Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH told his sister about my abortion

335 replies

JoSummer · 07/07/2021 17:44

AIBU to be distraught about this? I can’t work out whether I’m being too sensitive but I have felt like crying all day.

DH met his single sister today (she’s 25) who told him she is pregnant and will be having an abortion. It’s very early and she’s made the decision herself but was a bit upset. He decided to comfort her - and I do believe his intentions were honest/ good - by telling her that “we” had an abortion many many years ago (more than a decade ago) when we first got together.

This is something I have never told a soul. It was important to me that no one ever knew. That was just my way of coping with it. We talked about it at the time but he’s saying he “can’t remember” that he wasn’t supposed to share. I can’t believe he used something so personal to comfort another person, when I went through it alone.

OP posts:
Queenoftheflumps02 · 07/07/2021 21:19

Your DH, in my opinion, was wrong to tell his DSis about your abortion, without discussing it with you first.

If you and your DH agreed at the time, you would keep your decision private, to the extent you didn't tell your DM, then he should have respected and honoured this decision. It was not up to him to make a unilateral decision to tell someone, even his sister, about your abortion. I'm sure he could have offered support and empathy without disclosing your personal medical information.

LizzieW1969 · 07/07/2021 21:16

YANBU to be upset, but I also understand where he was coming from in trying to support his sister, who is going through a similar experience.

He should have asked you first, though, absolutely.

bjjgirl · 07/07/2021 21:14

YABU, it's his sister he wanted to help.

Let it go, he has apologised, honestly holding into anger is not going to help you.

Fwiw ex dp father of my 2 children and I he an abortion - I wouldn't mind if he had old even a friend or colleague to help them if they were going through the same.

In this position I wouldn't mind as he is trying to help a woman who is struggling with her decision, I would be proud of him

Brefugee · 07/07/2021 21:09

Take two to make a baby so should be two to make a decision.

Nope. Nope. Nope. If I'm pregnant and i decide on an abortion there is no way on earth anyone else can force me not to. Nobody.

I think this is inexcusable and i would never forgive it. Never. I certainly wouldn't be telling my DH anything outside of what's for dinner for a good long while, if ever.

I could be on board with it if my DH came home and asked my permission. And deffo echo others: tell him in no uncertain terms that this doesn't go any further. At all. Ever.

SecretSpAD · 07/07/2021 21:00

Many years before we met, a girlfriend of my husband had an abortion. He told me because he needed to talk through his feelings and emotions from that time (a complicated picture of relief and curiosity about what the child would have been like combined with guilt for being responsible for putting her in that position and a lot of other feelings). She knew he told me and she didn't like it. His, and my, feeling is that even though he supported her completely, it is and will always be part of his story and so he does have the right to share with me, his wife, or whoever he wishes.

It is definitely a woman's decision whether or not to continue with a pregnancy, but if a man knows that pregnancy will be terminated then he's going to have feelings and thoughts about it, even if it is relief.

GertietheGherkin · 07/07/2021 20:59

Hmmmm I'm always puzzled by the logic in these circumstances. So if I guy has sex with a woman and a child is conceived, it's the womans' decision as to whether she wants to have a termination, as it's her child, her body, her emotions according to some. The guy is supposedly not worth considering... But, if the woman decides to keep the child, the man still has no say, but he's expected by law to pay for the child... I find the logic in that very skewed.
If the woman has a termination the child is hers according to some... If she stays with the partner and has further pregnancies then the child becomes their child? It's a two person process. So the man shouldn't always be cut out of the equation.

OP it sounds very much like you've hidden your termination, and it's an unresolved situation that you would be best seeking a counsellor to work through your emotions and feelings.
It seems you still have unresolved feelings towards your husband too, in that you had to go through it alone, that was beyond his control, they wouldn't allow him in to be with you.

If he is close to his sister, and she's confided in him, he's shared his ( and yours) experience of a termination. It was obviously meant to help and understand her feelings, he's tried to console her, I don't think he can be villified for sharing his feelings with his Sister, they're family.

samyeagar · 07/07/2021 20:51

@Husbandno5

It was ‘technically’ your medical information to share, but it is an experience he went through also. IMO It is 100% not unreasonable to share an experience that he went through with whoever he chooses. It sounds like he was just trying to comfort his sister, which is a nice thing to do for his sis. You did go through it, so I it would have been nice to ask you first but he probably had some emotional feeling about it too, which is completely his experience to share. You can’t tell him, he’s not allowed to share his experience with who he wants to. I feel like that’s quite controlling. That said, I can understand why you are hurt. I hope you feel better. Especially as he has apologised once he knew it upset, I do feel in this situation he hasn’t really knowingly done anything wrong, and I probably would do the same.
See, this is where terminations and miscarriages get very muddied. While absolutely it is the womans sole choice to have a termination, and her story to share, the man involved also has his own story and lived experience that is completely his. The woman can share her experience and receive support without having it tied in any way to the man, because the entire process for her is contained within her own body and emotional space. Because the very nature of the situation requires the woman to have physically gone through it, the man cannot share his experience without it being tied directly back to the woman. Very messy when high charged and extremely personal emotions are involved.

My ex-wife and I had been married for a decade or so when she an early term miscarriage. The way I was dismissed, shut down, marginalized, as if I was not allowed to have it have any effect on me, because I didn't actually go through anything, by her and others through the aftermath of that. It ultimately left me feeling more relief than anything else that there was not going to be another child brought into our relationship.

Freckers · 07/07/2021 20:51

@JoSummer

^The fact that no-one seems to have a good relationship with your MIL means that it only takes MIL to say something along the lines of 'how could you, that's awful' or similar (if that's her belief) and SIL may go on the defensive with 'but DB and Jo did the same thing'.^

This is exactly what will happen one day. It doesn’t matter if I ask SIL to keep it to herself, I know she will tell her Mum. Her mother will make a nasty comment about it one day (although she’s being supportive right now, she has form!). I shouldn’t care but I do.

But again, doesn't that tell you that your anger isn't about your DH's conversation with his sister?
Wannakisstheteacher · 07/07/2021 20:49

It was his baby too. He can share the fact that his baby was aborted with anyone he wants. He was doing it to comfort his sister not to tell random people off the street.

tony68 · 07/07/2021 20:46

As someone who would have appreciated reassurance from others who had gone thru similar experiences I think yabu. He was there for his sister, comforting not gossiping. if it was me I'd have told her and not told you I'd told her, you'd never have known that the information had been divulged and I probably wouldn't have told you my sister was having an abortion either. Sorry op. I think you're being absolutely fucking ridiculous.

whatthejiggeries · 07/07/2021 20:43

Normally I would be fuming - under the circumstances I think it's understandable

Dentistlakes · 07/07/2021 20:42

There are very few people you can truly trust to keep something like this to themselves, but your husband should be one of them. Unfortunately, most people are incapable of keeping a secret and I think it’s entirely possible your SIL will share this at least with her own mother if it serves her own purpose to do so.

If someone tells me something in confidence, they can be 100% sure I will not share it, even with my husband. It’s not my information to share,

LyndzB · 07/07/2021 20:41

He was wrong. But I (slightly) understand his motivation in comforting his sister. However, I would expect an apology and acknowledgment he was wrong.

toocold54 · 07/07/2021 20:39

Would he be OK his sister knowing details about his penis if he needed an op on that?

If he had testicular cancer and chose to remove a testicle and then OPs brother had to make that decision I think it’s completely reasonable to mention how DH had it done and how he made that decision etc.

OP you say you’re more worried about MIL but if she’s that judgey I doubt SIL is going to mention she’s doing it so she’s then not going to tell her about you as she’s done the same thing.

If she has a mother who is that judgemental then thank God she has a brother she can confide in.

Twistiesandshout · 07/07/2021 20:38

It was your experience alone, termination is the most lonely experience there is. I am sorry he betrayed your trust.

olivesnutsandcheeseplease · 07/07/2021 20:38

I honestly don't know what I'd do in your situation. So totally unforgivable of your DH. I'd probably ask him to leave and give me some space if only to absolutely drive home how he has totally broken your trust

JacquelineCarlyle · 07/07/2021 20:34

I'd be so upset Op but not sure there's much you can actually do. Unless you consider splitting up with him over it, given he has apologised you need to let it go.

Dentistlakes · 07/07/2021 20:32

YANBU. It’s an appalling betrayal of trust.

JoSummer · 07/07/2021 20:31

^The fact that no-one seems to have a good relationship with your MIL means that it only takes MIL to say something along the lines of 'how could you, that's awful' or similar (if that's her belief) and SIL may go on the defensive with 'but DB and Jo did the same thing'.^

This is exactly what will happen one day. It doesn’t matter if I ask SIL to keep it to herself, I know she will tell her Mum. Her mother will make a nasty comment about it one day (although she’s being supportive right now, she has form!). I shouldn’t care but I do.

OP posts:
georgarina · 07/07/2021 20:31

YANBU

If he wanted to share HIS story with his sister then he could have said "I was in a relationship once where we made that choice".

samyeagar · 07/07/2021 20:25

@powershowerforanhour

*Would he be OK his sister knowing details about his penis if he needed an op on that?

Or for symmetry, would he be happy if the OP shared details of her husband’s traumatic genital surgery with her brother?

So you think an abortion is on the same level as genital surgery? I am 100% pro choice, and it is always the womans choice, but it does take 2 to make a baby.

It doesnt take 2 to require genital surgery*

If my husband was considering a vasectomy it's 100% his choice but I'd expect him to discuss it with me first and hear my feelings on the subject. It would affect me a bit- the door slamming shut on the possibility of any more children with him ever, and therefore probably no more children for me ever unless we split up (neither of us want another but at present we are only 99.5% sure of that I suppose).

If he had one, and then I blabbed all to my brother a few years later if he was contemplating one, DH would have every right to be upset.

While not an exact analogue in any way this was the first thing that came to my mind. I had a vasectomy about 15 years ago. I live here in the United States, and the first thing that struck me was that I actually had to have signed consent from my then wife to get one. The urologist would not even schedule the procedure until consent was provided. Yes, as recently as a bit over a decade ago, the state I live in, while not a codified law, the state medical boards had a policy requiring men to obtain spousal consent before getting a vasectomy.

We have since divorced and I am remarried now, and my current wife has regularly told other people about me being fixed. Never with any malice, and always in context. I can't fully explain why, but it always makes me feel a bit uncomfortable.

And I do have mixed feelings around her sharing that because on one hand, she wasn't even the one who had to sign the consent form, so not really a shared experience at all, but on the other hand, the fact that I have had a vasectomy does have an impact on our now shared experiences.

TurquoiseDragon · 07/07/2021 20:21

@IdblowJonSnow

I think it's perfectly understandable that OP feels extremely privately about her termination without assuming there is any shame attached to that.

Yanbu to be angry and hurt OP. I guess I can understand his motivation but he should have kept schtum for your sake.

I can understand the motivation, but he should never have said anything without OP's agreement. It's her medical info after all.

And then there's the other side. He happily told OP about his sister's dilemma. Did she agree he could tell OP?

He now needs to mend this as far as possible, certainly by talking to his sister and asking her not to tell anyone.

SimonedeBeauvoirscat · 07/07/2021 20:19

He needs to tell his sister in the firmest of terms that this information must not be shared.

I’m so sorry this has happened to you - it must be reviving a lot of the feelings you had at the time. I do agree with others that counselling might be worth considering, to explore your feelings and express your frustration in a safe space.

Your husband needs to understand that he has some reflecting to do about the burden you carried at that time, which clearly he didn’t carry. You say he wasn’t particularly emotional about the decision, that he was the influence that made you decide to keep it private. He’s put a massive burden on you because of both of those factors. I think both you and he need to process some of that buried emotion.

QueenBee52 · 07/07/2021 20:18

@DreamingofTimbuktu

Wow - people are being very harsh on your husband. He was trying to comfort his sister. That does not make him a selfish or a liar. I think you should consider counselling giving the situation is triggering so much upset for you.

using the termination HE 'originally' wanted nobody to know about to comfort her ?!

LondonJax · 07/07/2021 20:18

I can see where you're coming from OP.

The fact that no-one seems to have a good relationship with your MIL means that it only takes MIL to say something along the lines of 'how could you, that's awful' or similar (if that's her belief) and SIL may go on the defensive with 'but DB and Jo did the same thing'.

It's fine sharing things with people and he obviously had good intentions and, yes, it is his memory too. But you really have to trust the person you're confiding in and, if SIL is under pressure is she likely to tell? It's not hers to share but she may also not be prepared to have to take MIL or anyone else's remarks (if they're made) all on her shoulders.

I have a feeling your DH is beginning to realise he may have made a mistake by telling without talking to you. You kept his (and your) 'secret' and he's let yours (and his) go. What's out is out now unfortunately.

Swipe left for the next trending thread