Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is really petty of my SIL

168 replies

PettyGamePlaying · 07/07/2021 10:16

I have been with my DH for 30 years (met v young) and I am a couple of years older than my SIL. We are both now middle age women. For as long as I have known my SIL she has received Christmas and birthday presents from us. Before DH and I had DC we had very good jobs and so bought her decent things. When we had DC and I gave up work, we tried to tone it down but received very serious emotional blackmail from both her and MIL. Over the past decade I have toned it down, but not as much as I'd like.

So, every year my SIL asks for lovely gifts for herself and my DH says that she buys for our DC, so we have to really. It is like a transaction. She doesn't really buy for our DC though. She just bungs them £20. She bought them a gift at birth, but that's it. She has never once asked us what they like, what she can buy them or walked into a toy shop to buy them anything. So, a 3-year old got a £20, meanwhile, I have to traipse around going to her favorite Spa in the arse end of nowhere to buy her a voucher or go into town and urgently get a limited edition of some beauty box that is launched just for Christmas. If she ever asked me what my DC liked I could have easily given her lots of ideas to buy. DH and I never get gifts, but she sorted the DC so was OK.

Anyway, since I am sick of the above and always hosting Christmas, last year I told her that I was toning down Christmas presents and just buying small things. In the end, Christmas lunch at mine didn't happen due to lockdown.

So, my DC didn't receive a Christmas bung from her and they have now both had their birthdays and she sent them nothing. I don't actually care and neither do they but I think this is really petty. SIL and MIL have form for game playing. I have seen it a million times with other people and they have done it to me too. If you do something they don't like, even if you are in the right, you get punished by being snubbed or excluded. I have 8 nieces and nephews and I have never missed an occasion and I'd never be petty around them. MIL and SIL seem to think that a "punishment" will bring us into line or upset us and teach us a lesson.

I'm not sitting here upset for us or my DC. I am sitting here just thinking that I am sick of this type of shit and can't be arsed with their games. I don't want to acknowledge to her that I am bothered. My DH is a bit upset, but I just think it is pathetic. I think the best thing I can do here is to fake it till I make it and act as if I haven't even noticed.

She has already indicated that she won't be seeing PIL this Christmas as it is her DP's turn to see his family, or she will be going on holiday. Oh, so that leaves muggins AGAIN to host. She has never hosted them, only me. I have told my DH that I am not hosting them and she can have them at her house, I don't care how many of his family are there or she can take them on holiday with her. That is her problem, I am not doing it. I am also not buying her anything ever again.

Inside I am fuming at these games. WWYD and AIBU?

OP posts:
Paddling654 · 08/07/2021 20:52

Paddling654 you don’t seem to understand appropriate behaviour with gift giving.

Thoughtfulness, rather the amount spent, is appropriate behaviour around gift giving. It's amazing that someone would actively decide not to be thoughtful and be unaware that this would be a hurtful move. The OP is very controlling to decide that any drop in reciprocal giving is 'petty' as her SIL is free to respond as she wishes to this. If someone behaved to me as the OP had done, I wouldn't feel inclined to continue with this farce but then it hasn't occurred to me not to be grateful for any gift given to my children.

I wonder why the OP spends time with these people if she despises them to the point that giving cash in a card is evidence of something dreadful.

This is the kind of daughter in law I hope never to end up with!

Paddling654 · 08/07/2021 20:43

CoralSparkles

That's ridiculous but in that case, it seems odd that the OP expects gifts. She seems well aware that there 'should' be reciprocity around hosting so she understands the concept.

What she seems to have done is extremely petty. She has lowered the cost of the gift she gives her SIL (and removed the 'thoughtfulness' from the gift so goodness knows what it is) to recover the costs of catering for her on Christmas Day - so the SIL is ostensibly receiving hospitality but in reality paying for her own meal. Her SIL has foiled this plan by reducing the amount she gives to nothing.

Talk about a race to the bottom.

Noshowlomo · 08/07/2021 19:38

YADNBU

CoralSparkles · 08/07/2021 19:33

@Paddling654 you don’t give gifts (in your case £20 note to OP’s 2 DC) and expect a gift back, let alone an expensive gift.

Purplepeoniesdroppingpetals · 08/07/2021 19:30

Tell them that you’ve seen the light and going on holiday for Christmas is the way forward, as per sil. Then suggest that they get a request to visit her house in early and sell it as a novelty.

RainbowOctopus · 08/07/2021 19:20

Why not book a lovely Christmas meal out. Say ‘this year we plan to support the hospitality sector that has been really hard hit by Covid. We are going to X at X O’clock. Feel free to join us there, it’s X per head’
You’ll probably still be quids in, hosting is very expensive. And as for gifts, just call it, say ‘we’re not doing gifts so please don’t feel you have to’
Good luck with it all, be brave and decisive so you can free up some brain space!

Eddielzzard · 08/07/2021 19:19

It doesn't even register to them that perhaps we are sick of always sucking up the cost and the hassle of hosting Christmas.

Believe me it registers, because that's exactly why they don't offer to host. You absolutely mustn't fall into that silence and invite them.

Your DH could say something like 'you know after 30 years I don't believe we've ever been to yours for Christmas. How about you host this year?'

PrinzessinCressida · 08/07/2021 19:18

Well, @Paddling654, as at now, approximately 944 people (95% of a total of 994 respondents) agree with the OP, and 50 don't. Instead of twisting the OP's posts to try and excuse her SIL's unacceptable behaviour, you might want to put any personal agendas aside and pay attention to what nearly 1,000 people are saying. Hmm

Tulips15 · 08/07/2021 19:07

Me andy siblings dont buy each other anything, never have.
There is 9children between us- We dont buy them gifts either, we get them.together though around xmas at the local soft play center of day trip out.

I would therefore not be buying SIL any other gifts again and stop hosting them.
Selfish to leave it up to one family to host each yer

GreyhoundG1rl · 08/07/2021 19:06

How did you even get to this point? Why didn't you just laugh the first time a grown woman demanded lovely presents from you?!

DocDog · 08/07/2021 19:03

@Paddling654

I just didn't buy her anything thoughtful.

I have never before come across someone so happy to admit their lack of kindness. I would find it very difficult to spend any amount of money on a relative and avoid buying anything thoughtful.

As for buying her lunch, it's clear she's coming to please her mum and this is not a favour to her. She does seem to do everything possible to avoid a family Christmas and I don't blame her. You all sound like the least loving functional family imaginable.

If she gifts £80 at each Christmas and birthday, as you seem to say she always did, you're unlikely to be out of pocket.

Yep, it's SIL.

Mummyoflittledragon · 08/07/2021 19:01

Your Sil sounds horrible. Your mil too. Interesting that your mil knows whose house to go to for Christmas. Well done for being able to detach. And ignoring a poster with a very entitled attitude.

DagenhamRoundhouse · 08/07/2021 19:01

Aren't people strange? The games they play.

angela99999 · 08/07/2021 18:59

@PettyGamePlaying

Oh dear, seems like a massive nerve has been zapped here. Perhaps Paddington is my SIL. She certainly sounds like her.
I'm sure she is your SIL! Bunging £20 in a card is hardly caring and thoughtful - let alone time-consuming or generous. It's what I do for my grown up nephews and nieces! Only I'm a little more generous....
Diva66 · 08/07/2021 18:57

Just tell them you’ve made plans for Christmas. No need to tell them what those plans are.

Thewinterofdiscontent · 08/07/2021 18:56

Stay strong and don’t buy. I know a lot but because we like to be kind but actually it’s a chore alot of the time. There’s too much choice and not enough time.

Send a bunch of flowers as her card if you want to acknowledge her birthday for DH sake ( and be the bigger person ) But that’s it for effort.

Christmas invites for Christmas nibbles only, on Christmas Eve. Or Bixing Day if you think they might find a need to stay over.

MikeHat · 08/07/2021 18:54

I'm a bit on the fence here.
DH's family don't go in for big gifts. One is positively stingy and a family joke, never more than a fiver spent. Another sends (generous) gift vouchers for shops. We live in the back of beyond and I spent my life bying the bloody vouchers off the DC so they could buy something.

So my stance is to buy nice gifts for all adults and put cash in an envelope for children up to age 18.
Children like cash much better than a toy they already have or a voucher they cannot use.

TheGlassBlowersDaughter · 08/07/2021 18:53

I said YABU because you seem as invested in the drama as they are. You're saying you don't care but are also saying they are 'very petty' and you're posting on MN about it. That suggests you do care. It seems obvious they would scale back presents if you did. You scaled back; so did they.
As for Christmas, that's up to you and your DH. No-one makes you host. You're an adult. From the little you've posted it sounds as though your DH is caught in the middle of the drama between you all. It all sounds exhausting. Decide together what you are doing for Christmas. Announce it now. And don't spend any more time thinking or talking about it. This is all taking up too much energy.

justlliloleme · 08/07/2021 18:47

Paddling you sound like an entitled dick. If you are the SIL there are 6 pages of comments telling you the same.

whataboutbob · 08/07/2021 18:47

Aaaah Christmas. Enough to make me wish we lived under a communist regime.

lastcall · 08/07/2021 18:42

SIL told me that she would stop presents at 18. I totally understand that, but why am I buying someone 40+ massive presents

Because you're a mug. I agree with your decision to just stop. Shame you didn't do it years ago or put your DH in charge of gifts for her if he couldn't cope with the fall out.

FeeLock · 08/07/2021 18:37

Definitely time to disengage, emotionally and literally. Tell your DH that they're his family and he needs to deal with them (he should have been doing this from the beginning of the games!).

We all have rellies who learn how to point-score before leaving kindergarten. I've had it and although it was difficult living through it, it was a blessing in disguise as I barely hear about them any more.

All good wishes to you. Flowers

bigmumsymcgraw · 08/07/2021 18:36

Too long a tale Gave up reading Life too short Do what u want Who cares if SIL and MIL huff - they sound awful so why care

Nocutenamesleft · 08/07/2021 18:29

@HouseOfGoldandBones

She's done you a huge favour OP. I'd be sending her a message saying:

Hi SIL, I think your idea of stopping Christmas & birthday presents is great now the DCs are getting older.
Unfortunately we won't be able to host PIL for Christmas this year as we've decided to do our own thing.
See you soon.

Yes. This!!!
jwpetal · 08/07/2021 18:24

You can do as we do for Christmas. the host buys the Turkey and everyone coming brings the rest of the food. We all contribute to the dinner. If they don't show up with their assigned food then Turkey it is. Or if you dp decides to fall to the pressure of the family, have him do the dinner.
As for the sil, that is really sad though I don't really get the toned down comment. Whether you pay £10 or £30 for a gift, you can do it with some conscious effort. Perhaps that wording was a bit questionable. However, her attitude now is sad and petty. Some good boundaries are needed. This has to also come from your partner.