point - jockeys. They're tiny and light for a reason.

Same for prison officers. If you were 5ft 1 and 8 stone soaking wet you would not be suitable to be a prison officer.

There are many jobs that require you to be a certain size for very valid reasons.

Dinosaurballoon · 08/07/2021 10:19

She might not want to but point is she won’t get through the cabin crew assessment stage if she doesn’t that’s the only point of the thread?

EileenGC · 08/07/2021 10:18

the airlines are sexist and her friend isn't paranoid to feel she's being objectified.

That's not a wrong statement.
What most people are trying to explain though, it's that even if you overlook the blatant sexism that still exists in the industry, this is a matter of health and safety.

I take 50-60 flights each year. I've seen many a situation where yes, an overweight or obese flight attendant would struggle to assist passengers adequately.

Someone suffering a stroke or going unconscious in the middle seat of a very cramped plane, cabin crew might need to lift this person off their seat to perform CPR. Same for those injured after some serious turbulence. There might be broken legs, luggage flying all around the cabin, etc.
Sick passengers, where crew might need to squeeze inside a row of seats to assist with clean up or simply give a hand.
Have you seen those tiny seats cabin crew strap themselves in during take off and landing? You don't fit in those as a size 18. You also don't fly the same plane every day, so you can't expect they will modify them for you.

There are 747s and 380s where you have to walk up some tiny stairs in the middle of some mild turbulence with a tray in your hands, like a PP explained. There are teeny tiny planes, like those BA Cityflyers that cover London-Amsterdam 5 times a day, where everyone and everything is squeezed into a tiny space with barely a few cm margin. Cabin crew are still expected to maneuver around graciously, and serve food, drink, help in emergencies.

Most cabin crew start by working on short routes, tiny planes, small crew, until they progress up to larger aircrafts and longer routes. They need to fit in all types of planes, be able to evacuate passengers through the tiniest of doors/windows, so it's no surprise there is a weight/height proportion requirement for these jobs.

It's not discrimination or sexism, it's common sense.

33feethighandrising · 08/07/2021 10:18

[quote RampantIvy]**@33feethighandrising* it's quite possible that the physical requirements for female cabin crew are misogynistic and* for practical and safety reasons. Space in aircraft is very limited and I often see overweight people shuffling sideways down the aisle. Can you really see a flight attendant shuffling sideways to push a trolley?[/quote]
Yes, of course being massively overweight would be a problem for safety.

But, the airlines are using weight as an excuse to recruit slim and attractive cabin crew, beyond safety requirements.

It's depressing to see so many people here making excuses and covering for these sexist practices, or refusing to believe this happens.

Why not do even minimal research before commenting?

Maybe put "airline sexist interviews body type" into Google as I just did to get the articles above, to find that there has been loads written on this. The OP is far from alone in noticing this is an issue.

Pinotpleasure · 08/07/2021 10:17

I haven’t read all of the previous 10 pages....but I used to live in Singapore and one of my friends worked as cabin crew for Singapore Airlines.

The maximum weight for female cabin crew is 47kg/7 stone 5 pounds.

My friend was of Indian Singaporean ethnicity and said that it was very difficult for the non-Chinese Singaporeans to get jobs with the airline. She was very thin but she said that generally the Indian and Malay women tended to have more body fat than the Chinese. I don’t know if this was true or not.

However, the ‘Singapore Girl’ is a huge selling point for the airline and they are extremely strict on grooming and appearance (even their hairstyles whilst working, nail polish, lipstick colour etc). The airline would never countenance a ‘fuller figure’ for male or female cabin crew.

Mibbiesaye · 08/07/2021 10:17

@33feethighandrising When I was CC, heels were only worn to and from the flight. Flats were mandatory during the flight.