Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know IABU in not wanting to ask for maintenance. Need some sense!

242 replies

swiftt · 06/07/2021 14:52

I’ve posted about this situation before. Back story: I have a 3 week old baby. Her dad is involved but we are not together, and we never have been. He stayed with me for 2 weeks after her birth and is currently seeing her for a few hours every other evening and more at the weekend. He works full time. I’m on maternity leave and it drops down to approx £150/week as of this month.

I asked if we could have a discussion about maintenance amounts months ago and he put it off, we argued and eventually he said we’d sort it nearer the time. Well, she’s here now and we still haven’t come to an agreement. I know I need to bring this up with him again but he has made some comments recently about money and I feel like I’m walking on eggshells when I think about bringing it up. We had a newborn photo shoot done last week and when I asked him to transfer me his half for the photos (this was agreed well in advance of doing the photo shoot) he said, ‘oh, I want a new TV. Will you pay half?’ Then said he was just joking about how he wants something and I should pay half for it. I asked him in advance if he wanted the photos done and gave him the option of saying no, so to pass that off as a joke really felt like more of a dig to me.

He’s also made other comments in the past about how unfair maintenance is etc, and I feel like I’m just anticipating an argument about him basically not wanting to give me money, even though it’s for our daughter. I said to him before that even if I don’t end up needing the money for her, I’d save it in a bank account for her. I’m not the type to go and spend it on crap for the sake of it.

He’s coming over to see her tonight and I really need to nail this conversation as I’m well aware that I’m just dragging it on and making it worse but I feel so anxious about it. For context, he has bought a couple of packs of nappies and brings some stuff in from the shops for me when he visits (had a c section so I can’t drive yet). I’ve bought anything else we’ve needed for baby since she was born and haven’t asked him to contribute.

Also very aware of how pathetic I sound in this situation. I usually don’t have issues with assertiveness but he’s really difficult to have a conversation with and I’m not feeling totally in the right headspace just yet, with dealing with a newborn, sleep deprivation and doing it mostly on my own. From my other threads, I also know this doesn’t bode well for co-parenting but I just need advice on the here and now.

Bottom line here: I feel irrationally guilty about asking for child maintenance money even though my daughter is entitled to it. How do I grow some balls?!

OP posts:
DameFanny · 20/07/2021 11:21

If he offers £50 a week and CMS says it's £65, he can up his standing order when the report comes in. If he offers 100 a week and CMS says 65, you can either repay the 35, or he can be a decent dad and let you keep it.

It'll be up to him to make the payments whether he calculates then or the CMS does. The difference is, if he misses payments the CMS will pursue him for them, if the claim has gone via them.

And then they'll take an extra percentage of his calculated claim for their costs, so it's in his interests to make the payments on time.

thenewduchessofhastings · 20/07/2021 11:04

Your not grabby and don't have to justify what it's for.He is her father,your not a couple sharing finances therefore he legally has to pay maintenance.

He is bullying you.I'd simply go through CMS;you don't know how much he earns exactly and I've a feeling he'll try to offer you less money than your LO is entitled to.

DameFanny · 20/07/2021 11:04

I don't see why not - and tell him when CMS come back with their calculation you can repay him any overpayment* if he wants

*There won't be an overpayment, bet you anything

swiftt · 20/07/2021 11:00

He’s now messaged saying he’s worked out his income and offered X amount monthly, going up to X amount when he gets a pay rise in the next few months. I’ve already paid for the CMS application and still want to go through them. Can I accept him paying at the end of this month through a private arrangement before CMS have sorted my claim, or will that mess everything up? I’m just wary it could still take weeks for them to sort things out with him.

OP posts:
DameFanny · 20/07/2021 10:19

You're going to have to grey rock him on this OP. Just practise some set phrases - "routine is important for babies to feel secure"; "if I know how much money is coming in and when, I'll be better able to plan her care and save for the bigger purchases down the line"; "CMS only costs more if you miss payments and they have to get it direct from your employer"; "I've said you can spend time with her when you want, just make sure she's not sleeping and we're not doing something else first"; "we can set up a specific schedule for her if that would make you more comfortable" etc etc. Find your own words and practise.

But also keep track of how much time he's spending with her vs being in your house expecting to be fed/entertained, in case he tries to pull a fast one with CMS claiming he's a main carer or something.

You can do this.

swiftt · 20/07/2021 09:31

Some of the comments he made last night are still swirling round my head this morning. One of them being that if I’m so desperate for the money then he’ll give me it now, to which I had to explain that I’m not desperate, I just wanted it sorted so I didn’t have to worry about it later down the line. Everything just feels so awkward now, I’m dreading the next time he comes to see the baby already.

OP posts:
cptartapp · 20/07/2021 06:59

Whatever he give you he'll still be shortchanging you. By hundreds of thousands over the years. What's the cost of a 24/7 nanny half of every week? Then add on clothes, food, nappies, etc etc etc. His contribution won't touch the sides over the years. And you'll be the one making all the sacrifices, social life, career, pension.
If he honestly thought the' better deal' was seeing more of his DD he'll go for 50/50. Laughable. All talk and no action.

Briarshollow · 19/07/2021 23:41

Well isn’t he a nasty piece of work? As others have said, he knows how soft you are and how easily he could have manipulated you into accepting him never paying anything. Ever. So now he’s furious that you’ve removed his chance to do that.

It’s good you’ve done it officially. Now you just really need to work on taking absolutely no shit from him. For the sake of your baby. Please, toughen up.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/07/2021 23:22

Also his parting comment shows he still has no clue 'you'll get your money', it's not your money, it's your daughters money, the absolute minimum that she is legally entitled to

DelphiniumBlue · 19/07/2021 22:57

It's not up to him how any maintenance is spent, don't pander by saying you'll save it.
It's his contribution towards the cost of raising his child, which include a proportion of rent, bills etc as well as food, kit, and any other expenses.You don't need to justify it in any way.
If he won't discuss it properly or agree to pay a regular fixed amount then you'll need to go through CMS.

Dogvmarmot · 19/07/2021 22:55

@swiftt

He’s just been over to see her and, stupidly I know, I mentioned that CMS had processed the claim and would be in touch with him soon but I also gave him the heads up that it’ll need paid this month. Well, I’m totally unreasonable because if I’d just waited a few days, he’d have sorted it. He told me he didn’t know how much he was getting paid which is why he hasn’t sorted it already. He categorically did not tell me that, he told me that after I told him I’d gone to CMS! Also, who takes a new job without knowing their salary? I know it’s just excuse after excuse and I’m so annoyed with myself for getting upset again. He left the living room and sulked in my kitchen for about half an hour whilst I fed the baby. I actually thought he’d left. I ended up saying to him that I don’t understand why he’s even annoyed if it was goon to get sorted anyway, well the outcome is the same this way? He’s still having to pay the bare minimum! Then he started on about how I’ve got the ‘better deal’ here because I get to see her all the time. I had to try and explain (again, I know I shouldn’t even entertain it) that actually it’s really hard going being a stay at home mum with a newborn and I could do without the stress of money worries. Well, unreasonable me again apparently. He says it’s hard that he only gets to see her every other day. He knows fine well that he’s welcome to see her here any time he likes, I’ve never stipulated contact and we don’t have an agreement about it so if he wanted to see her more then he absolutely could. Wouldn’t even stay an extra 20 minutes tonight to give her a bath and get her ready for bed whilst I grabbed some cold dinner. Couldn’t possibly do that. Need to stop engaging with him, I know. He didn’t even say bye, just said ‘don’t worry, you’ll get your money’ and left. Kicking myself now for even saying anything in the first place.
he is annoyed as CMS will mean he will be expected to make a set regular payment. He is obviously hoping he just give you a bit of cash here and there when he feels like it. There was nothing to stop him setting up a regular direct debit to your account. Just ignore all his excuses. A baby is v expensive - reduced income during maternity leave, then child care/clothes, extra space and food. a baby becomes a child with all those costs. Good for you for starting CMS so you dont spend the next 18 year asking him for cash . he sounds v v immature.
GrandmasCat · 19/07/2021 22:45

It is not too early to set a contact pattern, you can for example arrange for him to see her on Tuesdays and Thursday from 6 to 730 and Saturdays from 10 to 12. Being so young and breastfeeding you don’t need to allocate for him taking her out or overnight stays- that will come, in due course, if he is able to maintain the first contact agreement in the first place.

swiftt · 19/07/2021 22:45

@DrinkFeckArseBrick thank you. I really am going to try and detach myself. I can’t keep dealing with this stress and upset. He always makes me feel like I’m in the wrong.

OP posts:
QueenBee52 · 19/07/2021 22:28

*advice

QueenBee52 · 19/07/2021 22:27

@DrinkFeckArseBrick

OP listen to this advise, it's sold gold and truthful.

He wants to control everything, with minimal effort.. and you are enabling him... it needs to STOP.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 19/07/2021 22:06

Hi OP

I know you wanted to try and be friends and have an amicable co parent relationship with him but he is making this impossible. I think you need to accept that he isn't making a great start at being a parent, at the moment you can't trust him to put your daughters best interests first, and he certainly doesnt give a shit about what is best for you. He is only looking at his point of view not considering yours or your daughters and thats unlikely to change. I think you need to accept this and try and take a step back, engage with him less and stop hoping he will be reasonable; he won't, he will continue to engage in these tit for tat conversations, not changing nappies because it's not his turn or not helping care for his daughter because of some way he perceives you've somehow got it better than him. Stop trying to involve him in any family type activities like days out or photos or anything, he is massively ungrateful for all your efforts and throws your thoughtfulness back in your face. I can see when you're older asking him to join in with a theme park trip or something and him sulking because you've taken her on more rides. Detach a bit and create some distance and I think it will be easier for you and your daughter. There is no point in involving him if he is going to be snappy and sulky in front of her, it's going to make her paranoid when she is a bit bigger that she has got to keep count of who she does what with so there isn't an argument.

swiftt · 19/07/2021 21:49

I don’t even know where to start with a contact agreement. She’s only a month old. The flexibility works both ways at the moment but I do definitely want a routine for her and a set schedule when she’s a little older.

OP posts:
acolderwar · 19/07/2021 21:10

You really need to get tougher with him. When he visits the baby he needs to sort himself out entirely and bring his own food if he can't deal with not eating for a couple of hours, and he needs to be responsible for all care for the baby whilst there, and you can go crack on doing something else in the house. And it would be easier for you if there was a visiting schedule too, so you can make other plans and so he has no room to just turn up whenever he wants.

TotorosCatBus · 19/07/2021 21:03

*Careful there, “see her whenever you want” is the perfect recipe for massive issues down the line. You both need to agree to a pattern of contact.

You need to agree on a routine to see her, because you and your kid need that structure to manage your child expectations, organise your work/book nursery and rebuild your life.*

Absolutely this
If you're not careful you'll end up cancelling stuff that you want to do with your dd or not doing stuff just in case your ex pops round. Your dd will suffer if you start living ad hoc like this - kids like routine and Dad popping round whenever could lead to her feeling anxious because she doesn't know whether he's coming or not. Even if routine sounds crap because you're a laid back person, it's a sensitive thing to do imo.

GrandmasCat · 19/07/2021 20:59

Careful there, “see her whenever you want” is the perfect recipe for massive issues down the line. You both need to agree to a pattern of contact.

You need to agree on a routine to see her, because you and your kid need that structure to manage your child expectations, organise your work/book nursery and rebuild your life.

There is also a important thing, a lot of men suddenly decide they want 50/50 contact. It may work for some couples, especially where the dad is a very hands on responsible parent but in many occasions it is because if you agree to 50/50 they don’t have to pay maintenance at all (if it accidentally go to 51/49 on his favour, easily done with a miscalculated holiday, you loose your child benefit, universal credit and have to pay him maintenance) So don’t go the easy going route with a flaky parent who has not even imagined he must pay maintenance regularly even after months of visiting his child. You need to start as you plan to go.

swiftt · 19/07/2021 20:43

He’s just been over to see her and, stupidly I know, I mentioned that CMS had processed the claim and would be in touch with him soon but I also gave him the heads up that it’ll need paid this month. Well, I’m totally unreasonable because if I’d just waited a few days, he’d have sorted it. He told me he didn’t know how much he was getting paid which is why he hasn’t sorted it already. He categorically did not tell me that, he told me that after I told him I’d gone to CMS! Also, who takes a new job without knowing their salary? I know it’s just excuse after excuse and I’m so annoyed with myself for getting upset again. He left the living room and sulked in my kitchen for about half an hour whilst I fed the baby. I actually thought he’d left. I ended up saying to him that I don’t understand why he’s even annoyed if it was goon to get sorted anyway, well the outcome is the same this way? He’s still having to pay the bare minimum! Then he started on about how I’ve got the ‘better deal’ here because I get to see her all the time. I had to try and explain (again, I know I shouldn’t even entertain it) that actually it’s really hard going being a stay at home mum with a newborn and I could do without the stress of money worries. Well, unreasonable me again apparently. He says it’s hard that he only gets to see her every other day. He knows fine well that he’s welcome to see her here any time he likes, I’ve never stipulated contact and we don’t have an agreement about it so if he wanted to see her more then he absolutely could. Wouldn’t even stay an extra 20 minutes tonight to give her a bath and get her ready for bed whilst I grabbed some cold dinner. Couldn’t possibly do that. Need to stop engaging with him, I know. He didn’t even say bye, just said ‘don’t worry, you’ll get your money’ and left. Kicking myself now for even saying anything in the first place.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 15/07/2021 14:35

It's short-term pain for long-term gain. There's a not a hope in hell he'd have paid voluntarily for years. You'd be begging, he'd use it to control you. Now it's all set up and sorted. No ongoing conversations necessary.

And bonus, you've signaled to him you aren't quite the mug he thought. That's good.

newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 11:45

Oh ... and I can't believe you made him tea with a newborn! Kudos to you - I could barely find the time to stick a few pieces of toast in the toaster in those early weeks 😂

That said ... please don't be making him any meals again!! Thanks

newmummy21 · 15/07/2021 11:43

@swiftt

Firstly, congratulations on your little one Thanks

Secondly, you are simply incredible for doing this alone. Those early weeks are TOUGH (my baby is 12 weeks and it's got slightly easier but I can't even imagine having done it all alone). Your baby is lucky to have such a strong mummy.

Thirdly, I echo all the rest of the advice - stand by your guns and do not let this idiot fob you off. I hope the CMS are helpful and that get what you and your baby are entitled to and deserve. Sending Cake and Thanks to you

PumpkinKlNG · 15/07/2021 08:42

He’s not her boyfriend or ex, they were never in a relationship, she said that on the last thread. I think if she thinks they are going to co parent or even get along for the next 18 years then she is very naive, I would be very surprised if he sticks around at all.