Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think its immoral to charge children rent?

330 replies

CatsArePeople · 07/07/2021 14:24

Unless you're saving/investing it for them.

Bring on the biscuits Grin

OP posts:
Sloaneslone · 08/07/2021 13:45

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@Sloaneslone - it’s a civil obligation so you don’t get “charged” if you fail to financially support your children. I have seen children enforce this obligation against their parents in my old job though. And rightly so. But it’s hard for kids to actually sue to enforce unless they are estranged (and even then). It’s pretty awful to neglect your children though or use them for cash as soon as they are 16. As I say, you have till 25 to support them if they are in education.[/quote]
I would love to see some info on cases where adults, are forced to pay for other other adults to attend education.

There has to be record of it being enforced. And it would need to be normal people. Not the adult children of millionaires.

Who exactly is using their kids for cash at 16?

Most of us are talking about working adults, not children. Not people in education.

And from what I understand, it nor just as simple as you say.

thegcatsmother · 08/07/2021 12:40

I hasten to add, ds has been supported by us in full, until he started work last month at 25.

CandyLeBonBon · 08/07/2021 12:40

@CayrolBaaaskin

I would add that while it may not be avoidable for some, children shouldn’t feel obliged to support their parents either imo. Putting the responsibility on a teenager to support the household is wrong imo. Let them be a child.
I don't consider a 21year old living at home and earning a full time wage to be a child. Stop infantilising young people!
CayrolBaaaskin · 08/07/2021 11:55

I would add that while it may not be avoidable for some, children shouldn’t feel obliged to support their parents either imo. Putting the responsibility on a teenager to support the household is wrong imo. Let them be a child.

CayrolBaaaskin · 08/07/2021 11:48

@Sloaneslone - it’s a civil obligation so you don’t get “charged” if you fail to financially support your children. I have seen children enforce this obligation against their parents in my old job though. And rightly so. But it’s hard for kids to actually sue to enforce unless they are estranged (and even then). It’s pretty awful to neglect your children though or use them for cash as soon as they are 16. As I say, you have till 25 to support them if they are in education.

thegcatsmother · 08/07/2021 07:44

We supported ds through his BA and MA,so no loans at all. He spent 15 months living at home trying to find a job in his field, then Covid hit, and he still lived with and was supported by us. He now works full time, and damn right, I charge him keep. £50 a week, which means he is quids in. It's way less than he would pay in rent, bills, food and travel if he moved out.

ClareBlue · 08/07/2021 06:38

My mother charged all of us 25 percent of our income once we left school. We were all living independently by the time we were 21 and none have ever returned. We all get on fine and visit and stay over with each other. All our children live independently all before they were 20.
Absolutely adult children should pay rent.

upthekyber · 08/07/2021 00:36

You mean fellow adults living and contributing to the household costs?
No not really, and I paid my mum and dad, I intend to charge them a 1:3 of their take home when working full time or part time if they are not studying.
Whilst in full time education I am happy to continue to support and allow them to live with us for free or if they can't work for any reason.

I do think it is immoral for adults to freeload off the older and elderly people mind...

viques · 07/07/2021 23:00

@PurpleHoodie

viques your post of 16.23
? Not me.
WhatAShilohPitt · 07/07/2021 23:00

Well, it sounds like you are speaking from a position of privilege where you don’t need the money. Not everyone can afford to maintain adult (old enough to be earning a wage) children indefinitely. People receiving benefits for their children need to pay for food etc once they teach the age where they no longer get benefits. Others may just think that if you earn then you contribute to the family. It’s not immoral - that’s just over the top.

Elleherd · 07/07/2021 22:54

However there are some people who can't financially support another adult and they shouldn't be condemned for it.

Actually there are many people unable to financially support another adult, and while it is well meant, it is shocking that anyone should have to even suggest that they shouldn't be condemned for not being part of the privileged ranks who can.

IamnotSethRogan · 07/07/2021 22:07

My parents and DH parents have never charged us rent and as a result we're all home owners. I don't think it breeds feckless losers.

However there are some people who can't financially support another adult and they shouldn't be condemned for it.

Furries · 07/07/2021 21:58

Weird - I normally feel drawn to cat people ...

I think my cat engages with me way more than the OP has with this thread 😂. At least they admitted they were bored.

Nice to see a thread where everyone has their heads screwed on right and, at the end of the day, it all come down to personal circumstances and that there’s pretty much no judgement. So, nice one OP, the responses were all great to read.

shivawn · 07/07/2021 21:47

Although I wouldn't personally charge my adult children rent, I don't see any problem with working adult children paying rent to live at home once they're out of education.

Marty13 · 07/07/2021 21:24

While immoral is a strong word, I certainly wouldn't take money off my kids if I didn't need it, just to "teach them that money is valuable".

I'd consider it reasonable and right to support them financially while at uni if I can afford it.

If I can't afford it, sit down with them and work out together how to make it work. That may involve them having to find a job or to take a loan.

Once uni is over (so around 23 years old) if they haven't already moved out, sit down with them and talk about what their plan is. If that involves them staying at home I wouldn't charge rent but may ask a contribution towards living costs (so food, utilities, etc). I would also expect them to have some sort of plan (save for a deposit for X months ? Move in with a friend at X date ?)

But no, I wouldn't start charging the moment they turn 18. Surely there is a middle ground between taking money from your 18 year old child and them staying rent-free at home until they're 45...

Obviously if the parent is struggling financially that's different. But otherwise, either you're okay with them staying home, or you're not. Charging them money to "incentivize them to leave" is pretty underhanded. Just tell them you want them to move out.

If they can't afford to move out they probably can't afford to pay rent anyhow.

Crimeismymiddlename · 07/07/2021 21:20

Adult children with an income, of course they should pay their way. Actual children, obviously not.

PurpleHoodie · 07/07/2021 21:14

viques your post of 16.23

Tulips15 · 07/07/2021 20:47

@PennyRoyal

DD20 works full time, earning more than me. When she finished college, child benefit and maintenance from her father stopped as well as council tax going up. I use half of what she pays to help with shopping/rent etc. The other half I save towards her first house (she doesn't know).
I plan to do this. DD turns 18 next month, taking a gap year and is working FT instead. She hopes to rent her own place ASAP from next month though. If she is here, I will save half of her rent.
Tumbleweed101 · 07/07/2021 19:54

My adult daughter earns more than me. All I've made her pay is her half of the council tax (single parent so used to get single adult discount), what I lost when her tax credits stopped and a bit towards food. Think that is more than reasonable. She can still save about £200 a month and havr ample spending.

Happieronmyown · 07/07/2021 19:50

@AnneLovesGilbert was your rather sarcastic post meant for the op, just because the question's been asked before? Who made you the thread police??
If you're not interested in the thread just ignore & move on 🙄

MorganKitten · 07/07/2021 19:49

I paid rent from the age of 18 when working, taught me to budget.

LibertyMole · 07/07/2021 19:29

‘I had that with my family. I ended up home longer than I should be because my mother couldn't afford her own rent without benefits or my money.’

Because amazingly, the government don’t see it as her rent when another adult is living there; they see it as both of your rent if you are an adult.

shouldistop · 07/07/2021 19:26

An adult working full time and living at home should be paying towards the house.

A student or very young adult starting out / on a part time job then I wouldn't take money.

sanityisamyth · 07/07/2021 19:26

When I was off uni for a year on compassionate leave, I got a minimum wage, full time job with people my mother knew.

She didn't charge me rent.

She had her friends make the cheques payable to "initial surname" as we share the same initial. She had 100% of my wages, except for train fare to get to work.

She then left me a shelf in the fridge for my food, except I couldn't buy any as she had all my wages. I lost a lot of weight as the job was very active. I basically didn't eat for 10 months.

Some parents are arseholes. I wouldn't have minded 10/20% of my wages but she left me with nothing.

LibertyMole · 07/07/2021 19:25

Tiger, it isn’t my son’s home. It is my home, which I took out a tenancy on after he had left home.

It is not a place for him to come and live in to save up money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread