Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to buy a car on PCP???

185 replies

MoonbeamSprinkles · 07/07/2021 10:52

I have never bought a car before and I'm totally confused about what's for the best.

I have just passed my test and am looking for a Kia Picanto 3, I'm not the most confident driver so I like the fact it has reversing cameras etc.
I have about 8.5K saved and earmarked for the car.

My options are

  1. Buy a 3 year old car outright for about 8.5k.

  2. Buy a nearly new car for around 12k and dip into rainy day savings.

  3. Buy a new car on PCP put down a 5k deposit and keep the 3.5k for the monthly payments and hand the car back at the end.

The dealership offer very low rates on PCP but it looks too good to be true, I've never had a credit card or loans and I hate the thought of being in debt.
It would be nice to have a brand new car that I could 100% trust though.

If I have a PCP contract and I want to trade my car in would I need to put another cash deposit down when I give it back?

Any advice would be helpful, I'm a long time lurker of mumsnet and you always know whats what when it comes to cars.

OP posts:
Reallybadidea · 07/07/2021 13:05

Could one of the 'never buy a depreciating asset' people explain why? I can understand that using finance to fund buying a brand new car will probably be a really terrible idea, but why is using cash savings to buy a used car worse than pcp? Why don't people hire all their depreciating assets - which is basically everything other than a house?

SlipperyLizard · 07/07/2021 12:57

Option 1, or 2 if you want something newer.

PCP looks cheap for a new car, but you end up on a treadmill of payments that never end. You effectively pay off the depreciation, then hand it back and pay off the depreciation on the next one. Repeat until you have spent ££££s that could be better invested in a pension!

Yes, you get a new car every few years, so if that’s important to you it might suit, but it isn’t “cheap”.

We buy cars that are 3/4 years old but reliable brands/models. We generally keep them until they are uneconomical to repair then buy again. Currently got a 5 year old Mercedes that we love but could never afford new.

But brand new cars aren’t important to us, not wasting money on cars is.

MattHancocksSexTape · 07/07/2021 12:51

@MoonbeamSprinkles

I am going for a test drive to a kia garage tomorrow with my very impulsive mother who loves her PCP car so I need the iron will of mumsnet to keep me on the straight and narrow.
@MoonbeamSprinkles

I would postpone this until you are certain of what you want. Pushy sales people. Pushy mother. Shiny cars. You could end up succumbing to pressure in the moment.

Buy a second hand car, if you scratch it, it’s on you. Reversing cameras are common these days. A quick search on autotrader found a Kia picanto with reversing camera and 9k miles on the clock for £8.5k.

hennybeans · 07/07/2021 12:46

Definitely option 1.

We've always bought our cars slightly used and kept them for ten years. Generally we've had car payments for the first 2-3 years via a bank loan, then own the car outright with no payments for 7-8. We tend to go for reliable Toyotas as well. All the other ways of paying are just a way for the dealerships and car companies to get more money from you. As a society in general, we don't need new cars every three years. It's the same with mobiles, and washing machines, and everything else.

DynamoKev · 07/07/2021 12:40

@Shade17

Okay fair enough but I was talking about cars that people can use - not put in a garage/storage and only use when it's not raining ;)

Plenty of cars you can use/rag/track and still appreciate in value. I rarely sell a car for less than I paid for it.

Blimey, you live and learn. I have never made a penny on any of mine.
BarbaraofSeville · 07/07/2021 12:40

The OP is a new driver and wants a car for day to day use that's going to be easy to drive and look after and cheap to insure.

It doesn't sound like she's in a position to set herself up as an amateur car trader in whatever niche type of car bucks the trend against 99% of other cars that depreciate not appreciate in value as you keep them.

CorianderBee · 07/07/2021 12:38

Buy 1.

I've had PCP before and it was handy and a good price, BUT that's only if nothing goes wrong. My sisters currently unable to drive.... but is locked into the contract so still has to shell out every month for a car she can't use.

It's very hard to get out of the contract once your in it and you will legally HAVE to pay even if you lose your job, become unwell, break your legs etc.

Shortbreadbrokemytooth · 07/07/2021 12:36

I agree with pp who say don’t get a brand new car when you have just passed your test. You are very likely to get scratches or minor dents. I would definitely go for option 1 in your situation.

Do consider buying a car from one of the online dealers such as Cazoo and Cinch. Their inspections are very thorough, you have a decent warranty and it cuts out having to negotiate with car dealers!

Shade17 · 07/07/2021 12:36

Okay fair enough but I was talking about cars that people can use - not put in a garage/storage and only use when it's not raining ;)

Plenty of cars you can use/rag/track and still appreciate in value. I rarely sell a car for less than I paid for it.

Morgan12 · 07/07/2021 12:35

@igotdemons

Think very carefully before you buy a car on PCP. You’ll need to pay to have it serviced every year by the dealer, as well as an MOT before you hand it back (we weren’t made aware of that until the time). You’ll also have to pay for any damage incurred, even if it’s just cosmetic or they’ll deduct it off at the end (if there’s any equity left, if not you’ll have to pay). We thought we’d have enough ‘equity’ at the end for a deposit for the next car but it turned out we literally had none, despite the car being immaculate with only 12,000 miles on the clock! I’m also assuming that if your car is worth less than the remaining finance at the end of the term, you’ll have to pay the difference in that, too. Do your research, it sounds great but it isn’t necessarily the case!
This sounds like a lease and not PCP?

