Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH told his sister about my abortion

335 replies

JoSummer · 07/07/2021 17:44

AIBU to be distraught about this? I can’t work out whether I’m being too sensitive but I have felt like crying all day.

DH met his single sister today (she’s 25) who told him she is pregnant and will be having an abortion. It’s very early and she’s made the decision herself but was a bit upset. He decided to comfort her - and I do believe his intentions were honest/ good - by telling her that “we” had an abortion many many years ago (more than a decade ago) when we first got together.

This is something I have never told a soul. It was important to me that no one ever knew. That was just my way of coping with it. We talked about it at the time but he’s saying he “can’t remember” that he wasn’t supposed to share. I can’t believe he used something so personal to comfort another person, when I went through it alone.

OP posts:
Spidey66 · 08/07/2021 02:55

While I can sympathise with how hurt you feel, I agree with those having some sympathy for him as well.

It was his sister, not some guy down the pub. He was trying to show her support in a difficult time. By telling her, he was demonstrating he had shared a similar distressing event. Ok I know he hasn't had a termination himself, but you know what I mean.

I think while its ok to let him know your feelings, in your shoes I would accept there was no malicious intent.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 08/07/2021 02:43

YANBU.
I'd be most upset over that. Putting it mildly.

QueenBee52 · 08/07/2021 01:17

In your posts though you do seem more worried about how others view your decision than anything else

Damn right she is worried.. there are people in all walks of life who would absolutely JUDGE OP's choice to terminate a pregnancy..

lets not pretend that everyone is in life is Pro-Choice..

there are also Pro-Life advocates who feel very strongly perhaps even a member of her Family and this information could change their relationship forever..

IT WAS PRIVATE !?

PixieAndProsecco · 08/07/2021 00:55

I think you're being unreasonable OP.

I had an abortion 7 years ago, at the end of my relationship with an ex.
We both had one child from previous relationships, were good parents but were in a toxic situation. We both agreed a termination was the correct path. We were both upset and affected by it.

I may have went through the procedure alone but it was 100% his experience too - from finding out he has created a child, to the discussions around what to do, to the aftermath of the procedure.

If he chose to tell someone that this happened during our relationship, talk about his feelings and experience of it then that is 100% his choice and not something I can get annoyed about. Just like he couldn't get annoyed at me for doing the same even if he didn't want to do that. He doesn't get to control who I discuss my experiences with and why.

If he chose to speak about it to comfort another person and provide them with a lived experience and safe area then that too is his prerogative.

I also wouldn't ask him to lie about who he went through that with, that's bizarre.

In your posts though you do seem more worried about how others view your decision than anything else. I agree with the poster who mentioned unresolved issues and potentially looking at some counselling to help address these thoughts.

ARoseDowntown · 08/07/2021 00:08

Also, it doesn’t make it better that he told his sister and not some random in the pub. Might make it worse, in fact. There is plenty I’d happily tell a random in the pub but never, in a million years, my sister in law or mother in law!

ARoseDowntown · 08/07/2021 00:06

Disclosing someone’s private medical history is unacceptable. He did not have to say you’d had an abortion.

Betraying your trust by disclosing something so important to you (anything, not necessarily about this abortion) would go to the core of my ability to trust him with any other information, and also make me question how well he knows me if he didn’t know I wouldn’t want his sister to know this. I don’t k ow what is do about this, having two DC with him now. Probably nothing, practically. What can you do, realistically?

Sharing that he too has lost a foetus/child and providing his sister with support in this way is absolutely his prerogative. He doesn’t have to say abortion, or miscarriage, or stillbirth, or anything - just that he’s faced losing a foetus/child. If she’d pressed him, he should have said he wasn’t at liberty to say more because it impacts someone else.

Couchbettato · 07/07/2021 23:53

@CrazyNeighbour

I also think you’re being somewhat unreasonable.

Your SIL is (hopefully) going to be in your lives for decades to come. In her position, if I ever found out in the future I would be so so angry with you, and you would know it.

Your DH should tell her never to mention it. She doesn’t “have one over you” or anything like that. She knows that other people have been through the experience she is going through and have come out the other side.

Can I ask OP if he had asked your permission to say, would you have offered the comfort or would it have been a “Nah, she can go through it alone”.

You can comfort someone without disclosing someone else's private medical information.
Rillington · 07/07/2021 23:22

It's not like he sat in the pub telling everyone. He told his sister to comfort her. It was his child too at the end of the day.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 07/07/2021 23:19

Wow, it’s amazing that you managed to make a baby all by yourself. Oh hang on, someone else with human feelings and emotions had a part to play and is entitled to their own feelings about it too.

He is absolutely entitled to his feelings. He is not entitled to disclose ops private medical information after she expressly said not to.

You find it inexcusable and unforgivable? Yet I’m sure you’d be the first with your hand out to the Cms if you made a choice to keep the baby even if he wasn’t on board.

Yes, because the man's choices stop at ejaculation. The woman has choices after that. If a baby is born because of those choices the man absolutely should pay. Its not the child's fault. Nobody forced the guy to have sex.

Talking about getting rid of your own baby is nowhere near as bad as actually doing it. I’m guessing you also agree with late term terminations also because of course “it’s your body and your choice even if there is a fully formed baby there at 38 weeks”.

