Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cabin Crew interview process ended based on weight - discrimination?

361 replies

CityCommuter · 07/07/2021 22:35

I feel sorry for a friend who has always wanted to be a flight attendant / part of cabin crew for as long as I can remember. She applied and got as far as the first interview phase having already submitted a detailed application form. The form states that 'weight must be in proportion to height'.

She believes that the interview panel judged her when she walked into the room by the way they looked at her (UK size 18, height 5'5"). Obviously weight wasn't mentioned but she didn't get approval for the next interview phase. She thinks it's discrimination on their part and that it shouldn't matter even if she was a size 24! She doesn't even look like a size 18 btw but more like a 14. I'd like to advise her to lose a few pounds but can't as she has always been very sensitive to any weight related conversation even if talking about someone else! What advise would you give her?

OP posts:
Cavalierqueen · 08/07/2021 15:09

Try Saudi Airlines. Big Arabic men who will wrestle your ridiculous seat to retrieve your phone.

TheFoundations · 08/07/2021 15:06

@WorriedWishingWell

Yes she is being discriminated against on basis of her weight but that is lawful, providing men are treated in the same way.
They likely are. I've never seen a big muscular air steward. They always look like jockeys. Slight.
Blondeshavemorefun · 08/07/2021 14:38

Airline staff need to be slim to fit down ailse and squeeze behind the trolley

If she truly wants the job she needs to diet and lose a few stone /slim to a 10/12

WorriedWishingWell · 08/07/2021 14:19

Yes she is being discriminated against on basis of her weight but that is lawful, providing men are treated in the same way.

Cavalierqueen · 08/07/2021 14:15

Join me (not CC but do annual training) on air crash in water simulation. To be plunged by a crane at high speed into a deep pool strapped into a jumpseatnand have 8 seconds to escape. They are not dollies, they are highly trained. The CC on my annual licence exam are always the most proficient. It's absolutely terrifying every time. In a copter my only job is to escape. They have to then account for people and life save.

Cavalierqueen · 08/07/2021 14:10

Before I lost weight, I landed in Bahrain and was the only person in the Cain and the crew asked if they could bring someone to counterbalance my weight... They brought 3 men Grin

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/07/2021 14:02

Yes cabin crew legitimately have certain fitness and size requirements to fulfil their role. Therefore some may be too big others too small too. Fitness for purpose in it’s literal sense. Super size cruise ships should be able to accommodate other sizes much more favourably than civil aviation where bums on seats is key is maximise occupancy per flight. There is little other room for manoeuvre on the other people (cabin attendants) airlines can select themselves for over crowded aeroplanes.

Rhinothunder · 08/07/2021 13:55

Sorry OP but the plain truth is that she is obese and as an obese person she is too large to safely do the job.

At least it is something she can change, if she wants to.

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/07/2021 13:47

@PrincessNutella

Planes are conscious of every pound of weight they have on board anyway--it costs them.
Which is why there is the system of excess baggage. This you don’t get on an all inclusive cruise ship where one can be a glutton and gain personal excess baggage.

I head some airlines have difficulty accommodating some passengers and so have suggested booking double seats if physically more suited. Again this is not discrimination if one can not fit into standard seating if you are too big needing more room. Usually you find on busy flights the taller passengers opting for bulkhead extra legroom seats. This is a reasonable accommodation adjustment other than booking your own private jet at astronomical prohibitive expense.

Teddy1970 · 08/07/2021 13:45

@AmIPeriOrAreYouJustAnnoying

Being cabin staff is more skin to being a waitress/waiter. It's not comparable to being in the army or being a firefighter FFS!
What an insulting comment, cabin crew have to go through 6-8 week training on everything that could possibly happen on an aircraft, plane crashes, ditching in the sea, hijacking, pilot incapacitation, death onboard, fires in the cabin, we HAVE to know our evacuation drills off by heart because you can't access the manual when you're crashing, does a waitress know the difference between therapeutic, reserve and PSU oxygen available in certain types of aircraft? Thought not, we can be tri fleeted, so that means you can be trained in 3 different types of aircraft and the differences between Airbus and Boeing is staggering and after all that we have to sit yearly exams to keep our license current, if we fail those exams you get grounded and it can land you in trouble with the Airline, so you can fuck right off with your waitress in the sky bollocks.
notimagain · 08/07/2021 13:45

@AmIPeriOrAreYouJustAnnoying

Being cabin staff is more skin to being a waitress/waiter. It's not comparable to being in the army or being a firefighter FFS!
Umm..You’re going to get some feedback on that…..

When I was flying it was considered that one of the most serious emergencies you could have in flight was a fire in the passenger compartment……it should be pretty obvious why won’t frighten you with the stats that have been gleaned over the years following some accidents..

As a result it’s pretty much a universal requirement that cabin crew are required to have some skills/proficiency in fire fighting. It’s not up to the standards you’d expect from fire/rescue stuff full timers but it’s a proficiency that’s trained and examined at least every couple of years.

BadLad · 08/07/2021 13:43

@Cavalierqueen

Saudi Airlines first class is the best. They put a mattress on the bed and literally tick you in like your mum would. Blissfully relaxing. I am so glad they are over the blockade and I can go back to them.
Their selection of wines and spirits tends to be disappointing.
Thevoiceofreason2021 · 08/07/2021 13:39

There are loads of reasons why an air steward would need to have a healthy BMI
Insurance - airlines have to medically insure their crew and often insurance dictates things like weight limits. Medical certificate- I assume that flight crew have to pass a medical every year or so, they may well not pass people with a high BMI. Not to mention things like evacuation drills, sea survival course (but f they do it) Fit to do the job - if squeezing in/ out of tight spaces is required - for say inspection purposes or a particularly small plane gangway is required then she needs to be able to do it comfortably.iHealth and safety: the employer has a responsibility to ensure their staff can undertake their jobs safely. If they feel that some ones size may impede their ability to do their job than they can’t employ them. I’m afraid your friend needs to find another airline or a career that does not have these restrictions. The jobs not for her….she needs to move on

notimagain · 08/07/2021 13:38

@PrincessNutella

Planes are conscious of every pound of weight they have on board anyway--it costs them.
They are but in the thirty plus years I spent flying (probably on the other side of the flight deck door from some here) I never ever heard of crew weight vs. fuel burn as being a consideration when it comes to Cabin Crew recruitment….it was a factor that came into a lot of things, but not that.
ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/07/2021 13:33

@ AllieBallyBee
@ Xenia
“A lot of men have been very disappointed over the last 15 years as to how old and over weight the staff have become on flights. Some airlines have gone out of their way to advertise the staff are young female and pretty. This was not the link I was after but interesting nevertheless

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-34242151
It's terrible for men not having someone they can look at who they might want to fuck on a flight. Especially if it's long haul. What are they meant to do for all that time?

Thoughts and prayers.”
——————————-
Are you seriously meaning this quoted in full so not out of context above?

You are suggesting that civil aviation for leisure or business is otherwise a sex related flying enterprise? Is this not extremely discriminatory, hateful and an insult to accuse all of us who fly, men, women and children, of being accessories to a surreal fantasist world? This is getting weird now with woke interference hyper sensitivity intolerance against private businesses employing who they like or dislike the look of. You as a consumer can legitimately exercise your choice/discrimination based on your own views. Air India does not have particularly demanding standards anyway. There is a diversity of different airlines for you to base your consumer preferences so you can discriminate against airlines with staff not to your liking.

MurielSpriggs · 08/07/2021 13:30

@SoupDragon

I will repost the Collins definition!

Which clearly mentions "less fairly" and "less well". Which they aren't. It's like saying a blind person is being discriminated against because they can't be a surgeon.

It's like saying a blind person is being discriminated against because they can't be a surgeon.

Exactly! I think we agree.

SoupDragon · 08/07/2021 13:27

I will repost the Collins definition!

Which clearly mentions "less fairly" and "less well". Which they aren't. It's like saying a blind person is being discriminated against because they can't be a surgeon.

MurielSpriggs · 08/07/2021 13:25

@AmIPeriOrAreYouJustAnnoying

Being cabin staff is more skin to being a waitress/waiter. It's not comparable to being in the army or being a firefighter FFS!
Well, maybe a waiter in a restaurant in very confined quarters, with far too many tables jammed in? And the staff at Pizza Express are less likely to find themselves and their restaurant plunged into the Atlantic and having to help the diners to don life jackets and slide into the Atlantic via inflatable chutes!
AmIPeriOrAreYouJustAnnoying · 08/07/2021 13:20

Being cabin staff is more skin to being a waitress/waiter. It's not comparable to being in the army or being a firefighter FFS!

PrincessNutella · 08/07/2021 13:19

Planes are conscious of every pound of weight they have on board anyway--it costs them.

AmIPeriOrAreYouJustAnnoying · 08/07/2021 13:18

Exactly! @AllieBallyBee
Why not get them to wear bikini tops whilst stewarding too? For the poor men. 🙈

dayslikethese1 · 08/07/2021 13:17

I'm confused, did the friend know the BMI requirement prior to interview and apply anyway or did they only bring it up at interview?

AmIPeriOrAreYouJustAnnoying · 08/07/2021 13:16

She could ask for feedback on the interview.

If you are her friend you won't mention her weight to her. Or "advise" her on her weight as this would make you a patronising arsehole.

🤷‍♀️

MurielSpriggs · 08/07/2021 13:12

@Bluntness100

Errrm, it is definitely discrimination! That is exactly the definition of the word discrimination. I posted it earlier

The definition of discrimination is actually the unjust or prejudicial treatment of different categories of people.

This is not discrimination becayse it is neither unjust or prejudicial. Hence why it is legally permissible.

I will repost the Collins definition!

discrimination
(dɪskrɪmɪneɪʃən)
1. UNCOUNTABLE NOUN
Discrimination is the practice of treating one person or group of people less fairly or less well than other people or groups.
www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/discrimination

The employer is treating overweight applicants less well - it's discrimination.

Google's preferred Oxford Languages has two senses of the word:
discriminate
/dɪˈskrɪmɪneɪt/
verb
1.
recognize a distinction; differentiate.
"babies can discriminate between different facial expressions"
Similar:
differentiate
distinguish
draw/recognize a distinction
tell the difference
discern a difference
separate
tell apart
2.
make an unjust or prejudicial distinction in the treatment of different categories of people, especially on the grounds of race, sex, age, or disability.
"existing employment policies discriminate against women"

In the first sense the employer is recognising a difference - that fat people would be less able to perform certain elements of the job.

(No one seems to suggest that babies discriminating between different facial expressions need to be brought to book Grin)

AllieBallyBee · 08/07/2021 13:09

[quote Xenia]A lot of men have been very disappointed over the last 15 years as to how old and over weight the staff have become on flights. Some airlines have gone out of their way to advertise the staff are young female and pretty. This was not the link I was after but interesting nevertheless

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-34242151[/quote]
It's terrible for men not having someone they can look at who they might want to fuck on a flight. Especially if it's long haul. What are they meant to do for all that time?

Thoughts and prayers.