I change my car every two years on PCP. The garage phones me to tell me I'm due a service and always then offer a new car. So I just take the new car. Never ever had to pay for any damage etc. But my mum had to pay damages after her leased car went back.

DynamoKev · 07/07/2021 12:33

PCP threads are like bog brush and shoes off threads :)

DynamoKev · 07/07/2021 12:32

@Shade17

Everything to do with cars (except for tiny number of very expensive and rare ones) is throwing money away

Not relevant to the OP but there are plenty of cars you can buy for under 10k that will appreciate in value.

Okay fair enough but I was talking about cars that people can use - not put in a garage/storage and only use when it's not raining ;)
Gardentiger · 07/07/2021 12:29

I really think it's best to buy with your first car - speaking from experience I had two minor prangs from reversing in to a tree and a small wall in my first few years of driving - and this was after passing with flying colours!

When you pass your test, it isn't the end of learning. The first few years of being out in your own are when you are most likely to cause some dents and scrapes, especially when moving from the car you learned on to one that's a different size and shape. After more experience, you will be able to get in any car and have the spacial awareness not to prang it, but it's a learning curve

Essentialironingwater · 07/07/2021 12:28

I got a PCP and wouldn't again. Now instead of the monthly payment I save the money each month and roll it into payment towards my next car. I've ended up much better off.

If you do go for PCP at the end consider selling the car instead if in good condition. I sold mine to webuyanycar, and got 2k more than the balloon payment. Obviously it won't always work out like that but it's worth checking out.

We will buy cars outright every time now. If there's a cashflow issue id rather get a cheap loan or 0% credit card for the difference.

catfunk · 07/07/2021 12:27

Option 1. A 3 year old car will be great.

Shade17 · 07/07/2021 12:26

Everything to do with cars (except for tiny number of very expensive and rare ones) is throwing money away

Not relevant to the OP but there are plenty of cars you can buy for under 10k that will appreciate in value.

DIYandEatCake · 07/07/2021 12:24

I’d go for option one, but buy from a reputable garage with a warranty. The first car I bought was a secondhand Ford Fiesta, which cost just under £7000 - I bought it from a Ford dealer as an ‘approved used car’ with a year’s warranty, for peace of mind - it was maybe a bit more expensive than buying privately but definitively less risky. It was a fantastic car that I had for 11 years and had no issues with. Maybe look to see if Kia do a similar approved used car warranty scheme?

BarbaraofSeville · 07/07/2021 12:23

They're a lot more forgiving of scratches than people fear, the last one I sent back was quite tatty and I got a bill for about £60, most of the damage was deemed fair wear and tear.

The downside I see with PCP is that if you hand the car back and don't get another one, you've basically given your deposit away. I had PCP on a Skoda Citigo and the deposit was only one month payment. I'd expect to pay only a very small deposit on such a small car as a Kia Picanto.

On the matter of the Kia Picanto, we had one as a holiday hire car. The boot is very very small. It was also completely gutless. I thought my Skoda Citigo was much more practical, decent sized boot for a small car, and copes fine with longer journeys. I got mine for £130 deposit and £130 pm but that was a few years ago. But the money you're talking about spending OP will get a nearly new one, or a decent PCP deal.

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2021 12:21

I'm impressed that @Blossomtoes has managed several 0% PCP deals and built up equity every time (I'll use your dealer next time!) but that scenario is rare

Toyota Peterborough! We always overestimate our mileage - we’re waaaaay under with our current cars. It also helps that we both drive Toyotas and they know they’ve got us for life now, they treat us very well.

DynamoKev · 07/07/2021 12:20

On the other hand I don't want to just throw money away so if I'm just being snobby I don't mind being told.
Everything to do with cars (except for tiny number of very expensive and rare ones) is throwing money away - the only question is how much.

user1471429368 · 07/07/2021 12:17

I recently bought a 2nd hand car and paid half from my savings and the other half on an interest free credit card. So I now dip into my savings monthly to pay the monthly minimum (or more). This keeps some savings in tact but also available if I need it for anything else.

DynamoKev · 07/07/2021 12:17

I haven't got kids, have managed to get to the point in my business where I have a decent income and fancy treating myself.
Do you run your own business?
If so you should definitely talk to your accountant about whether it would be more cost effective for the business to finance your car and for you to run it as a company car - this works especially well for electric and hybrid cars.

VeganVeal · 07/07/2021 12:16

Buy outright, and spend less than the £8.5k. Chances are you'll have a few scrapes in it here and there if you've just passed your test.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 07/07/2021 12:12

I've got mine on PCP as there's no way I'd be able to afford it otherwise. I've almost broke even with the payments already so I'm hopeful there will be some equity in the car, if not I'll look into refinancing the balloon payment. I'm hoping to trade it in for another one after 3 years though.

@thatonehasalittlecar it's not as though the car will be scrapped, someone else will buy it so it will go on! I don't want to have to MOT it or deal with the rust (it's known for that) so it suits me to hand it back.

linerforlife · 07/07/2021 12:07

I have a car on finance and have done for the last 10 or so years. I like having a new car as they're comfortable, more economical to drive and are under warranty so if anything breaks I don't get hit by an unexpected bill. I like the peace of mind that gives me as they're very unlikely to break down and so to me that is worth the money.