Having an abortion isn't 'bad' at all. And yes, the womans body, the womans choice, as early as possible, as late as necessary.

Typical forced birther bring up 38 week abortions as if that would ever happen though.

CrazyNeighbour · 07/07/2021 23:07

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

User135792468 · 07/07/2021 22:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EKGEMS · 07/07/2021 22:50

@ivfgottwins Ok-thanks for that correction on my post. I'd be upset if it were me but looks like it's a pretty divided consensus

BusyLizzie61 · 07/07/2021 22:16

I think that yabu.

It was his baby too, so of course it has affected him.

If you're not ashamed, and believe it was the right decision, I don't really see what the issue is with him sharing, in an appropriate manner; it wasn't t mates down the pub after 1 too many, as a badge of honour or similar shit.

I would imagine that you've shared information, however notable with other s, when he'd have preferred not...

As for talk of separation, that's ott imo. You had an abortion. You made that choice. Live and stand by it.

Littlecaf · 07/07/2021 22:06

“ It is definitely a woman's decision whether or not to continue with a pregnancy, but if a man knows that pregnancy will be terminated then he's going to have feelings and thoughts about it, even if it is relief.”

This. My BFF had a late term abortion many years ago. Her DP was devastated. She was very angry he was devastated. Absolutely her choice to terminate but it doesn’t stop the man from having feelings about it. We spoke about it at the time and although she needed comfort and understanding I recall expressing sympathy for her DPs feelings but trying to do it tentatively without hurting her. Sending Flowers OP.

toocold54 · 07/07/2021 22:04

In this position I wouldn't mind as he is trying to help a woman who is struggling with her decision, I would be proud of him

I completely agree.
If my brother told me about his gf I’d be so thankful that he shared it and he felt it’s not something to be ashamed or embarrassed about which we often feel which is why we keep it secret.

DifficultPifcultLemonDifficult · 07/07/2021 22:03

If he absolutely had to talk about his experience in order to support his sister, then why did he have to say who it was with. He could have been vague about the partner.

ivfgottwins · 07/07/2021 22:02

So your husband at the time requested you to keep it quiet

No the OP said it was 100% a joint decision not to tell anyone

samyeagar · 07/07/2021 21:54

@Strictly1

I understand you're upset but I think it was something that impacted him too. He has apologised and had good intentions. For those saying it was only the OP's body, pregnancy- do you really think that men should have no feelings or involvement until the baby is born?
This is where differing biology combined with body autonomy gets complicated. The entire process, physical and emotional, for a woman can be completely self contained and removed from the man. For a man, there is no physical, and his emotional is directly tied to the woman, so he does not have any real autonomy.

Which is why men really need to think long and hard about who they breed with.

Holly60 · 07/07/2021 21:50

It’s really interesting the split between people referring to an abortion as just ‘a medical procedure’ and those recognising that actually there was a baby (and that the baby had two parents) of course the medical procedure part is horrific, and belongs entirely to OP, but the partner also lost a baby. Perhaps he didn’t go into massive detail with his sister about the actual procedure (which of course she can find it in from other sources) but was able to talk to her about the reality of losing a baby to abortion- because he did experience that, and of course there can be and often is grief there for both partners - male and female.

Of course he couldn’t talk about his own experiences of baby loss through abortion without it being obvious that it was his partner who had actually had to go through the procedure.

Strictly1 · 07/07/2021 21:46

I understand you're upset but I think it was something that impacted him too. He has apologised and had good intentions.
For those saying it was only the OP's body, pregnancy- do you really think that men should have no feelings or involvement until the baby is born?

Viviennemary · 07/07/2021 21:44

Even if it has an impact on the man it's not his right to share such a personal thing especially as in this case quite a long period of time has elapsed and they both chose not to share it with family at the time.

EKGEMS · 07/07/2021 21:44

@JoSummer So your husband at the time requested you to keep it quiet but then breaks your confidentiality to blab it to his sister to make her feel better vs you being able to confide in other people at the time? Hmm I call that hypocrisy and I would be incandescent

Strictly1 · 07/07/2021 21:40

@Summersun2020

Oh just fuck OFF with the “it was his experience too”. No it wasn’t. NOT his body, NOT his abortion, NOT his decision to share. Op I’m so so sorry hes betrayed you in this way. I would be so upset.
Are you saying it had nothing to do with him then?
notanothertakeaway · 07/07/2021 21:22

@Summersun2020

Oh just fuck OFF with the “it was his experience too”. No it wasn’t. NOT his body, NOT his abortion, NOT his decision to share. Op I’m so so sorry hes betrayed you in this way. I would be so upset.
I know someone whose GF had a termination, joint decision, and he took it really, really badly. So, in his case, he absolutely experienced it

So yes, it's a far bigger issue for the woman, but I don't agree that it has no impact on the man

TheValeyard · 07/07/2021 21:20

YANBU, but i can see why he did it. It sounds like it was a kind but thoughtless thing to do, that might have seemed like the right thing to offer comfort or advice, or in the heat of an emotional discussion.

On balance, he was definitely in the wrong, but i can see how it happened.

Take two to make a baby so should be two to make a decision.

No, just no.

Swipe left for the next trending thread