Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to buy a car on PCP???

185 replies

MoonbeamSprinkles · 07/07/2021 10:52

I have never bought a car before and I'm totally confused about what's for the best.

I have just passed my test and am looking for a Kia Picanto 3, I'm not the most confident driver so I like the fact it has reversing cameras etc.
I have about 8.5K saved and earmarked for the car.

My options are

  1. Buy a 3 year old car outright for about 8.5k.

  2. Buy a nearly new car for around 12k and dip into rainy day savings.

  3. Buy a new car on PCP put down a 5k deposit and keep the 3.5k for the monthly payments and hand the car back at the end.

The dealership offer very low rates on PCP but it looks too good to be true, I've never had a credit card or loans and I hate the thought of being in debt.
It would be nice to have a brand new car that I could 100% trust though.

If I have a PCP contract and I want to trade my car in would I need to put another cash deposit down when I give it back?

Any advice would be helpful, I'm a long time lurker of mumsnet and you always know whats what when it comes to cars.

OP posts:
DuzzyFuck · 07/07/2021 13:59

Another vote for buy outright. As a new driver you're likely to scratch or knock it, and knowing it doesn't matter is a relief.

Also I'd wonder what the situation is if someone else damages your PCP car? I've had a wing mirror smashed off by someone who didn't stop, and other small dints from other peoples doors over the years. Owning my car outright has meant I could have it fixed (or not, for small dints) and shrug it off.

My first car was £1k (although it was a heap and the garage ripped me off). It wasn't until I'd been driving for about 15 years that I spent a decent amount on a nearly new car - £8k on a 2 year old Fiat.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 07/07/2021 13:57

(This is dipping into savings not getting pcp btw)

OP posts:
MoonbeamSprinkles · 07/07/2021 13:56

How long does a car last??

If I buy a nearly new car for 12k and keep it 7 years that’s £142 a month
Whereas if I buy a 3 year old car for £8.5k and keep it 4 years that’s £177 a month Confused

And if I buy a brand new one for 14k and keep it 7 that’s £167 a month

So according to my maths it still works out cheaper in the long run to buy new but my maths must be wrong because everyone always says it’s cheaper to buy second hand so where am I going wrong?

OP posts:
HomerSimpsonsDonut · 07/07/2021 13:56

Please think very carefully if you choose the PCP option
I took a car out on a PCP deal and it was one of the worst decisions financially I've ever made in my life.
Ended up taking out a bank loan to pay off the PCP. The bank loan was cheaper to pay off.

CharlieWorkCharlieSad · 07/07/2021 13:53

I've never bought a car that cost more than £1000!!

Our current car cost £300 and has passed every Mot for the last 3 years! She's a beauty Grin

I hate credit cards and finance etc. I'd rather just go with out then ever get in debt.

I would use the money you have to buy a car.

Reallybadidea · 07/07/2021 13:50

I'm interested in the financial concept. You chose to answer my first question, I didn't force you. Really no need to be so rude.

ReviewingTheSituation · 07/07/2021 13:44

All the people supporting PCP are saying why it's right for THEM. And they're all good, valid reasons. It was right for me too, until a year ago.

But it's better to consider what's right for OP, and her set of circumstances. What's right for one person and their lifestyle/driving experience/financial position isn't right for everyone. You can be a big advocate of something but still recognise it's not the best for someone else.

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2021 13:43

@Reallybadidea

Because then you can use your cash savings for something else.

But that doesn't mean it makes more financial sense to 'hire a depreciating asset', just that you don't need to use your savings to buy a car. If I don't need the savings for anything else, why is pcp better than a nearly new car bought with cash? The implication with the 'depreciating asset' line seems to be that pcp saves you money. Does it? How?

What is this? The Spanish Inquisition? Do your own cost/benefit analysis, like I did.
Reallybadidea · 07/07/2021 13:40

Because then you can use your cash savings for something else.

But that doesn't mean it makes more financial sense to 'hire a depreciating asset', just that you don't need to use your savings to buy a car. If I don't need the savings for anything else, why is pcp better than a nearly new car bought with cash? The implication with the 'depreciating asset' line seems to be that pcp saves you money. Does it? How?

Blossomtoes · 07/07/2021 13:29

@DogInATent

Option 1.

I don't know why the pro-PCP enthusiasts think that depreciation doesn't apply to them. It's built into the cost, and new cars depreciate fastest in the first 18 months.

Indeed. But your pcp contract is based on the same price as a buyer pays and you get a brand new car after two/three years. A buyer doesn’t.
pinkflask · 07/07/2021 13:28

I did option 1 - a 3 year old £8000 car is still a really nice car! Mine felt as good as new (had about 35000 miles on it), still smelt newish, looked shiny and nice. I've had it since 2019 and it's sailed through services so far. I can see myself driving it for at least another couple of years easily and maybe up to about 5 more years - or just driving it into the ground! So it's not like you're getting a horrendous old banger OR that the new version will be amazingly miles better.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/07/2021 13:26

@spinningspaniels

MN hates PCP/leasing. So you really won't get a balanced view on here.

We've done PCP or leased for the last 7/8 years. It's stress free motoring, and the car needs one service in 3 years, and possibly 2 sets of tyres.

My days of old bangers and frequent garage visits are long behind me.

Plus freedom from the hassle of buying and selling in the second hand market and dealing with time wasters, shysters and the illiterate idiots who hang around in FB marketplace.

When I had a PCP car, the original tyres were still just legal when I returned the car. I was planning to buy it, but I decided to go back into my company car scheme instead.

TheArtfulCodger · 07/07/2021 13:24

We've had PCP cars for a few years and it works for us. We take out the added insurance for damage so don't have to worry about scratches.

I've been driving for 40 years and have had my share of old bangers and unreliable secondhand cars. I'd always chose PCP now.

nc8765 · 07/07/2021 13:24

Option 1.

We always buy our cars for cash.

DogInATent · 07/07/2021 13:22

Option 1.

I don't know why the pro-PCP enthusiasts think that depreciation doesn't apply to them. It's built into the cost, and new cars depreciate fastest in the first 18 months.

PurBal · 07/07/2021 13:22

Unless you have no other option stay clear of PCP.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 07/07/2021 13:17

I really don’t think I’d want the headache of running it as a company car anyway for what would probably be a small discount in the grand scheme of things.

When I’ve gone through the numbers with my accountant in the past it’s always only saved a tiny bit for quite a lot more paper work and stress.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 07/07/2021 13:17

@Reallybadidea

Could one of the 'never buy a depreciating asset' people explain why? I can understand that using finance to fund buying a brand new car will probably be a really terrible idea, but why is using cash savings to buy a used car worse than pcp? Why don't people hire all their depreciating assets - which is basically everything other than a house?
Because then you can use your cash savings for something else. People used to hire things like TVs, then they got too cheap to make it worthwhile. There’s a huge difference between a £1k fridge and a £30k car, both in price and depreciation. We always use 0% finance for big ticket items too - why use our savings?
spinningspaniels · 07/07/2021 13:16

MN hates PCP/leasing. So you really won't get a balanced view on here.

We've done PCP or leased for the last 7/8 years. It's stress free motoring, and the car needs one service in 3 years, and possibly 2 sets of tyres.

My days of old bangers and frequent garage visits are long behind me.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 07/07/2021 13:15

Kia warranties are 7 years so that’s reassuring

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 07/07/2021 13:14

I think having your business finance your car is only strictly allowed if most or all of its use is for business purposes.

If you don't use the car for business much, it's not really allowed to put all the cost through the business. People probably do it because they think they won't get caught and maybe they won't, I don't know how often HMRC carry out compliance checks.

But it's worth asking the question of your accountant or looking on HMRC. Even if you don't put the car through the business, you could always claim the 45 p a mile for business miles without any worries that you're stretching the truth about your tax affairs.

queenie273646 · 07/07/2021 13:13

Option 1! Buy from a main dealer Kia, audi, whoever they give you at least one year warranty on approved cars sometimes companies give 2 year when they have offers on then u have the protection if anything goes wrong u can just get the main dealer to fix it, I got mine with Audi and also you also get Audi breakdown cover included with the warranty .

Bryonyshcmyony · 07/07/2021 13:11

You can't claim a car is for business use then use it for wholly personal use

Bryonyshcmyony · 07/07/2021 13:11

I couldn't possibly do PCp as I live down a rutted overgrown country lane and the chance of scrapes is super high.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 07/07/2021 13:08

Do you run your own business?
If so you should definitely talk to your accountant about whether it would be more cost effective for the business to finance your car and for you to run it as a company car - this works especially well for electric and hybrid cars.

Well this really puts a spanner in.

Yes I do own my own business but it was my understanding that because the car would be almost 100% personal use that it would work out about the same.

OP posts: