Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is really petty of my SIL

168 replies

PettyGamePlaying · 07/07/2021 10:16

I have been with my DH for 30 years (met v young) and I am a couple of years older than my SIL. We are both now middle age women. For as long as I have known my SIL she has received Christmas and birthday presents from us. Before DH and I had DC we had very good jobs and so bought her decent things. When we had DC and I gave up work, we tried to tone it down but received very serious emotional blackmail from both her and MIL. Over the past decade I have toned it down, but not as much as I'd like.

So, every year my SIL asks for lovely gifts for herself and my DH says that she buys for our DC, so we have to really. It is like a transaction. She doesn't really buy for our DC though. She just bungs them £20. She bought them a gift at birth, but that's it. She has never once asked us what they like, what she can buy them or walked into a toy shop to buy them anything. So, a 3-year old got a £20, meanwhile, I have to traipse around going to her favorite Spa in the arse end of nowhere to buy her a voucher or go into town and urgently get a limited edition of some beauty box that is launched just for Christmas. If she ever asked me what my DC liked I could have easily given her lots of ideas to buy. DH and I never get gifts, but she sorted the DC so was OK.

Anyway, since I am sick of the above and always hosting Christmas, last year I told her that I was toning down Christmas presents and just buying small things. In the end, Christmas lunch at mine didn't happen due to lockdown.

So, my DC didn't receive a Christmas bung from her and they have now both had their birthdays and she sent them nothing. I don't actually care and neither do they but I think this is really petty. SIL and MIL have form for game playing. I have seen it a million times with other people and they have done it to me too. If you do something they don't like, even if you are in the right, you get punished by being snubbed or excluded. I have 8 nieces and nephews and I have never missed an occasion and I'd never be petty around them. MIL and SIL seem to think that a "punishment" will bring us into line or upset us and teach us a lesson.

I'm not sitting here upset for us or my DC. I am sitting here just thinking that I am sick of this type of shit and can't be arsed with their games. I don't want to acknowledge to her that I am bothered. My DH is a bit upset, but I just think it is pathetic. I think the best thing I can do here is to fake it till I make it and act as if I haven't even noticed.

She has already indicated that she won't be seeing PIL this Christmas as it is her DP's turn to see his family, or she will be going on holiday. Oh, so that leaves muggins AGAIN to host. She has never hosted them, only me. I have told my DH that I am not hosting them and she can have them at her house, I don't care how many of his family are there or she can take them on holiday with her. That is her problem, I am not doing it. I am also not buying her anything ever again.

Inside I am fuming at these games. WWYD and AIBU?

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 07/07/2021 12:29

We stopped doing adult presents and my single, no children sister was told that she didn't have to buy for the children. I think children should be bought for, but it's personal choice.

YABU about your DH's parents. She is entitled to go on holiday, or go to her in-laws. Then it's a joint decision and effort to have or not, his parents.

Why when women want to do what they want at Christmas does every other woman in the family turn on her? This is how this Martyr shit keeps on going.

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 07/07/2021 12:28

@Blossomtoes

Thing about games is that most of them need more than one player. There’s no game any more if you refuse to engage. Well done, that woman! Stick to your guns.
Oh goodness, @Blossomtoes. I think I need to laminate this. Thanks.

@PettyGamePlaying. This is really annoying, but now you have been freed from the tryanny of traipsing round getting speshul things for your speshul Pwincess SIL.

Look on the brightside. Don't be drawn in again if they try to start it up again at a later point.

ClawedButler · 07/07/2021 12:28

You don't HAVE to host. The world won't stop turning, nobody will catch fire.

Just disengage from the nonsense. Nothing you can do or say will be enough for a middle-aged brat, so why bother? Don't sink to their level and get petty or passive-aggressive about it, or about changing your plans. Or to put it another way, don't wrestle with a pig. You both get covered in shit but moreover the pig likes it.

PearlNextDoor · 07/07/2021 12:27

I agree with you that she sounds very transactional. But when somebody gives me something I have that, crap, do I owe you now? feeling! (well, if I feel they are transactional).

So I'd be relieved she hadn't given your dc twenty pound each.

tell her not doing presents this year!

TooWicked · 07/07/2021 12:22

Why isn’t your DH running around in the arse end of nowhere buying spa vouchers or beauty boxes?

Why isn’t your DH shopping, cleaning, cooking and hosting Christmas for his family?

Forget SIL, tell your husband that you’re leaving her and PIL’s all to him to sort out from today going forward.

As a PP said this is a win-win for you. So what if your kids don’t get a £20 bung from their auntie? You’re saving hundreds by not pandering to her any more.

Grow a backbone and tell your DH that you’re out and it’s all his responsibility from today

Onlinedilema · 07/07/2021 12:15

I agree with everyone else. Stop buying her anything. Let Dh but for his family. Stop hosting unless your dh does all the prep and cooking, cleaning but if he isn't up for that then tell him no, you are not hosting.

Beautiful3 · 07/07/2021 12:14

Thought I should add that I have done the same thing as my advice earlier. I no longer buy presents for anyone apart from my children and husband. I started it 4 years ago and it's the best thing I ever did. I used to host for all the ones that asked to come. But I got annoyed at washing, cleaning, cooking and hosting for a bunch of drunk men (fil & bils), all day and night! They never seemed to know when to go home. I literally felt like a slave. I just snapped 8 years ago one Christmas, and said never again. Now I say, " I don't know what my plans are" (Im waiting to see if I'm going to parents or a friend) until literally the week before Christmas, then I explain how its going to be a quiet one with just us. Sometimes I say its not a traditional turkey dinner, as we fancy doing something different. No-one seems to want to come to that, as it seems boring. Also my husbands more supportive now. If someone outright asks for an invitation, he'll say, "that's not fair on beautiful, because she never gets any help." I love my husband.

TreeSmuggler · 07/07/2021 12:07

She sounds a bit annoying but you wanted to stop doing presents, and she has agreed and done as requested. That's good isn't it?

SarahBellam · 07/07/2021 12:06

“Dear SIL, I’m so pleased we’ve decided to stop swapping presents. It’s so much better for the environment (and for our pockets). If anything it’s made us realise how much Christmas has got out of hand and how stressful it is to keep hosting every year, so we’re going to dial it right back and just have Christmas her for me, DW, and the kids. I think it’ll be a lot more relaxed for everyone.”

Then get your DH to send it. It’s his family, not yours.

Notaroadrunner · 07/07/2021 12:02

I note that you won't ever be buying SIL a gift again so at least there is one positive to her pettiness. And why were you bothering buying before now? It should have been your Dh and if he couldn't be bothered then it wouldn't have been your issue if she was in strop. You need to cut out the wifework! Let him look after his side of the family.

As for Christmas, you've told Dh you are not hosting so let that be the end of it. Don't back down. Surely his parents are capable of cooking a dinner for themselves. Do they ever invite you to their house?

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 07/07/2021 12:01

Sorry. MRS toothybitch Wink

PiffleWiffleWoozle · 07/07/2021 12:00

I would leave the present buying to DH instead, it’s his sister (or his brother’s wife) I assume?

YABU to feel entitled to presents of any kind for your kids from her though, just is she IBU to feel entitled to any kind of present from you.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 07/07/2021 12:00

I was going to post but toothybitch said all I wanted to say Grin

From an ex-muggins 🌻

honeylulu · 07/07/2021 11:55

Think about it, her "punishment" actually works out better for you. SIL saves £20. You save a whole lot more including your own time and effort. Win win! Stick an extra £20 in DC's money box with your "saving" if that helps you feel they haven't missed out.

And stick to your guns about not hosting Christmas! I bet it's you who does the work rather than your DH.

Beautiful3 · 07/07/2021 11:54

I think the best thing that you can do is to forgot all this, as it's toxic. Forget it all. Before Christmas send out a mass message to say, we re no longer doing gifts, so please don't buy for us and our children. If people ask what you're doing for Christmas, say just a quiet one this year. You could even have an unusual one e.g. curry on the day or something, that will put people off from wanting to spend it with you! It's a neat trick that my bil likes to do! Which works!

EscapeTheCastle · 07/07/2021 11:43

This could work out well.
You have the PIL this year, she has them next and alternate from then on in so then you never have to host SIL again.
Don't let the SIL colour your view of all the rest of the family.

RainCloudz · 07/07/2021 11:34

Why can't PIL host?

Natty13 · 07/07/2021 11:14

You sound like an absolute martyr. You don't HAVE to do any of this stuff, you're choosing to. Sometimes the choice is between 2 things you don't want to do (hosting Christmas vs not) but you still have the choice of which one you take.

Personally I make the choices which don't end up with me fuming, fed up, burnt out, complaining about my lifein order to keep everyone around me "happy". Guess what, the world didn't cave in and my friends and family are still around.

KarmaStar · 07/07/2021 11:07

My mum said to me that people will treat you how you allow them to,or lead them to.
If you keep giving,keep hosting,people come to see it as the normal.
Time to stop,as you've said,and good on you.💐

Don't host.
Don't buy for sil.
Don't offer apology or reason.

Do have a lovely time
Do use the money to treat yourself.

HouseOfGoldandBones · 07/07/2021 11:03

She's done you a huge favour OP.
I'd be sending her a message saying:

Hi SIL, I think your idea of stopping Christmas & birthday presents is great now the DCs are getting older.
Unfortunately we won't be able to host PIL for Christmas this year as we've decided to do our own thing.
See you soon.

MrsToothyBitch · 07/07/2021 10:57

Also if DH insists on getting his sister a personal present, he funds it himself- so if wants to dig deep it's on him; family finances now only stretch to token gifts from the pound shop.

SpindleWhorl · 07/07/2021 10:54

I get the impression from the OP that she always gets landed with having everyone for Christmas:

Anyway, since I am sick of the above and always hosting Christmas

Oh, so that leaves muggins AGAIN to host. She has never hosted them, only me

... and that she needs a break.

Zari29 · 07/07/2021 10:54

Oh, so that leaves muggins AGAIN to host. She has never hosted them, only me.

You have played the role of muggins for 30 years so there is no point at being angry at her when you entertained this. She is a CF and has these expectations because you set them and just continued along. Just stop all of this now. You know what she is like, you've had 30 years of examples so what more do you need?

MrsToothyBitch · 07/07/2021 10:53

What a spoilt brat she is!

I think you need to plan for Christmas pretty early this year. I'd text her in early Autumn and remind her Christmas will be upon us before we know. Then thank her for the money sent to the children in previous years but you just want to let her know you wholeheartedly support her decision to end your reciprocal xmas gift giving with you, effective immediately. If she throws a wobbler, ignore. If Mil insists, ignore. Such a shame if the fall out means MiL obviously won't want to come for Christmas.

Covid is also your friend here; they reckon curbs might have to be reintroduced in autumn-winter cough/cold season. Suggest that in light of this, rather than have Christmas ruined last minute, everyone just plans for themselves. They've got ages to get used to it.

Heartofglass12345 · 07/07/2021 10:53

Why do you have to do it though? Why isn't your husband traipsing to the arse end of nowhere or rushing to buy her something? If he doesn't care then you shouldn't either. I don't understand why women take it upon themselves to sort out presents for their partners family. I have no input into my husbands gifts for his family, like he doesn't with mine, apart from maybe asking each other for ideas/ opinions.
As for Christmas, again, why does it all seem to be down to you? What are they like when they come over? Are they easy going or entitled? That would make it or break it for me.